I now have all the pieces needed to synthesize a precise diagnostic interpretation. Let me compile the complete analysis.
Vestibular Screening Analysis — Sign-by-Sign Interpretation
Recap of All Findings (Both Sessions)
| Test | Finding |
|---|
| Fukuda (Unterberger) Stepping Test | Rotates >45° to the LEFT |
| Tandem gait | Abnormal |
| Romberg (classical + sharpened) | Positive |
| Head Impulse Test (HIT) | Direction-changing corrective saccades (not a clean unilateral catch-up) |
| Gaze-Evoked Nystagmus | Present — direction changes with gaze direction |
| Skew Deviation | Present |
| Finger-to-Nose | Undershooting (hypometria) |
| Positional tests (Hallpike, Supine Roll) | Normal |
Diagnosis: Central Vestibular Syndrome — Cerebellar/Posterior Fossa Lesion (LEFT SIDE)
This is unequivocally a central vestibular picture, not peripheral. Here is the sign-by-sign reasoning:
1. Fukuda Stepping Test — Rotation >45° LEFT
The Fukuda test reflects unilateral labyrinthine asymmetry. The patient deviates toward the hypofunctional (weaker) side.
"The patient turning clockwise/counterclockwise during the test is considered positive for peripheral vestibular weakness... most sensitive for severe or profound unilateral labyrinthine dysfunction." — Cummings Otolaryngology, 8e
Turning left >45° indicates weakness/suppression of the LEFT vestibular system (or cerebellar pathways on the LEFT). However, this test alone does not distinguish peripheral from central — it just localizes the side.
Key point: In a cerebellar infarction (PICA territory), the cerebellar modulation of the VOR is lost ipsilaterally, producing an apparent "peripheral-like" deviation toward the lesioned side on Fukuda.
2. Head Impulse Test (HIT) — Direction-Changing / No Clean Corrective Saccade
This is the most critical finding for central localization.
In peripheral vestibular disease (vestibular neuritis):
- HIT shows a unilateral catch-up saccade (toward the lesioned side) = POSITIVE
In central disease (cerebellar stroke):
- HIT is normal (no catch-up saccade) OR shows direction-changing saccades = NEGATIVE/abnormal in a way inconsistent with peripheral
"If the horizontal head impulse test was normal (i.e., no catch-up saccade), there was skew deviation, or direction-changing nystagmus → 100% sensitivity and 90% specificity for stroke." — Cummings Otolaryngology, 8e (HINTS studies)
"A negative head-thrust test (no corrective saccade) or skew deviation could be the key indicators of a central rather than a peripheral vestibular lesion." — Bradley & Daroff's Neurology
Direction-changing corrective saccades on HIT = CENTRAL SIGN.
3. Gaze-Evoked Nystagmus — Direction-Changing
This is pathognomonic of central/cerebellar dysfunction.
"Direction-changing gaze-evoked nystagmus: patient looks to the LEFT and has left-beating nystagmus; looks to the RIGHT and has right-beating nystagmus... characteristic of brainstem or cerebellar strokes." — Bradley & Daroff's Neurology
"Horizontal nystagmus that changes direction with gaze (gaze-evoked nystagmus) is characteristic of lesions of the cerebellar pathways." — Harrison's Principles, 22e
In peripheral disease, nystagmus is unidirectional and follows Alexander's Law (increases when looking toward fast phase). Direction-changing nystagmus = CENTRAL.
The mechanism: failure of the neural integrator (flocculus/nodulus of cerebellum + nucleus prepositus hypoglossi) to hold eccentric gaze → eyes drift back to midline → corrective fast phase in the direction of gaze.
4. Skew Deviation — Present
Skew deviation (vertical misalignment of the eyes) = disruption of central otolithic pathways.
"Skew deviation and the ocular tilt reaction occur with vestibular nuclei and medullary lesions... The full ocular tilt reaction is not often observed with peripheral vestibular lesions." — Cummings Otolaryngology
"Lateral medullary lesions damage the otolithic vestibular nuclei; patients with Wallenberg syndrome often demonstrate skew deviation with hypotropia on the side of the lesion." — Localization in Clinical Neurology, 8e
Skew deviation with a positive HINTS profile (normal or direction-changing HIT + direction-changing nystagmus + skew) = stroke until proven otherwise.
5. Finger-to-Nose — Undershooting (Hypometria)
Dysmetria (under/overshooting on finger-to-nose) = cerebellar sign.
"Additional cerebellar function tests can be useful adjuncts — finger to nose, rapid hand alternation, and heel-to-shin testing may detect cerebellar dysfunction which can affect balance." — Cummings Otolaryngology
"Overshooting or undershooting of voluntary movements (dysmetria)... are all cerebellar signs." — Adams & Victor's Neurology
Undershooting specifically = hypometria, seen with cerebellar hemisphere lesions. This confirms the lesion is ipsilateral cerebellar hemisphere (LEFT), since finger-to-nose dysmetria is ipsilateral to the lesion.
6. Positional Tests (Dix-Hallpike, Supine Roll) — NORMAL
This is highly important. Normal positional tests EXCLUDE BPPV as a cause. This further confirms:
- No canalolithiasis
- No cupulolithiasis
- The canal organs are not the primary pathology
HINTS Summary in This Patient
| HINTS Component | Finding | Interpretation |
|---|
| H — Head Impulse Test | Direction-changing / no clean unilateral saccade | CENTRAL |
| I — Nystagmus | Direction-changing, gaze-evoked | CENTRAL |
| N — No skew | Skew deviation PRESENT | CENTRAL |
All three HINTS components point CENTRAL → Stroke until proven otherwise.
Final Diagnosis
Left Cerebellar Infarction (likely PICA or SCA territory, LEFT side)
Localizing signs pointing LEFT:
- Fukuda deviation LEFT → left cerebellar/vestibular hypofunction
- Finger-to-nose undershooting (hypometria) — ipsilateral to the cerebellar lesion
Central (not peripheral) confirmed by:
- Direction-changing gaze-evoked nystagmus
- Direction-changing/absent corrective saccade on HIT
- Skew deviation
- Finger-to-nose dysmetria (absent in peripheral vertigo)
- No BPPV on positional testing
- Persistent imbalance >15 days (peripheral vestibular neuritis recovers faster)
Immediate Action Plan
- MRI brain with DWI + FLAIR (urgently — confirms infarct; at 15 days, lesion will be clearly visible)
- MRA posterior circulation — assess vertebral artery, PICA, basilar
- Cardiology workup — ECG, Holter, Echo (embolic source)
- Vascular risk factor control — BP, HbA1c, lipids
- Antiplatelet + statin (if ischemic stroke confirmed)
- Vestibular rehabilitation referral — balance physiotherapy
Why Peripheral Is EXCLUDED
| Feature | This Patient | Peripheral (Neuritis) |
|---|
| HIT | Direction-changing saccade | Unilateral catch-up saccade |
| Nystagmus | Direction-changing | Unidirectional |
| Skew | Present | Absent |
| Finger-to-nose | Dysmetric | Normal |
| Positional tests | Normal | May be abnormal |
| Duration of imbalance | 15 days, persistent | Usually resolving |
The clinical picture is a central vestibular syndrome localized to the left cerebellar hemisphere, consistent with left PICA territory cerebellar infarction.
Sources: Cummings Otolaryngology, 8e; Bradley & Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice; Adams & Victor's Principles of Neurology, 12e; Harrison's Principles, 22e; Localization in Clinical Neurology, 8e