I now have all the content needed. Here is the comprehensive, detailed answer on treatment of fractures:
TREATMENT OF FRACTURES
(Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition - Chapter 32)
FRAMEWORK: APLEY'S 4 PRINCIPLES
The entire treatment of any fracture is built around four sequential steps:
REDUCE → HOLD → HEAL → REHABILITATE
The overarching goal is to return the patient to their pre-injury level of function as quickly and safely as possible.
STEP 1: REDUCE
When Is Reduction Needed?
Ask: "If this bone healed in its current position, would the patient have optimum function?"
| Fracture Type | Reduction Goal |
|---|
| Intra-articular | Anatomical reduction - perfect restoration of joint surface to prevent secondary osteoarthritis |
| Extra-articular | Mechanical alignment - restore length, alignment and rotation (not necessarily perfect apposition) |
| Children (extra-articular) | Greater degrees of displacement can be accepted due to remodelling potential |
Note on acceptability: Even 2 mm of articular displacement may be acceptable in the patella or tibial plateau, but is NOT acceptable in the condylar joints of the fingers - acceptability varies by joint.
Methods of Reduction
A) Closed Reduction (Manipulation Under Anaesthesia - MUA)
- No surgical exposure of bone
- Technique: Reverse the mechanism of injury - traction, counter-traction, manipulation
- On occasion, the deformity must first be exaggerated before correcting (to disengage impacted fragments)
- The intact soft-tissue and periosteal hinge is used as a biological aid to reduction
- After reduction, adequacy is checked with fluoroscopy
B) Open Reduction
- Surgical exposure of fracture
- Used when:
- Closed reduction is not achieved or unlikely to succeed
- Soft tissue or interposed muscle prevents reduction
- Anatomical reduction is mandatory (intra-articular fractures)
- Caution: Do NOT strip intact periosteum excessively - this devascularises fracture fragments and impairs healing
C) Combined (Closed + Open)
- Combination of both methods may be used for certain fractures
STEP 2: HOLD (FIXATION)
When the fracture is in an acceptable position, it must be held until it heals. The aim of fixation is to:
- Optimise the biological environment for healing
- Optimise the mechanical environment (stability appropriate to healing mode)
- Allow the patient to function as normally as possible
Stability Concepts
| Type | Description | Bone Healing Mode | Ideal For |
|---|
| Absolute stability | No interfragmentary movement; compression across fracture | Direct (primary) bone healing - no callus | Intra-articular fractures |
| Relative stability | Controlled micro-movement at fracture site | Indirect (secondary) healing - callus formation | Extra-articular fractures |
NON-OPERATIVE METHODS
1. Plaster Cast and Splints
Types:
- Plaster of Paris (POP): Preferred in acute fractures - easier to mould, conforms to limb shape
- Synthetic casting materials: Lighter, stronger, but less mouldable - used after swelling settles
- Backslab: Partial (half-circumference) cast applied acutely to allow for post-injury swelling; must be accompanied by close clinical observation
- Full cast split along length: Provides full-length support while accommodating swelling
Three-point moulding technique: The intact dorsal periosteal hinge is kept under tension while the cast moulds the bone under compression - a key technique for maintaining position in distal radial fractures.
