I now have comprehensive data from Bailey & Love's Chapter 64. I have enough information to write a thorough, well-structured answer covering everything from anatomy to surgery. Let me compile it now.
HERNIA - Complete Overview
Source: Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition, Chapter 64
1. DEFINITION
A hernia is the protrusion of a viscus or part of a viscus through an abnormal opening in the walls of its containing cavity. In the abdomen, this means abdominal contents (fat, omentum, bowel) pushing through a weak point or defect in the abdominal wall.
2. ANATOMY OF THE ABDOMINAL WALL
The abdominal wall is composed of muscle, bone, and fascia. It must simultaneously protect internal organs and allow flexibility - and that flexibility is what creates weakness.
Layers (lateral to medial):
- External oblique - fibres run downwards and medially
- Internal oblique - fibres run upwards and medially
- Transversus abdominis - fibres run horizontally
- Transversalis fascia - inner lining
- Peritoneum
Natural weak areas (hernia-prone sites):
- Inguinal canal - formed during testicular descent
- Femoral canal - below the inguinal ligament
- Linea alba - central join between rectus muscles (epigastric, umbilical)
- Umbilicus - where the umbilical cord was
- Spigelian line - lateral edge of rectus sheath
- Posterior lumbar triangles - Petit's and Grynfelt's
- Obturator canal - obturator hernia
- Diaphragm - Bochdalek, Morgagni, hiatal hernias
3. CAUSES OF HERNIA
| Category | Examples |
|---|
| Anatomical weakness | Natural gaps (inguinal ring, femoral canal) |
| Developmental failure | Patent processus vaginalis (congenital indirect inguinal) |
| Collagen disease | Inherited imbalance of collagen types; associated with aortic aneurysm, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome |
| Surgical scar | A healed laparotomy scar retains only 70% of original strength - incisional hernia in at least 10% of laparotomies |
| Ageing and pregnancy | Progressive weakening of abdominal wall |
| Increased intra-abdominal pressure | Chronic cough, constipation, prostatism, obesity, ascites |
| Primary muscle/nerve disease | Rare |
| Trauma | Blunt/sharp injury tearing muscles (e.g. high-speed MVA) |
Important: Most patients first notice a hernia after straining - the strain reveals the hernia rather than causing it. Hernia is fundamentally a collagen disease with histological evidence of abnormal collagen type ratios.
4. CLASSIFICATION OF HERNIAS
By location:
- Inguinal (direct and indirect) - most common overall
- Femoral - below inguinal ligament, more common in women
- Umbilical / paraumbilical
- Epigastric - through linea alba above umbilicus
- Incisional - through surgical scar
- Spigelian - through transversus aponeurosis at lateral rectus edge
- Obturator - through obturator canal
- Lumbar - Petit's triangle (inferior) or Grynfelt's (superior)
- Diaphragmatic - hiatal, Bochdalek, Morgagni
- Internal hernias - intra-abdominal (paraduodenal, mesenteric, etc.)
By clinical status:
| Term | Meaning |
|---|
| Reducible | Contents return to abdomen spontaneously or manually |
| Irreducible (Incarcerated) | Cannot be reduced but blood supply intact |
| Obstructed | Bowel in sac has lumen blocked - causes intestinal obstruction |
| Strangulated | Blood supply to contents is cut off - surgical emergency |
| Richter's hernia | Only part of bowel wall caught in neck - strangulation without full obstruction |
| Maydl's hernia | "W" loop hernia - two loops of bowel inside sac, middle loop (in abdomen) strangulates |
5. ANATOMY OF THE INGUINAL CANAL
The inguinal canal is ~4 cm long, running obliquely downward and medially, above the medial half of the inguinal ligament.
