Cubitus Varus Deformity — Comprehensive Guide
1. Definition & Overview
Cubitus varus (also called the "gunstock deformity") is an angular deformity of the elbow in which the carrying angle is reduced below normal, reversed, or negative — meaning the forearm deviates medially (inward/varus) relative to the long axis of the arm when the elbow is in full extension and the forearm is supinated.
Normal carrying angle:
- Males: 5–10°
- Females: 10–15°
- The angle normally allows the forearm to clear the hip when carrying objects — hence the name
In cubitus varus, this physiological valgus angulation is abolished or replaced by a varus (inward) tilt. The deformity is most commonly seen in children as a complication of malunited supracondylar fractures of the humerus.
2. Normal Elbow Anatomy & Carrying Angle
Panel A: Clinical photo — asymmetric carrying angles. Right arm shows cubitus varus (forearm deviated medially). Left arm shows normal valgus alignment. Panel B: AP radiographs — the right elbow (R) shows distal humeral malalignment with decreased Baumann's angle; the left (L) is normal.
The carrying angle is measured with the patient in the anatomical position — elbow fully extended, forearm supinated. The angle is formed between the long axis of the humerus and the long axis of the forearm. This angle:
- Disappears on full pronation
- Disappears on full flexion of the elbow
- Must be compared bilaterally
3. Etiology & Causes
Primary (Most Common) Cause
Malunited Supracondylar Fracture of the Humerus
- Overwhelmingly the most common cause in children (peak age 5–8 years)
- Accounts for >95% of all cases of cubitus varus
- Results from malunion (not growth arrest — this is a critical distinction)
- Posteromedial angulation of the distal fragment leads to varus malalignment on healing
- The Gartland Type III fracture (completely displaced, posteromedial rotation of distal fragment) carries the highest malunion risk
From Miller's Review of Orthopaedics: "Cubitus varus is typically the result of malunion, not growth arrest. It results in a gunstock deformity associated with poor cosmesis but does not generally affect function."
Other Causes (Less Common)
| Cause | Mechanism |
|---|
| Lateral condyle fracture malunion | Disrupts lateral physis → varus growth |
| Medial epicondyle fracture | Disrupts medial growth → lateral growth dominant → varus |
| Distal humeral physeal separation | Especially in children <6 years; frequently mistaken for dislocation |
| Growth plate injury (physeal arrest) | Asymmetric growth; lateral physeal damage → relative varus |
| Congenital causes | Rare — bony dysplasias |
| Rickets / metabolic bone disease | Varus bowing at multiple sites |
| Osteomyelitis of distal humerus | Septic destruction of lateral physis |
4. Pathology & Pathoanatomy
The deformity arises primarily at the distal humerus. In malunited supracondylar fractures:
- The distal fragment undergoes posteromedial rotation during displacement
- If inadequately reduced or re-displaced in a cast, the fragment heals in this malrotated position
- The result is medial tilting of the articular surface → varus carrying angle
- Internal rotation component is frequently present but often underappreciated clinically
- The distal humerus shows a "tilted" articular surface — the medial column is relatively lower than the lateral column
Key pathological components of cubitus varus:
- Varus angulation (primary) — decreased carrying angle
- Internal rotation (secondary, often overlooked)
- Hyperextension deformity (may coexist)
- Lateral condyle prominence — the lateral epicondyle becomes more prominent due to the angulation, creating the characteristic "gunstock" silhouette
The term "gunstock deformity" comes from the visual resemblance of the arm to an old musket gunstock — the upper arm and forearm form a shape similar to the stock and barrel of a rifle.
