Here is a complete, step-by-step account of the clinical examination of pleomorphic adenoma, structured as it would be conducted at the bedside or in an OSCE setting.
Clinical Examination of Pleomorphic Adenoma
Step 1: General Observation (From the End of the Bed)
Before touching the patient, stand back and observe:
- A visible swelling in the pre-auricular/parotid region, below the ear, pushing the ear lobe upward and outward
- No obvious facial asymmetry from nerve weakness
- Patient typically appears comfortable and in no distress (painless condition)
- Assess whether the swelling is unilateral or bilateral
Step 2: History Points that Guide Examination
| Question | Expected Answer in PSA |
|---|
| How long has it been there? | Months to many years - very slow growth |
| Is it painful? | No - painless |
| Any facial weakness? | No - facial nerve intact |
| Any sudden recent increase in size? | No (if yes - alarm for malignant transformation) |
| Any difficulty opening mouth / swallowing? | Usually no (deep lobe may cause dysphagia) |
Step 3: Inspection
Site and Extent
The parotid region is the most common location (>80% of cases). Inspect systematically:
For parotid PSA:
- Swelling below and in front of the ear, at the parotid tail
- The ear lobe is elevated and pushed outward - this is pathognomonic of parotid origin
- The swelling fills the space between the mastoid process posteriorly and the ramus of mandible anteriorly
- Lower border may extend toward the upper neck
Pre-auricular swelling in PSA with surgical markings:
Large pleomorphic adenoma of the parotid: note the surgical markings outlining the extent of the swelling anterior and inferior to the ear (Scott-Brown's Otorhinolaryngology, p. 162)
Gross neglected PSA (untreated for 15 years):
"Double head" - neglected parotid pleomorphic adenoma grown over 15 years, illustrating the enormous proportions these tumors can reach if left untreated (Bailey and Love, p. 861)
What to Note on Inspection
| Feature | Expected Finding |
|---|
| Skin color | Normal - no erythema, no discoloration |
| Skin surface | Smooth, no ulceration, no peau d'orange |
| Skin fixation | Skin moves freely over the swelling |
| Shape | Smooth, rounded, or lobulated contour |
| Scars | Check for previous surgery (recurrent PSA) |
| Facial symmetry | Symmetrical - no drooping, no lagophthalmos |
| Mouth opening | Ask patient to open mouth widely - look for paratonsillar/soft palate bulge (deep lobe tumor) |
Important: Ask the patient to open their mouth. If the tumor arises from accessory parotid tissue along Stensen's duct, it may only become visible or more prominent when the coronoid process moves forward - pushing the tumor outward.
Step 4: Palpation
This is the most informative part of the examination.
Approach
- Warm hands
- Stand to the side and slightly behind the patient
- Use both hands to compare both sides
- Always palpate gently first
Characteristics to Elicit
| Feature | Method | Expected Finding in PSA |
|---|
| Temperature | Dorsum of examining hand | Normal - not warm |
| Tenderness | Gentle pressure | Non-tender |
| Size | Measure in two dimensions | Usually 2-5 cm; can be larger if long-standing |
| Shape | Trace margins | Round or ovoid |
| Surface | Roll fingers over swelling | Smooth or bosselated (lobulated) |
| Consistency | Compress gently | Firm-rubbery typically; soft if myxoid-dominant; hard if chondroid-dominant |
| Margins | Edge of swelling | Well-defined, clearly demarcated |
| Mobility | Move in horizontal and vertical planes | Mobile in all directions - not fixed to skin or deep tissues |
| Skin fixation | Pinch skin over the swelling | Skin moves freely - not tethered |
| Deep fixation | Ask patient to clench teeth (masseter contracts, fixes parotid tissue) | Normal parotid tissue fixes; PSA should become less mobile on clenching if within the gland |
| Fluctuance | Two-finger test | Usually absent; myxoid tumors may appear fluctuant |
| Transillumination | If fluctuant | Negative (solid tumor) |
| Pulsatility | Feel for expansile pulsation | Absent |
Key clinical point on consistency:
The firmness varies directly with the stromal composition - soft in myxoid-dominant tumors, hard in tumors with extensive chondroid or collagenous stroma. This variation in consistency on palpation is itself a characteristic feature of PSA.
