I now have extensive content from Cummings. Here is a comprehensive, well-organized explanation:
Anterior Skull Base Approaches
Based on Cummings Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery
Anatomy of the Anterior Skull Base
The anterior skull base is formed by the cribriform plate medially and the ethmoidal roof laterally. The cribriform plate may be only 0.1–0.2 mm thick and often lies much lower than the ethmoidal roof. The lateral lamella of the cribriform plate connects to the ethmoidal roof and is particularly thin and vulnerable.
Keros Classification — categorizes the depth of the olfactory groove:
| Type | Depth | Risk |
|---|
| I | 1–3 mm | Lowest |
| II | 4–7 mm | Moderate |
| III | 8–16 mm | Highest (thin, steeply inclined lateral lamella) |
Key surgical landmarks include:
- Anterior ethmoidal artery — lies posterior to the frontal recess, sometimes "slings" down as a pedicle within the ethmoid; retraction into the orbit causes acute orbital hematoma and blindness
- Posterior ethmoidal artery — lies just anterior to the sphenoid sinus
- The skull base is highest anteriorly and slopes downward posteriorly — dissection should proceed from posterior to anterior once the skull base is identified
Overview of Surgical Approaches
Cummings categorizes approaches on a spectrum from purely intracranial (neurosurgical) to purely extracranial (endonasal endoscopic), with most contemporary procedures combining both:
"For anterior cranial base lesions, the most commonly used open approaches employ some form of frontal craniotomy (unilaterally or bilaterally) with some form of transfacial exposure (transnasal, transmaxillary, or transorbital)."
The major approaches fall into three broad categories:
1. Open Craniotomy-Based Approaches
Anterior Craniofacial Resection (ACR)
The traditional workhorse for sinonasal malignancies invading the anterior cranial fossa (squamous cell carcinoma, esthesioneuroblastoma, adenocarcinoma).
Combines:
- Bifrontal craniotomy (intracranial component — neurosurgeon)
- Transfacial exposure (extracranial component — usually lateral rhinotomy ± contralateral Lynch incision, or midfacial degloving)
Steps:
- Transfacial exposure first — periosteum elevated from nasal bones and medial/inferior orbit; naso-lacrimal duct identified and transected; anterior and posterior ethmoidal arteries cauterized/clipped
- Bifrontal craniotomy — if large frontal sinus, an osteoplastic flap is used; if small, a frontal bone flap with bur holes above the hairline
- Frontal lobe elevation — dura incised and olfactory nerves severed at the cribriform plate; dural closure made watertight (temporal fascia, fascia lata, or pericranium)
- Planum exposure — dura elevated to expose orbital roofs and planum sphenoidale; if disease involves the planum, optic canals are unroofed to protect intracranial optic nerves
- En bloc ethmoidectomy with osteotomies using sagittal saw; orbital exenteration added if orbital soft tissue invasion confirmed
Bicoronal Incision Technical Note:
- Placed in the true coronal plane at the level of the top of the helix (or slightly anterior)
- Preserves anterior branches of the superficial temporal artery
- High placement maximizes length of vascularized pericranial flap available for reconstruction
- Lateral elevation in subgaleal plane, with an interfascial incision at the temporal lines to protect the frontal branch of the facial nerve
CSF/brain swelling management: lumbar drain, controlled hyperventilation (PCO₂ 25–30 mmHg), mannitol, corticosteroids, withdrawal of 25–50 mL CSF intraoperatively.
Keyhole / Supraorbital Craniotomy
A minimally invasive open technique based on the concept that a small, tailored craniotomy can access deep-seated pathology with limited brain retraction.
- Craniotomy centered anterolaterally at the orbital roof/anterior fossa floor
- Incisions: transciliary, supraciliary, upper blepharoplasty, or transpalpebral
- Orbital osteotomy (Raza modification): increases visualization, limits frontal lobe retraction, expands working space; transpalpebral incision avoids frontalis palsy
- Access: anterior fossa, parasellar region, interpeduncular cistern
- Advantages: no facial scar, minimal brain retraction, wide exposure
2. Craniofacial Disassembly Techniques (Historical / Selected Cases)
Derived from plastic surgery for congenital craniofacial corrections; adapted for skull base by systematically dismantling the craniofacial skeleton to expose the skull base from below the neuraxis, reducing brain retraction:
- Le Fort I and II osteotomies, maxillary splitting
- Removal of the frontonasal unit
- Midfacial degloving with sublabial incisions
These remain in use for very large or very complex tumors but have largely been supplanted by endoscopic techniques.