5. Biomechanics
Altered Biomechanics in Cubitus Varus
| Parameter | Normal | Cubitus Varus |
|---|
| Carrying angle | +10–15° (valgus) | Neutral, 0°, or negative (varus) |
| Valgus stress at medial elbow | Normal | Reduced / reversed |
| Lateral compartment loading | Normal | Increased |
| Medial ulnar collateral ligament | Normal tension | Reduced tension (relative laxity) |
| Posterolateral rotatory stress | Normal | Increased — predisposes to PLRI |
Important Biomechanical Consequences:
-
Lateral compartment overloading — the medially angulated forearm transmits greater compressive force to the radiocapitellar (lateral) compartment during axial loading
-
Posterolateral rotatory instability (PLRI) — the malaligned distal humerus alters the course of the lateral collateral ligament complex. Over time, the LUCL (lateral ulnar collateral ligament) is stretched. This is the mechanism for late-onset elbow instability — a recognized late complication of untreated cubitus varus in adults
-
Valgus laxity of the medial side — the medial ulnar collateral ligament operates at a lower tension than normal, but the medial side is paradoxically less symptomatic than the lateral overloaded side
-
Snapping/subluxation of the triceps — the medial head of triceps may sublux over the medial epicondyle due to altered joint alignment, causing pain and a snapping sensation (another late complication)
-
Tardy ulnar nerve palsy (less common than in cubitus valgus) — but documented in cases where the deformity alters the cubital tunnel geometry
6. Signs & Symptoms
Clinical Presentation
In Children (Shortly After Fracture Healing)
- Cosmetic complaint is the dominant issue
- Medial deviation of the forearm when the arm is extended
- The deformity is often not noticed initially because the elbow is swollen; becomes apparent after swelling subsides
- No pain — the deformity in children is typically painless
- Full range of motion usually preserved (elbow flexion-extension and forearm rotation intact)
- Deformity is progressive in appearance during growth (though not from growth arrest)
Clinical Signs
| Sign | Description |
|---|
| Gunstock deformity | The pathognomonic appearance — medial angulation of the forearm |
| Reduced carrying angle | Angle <5° or negative (varus) compared to contralateral side |
| Lateral epicondyle prominence | Becomes more visible/palpable due to the varus angulation |
| "Reversed" carrying angle | Forearm deviates medially rather than laterally on extension |
From S. Das Manual of Clinical Surgery: "When the carrying angle is abnormally decreased the condition is called cubitus varus." From Bailey & Love's: "cubitus varus (gun-stock deformity): the carrying angle is reversed, secondary to a malunited supracondylar fracture."
The normal carrying angle is present on the right side; cubitus varus deformity is obvious on the left side. (S. Das Manual on Clinical Surgery, Fig 13.12)
Late Complications (Adults with Untreated Cubitus Varus)
- Lateral elbow pain — from overloaded radiocapitellar compartment
- Posterolateral rotatory instability (PLRI) — episodic elbow instability, usually with the arm outstretched
- Snapping triceps syndrome — medial triceps subluxation causing painful snapping
- Tardy ulnar nerve palsy — late-onset ulnar neuropathy (rare, less common than in cubitus valgus)
- Osteochondral lesions of the radiocapitellar joint from chronic overloading
7. Radiological Assessment
Standard Radiographs
AP and lateral views of both elbows in full extension are mandatory for comparison.
The Baumann Angle (Humeral–Capitellar Angle)
This is the critical radiographic measurement for detecting and quantifying cubitus varus.
The Baumann angle: measured on AP radiograph as the angle between the longitudinal axis of the humerus and the physeal line of the capitellum. Normal value: 70–75° (equivalent to ~9–26° of humeral–capitellar valgus). A reduced Baumann angle indicates varus malunion.
From Rosen's Emergency Medicine: "The Baumann angle, normally 70 to 75 degrees, can be helpful in detecting subtle fractures and is formed by a line drawn to follow the growth plate of the capitellum and a line perpendicular to the long axis of the humerus."
From Miller's Review of Orthopaedics: "Humeral-capitellar (Baumann) angle should be in valgus and fall between 9 and 26 degrees."
AP Radiograph Findings in Cubitus Varus:
AP elbow X-ray: significant cubitus varus deformity. The forearm (radius and ulna) is angulated medially relative to the humerus. Altered distal humeral morphology indicates a sequela of malunited supracondylar fracture.
