1. Stress and strain: definitions and classification
Stress
Stress is the internal resisting force developed per unit cross-sectional area when an external force is applied.
[
\text{Stress }(\sigma)=\frac{F}{A}
]
Unit: pascal (Pa) or commonly MPa ((N/mm^2)).
Types of stress
| Type | Force effect | Example in dentistry |
|---|
| Tensile stress | Pulls material apart | Tensile force on a bridge connector |
| Compressive stress | Squeezes material | Occlusal loading of restorative material |
| Shear stress | Causes one part to slide over another | Shearing of luting cement or composite at an interface |
| Torsional stress | Twisting force, producing shear | Rotation of an endodontic file |
| Flexural stress | Bending, with tension on one side and compression on the other | Denture base or fixed partial denture under load |
Strain
Strain is the deformation produced per unit original length as a result of stress.
[
\text{Strain }(\varepsilon)=\frac{\Delta L}{L_0}
]
It is dimensionless, often expressed as a percentage.
Types of strain
| Type | Description |
|---|
| Tensile strain | Increase in length due to tensile force |
| Compressive strain | Decrease in length due to compressive force |
| Shear strain | Angular distortion caused by shear stress |
| Volumetric strain | Change in volume of a material |
| Torsional strain | Angular deformation due to twisting |
Simple figure
Tensile stress/strain Compressive stress/strain
← F [ specimen ] F → F → [ specimen ] ← F
elongation shortening
Shear stress/strain
→ F
┌────────┐
│ │
└────────┘
← F
Parallel layers slide relative to each other.
2. Stress-strain curve: drawing and interpretation
Stress
^
| D = Ultimate tensile strength
| /\
| / \
| / \ E = Fracture point
| / \
| C ----/ \
| / \
| B --/
| /
| A
|____/________________________________> Strain
O
| Point/region | Interpretation |
|---|
| O-A: Proportional limit | Stress is directly proportional to strain. This is the straight-line elastic region and obeys Hooke's law. |
| Slope of O-A | Modulus of elasticity or Young's modulus. |
| A: Proportional limit | Maximum stress up to which stress is proportional to strain. |
| B: Elastic limit | Maximum stress a material can tolerate and still return completely to its original dimensions after unloading. |
| B-C: Yield region | Permanent or plastic deformation begins. |
| C: Yield strength | Stress at which appreciable plastic deformation occurs. |
| D: Ultimate tensile strength | Maximum stress sustained by the material. |
| D-E: Necking region | Local reduction in cross-sectional area occurs in ductile materials. |
| E: Fracture strength | Stress at which the specimen breaks. |
Areas under the curve
- Area under the elastic region: resilience.
- Total area up to fracture: toughness.
- A brittle material has little or no plastic region and fractures at low strain.
- A ductile material shows a long plastic region before fracture.
These definitions are consistent with a dental endodontic-materials review that describes resilience as elastic energy absorption and toughness as total energy absorption before failure (
NiTi biomechanics review).
3. Modulus of elasticity
Definition
Modulus of elasticity (E), or Young's modulus, is the ratio of stress to strain within the proportional elastic region.
[
E=\frac{\text{Stress}}{\text{Strain}}
]
It represents the stiffness or resistance of a material to elastic deformation.
Unit
Since strain has no unit:
[
\text{Unit of E} = \text{Pa}, \text{MPa}, \text{or GPa}
]
Measurement
It is measured using a tensile stress-strain test:
- A standardized specimen is subjected to a gradually increasing tensile load.
- Applied load and elongation are recorded.
- Stress and strain are calculated.
- The modulus of elasticity is the slope of the linear, initial part of the stress-strain curve.
[
E=\frac{\Delta \sigma}{\Delta \varepsilon}
]
Importance in dentistry
- Materials with a high modulus are rigid and resist deformation, such as metals and ceramics.
- Materials with a low modulus are more flexible, such as elastomeric impression materials and some resin materials.