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
| No wound | Limited access to soft tissues |
| No interference with fracture biology | Cumbersome (especially in elderly) |
| Cheap | Interferes with function |
| Adjustable | Poor mechanical stability |
| No implants to remove | "Plaster disease" - joint stiffness and muscle wasting |
2. Traction
- A stretching force applied along the limb axis to pull a fracture back to length and alignment
- Can be manual (temporary, for transfer/manipulation) or sustained via Thomas splint + balanced traction
- Thomas splint with balanced traction = classic management of femoral shaft fractures (now mainly used as temporary pre-operative stabilisation)
Types of Traction:
- Skin traction: Via adhesive tapes to skin (limited weight, skin complications)
- Skeletal traction: Pin through bone (calcaneum, distal femur, olecranon) - allows heavier weights
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
| No wound in zone of injury | Restricts patient mobility |
| No interference with fracture site | Expensive in hospital time |
| Cheap materials | Skin pressure ulcers |
| Adjustable | Pin site infection |
| Thromboembolic risk |
OPERATIVE METHODS
1. Kirschner Wires (K-wires)
- Smooth or threaded small-diameter metal wires drilled percutaneously or openly into bone
- Left proud of skin (bent over) and removed in clinic at 4-6 weeks
- Temporary or definitive fixation of small fragments
Indications (Table 32.6):
- Temporary fixation pending definitive surgery
- Definitive fixation of small fragments (wrist fractures, hand injuries)
- Tension band wiring of patella and olecranon fractures
- Temporary immobilisation of small joints
Complications: Pin site infection, wire breakage, loss of fixation, wire migration (especially dangerous around shoulder girdle - migration into thoracic cavity/heart reported)
2. External Fixator
- Metal pins/rods inserted percutaneously into bone above and below fracture, connected to an external metal frame
- Types:
- Unilateral (uniplanar) frame: Simplest; connecting bar on one side
- Ilizarov circular ring fixator: Multiple rings + transfixing wires; used for complex fractures, bone lengthening, deformity correction
- Taylor Spatial Frame: Computer-assisted ring fixator allowing gradual correction of deformity in 6 axes
Specific Indications:
- Open/contaminated fractures (soft tissues accessible for wound care)
- Damage control orthopaedics - rapid stabilisation in polytrauma patients too unwell for definitive surgery
- Temporary joint-spanning stabilisation (e.g., knee dislocation with arterial injury)
- Complex periarticular fractures - temporary stabilisation while soft-tissue damage recovers before definitive fixation
- Fractures with bone loss
- Fractures associated with infection
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
| No interference with fracture site | Pin site infection |
| Adjustable alignment after application | Interferes with plastic surgical procedures |
| Soft tissues fully accessible | Soft-tissue tethering |
| Rapid stabilisation | Cumbersome for patient |
| Hardware easy to remove | |
3. Plates and Screws
Mechanism:
- Lag screw: Generates compression across the fracture - optimises environment for direct bone healing
- Dynamic compression plate (DCP): Eccentric screw placement generates compression
- Neutralisation plate: Protects a lag screw from bending/torsional forces
- Buttress plate: Prevents shear and collapse of a metaphyseal fragment
- Locking plate (internal-external fixator): Locking screws thread into plate holes; plate does NOT need to contact bone; allows closed reduction + percutaneous insertion → behaves like an internal external fixator
Uses:
- Articular and periarticular fractures requiring anatomical reduction (open technique + plates + screws → absolute stability)
- Extra-articular fractures using locking plates (closed, percutaneous, relative stability)
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
| Can achieve anatomical reduction | May interfere with fracture biology |
| Allows early mobilisation | Periosteal/soft-tissue damage |
| Can provide absolute or relative stability | Does not normally allow immediate load-bearing |
| Potential infection |
| Metalwork complications |
| May require plate removal |
4. Intramedullary (IM) Nails
- A metal nail/rod inserted down the medullary canal of a long bone
- Proximal and distal locking screws maintain length, alignment, and rotation
- Best suited for diaphyseal fractures (femur, tibia, humerus)
- Provides relative stability → indirect/secondary bone healing via callus
Reamed vs. Unreamed:
| Feature | Reamed | Unreamed |
|---|
