TRALI Vs TACO short note in MD Anaesthesia
TRALI TACO differentiation diagnosis
| TRALI | TACO | |
|---|---|---|
| Incidence | 1:5000 transfused units | 1-6% of transfused recipients |
| Mortality trend | Declining (female donor deferral policy) | Rising (improved reporting) |
| Leading cause of transfusion death | Previously #1 | Currently #1 in USA |
| Feature | TRALI | TACO |
|---|---|---|
| Onset | During or up to 6h post-transfusion | During or up to 6h post-transfusion |
| Type of edema | Non-cardiogenic (exudative) | Cardiogenic (hydrostatic/transudative) |
| Blood pressure | Hypotension (32% cases) | Hypertension (hallmark) |
| Temperature | Fever (33% cases) | Afebrile |
| Cyanosis | Present (25%) | Present |
| JVP / CVP | Normal or low | Elevated |
| Heart sounds | Normal S3/S4 uncommon | S3 gallop, signs of LVF |
| Chest X-ray | Bilateral fluffy infiltrates, no cardiomegaly, no pleural effusion | Cardiomegaly, bilateral infiltrates, pleural effusions |
| Fluid balance | No obvious positive balance | Positive fluid balance |
| WBC | Leukopenia (neutrophil sequestration in lung) | Normal WBC |
| BNP/NT-proBNP | Normal or mildly raised | Markedly elevated |
| Response to diuresis | Caution - may worsen hypotension | Improves dramatically |
| Risk factors | Critically ill, multi-organ failure, haematological malignancy, prior lung injury | CHF, CKD, elderly, female, obesity, receiving multiple units rapidly |
| Investigation | TRALI | TACO |
|---|---|---|
| BNP | Normal | Elevated (>250 pg/mL) |
| Echo | Normal LV function, PCWP ≤ 18 mmHg | Reduced EF, PCWP > 18 mmHg |
| Pulmonary artery wedge pressure | ≤ 18 mmHg (non-cardiogenic) | > 18 mmHg (cardiogenic) |
| Protein content of edema fluid | High (exudative) - EF:serum protein ratio > 0.75 | Low (transudative) |
| CXR | Bilateral infiltrates, no cardiomegaly | Cardiomegaly + pleural effusions |
| Response to furosemide | Poor/may worsen | Rapid improvement |
| HLA/HNA antibodies (donor) | Often positive | Negative |
| WBC | Leukopenia | Normal |
| TRALI | TACO | |
|---|---|---|
| Primary strategy | Use male-only or non-alloimmunized donors for plasma/platelets | Restrictive transfusion strategy; avoid unnecessary units |
| Other measures | Pre-storage leukoreduction; solvent-detergent treated plasma; screen donors for HLA antibodies | Slow transfusion rate in high-risk patients; identify at-risk patients pre-transfusion |
| Patient selection | No specific restriction | Optimise volume status before transfusion; reduce plasma content of platelet units in high-risk |
Retry
TRALI TACO transfusion lung injury
| TRALI | TACO | |
|---|---|---|
| Incidence | ~1 per 5000 transfused units | 1-6% of transfused recipients |
| Leading cause of transfusion-related death | Previously #1 (mid-2000s) | Currently #1 in USA |
| Annual US fatalities (2017 FDA report) | 5 (possible/likely) | 11 (possible/likely) |
| Trend | Declining (donor deferral policy) | Rising (better reporting) |
TACO has overtaken TRALI as the leading transfusion-related killer in the USA, largely due to male-only plasma donor policies that reduced antibody-mediated TRALI, combined with improved TACO surveillance. (Tietz 7e)
| TRALI | TACO | |
|---|---|---|
| Recipient | Critically ill, sepsis, trauma, surgery, haematological malignancy, alcohol abuse, smoking, mechanical ventilation (high airway pressure), positive fluid balance | Cardiac failure, CKD, elderly (>70 yrs), female sex, Caucasian race, obesity, chronic lung disease, ICU patients, hypoalbuminaemia |
| Donor/Product | Multiparous female donor, FFP, pooled platelets, high-titre HLA/HNA antibodies, prolonged blood storage | Rapid transfusion rate, large-volume transfusion, multiple units |
| Feature | TRALI | TACO |
|---|---|---|
| Type of edema | Non-cardiogenic (exudative, high-protein) | Cardiogenic (transudative, low-protein) |
| Onset | During transfusion or up to 6h after | During or up to 6h after transfusion |
| Blood pressure | Hypotension (32% of cases) | Hypertension (hallmark finding) |
| Temperature | Fever (33% of cases) | Afebrile |