Scott-Brown's Otorhinolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery, p. 162
Step 5: Facial Nerve Assessment (MANDATORY in All Parotid Swellings)
Formally test all 5 branches of the facial nerve (CN VII). Record findings for each:
| Branch | Test | Expected in Benign PSA |
|---|
| Temporal | "Raise your eyebrows" | Normal - wrinkles symmetrical |
| Zygomatic | "Close your eyes tightly" | Normal - eyes close fully and symmetrically |
| Buccal | "Smile and show me your teeth" / "Puff out your cheeks" | Normal - symmetrical |
| Marginal mandibular | "Pull down your lower lip" | Normal - symmetrical |
| Cervical | "Tighten your neck muscles" / platysma contraction | Normal |
Any facial nerve palsy = red flag. In benign PSA, the facial nerve is ALWAYS intact. Facial palsy strongly indicates malignancy - either carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma or a primary malignant tumor.
Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, p. 861
Step 6: Intraoral Examination
Always examine inside the mouth for every parotid or salivary gland swelling.
Parotid Assessment Intraorally
-
Stensen's duct orifice - opposite the upper 2nd molar tooth (parotid papilla):
- Massage the gland from behind forward
- Clear saliva should flow freely = normal
- Turbid or purulent discharge = sialadenitis/sialadenosis (not PSA)
-
Paratonsillar bulge - ask patient to open wide and say "Aah":
- A deep lobe PSA pushing through the stylomandibular tunnel presents as a medially displaced tonsil or bulging of the soft palate/lateral pharyngeal wall
- This is the "dumbbell tumor" - one lobe palpable externally, one palpable intraorally
Minor Salivary Gland PSA (Hard Palate)
Most commonly found on the posterior-lateral hard palate:
- Smooth, firm, dome-shaped submucosal swelling
- Mucosa over it is intact and normal-colored
- Non-tender, non-pulsatile
- Slowly enlarging over months-years
Minor salivary gland PSA on the hard palate:
Minor salivary gland pleomorphic adenoma of the hard palate - smooth, submucosal, dome-shaped swelling with intact overlying mucosa (Cummings Otolaryngology, p. 1647)
Step 7: Bimanual Palpation (for Deep Lobe / Parapharyngeal Extension)
For suspected deep lobe involvement:
- Place one finger intraorally against the tonsil/lateral pharyngeal wall
- Place the other hand externally over the parotid
- A deep lobe extension or dumbbell tumor will be felt compressible between both fingers
- Always examine both sides for comparison
Step 8: Regional Lymph Node Examination
Systematically palpate all cervical lymph node groups:
| Group | Method |
|---|
| Parotid/preauricular nodes | In front of tragus |
| Periparotid nodes | Over the parotid gland itself |
| Jugulodigastric (Level II) | Below and anterior to the ear at the angle of mandible |
| Upper, mid, lower deep cervical chain | Along the sternocleidomastoid |
| Posterior triangle | Behind SCM |
| Submental / submandibular | Below the chin / under the mandible |
Expected finding in benign PSA: No palpable lymphadenopathy
Lymphadenopathy = red flag for malignancy or metastatic disease
Step 9: Examination of Other Salivary Glands
Always check the remaining salivary glands:
- Contralateral parotid: Usually normal; bilateral parotid swelling is characteristic of Warthin's tumor or systemic disease (sarcoidosis, Sjögren's), not PSA
- Submandibular glands: Bimanually palpate (one finger under chin externally, one finger on floor of mouth intraorally) - PSA can arise here
- Sublingual glands: Inspect and palpate intraorally
Step 10: Summary - Benign PSA vs. Malignancy Alarm Signs
| Feature | Benign PSA | Red Flag (Malignant) |
|---|
| Pain | Absent | Present |
| Facial nerve | Fully intact | Any palsy |
| Growth rate | Slow (years) | Rapid acceleration |
| Skin | Normal, free | Fixed, ulcerated |
| Consistency | Soft-firm-rubbery | Hard, stony |
| Mobility | Mobile | Fixed to skin or deep |
| Lymph nodes | Not palpable | Enlarged |
| Trismus | Absent | May be present |
| Duct secretion | Clear saliva | Unchanged / blood-stained |
Complete Examination Summary (OSCE-Style)
"This patient has a painless, slow-growing, well-defined, firm, mobile, bosselated swelling in the right parotid region measuring approximately [X] cm. The overlying skin is normal and freely mobile. The ear lobe is elevated. There is no facial nerve weakness on formal cranial nerve testing. Intraorally, the right Stensen's duct orifice is producing clear saliva; there is no paratonsillar bulge. Regional lymph nodes are not palpable. These findings are consistent with a pleomorphic adenoma of the right parotid gland."
- Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery 28th Edition, p. 861
- Scott-Brown's Otorhinolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery, p. 162
- Cummings Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, p. 1647