Key radiographic findings:
- Decreased or negative carrying angle on AP view
- Reduced Baumann angle (below normal 70–75°)
- Asymmetric metaphyseal height (medial column lower than lateral)
- Altered distal humeral shape
- Compare with contralateral normal elbow always
Additional Radiographic Lines (Lateral View):
- Anterior humeral line should bisect the middle third of the capitellum — displaced in type II/III fractures
- Fat pad signs — posterior fat pad displacement = pathologic (indicates joint effusion/fracture)
CT Scan
Useful preoperatively to:
- Quantify degree of varus, internal rotation, and hyperextension
- Plan corrective osteotomy geometry
- Assess for associated intra-articular changes (lateral compartment OA, loose bodies)
8. Classification
Classification of Cubitus Varus Deformity
There is no widely adopted single classification specifically for cubitus varus itself. It is classified based on:
A. Degree of Angular Deformity
| Grade | Carrying Angle |
|---|
| Mild | 0–5° (neutral, loss of normal valgus) |
| Moderate | Negative angle 5–15° (definite varus) |
| Severe | >15° varus |
B. Components of Deformity (Multiplanar Classification)
Complex cubitus varus has three components that must be assessed:
- Varus angulation (coronal plane) — primary deformity
- Internal rotation (axial plane) — often coexists, worsens cosmesis
- Hyperextension (sagittal plane) — may coexist, impacts function
C. Gartland Classification (of the Causative Supracondylar Fracture)
| Type | Description | Treatment |
|---|
| I | Nondisplaced | Long-arm cast 2–3 weeks |
| II | Displaced, posterior cortex intact | Cast vs. CRPP |
| IIIA | Completely displaced, posteromedial rotation | CRPP |
| IIIB | Completely displaced, posterolateral rotation | CRPP |
Type IIIA (posteromedial rotation of the distal fragment) carries the highest risk of cubitus varus malunion if inadequately reduced, as the medial rotation directly creates the varus tilt.
9. Investigations & Evaluation
Clinical Evaluation
History:
- Prior elbow fracture in childhood (supracondylar fracture)?
- Age at injury, treatment received
- Duration and progression of deformity
- Functional complaints? (most children are asymptomatic; adults may have pain, instability)
- Dominant limb affected?
Physical Examination:
- Inspect in anatomical position — compare carrying angles bilaterally
- Quantify the varus angle (or loss of valgus)
- Assess ROM — flexion-extension, pronation-supination (usually full)
- Assess for lateral condyle prominence
- Palpate medial epicondyle and assess ulnar nerve (Tinel's sign at cubital tunnel)
- Lateral pivot-shift test — for PLRI (if suspected late complication)
- Snapping triceps — check for medial triceps subluxation with flexion-extension
Imaging
| Investigation | Purpose |
|---|
| AP + lateral X-ray (bilateral) | Quantify deformity, compare Baumann angles |
| CT scan (3D reconstruction) | Pre-op planning, quantify rotation component |
| MRI | Assess for lateral compartment OA, LUCL integrity, osteochondral lesions |
| Ultrasound | Snapping triceps evaluation |
| Nerve conduction studies | If tardy ulnar nerve palsy suspected |
10. Treatment
Conservative (Non-surgical)
- Observation only for mild, asymptomatic deformities in children with good function
- No splinting or physiotherapy corrects an established bony deformity
- Appropriate when the deformity is cosmetically acceptable and there are no functional deficits
Surgical Treatment — Corrective Osteotomy
Surgery is indicated for:
- Moderate-to-severe deformity with cosmetic concern
- Functional impairment
- Pain (lateral compartment overloading)
- Posterolateral rotatory instability
- Snapping triceps syndrome
- Tardy nerve palsy
The timing of surgery: generally when the child is old enough to tolerate surgery safely (usually >6 years) and preferably before skeletal maturity. Earlier correction prevents late complications.