| Respiratory distress | Acute - tachypnoea, dyspnoea, cyanosis | Acute - dyspnoea, orthopnoea |
| Sputum | Pink frothy sputum possible | Pink frothy sputum |
| JVP/CVP | Normal or low | Elevated |
| Heart sounds | Normal | S3 gallop, signs of LVF |
| Peripheral oedema | Absent | Present |
| PaO2/FiO2 | < 300 | < 300 |
| Chest X-ray | Bilateral fluffy infiltrates, no cardiomegaly, no pleural effusions | Cardiomegaly, bilateral infiltrates, pleural effusions, Kerley B lines |
| WBC count | Leukopenia (neutrophil lung sequestration) | Normal |
| Fluid balance | No excess positive balance | Positive fluid balance |
| BNP / NT-proBNP | Normal or mildly elevated | Markedly elevated (>250 pg/mL) |
| PCWP (if measured) | ≤18 mmHg | >18 mmHg |
| Echocardiography | Normal LV function, no LVH | Reduced EF, diastolic dysfunction, elevated filling pressures |
| Edema fluid protein | High (exudative) - EF:serum ratio >0.75 | Low (transudative) |
| Response to diuretics | Poor; may worsen hypotension | Rapid improvement |
| Investigation | TRALI | TACO |
|---|---|---|
| BNP | Normal / mildly raised | Elevated (>250 pg/mL) - most useful bedside marker |
| CXR | Bilateral infiltrates, no cardiomegaly | Cardiomegaly, pleural effusions, cephalization |
| Echocardiography | Normal LV function | Impaired EF, elevated filling pressures |
| PAWP | ≤18 mmHg | >18 mmHg |
| Edema fluid analysis | Protein-rich (exudative) | Protein-poor (transudative) |
| CBC | Leukopenia | Normal |
| HLA/HNA antibody (donor) | Often positive | Negative |
| Response to furosemide | Minimal / worsens | Rapid improvement |
| Strategy | TRALI | TACO |
|---|---|---|
| Primary | Use male-only or non-alloimmunized donors for plasma and platelet products | Restrictive transfusion strategy - avoid unnecessary transfusions |
| Product measures | Pre-storage leukoreduction; solvent-detergent treated plasma; screen donors for HLA antibodies | Slow transfusion rate in high-risk patients; reduce plasma content of platelet units |
| Patient measures | Avoid unnecessary transfusion in critically ill | Identify at-risk patients pre-transfusion; optimise volume status before transfusion |
| Parameter | TRALI | TACO |
|---|---|---|
| Mechanism | Immune-mediated lung injury (non-cardiogenic) | Volume/pressure overload (cardiogenic) |
| BP | Hypotension | Hypertension |
| Fever | Yes | No |
| CVP | Low/normal | High |
| BNP | Normal | Elevated |
| CXR | No cardiomegaly | Cardiomegaly + effusions |
| WBC | Leukopenia | Normal |
| PCWP | ≤18 | >18 |
| Treatment | Supportive + fluid if hypotensive | Diuresis |
| Can they coexist? | Yes | Yes |
Activated clotting time - short note in MD Anaesthesia
"activated clotting time" heparin monitoring cardiopulmonary bypass
| Clinical Situation | Target ACT |
|---|---|
| Normal (no heparin) | 80-120 seconds (107 ± 13 sec) |
| Minimum safe for CPB initiation | >300 seconds |
| Standard target during CPB | >400-480 seconds |
| Off-pump CABG / MICS | >300 seconds |
| ECMO anticoagulation | 180-220 seconds (~1.5× normal) |
| PCI / cardiac catheterisation | 250-350 seconds |
| ECLS/LVAD (institution-specific) | 160-200 seconds |
| Aprotinin use during CPB | Maintain celite-ACT >750 sec (or use kaolin-ACT >400 sec) |
The basis for the 400-480 second CPB target comes from Bull et al. (1975) and Doty et al. (1979). Evidence is largely anecdotal but universally adopted. (Miller's Anesthesia 10e)
| Activator | Notes |
|---|---|
| Celite (diatomaceous earth) | More commonly used; prolonged by aprotinin (independent of heparin effect) |
| Kaolin | Not affected by aprotinin; preferred when aprotinin is used |
| Glass particles | Also used; different sensitivity profile |
Key point: Results from different ACT platforms are NOT interchangeable - each device and activator produces different normal and therapeutic ranges. A device-specific protocol is essential. (Tietz 7e)
Aprotinin effect: If aprotinin is used, celite-ACT should be maintained at >750 seconds (nearly double normal CPB target), while kaolin-ACT remains unaffected and should be maintained at >400 seconds. This is because aprotinin prolongs celite-ACT in a dose-dependent manner independently of heparin. (Tietz 7e)
