I now have comprehensive information from multiple surgical textbooks. Let me compile the complete, well-structured surgery viva answer.
Neck Swelling - Surgery Viva
APPROACH TO A NECK SWELLING
The classic surgical approach to any lump applies here - the 7 S's of a swelling:
- Site - Midline vs. Lateral; which triangle of neck?
- Size - Dimensions in cm
- Shape - Ovoid, spherical, irregular
- Surface - Smooth, nodular
- Consistency - Soft, firm, hard (stony hard), cystic, fluctuant
- Skin over swelling - Normal, inflamed, fixed
- Special tests - Pulsatility, compressibility, transillumination, bruit, movement with swallowing, movement with tongue protrusion (thyroglossal)
CLASSIFICATION BY SITE
MIDLINE NECK SWELLINGS
(from above downwards)
| Level | Swelling |
|---|
| Submental | Ludwig's angina, submental lymph nodes, sublingual dermoid, lipoma |
| Hyoid bone level | Thyroglossal cyst, subhyoid bursitis |
| Thyroid region | Goitre (isthmus, pyramidal lobe), enlarged lymph nodes, lipoma |
| Suprasternal | Lipoma in space of Burns, retrosternal goitre, thymic swelling |
| Anywhere midline | Dermoid cyst |
LATERAL NECK SWELLINGS by Triangle
| Triangle | Swellings |
|---|
| Submandibular | Lymph nodes, enlarged submandibular salivary gland, deep/plunging ranula, jaw growth extension |
| Carotid triangle | Carotid aneurysm, carotid body tumour, branchial cyst, branchiogenic carcinoma; thyroid swellings (deep to SCM), sternomastoid tumour (neonate) |
| Posterior triangle | Enlarged supraclavicular lymph nodes (including Virchow's node on left), cystic hygroma, pharyngeal pouch, subclavian aneurysm, aberrant thyroid, cervical rib, lipoma |
CLASSIFICATION BY CHARACTER
Acute Swellings
- Cellulitis, Ludwig's angina
- Boil, carbuncle
- Acute lymphadenitis
Chronic Swellings
| Type | Examples |
|---|
| Cystic | Branchial cyst, thyroglossal cyst, dermoid cyst, cystic hygroma, sebaceous cyst, cystic adenoma of thyroid, cold abscess |
| Solid | Thyroid swelling, branchiogenic carcinoma, sternomastoid tumour, lymph nodes |
| Pulsatile | Carotid/subclavian aneurysm, carotid body tumour, lymph node with transmitted pulsation, primary toxic goitre |
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS (COMPREHENSIVE)
1. Inflammatory / Infective
| Cause | Key Features |
|---|
| Reactive lymphadenitis | Tender, firm, mobile nodes; URTI/tonsillitis history |
| Tuberculous cervical lymphadenitis | Most common cause of cervical LN in Indian subcontinent; matted nodes, "cold abscess", "collar stud abscess", sinus tract formation; no pain/fever early |
| Bacterial adenitis | Streptococcus, Staphylococcus; tender, hot, may suppurate |
| Viral | EBV (infectious mononucleosis), HIV, CMV - bilateral, multiple nodes |
| Cat scratch disease | Bartonella henselae; unilateral nodes, history of cat scratch |
| Sialadenitis | Submandibular/parotid swelling; related to meals (submandibular duct stone) |
| Ludwig's angina | Diffuse, bilateral, floor of mouth + submental; life-threatening; oedema glottis risk |
| Thyroiditis | Tender thyroid, fever, may have transient thyrotoxicosis |
2. Congenital / Developmental
Thyroglossal Cyst (most important midline swelling)
- Origin: Persistence of thyroglossal duct (thyroid descends from foramen caecum to neck)
- Age: Mainly children, but any age
- Site: Midline, just below the hyoid bone (most common); can be at any level from foramen caecum to isthmus
- Pathognomonic sign: Moves upwards on swallowing AND on tongue protrusion (tethered to base of tongue via the tract)
- Character: Cystic, smooth, non-tender, fluctuant
- Complications: Infection, abscess, fistula, malignancy (papillary carcinoma in 1%)
- Investigation: Ultrasound to confirm (must confirm normal thyroid inferiorly); CT scan
- Treatment: Sistrunk operation - excision of cyst + central portion of hyoid bone + tract up to base of tongue (prevents recurrence)