Boundaries:
| Wall | Structure |
|---|
| Anterior | External oblique aponeurosis (+ internal oblique laterally) |
| Posterior | Transversalis fascia (+ conjoint tendon medially) |
| Roof | Arching fibres of internal oblique and transversus |
| Floor | Inguinal ligament and lacunar ligament medially |
Key landmarks:
- Deep (internal) inguinal ring - defect in transversalis fascia; lies midway between ASIS and pubic tubercle, ~2-3 cm above femoral artery. The inferior epigastric vessels lie just medial to it
- Superficial (external) inguinal ring - V-shaped defect in external oblique aponeurosis, just above the pubic tubercle
- Conjoint tendon - fused internal oblique + transversus, attaches to pubic tubercle; forms the medial posterior wall
Contents of inguinal canal:
- In males: spermatic cord (vas deferens, testicular artery, pampiniform plexus, cremasteric muscle, ilioinguinal nerve)
- In females: round ligament, ilioinguinal nerve
6. INGUINAL HERNIA
The most common hernia overall. ~90% are in men (inguinal hernia is 10x more common in men).
Indirect (Lateral/Oblique) Inguinal Hernia
- Hernia sac enters through the deep inguinal ring and travels along the inguinal canal
- Lies lateral to the inferior epigastric vessels
- Can extend into the scrotum (complete hernia)
- Congenital type: due to patent processus vaginalis
- Acquired type: also possible in adults
- More common in younger males
Direct (Medial) Inguinal Hernia
- Hernia pushes directly through the posterior wall of the canal (Hesselbach's triangle)
- Lies medial to the inferior epigastric vessels
- Hesselbach's triangle: medial border = lateral edge of rectus; lateral border = inferior epigastric vessels; inferior border = inguinal ligament
- Always acquired; related to weakness of transversalis fascia
- More common in older males; rarely strangulates
Pantaloon Hernia
- A combined direct + indirect hernia straddling the inferior epigastric vessels (like trouser legs)
Distinguishing Direct vs Indirect (clinical):
- Reduce the hernia and press over the deep ring (2 cm above femoral artery midpoint). If hernia reappears despite pressure = direct. If controlled = indirect
7. FEMORAL HERNIA
- Passes through the femoral canal (below inguinal ligament, medial to femoral vein)
- Boundaries of femoral canal: femoral vein (lateral), inguinal ligament (anterior), iliopectineal/Cooper's ligament (posterior), lacunar/Gimbernat's ligament (medial - sharp, unyielding edge)
- More common in thin, elderly women (wider female pelvis widens femoral canal)
- 50% present as an emergency with strangulation
- Appears below and lateral to the pubic tubercle (unlike inguinal which is above and medial)
- Often loses cough impulse due to tight neck; easily mistaken for lymph node
Differential diagnosis of femoral hernia:
- Inguinal hernia
- Enlarged lymph node
- Saphena varix
- Femoral artery aneurysm
- Psoas abscess
8. SYMPTOMS AND CLINICAL FEATURES
Typical presentation:
- Lump at a hernia site that appears on standing/straining/coughing
- Dragging or aching discomfort, worse on activity
- In groin hernias: heaviness or ache after prolonged standing
- Hernia may disappear on lying down (reducible)
Examination:
- Examine lying first, then standing (increases hernia size)
- Ask to cough or Valsalva - cough impulse confirms hernia
- Check reducibility - patient may reduce it themselves
- Assess skin overlying hernia - cellulitis = strangulation, emergency
- Check both groins (occult contralateral hernia in ~20%)
- Examine scrotum (in groin hernias)
- Check for previous repair scars
Red flags - emergency:
- Sudden pain, irreducibility, overlying cellulitis, vomiting, no cough impulse = suspect strangulation - urgent surgery
9. INVESTIGATIONS
- Most hernias are diagnosed clinically
- Ultrasound - useful for impalpable hernias, distinguishing fluid from solid
- CT scan - obese patients, complex/internal hernias, suspected incisional hernia contents
- MRI - rarely needed; useful in athletes with groin pain (sports hernia / Gilmore's groin)
- Herniography (injection of contrast into peritoneum) - historical, rarely used
10. COMPLICATIONS OF UNTREATED HERNIA
- Irreducibility - contents cannot be returned; may be chronic (e.g. sliding hernia) or acute
- Obstruction - bowel in sac obstructs; vomiting, distension, colicky pain
- Strangulation - vascular compromise leads to ischaemia, then necrosis; requires emergency surgery; higher risk with narrow neck (femoral, paraumbilical)
- Incarceration - chronic irreducibility with adhesions
11. NON-SURGICAL MANAGEMENT
- Conservative (watchful waiting): Acceptable in elderly, unfit patients with minimally symptomatic, easily reducible hernias
- Truss: An external compression device to keep hernia reduced. Only for unfit patients who refuse surgery. Does not treat the hernia and complications can still occur. Poor patient compliance.