| Factor | Effect on ACT | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Hemodilution | Prolongs (in heparinised patients) | Dilution of coagulation factors |
| Hypothermia | Prolongs | Slows enzymatic reactions |
| Thrombocytopenia | Prolongs | Reduced platelet contribution to clotting |
| Platelet inhibitors | Prolongs | Impaired platelet activation |
| Platelet lysis | Shortens | Release of platelet phospholipids accelerates clotting |
| Aprotinin | Prolongs celite-ACT only | Anti-fibrinolytic drug; direct activator interference |
| Surgical stress | Shortens | Pro-coagulant tissue factor release |
| Factor XII / HMWK / prekallikrein deficiency | Grossly prolongs | Contact phase compromised - test becomes unusable |
| Test | ACT | aPTT | Anti-Xa | Heparin concentration (protamine titration) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heparin range | High-dose (CPB, ECMO) | Moderate-dose (therapeutic) | All ranges | High-dose (CPB) |
| Point-of-care | Yes | No (lab-based usually) | No | Yes (Hepcon HMS) |
| Affected by hypothermia | Yes (prolonged) | Yes | No | No |
| Affected by hemodilution | Yes (prolonged) | Yes | No | No |
| Affected by aprotinin | Yes (celite-ACT) | No | No | No |
| AT deficiency impact | Undetected | Undetected | Indirect | Undetected |
| Sensitivity at low [heparin] | Poor | Good | Excellent | Good |
| Best for | CPB, ECMO, PCI | Therapeutic UFH | LMWH; low-dose UFH | Adjunct to ACT in CPB |
| Limitations | Platform variability; factor deficiency interference | Lab delay; false prolongation | Not widely POC | Doesn't assess anticoagulant effect directly |
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Introduced by | Hattersley, 1966 |
| Sample type | Whole blood (POC) |
| Activators | Celite, kaolin, glass |
| Normal value | 80-120 seconds |
| CPB target | >400-480 seconds |
| ECMO target | 180-220 seconds |
| Mechanism monitored | Intrinsic + common pathway |
| Main use | High-dose UFH monitoring |
| Key limitation | Poor correlation with heparin level; platform variability |
| Aprotinin effect | Prolongs celite-ACT only (not kaolin) |
| Heparin resistance | ACT <400 sec despite >600 units/kg; treat with AT/FFP |
| Reversal check | ACT returns to baseline after protamine |
Prothrombin time , INR, APTT - short note in MD Anaesthesia
prothrombin time INR perioperative coagulation monitoring
| Pathway | Tests It | Key Factors |
|---|---|---|
| Extrinsic pathway (initiation) | PT / INR | Tissue factor (TF) + Factor VII |
| Intrinsic pathway (amplification, contact) | aPTT | XII, XI, IX, VIII, Prekallikrein, HMWK |
| Common pathway | Both PT and aPTT | X, V, II (thrombin), I (fibrinogen) |
Important caveat: The classic cascade is an oversimplification. Individuals with Factor XII, prekallikrein, or HMWK deficiencies have a prolonged aPTT but do not bleed clinically, because in vivo haemostasis is primarily initiated by the TF-VIIa complex. (Miller's Anesthesia 10e)
| Parameter | Normal Range |
|---|---|
| PT | 11-14 seconds (lab-specific; typically ~12-15 sec) |
| INR | 0.9-1.1 (normal, no anticoagulation) |
| Therapeutic INR (warfarin - DVT/PE/AF) | 2.0-3.0 |
| Therapeutic INR (mechanical heart valve) | 2.5-3.5 |
| Parameter | Range |
|---|---|
| aPTT (normal) | 25-35 seconds (laboratory-specific; ranges vary widely) |
| Therapeutic aPTT (UFH therapy) | 1.5-2.5× mean normal (lab-specific calibration required) |
| Corresponding heparin level | 0.3-0.7 IU/mL (anti-Xa) or 0.2-0.4 IU/mL (protamine titration) |
Critical: There is no universal normal range for aPTT analogous to INR. Each laboratory must establish its own therapeutic aPTT range for its specific reagent-instrument combination by correlation with anti-Xa heparin levels. (Tietz 7e; Miller's Anesthesia 10e)
| Cause | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Warfarin / VKA therapy | Inhibits Vit K-dependent factors II, VII, IX, X - early PT effect (FVII shortest t½) |