Branchial Cyst
- Origin: Remnants of second branchial cleft (most common); lined by squamous epithelium
- Age: Young adults (does not manifest in childhood despite being congenital)
- Site: Junction of upper 1/3 and middle 1/3 of sternomastoid, at its anterior border (half in front, half behind SCM); upper/lateral neck
- Character: Soft, ovoid, fluctuant; surface smooth; long axis runs forwards and downwards
- Transillumination: Usually NEGATIVE (content is thick, turbid white fluid containing cholesterol crystals and desquamated epithelial cells)
- Diagnostic test: FNA shows cholesterol crystals - pathognomonic
- Key point: In patients >35 years, always exclude metastatic lymph node (necrotic) before assuming branchial cyst
- Treatment: Complete surgical excision (passes superficial to hypoglossal and glossopharyngeal nerves, deep to posterior belly of digastric; identify spinal accessory nerve)
Branchial Fistula
- Persistent second branchial cleft
- External opening: lower 1/3 of neck, anterior border of SCM
- Internal opening: anterior pillar of fauces, behind the tonsil
- May be unilateral or bilateral
Cystic Hygroma (Lymphangioma)
- Origin: Congenital lymphangioma - abnormal lymphatic development
- Age: Infants and children (usually present at birth or by age 2)
- Site: Root of neck, posterior triangle; may extend to axilla, mediastinum
- Character: Multilocular, brilliantly transilluminates (clear fluid); soft; fluid can be compressed from one locule to another; shows impulse on coughing if mediastinal extension
- Treatment: Sclerotherapy (OK-432, bleomycin) or surgical excision
Dermoid Cyst
- Midline, anywhere; smooth, doughy, non-fluctuant; does NOT transilluminate well; does NOT move with swallowing
Laryngocele
- Air-filled or mucus-filled; arises from laryngeal ventricle
- May be internal (within thyroid cartilage) or external (protrudes through thyrohyoid membrane)
- Increases with Valsalva/coughing; reducible
Cervical Rib
- Posterior triangle, supraclavicular; may cause thoracic outlet syndrome (vascular/neurological symptoms in arm)
3. Neoplastic - Benign
| Tumour | Features |
|---|
| Goitre | Moves with swallowing (attached to trachea/larynx); midline + bilateral; multiple types |
| Solitary thyroid nodule | Moves with swallowing; consider malignancy (10-15% risk) |
| Carotid body tumour (Paraganglioma) | At carotid bifurcation (C3-4 level, anterior to SCM); pulsatile, bruit; moves laterally but NOT vertically ("Fontaine's sign" or "potato tumour"); transmitted pulsation from carotid |
| Salivary gland tumour | Parotid (angle of jaw), submandibular; pleomorphic adenoma most common |
| Lipoma | Soft, lobulated, non-tender; posterior triangle common |
| Neurofibroma/Schwannoma | Moves horizontally but NOT vertically (tethered to nerve) |
4. Neoplastic - Malignant
Cervical Lymph Node Metastasis (most common malignant neck mass in adults >40)
- Features: Stony hard, irregular surface, fixed to skin or deep structures, painless, rapidly growing
- Majority: Deep to anterior border of SCM
- Search for primary:
- Above clavicle: Oral cavity (floor of mouth, tongue), tonsil, nasopharynx, larynx, thyroid, external auditory meatus, parotid
- Left supraclavicular (Virchow's node / Troisier's sign): Infraclavicular primary - stomach, colon, lung, breast, ovary, testis (via thoracic duct)
- Bilateral supraclavicular: Lymphoma or infraclavicular primary
Primary Lymphoma (Hodgkin's/Non-Hodgkin's)
- Young adults or elderly; rubbery-firm, multiple nodes; systemic "B symptoms" (fever, night sweats, weight loss)
- Hodgkin's: cervical nodes involved in 60-70% of cases
Thyroid Carcinoma
- Moves with swallowing; hard, irregular; may cause hoarseness (recurrent laryngeal nerve invasion), dysphagia, dyspnoea
KEY VIVA QUESTIONS
Q: What is the most important clinical sign of a thyroglossal cyst?
