Obscure Autopsy and Negative Autopsy
1. Negative autopsy
A negative autopsy is one in which the cause of death cannot be found even after:
- Complete external and internal examination
- Histopathological examination
- Toxicological analysis
- Other necessary laboratory investigations
There are no positive findings sufficient to explain death.
Causes / reasons
- Inadequate history, for example vagal inhibition, epilepsy, anaphylaxis or laryngospasm in drowning
- Missed external signs, for example needle marks, snake/insect bite mark, electrical burn
- Incomplete internal examination, such as missed air embolism or pneumothorax
- Inadequate histopathology or laboratory investigations
- Toxicology not done
- Lack of skill or experience of the autopsy surgeon
2. Obscure autopsy
An obscure autopsy is an autopsy where the cause of death is not definite because findings are minimal, vague, doubtful or obscure. Sometimes there may be no positive finding. It is common in sudden unexpected death, especially in a young apparently healthy person.
Causes
-
Natural disease / functional deaths
- Epilepsy
- Cardiac arrhythmia or paroxysmal fibrillation
- Death precipitated by emotion or exertion
-
Biochemical disturbances
- Uraemia
- Diabetes and hypoglycaemia
- Potassium imbalance, especially hyperkalaemia
- Anaemic anoxia
-
Endocrine disorders
- Adrenal insufficiency
- Thyrotoxicosis
- Myxoedema
-
Concealed trauma
- Cerebral concussion
- Blunt injury to heart
- Reflex vagal inhibition
- Self-reduced neck injury
-
Poisoning without gross changes
- Narcotic poisoning
- Anaesthetic overdose
- Neurotoxic/cytotoxic poisons
- Plant poisons
-
Miscellaneous
- Anaphylaxis
- Drug idiosyncrasy
- Snake bite
Difference
- Negative autopsy: No cause is found after a complete autopsy plus all ancillary tests.
- Obscure autopsy: Minor or doubtful findings may be present, but they do not establish a definite cause of death.
In such cases, the doctor should not give a speculative cause of death. History, scene findings, repeat examination, histology, toxicology, biochemical, microbiological and sometimes molecular tests should be considered.
Source: The Essentials of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, 36th ed., pp. 148-149.