- All symptomatic hernias with acceptable operative risk should be repaired
12. SURGICAL PRINCIPLES - MESH
Closure of the hernia defect alone has a high recurrence rate. Mesh reinforcement is the standard of care.
How mesh is used:
- Bridge a defect: mesh fixed over defect as tension-free patch
- Augment a repair: defect closed with sutures + mesh added for reinforcement
- Mesh plug (pushing mesh into defect) largely abandoned - causes "meshoma", migration, erosion, fistula
Mesh types:
- Synthetic (non-absorbable): Polypropylene (commonest - inert, hydrophobic, monofilament, resists bacteria), polyester, PTFE
- Biological mesh: Derived from human/animal tissue (porcine dermis, bovine pericardium) - used in contaminated fields, but expensive and higher recurrence
- Composite mesh: Anti-adhesive barrier on one side (for intraperitoneal placement)
- Absorbable mesh: Only as a temporary bridge; not for permanent repair
13. INGUINAL HERNIA REPAIR - SURGICAL OPTIONS
A) Herniotomy (Children)
- Simply excise and ligate the patent processus vaginalis sac
- No muscle repair needed in children - sufficient alone
B) Open Suture Repair (Historical / Developing Countries)
- Bassini's repair (1890): Opens inguinal canal, sac dealt with, sutures placed between conjoint tendon and inguinal ligament (posterior wall strengthened). Over 150 modifications described.
- Shouldice repair: Opens transversalis fascia, creates double-breasted repair (4-layer). Expert centres report <2% lifetime failure. Technically demanding.
- Maloney darn: Continuous nylon/polypropylene darned between conjoint tendon and inguinal ligament
C) Open Mesh Repair (Lichtenstein - Gold Standard for Open)
- Tension-free flat mesh sutured over the posterior wall of the inguinal canal
- Mesh overlaps all the weak areas
- Local/regional/general anaesthesia - can be done safely even in high-risk patients
- Recurrence rate <2% in experienced hands
- Current standard for open inguinal hernia repair
D) Laparoscopic Repair (Minimally Invasive)
Two main approaches - both place mesh in the preperitoneal space:
TAPP (Transabdominal Preperitoneal):
- Enter abdomen laparoscopically, incise peritoneum over inguinal region, place large mesh in preperitoneal space, close peritoneum over mesh
- Can inspect both sides and repair bilateral hernias simultaneously
TEP (Totally Extraperitoneal):
- Never enters peritoneal cavity; work entirely in preperitoneal space via balloon dissection
- Mesh covers the myopectineal orifice (inguinal + femoral + obturator areas)
- No peritoneal closure needed
Advantages of laparoscopic repair:
- Less postoperative pain
- Faster return to activity
- Better for bilateral hernias (both repaired through same ports)
- Better for recurrent hernias after previous open anterior repair
Complications of laparoscopic repair:
- Neurovascular injury (lateral cutaneous nerve of thigh, femoral vessels)
- Trocar site hernia
- Visceral injury
- Requires general anaesthesia
Key nerves at risk in inguinal hernia surgery:
- Ilioinguinal nerve - runs in inguinal canal; injury causes numbness inner thigh/scrotum
- Iliohypogastric nerve - runs above inguinal canal
- Genitofemoral nerve (genital branch) - runs with spermatic cord
- Lateral cutaneous nerve of thigh - at risk laparoscopically
14. FEMORAL HERNIA REPAIR
Three approaches - all should have mesh:
- Low (Lockwood) approach - through skin crease below inguinal ligament