3. Endoscopic Endonasal Approaches (EEA)
Expanded by Kassam et al. (University of Pittsburgh, 2005) to the full ventral skull base — from crista galli to foramen magnum. This is now the most dynamic area of growth in anterior skull base surgery.
Documented advantages: No facial scars, decreased trauma to normal tissue, decreased hospital length of stay, improved quality of life, diminished morbidity.
Sagittal Plane Modules for Anterior Skull Base
Fig. 176.17 — Sagittal CT showing the three anterior skull base EEA modules:
| Module | Area of Access | Bone Removed | CN at Risk | Common Pathologies | Key Complications |
|---|
| Transfrontal (sagittal) | Posterior table & floor of frontal sinus | Posterior table of frontal sinus | — | Mucocele, frontal osteoma, nasal dermoid, erosive inflammatory disease | CSF leak, orbital hematoma, frontal recess stenosis |
| Transcribriform (sagittal) | Crista galli → planum sphenoidale | Cribriform plate, crista galli | Olfactory (I) | Olfactory groove meningiomas, esthesioneuroblastoma, encephaloceles, CSF leak, sinonasal tumors | CSF leak, anterior cerebral artery bleed, anosmia, orbital hematoma |
| Transplanum / Transtuberculum (sagittal) | Suprasellar region, posterior anterior cranial base | Planum sphenoidale, tuberculum, optic strut, medial clinoid | Optic nerve/chiasm (II) | Planum meningiomas, suprasellar pituitary adenoma, craniopharyngioma, optic nerve glioma | CSF leak, ICA/ophthalmic artery bleed, cavernous sinus bleed, DI, optic nerve injury |
Coronal Plane Modules
| Module | Area of Access | CN at Risk | Pathologies |
|---|
| Supraorbital | Orbital roof | Optic nerve | Fibro-osseous lesions |
| Transorbital | Intraconal lesions inferomedial to optic nerve | Optic nerve | Hemangiomas, schwannomas |
EEA Surgical Setup
Each module begins with bilateral exposure creating a single rectangular cavity in the sphenoid sinus via: right middle turbinectomy → removal of sphenoid rostrum → lateralization of left middle turbinate → bilateral sphenoidectomy extended to medial pterygoid plates → resection of ~1–2 cm of posterior nasal septum.
4. Algorithm for Approach Selection
Fig. 176.18 — Naunheim et al. algorithm:
Key decision points:
- Tumor involves overlying skin, nasal bones, frontal bone, or orbital soft tissue?
- No → endoscopic approach feasible
- No intracranial extension → Endoscopic alone
- Intracranial extension, medial to orbital wall, adequate nasoseptal flap → Endoscopic alone
- Intracranial extension, extension lateral to medial orbital wall → Endoscopic + Craniotomy
- Yes → open transfacial required
- No intracranial extension → Transfacial
- Intracranial extension → Transfacial + Craniotomy
Contraindications to Purely Endonasal Approach
- Involvement of nasal bones or anterior table of frontal sinus
- Overlying skin of nasal dorsum or frontal sinus
- Orbital involvement requiring exenteration
- Need for vascular reconstruction
- Relative: expected very long operative duration
Summary Table: Anterior Skull Base Approaches
| Approach | Access | Best For | Advantage |
|---|
| Anterior craniofacial resection | Bifrontal craniotomy + transfacial | SCC, esthesioneuroblastoma, adenocarcinoma with anterior fossa invasion | Wide exposure, en bloc resection |
| Supraorbital/keyhole craniotomy | Small anterolateral craniotomy | Anterior fossa, parasellar lesions | Minimal retraction, cosmetic |
| Craniofacial disassembly | Facial osteotomies + craniotomy | Very large/complex tumors | Wide inferior exposure |
| EEA Transcribriform | Endonasal | Olfactory groove meningioma, esthesioneuroblastoma | No facial scar, minimal morbidity |
| EEA Transplanum/Transtuberculum | Endonasal | Planum meningioma, craniopharyngioma | Suprasellar access without retraction |
| EEA Transfrontal | Endonasal | Mucocele, osteoma, nasal dermoid | Avoids external incision |
Sources: Cummings Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, 7th ed., Ch. 44 (pp. 873–973) and Ch. 176 (pp. 3360–3368).