| Vitamin K deficiency | Same as above |
| Isolated Factor VII deficiency | Extrinsic pathway only |
| Early liver disease | FVII synthesised by liver; falls early |
| Cause | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Haemophilia A (FVIII deficiency) | Intrinsic pathway |
| Haemophilia B (FIX deficiency) | Intrinsic pathway |
| Factor XI deficiency | Intrinsic pathway |
| Lupus anticoagulant | Phospholipid antibody; paradoxically thrombotic in vivo |
| UFH therapy | Potentiates AT; affects intrinsic and common |
| Contact factor deficiencies (FXII, prekallikrein, HMWK) | Prolonged aPTT - no bleeding |
| Acquired FVIII inhibitor | Post-partum, autoimmune |
| von Willebrand Disease (Type 3 / severe) | Low FVIII (VWF is FVIII carrier) |
| Cause | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| DIC | Consumption of all factors; typically PT > aPTT |
| Severe liver disease | Impaired synthesis of all clotting factors (except FVIII) |
| Massive transfusion / dilutional coagulopathy | Dilution of all factors |
| Warfarin overdose | Extensive factor II, V, VII, IX, X depletion |
| Common pathway deficiencies (FV, FX, FII, fibrinogen) | Both pathways converge |
| Direct thrombin inhibitors (argatroban, hirudin) | Affect both PT and aPTT |
| Hypothermia | Enzymatic reactions slowed (though lab PT/aPTT tested at 37°C - does NOT reflect this) |
| Result after Mixing | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Corrects to normal (aPTT/PT within normal range) | Factor deficiency - normal plasma provides the missing factor |
| Does NOT correct (still prolonged) | Inhibitor present (lupus anticoagulant, specific factor inhibitor, heparin) - inhibitor also inhibits normal plasma |
| Corrects immediately but prolongs on incubation at 37°C | Acquired Factor VIII inhibitor (time-dependent inhibitor - Bethesda assay confirms) |
Even in severe factor deficiency, substantial correction occurs - normal plasma at 50% mix provides ~50% factor levels which is usually above the threshold for clot formation. (Barash's Clinical Anesthesia 9e; Miller's Anesthesia 10e)
| Limitation | PT/INR | aPTT |
|---|---|---|
| Reagent variability | Solved for warfarin by INR; NOT valid in other coagulopathies | No universal standard; lab-specific ranges |
| Does not reflect whole-blood haemostasis | Yes - plasma only test | Yes - plasma only test |
| Does not measure platelet function | Yes | Yes |
| Does not detect hypofibrinogenaemia until severe | Often | Often |
| Does not detect FXIII deficiency | Yes | Yes |
| Affected by anticoagulant in sample (citrate underfill/overfill) | Yes | Yes (particularly for heparin monitoring) |
| Not valid for high-dose heparin (CPB) | n/a | Unmeasurable |
| Does not reflect in vivo effects of hypothermia/acidaemia | Yes | Yes |
| Poor predictor of surgical bleeding in healthy patients | Yes | Yes |
| Feature | PT | INR | aPTT |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pathway tested | Extrinsic + common | Extrinsic + common (standardised) | Intrinsic + common |
| Initiating reagent | Tissue factor + phospholipid + Ca²⁺ | Derived from PT | Phospholipid + contact activator + Ca²⁺ |
| Factors tested | I, II, V, VII, X | I, II, V, VII, X | I, II, V, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, HMWK, PK |
| Normal range | 11-14 sec | 0.9-1.1 | 25-35 sec |
| Primary clinical use | Liver function; warfarin monitoring | Warfarin monitoring (standardised) | UFH monitoring; haemophilia screen |
| Vitamin K factor screen | Yes (II, VII, X) | Yes | Partial (II, IX, X) |
| Haemophilia screen | No | No | Yes (VIII, IX) |
| Warfarin monitoring | Yes (but non-standardised) | Yes (gold standard) | No |
| UFH monitoring | No | No | Yes (moderate dose) |
| High-dose heparin (CPB) | No | No | No (use ACT) |
| DIC | Prolonged | Prolonged | Prolonged |
| Liver disease | Prolonged early | Prolonged | Later |
| FXII deficiency | Normal | Normal | Prolonged (no bleeding) |
| Lupus anticoagulant | Normal or prolonged | Normal or prolonged | Prolonged (no correction on mixing) |