- High (McEvedy) approach - vertical incision through rectus sheath, accessing preperitoneal space; best for strangulation/bowel resection needed
- Inguinal (Lotheissen) approach - through inguinal canal, opening floor; risk of creating inguinal hernia
15. UMBILICAL HERNIA
Children:
- Occurs in up to 10% of infants (higher in premature and Black infants)
- 95% resolve spontaneously by age 2 - conservative management
- Strangulation extremely rare under 3 years
- Surgery if persists beyond age 2: excise sac, close linea alba defect with sutures
Adults (Paraumbilical):
- Predisposed by: obesity, pregnancy, liver cirrhosis with ascites
- Small ones contain fat/omentum; larger ones contain bowel
- Narrow neck = prone to strangulation
- Surgery: repair with mesh (small defects may be sutured, larger ones require mesh)
16. INCISIONAL HERNIA
- Occurs through a previous surgical scar
- At least 10% of laparotomy incisions develop incisional hernia (wound heals to only 70% of original strength)
- Laparoscopic port sites: ~1% hernia rate
- Risk factors: wound infection, obesity, poor technique, malnutrition, steroids, re-operation
- Often large with multiple defects; contents include omentum, bowel
- Repair: Mesh essential for all but the smallest defects. Can be open (retromuscular/sublay position preferred) or laparoscopic (IPOM - intraperitoneal onlay mesh)
17. OTHER HERNIAS
| Hernia | Key Points |
|---|
| Epigastric | Through linea alba above umbilicus; usually contain pre-peritoneal fat; often cause pain disproportionate to size; repair with suture or mesh |
| Spigelian | Through transversus aponeurosis at lateral rectus edge; intermittent pain in young; reducible lump in older; diagnosis by CT/US; surgery recommended (narrow neck strangulates) |
| Obturator | Elderly thin women; presents with small bowel obstruction; Howship-Romberg sign (pain on medial thigh rotating hip); high mortality |
| Lumbar | Petit's (inferior) or Grynfelt's (superior) triangle; rare; often contain retroperitoneal fat |
| Diaphragmatic - Hiatal | Stomach herniates through oesophageal hiatus; type I (sliding) most common; type II/III/IV paraesophageal - risk of strangulation |
| Diaphragmatic - Bochdalek | Posterolateral; congenital; common cause of respiratory distress in neonates |
| Diaphragmatic - Morgagni | Anterior; congenital; often asymptomatic |
18. COMPLICATIONS OF HERNIA SURGERY
- Haematoma / seroma - common, usually resolve
- Wound infection - mesh infection serious; may require mesh removal
- Nerve injury - chronic groin pain (most troublesome long-term complication), numbness
- Vas deferens injury - risk of infertility (bilateral operations)
- Testicular atrophy - disruption of testicular blood supply
- Recurrence - ~2% with mesh repair; higher with suture-only repair
- Mesh complications - migration, erosion into adjacent structures, meshoma (plug hernia), fistula
Quick Reference Summary
| Feature | Indirect Inguinal | Direct Inguinal | Femoral |
|---|
| Site | Deep inguinal ring | Posterior wall of canal | Femoral canal |
| Relation to inferior epigastric vessels | Lateral | Medial | Below inguinal ligament |
| Age/sex | Young males | Older males | Elderly females |
| Strangulation risk | Moderate | Low | Very high (50%) |
| Congenital type | Yes (patent PV) | No | No |
| Extension | Into scrotum | Rarely | Turns superiorly |
Sources: Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery 28th Edition, Chapter 64; Fischer's Mastery of Surgery 8th Ed; Maingot's Abdominal Operations