| Canal widened before nail | Yes | No |
| Nail diameter | Larger | Smaller |
| Cortical blood supply | Disrupted during reaming | Preserved |
| Nail strength | Greater | Lesser |
| Use | Standard for femur/tibia | Contaminated/open fractures |
Advantages of IM Nailing:
- Minimally invasive
- Allows early weight-bearing
- Less periosteal damage than ORIF
- Mechanical alignment without anatomical exposure
- Suitable for segmental fractures
Disadvantages:
- Technically demanding procedure
- Intramedullary reaming disrupts endosteal blood supply
- Risk of fat embolism (reaming)
- Not ideal for articular fractures
- Rotational alignment must be checked carefully
5. Arthroplasty (Joint Replacement)
- Used when fracture fragments cannot be reliably held together OR when the articular surface is so badly destroyed that reconstruction is not feasible
- Examples:
- Hemiarthroplasty (femoral head replacement) for displaced subcapital femoral neck fracture in elderly osteoporotic patients
- Total hip arthroplasty for displaced femoral neck fracture in active elderly patients
- Radial head replacement for comminuted radial head fractures
- Elbow arthroplasty for distal humeral fractures in elderly
- Reverse polarity shoulder arthroplasty for osteoporotic proximal humeral fractures in elderly
INDICATIONS FOR SURGERY (Table 32.11)
- Fracture requiring treatment that is unsuitable for non-operative measures
- Open fractures
- Failed non-operative management
- Multiple injuries / polytrauma
- Pathological or impending pathological fractures
- Displaced intra-articular fractures
- Growth plate fractures at risk of arrest (Salter-Harris types III-V)
- Avulsion fractures compromising functional integrity of a ligament/tendon (e.g., olecranon fracture)
- Established non-unions or malunions
STEP 3: HEAL
Factors that SLOW fracture healing (Bailey & Love):
- Diabetes mellitus (doubles time to union)
- Diminished blood supply (peripheral vascular disease, vascular injury)
- Smoking
- NSAIDs
- Infection at the fracture site
- Corticosteroids
Methods to Enhance Fracture Healing
| Method | Type |
|---|
| Bone marrow injections | Biological (orthobiologics) |
| Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) | Biological |
| Controlled axial micromotion (external fixator) | Mechanical |
| Electromagnetic stimulation | Physical |
| Low-intensity pulsed ultrasound (LIPUS) | Physical |
Note: Good basic science evidence supports these, but clinical evidence for primary closed fractures remains limited.
Monitoring Union
- Clinical: Pain and tenderness progressively diminish; limb can be loaded
- Radiological: Progressive callus formation; bridging callus on 3 of 4 cortices = radiological union
- Time frames (approximate):
- Upper limb: 6-8 weeks (diaphysis)
- Lower limb: 12-16 weeks (diaphysis)
- Cancellous fractures: faster than cortical
STEP 4: REHABILITATE
- Rehabilitation begins as soon as feasible after injury - does not need to wait for full bony union
- Move adjacent joints early: e.g., elbow and shoulder exercises while in a wrist cast (prevents "plaster disease")
- Goals:
- Restore range of movement
- Rebuild muscle strength and bulk
- Restore proprioception and balance
- Return to work and daily activities
Rehabilitation Team:
- Physiotherapist - exercises, gait training, weight-bearing progression
- Occupational therapist - activities of daily living, splinting, workplace modification
- Surgeon - staged progression of weight-bearing, implant removal when appropriate
RISKS AND BENEFITS OF FRACTURE TREATMENT (Table 32.3)
| Benefits | Risks |
|---|
| Pain relief | Anaesthesia |
| Prevention of infection | Introduction of infection |
| Restoration of anatomy | Damage to soft tissues and neurovascular structures |
| Early movement of limb | Devitalising bone |
| Early movement of patient | Need for implant removal |
| Improved function | Financial cost of treatment |
| Reduced risk of secondary arthritis | |
MANAGEMENT OF OPEN FRACTURES
- ABCDE - stabilise the patient first (ATLS)
- Wound photograph - document before any dressing
- Saline-soaked dressing + backslab - do not probe wound
- IV antibiotics - co-amoxiclav (or cefuroxime + metronidazole for Grade III); within 1 hour of injury
- Anti-tetanus prophylaxis
- Definitive debridement - within 6 hours for contaminated wounds (Grade III); within 24 hours for low-grade injuries
- Wound closure - primary closure if clean; delayed primary closure or flap coverage if contaminated/Grade IIIb
- Fracture stabilisation - external fixation preferred in contaminated open fractures initially; IM nail or ORIF once wound clean
Source: Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition, Chapter 32 - Extremity Trauma