Types of Corrective Osteotomy
1. Lateral Closing-Wedge Osteotomy (Most Common)
- A wedge of bone is removed from the lateral side of the distal humerus (supracondylar region)
- The wedge is sized to correct the varus angle
- Medial cortex remains as a hinge
- Fixation: K-wires (crossed pins), plate and screws
- Advantages: Simple, reproducible, widely used
- Disadvantages: Increases lateral condyle prominence; does not correct rotational component
2. Dome (Curved) Osteotomy
- Curved cut allows correction in multiple planes simultaneously
- Addresses varus AND rotation in one procedure
- Technically more demanding
3. Step-Cut Osteotomy
- Step-shaped cut provides inherent stability
- Good rotational control
4. Medial Opening-Wedge Osteotomy
- A wedge is opened on the medial side
- Less popular; requires bone graft
5. French Osteotomy
- Modified lateral closing wedge with internal rotation correction
- Specifically designed to address the rotational component
Fixation Methods:
- Crossed K-wires — most commonly used in children; removed at 4–6 weeks
- Plate and screws — preferred in adolescents and adults for stability
- External fixator — for complex or revision cases
Surgical correction of cubitus varus: (A) preoperative gunstock deformity; (B, C) AP and lateral radiographs showing bony malalignment; (D) post-osteotomy K-wire fixation; (E) clinical correction achieved; (F-H) progressive healing on follow-up radiographs.
Clinical photographs: (a) preoperative — clear varus angulation with 20° of malalignment; (b) postoperative — carrying angle restored to near-normal after corrective osteotomy.
Postoperative Management
- Long-arm cast/splint at 90° elbow flexion for 4–6 weeks
- K-wires removed at 4–6 weeks under sedation
- Physiotherapy for ROM recovery (though ROM usually returns spontaneously in children)
- Expected correction to normal or slight overcorrection to valgus (5–10°)
11. Complications of Cubitus Varus (Untreated) & Post-Surgical
Untreated Complications
| Complication | Mechanism | Notes |
|---|
| Posterolateral rotatory instability (PLRI) | Chronic LUCL stretch from malalignment | Most serious late complication |
| Lateral compartment OA | Chronic overloading | Radiocapitellar arthritis |
| Snapping triceps syndrome | Medial triceps subluxation | Pain and snapping with elbow motion |
| Tardy ulnar nerve palsy | Altered cubital tunnel geometry | Less common than in cubitus valgus |
| Osteochondral lesions | Radiocapitellar impaction | Capitellar OCD |
Post-Surgical Complications
| Complication | Notes |
|---|
| Recurrence | Inadequate correction or growth-related |
| Overcorrection → cubitus valgus | Risks tardy ulnar nerve palsy |
| Iatrogenic ulnar nerve injury | From medial pin placement (3–8%) |
| Lateral condyle prominence | Increased with closing-wedge technique |
| Delayed union / non-union | Rare |
| Pin-site infection | More common in younger patients |
| Compartment syndrome | Rare |
12. Cubitus Varus vs Cubitus Valgus — Comparison
| Feature | Cubitus Varus | Cubitus Valgus |
|---|
| Carrying angle | Decreased / reversed | Increased |
| Forearm deviation | Medial (inward) | Lateral (outward) |
| Common cause | Malunited supracondylar fracture | Malunited lateral condyle fracture |
| Cosmesis | Gunstock deformity | Less obvious |
| Function | Usually preserved | Usually preserved |
| Nerve risk | PLRI, rarely ulnar nerve | Tardy ulnar nerve palsy (classic) |
| Mechanism | Malunion | Malunion / growth arrest |
13. Summary
| Key Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Definition | Decreased/reversed carrying angle; medial forearm deviation |
| Synonym | Gunstock deformity |
| Most common cause | Malunited supracondylar humerus fracture (type III, posteromedial) |
| Mechanism | Malunion (not growth arrest) |
| Key sign | Reversed carrying angle + lateral condyle prominence |
| Key investigation | AP X-ray both elbows; Baumann angle (normal 70–75°) |
| Functional impairment | Usually minimal in children; late PLRI in adults |
| Treatment of choice | Lateral closing-wedge osteotomy + K-wire fixation |
| Most feared late complication | Posterolateral rotatory instability |
Sources:
- S. Das: A Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th Edition, Chapter 13
- Miller's Review of Orthopaedics, 9th Edition, Chapters 4 & 11
- Rosen's Emergency Medicine, 8th Edition, Chapter 170
- Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition, Chapter 35