A: It moves upward on swallowing AND on protrusion of the tongue (pathognomonic - tethered to the foramen caecum via the tract through the hyoid bone).
Q: What is the Sistrunk operation?
A: Excision of thyroglossal cyst along with the central portion (body) of the hyoid bone and the tract up to the base of the tongue. Removing just the cyst without the hyoid leads to high recurrence rates.
Q: What is the content of a branchial cyst and how do you confirm diagnosis?
A: Thick, turbid fluid containing cholesterol crystals and desquamated squamous epithelial cells. FNA revealing cholesterol crystals is diagnostic.
Q: What is the difference between cystic hygroma and branchial cyst on transillumination?
A: Cystic hygroma transilluminates brilliantly (clear lymphatic fluid). Branchial cyst does NOT transilluminate (thick, turbid content).
Q: What is Virchow's (Troisier's) node?
A: An enlarged left supraclavicular lymph node due to metastasis from an infraclavicular primary tumour (classically gastric carcinoma). It receives lymph via the thoracic duct.
Q: What is a "collar stud" abscess?
A: Occurs in tuberculous cervical lymphadenitis when the deep cervical fascia is breached - pus tracks from a deep abscess through a small opening in the fascia to form a superficial abscess, giving a dumbbell/collar stud shape. Clinically: fluctuation is more easily elicited in the superficial component.
Q: What is a carotid body tumour and how does it differ from a pulsatile lymph node?
A: Carotid body tumour is a paraganglioma at the carotid bifurcation. It is truly pulsatile (expansile) with an audible bruit, and can be moved laterally but NOT vertically ("potato tumour" / Fontaine's sign). A lymph node near the carotid only shows transmitted (not expansile) pulsation.
Q: Which neck lumps move with swallowing?
A: Thyroid swellings, thyroglossal cyst (also moves with tongue protrusion), subhyoid bursitis (attached to hyoid). These structures are attached to the pretracheal fascia.
Q: What are the features of malignant vs. benign lymph nodes?
| Feature | Benign | Malignant |
|---|
| Tenderness | Present | Absent |
| Consistency | Firm/soft | Stony hard |
| Surface | Smooth | Nodular/irregular |
| Mobility | Mobile | Fixed (late) |
| Skin | Normal | May be adherent |
| Size | Usually <2 cm | Often >2 cm |
Q: What is Ludwig's angina?
A: Severe, rapidly spreading bilateral cellulitis of the floor of the mouth involving submandibular, submental, and sublingual spaces. It is a surgical emergency - the danger is oedema of the glottis causing asphyxia. Caused by dental infection (usually mandibular molar). Management: airway protection, IV antibiotics, surgical decompression.
INVESTIGATIONS FOR NECK SWELLING
| Investigation | Purpose |
|---|
| Ultrasound neck | First-line; cystic vs. solid, thyroid nodule assessment, guide FNAC |
| FNAC | Cytological diagnosis (lymphoma, metastasis, thyroid) |
| CT neck with contrast | Assess extent, vascular involvement, deep structures, staging |
| MRI | Soft tissue delineation, parapharyngeal lesions |
| X-ray chest/neck | Tracheal deviation, mediastinal widening, cervical rib |
| Thyroid function tests | If thyroid swelling suspected |
| Mantoux/IGRA | Suspected TB lymphadenitis |
| LDH, ESR, PET-CT | Lymphoma staging |
| Barium swallow | Pharyngeal pouch |
| Panendoscopy | Search for primary in head and neck malignancy |
Sources: S Das Manual on Clinical Surgery 13e, Chapter 26 & 27; Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery 28e, Chapter 52; Sabiston Textbook of Surgery; Scott-Brown's Otorhinolaryngology & Head and Neck Surgery, Chapter 36; Rosen's Emergency Medicine