- An appropriate modulus helps distribute occlusal forces and limit deformation or fracture.
- For restorations, a modulus reasonably compatible with tooth structure is desirable. Very stiff restorations may concentrate stress, whereas very flexible restorations may deform, debond, or allow marginal leakage.
- In implants, a large difference in stiffness between implant and bone can contribute to stress shielding. A review of dental restorative materials notes that elastic modulus governs stiffness and deformation resistance (review of composite restorations).
4. Toughness and resilience
Toughness
Toughness is the ability of a material to absorb energy and undergo elastic plus plastic deformation before fracture.
[
\text{Toughness} = \text{total area under the stress-strain curve up to fracture}
]
A tough material resists fracture because it can absorb considerable energy.
Resilience
Resilience is the ability of a material to absorb energy during elastic deformation and release that energy on unloading without permanent deformation.
[
\text{Modulus of resilience} =
\text{area under the stress-strain curve up to the elastic limit}
]
Does higher toughness always mean higher strength?
No. Toughness and strength are not the same.
- Strength is the maximum stress a material can withstand.
- Toughness depends on both strength and the ability to deform plastically, that is, ductility.
Examples:
- A ceramic can have high compressive strength but low toughness because it fractures with little plastic deformation.
- A ductile metal may be highly tough even if its strength is not the highest.
5. Fracture toughness and unit
Fracture toughness is the resistance of a material containing a crack or flaw to crack initiation and propagation under stress.
It indicates how well a material resists catastrophic fracture in the presence of a defect.
[
K_{IC} = Y \sigma \sqrt{\pi a}
]
Where:
- (K_{IC}) = plane-strain fracture toughness
- (Y) = geometric factor
- (\sigma) = applied stress
- (a) = crack length
Unit:
[
\boxed{\text{MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}}
]
It may also be expressed as:
[
\boxed{\text{MN m}^{-3/2}}
]
Fracture toughness is particularly important for dental ceramics because microscopic flaws can propagate and cause sudden fracture.
6. Brittle materials used in dentistry and why they are called brittle
Examples
- Dental porcelain and other dental ceramics
- Glass ionomer cement
- Zinc phosphate cement
- Zinc oxide-eugenol cement
- Gypsum products: impression plaster, model plaster, dental stone, die stone
- Dental amalgam, relatively brittle compared with ductile metallic alloys
- Acrylic resin denture base, particularly after aging or when not adequately reinforced
Why are they called brittle?
They are called brittle because they fracture with little or no plastic deformation. On a stress-strain curve, brittle materials show:
- a small strain before fracture
- negligible yield or plastic region
- sudden failure
- relatively low fracture toughness
Brittle material: Ductile material:
Stress Stress
^ ^
| / fracture | /\
| / | / \ fracture
|/ |_____/ \__
+--------> strain +--------------> strain
very small strain large plastic strain
7. Ductility and malleability
Ductility
Ductility is the ability of a material to undergo permanent deformation under tensile stress before fracture.
A ductile material can be drawn into wire.
Examples: gold, wrought orthodontic wire, titanium, stainless steel, cobalt-chromium alloy to a limited extent.
Malleability
Malleability is the ability of a material to undergo permanent deformation under compressive stress without fracture.
A malleable material can be hammered or rolled into thin sheets.
Example: gold is highly malleable.
Three methods for determining ductility
-
Percentage elongation
[
%\text{ elongation} =
\frac{\text{final gauge length - original gauge length}}
{\text{original gauge length}}
\times 100
]
-
Percentage reduction in area
[
%\text{ reduction in area} =
\frac{\text{original cross-sectional area - final area}}
{\text{original cross-sectional area}}
\times 100
]
-
Bend test
The specimen is bent through a specified angle or around a mandrel. Greater bending without cracking or fracture indicates greater ductility.
High percentage elongation and high percentage reduction in area indicate a more ductile dental material.