I now have rich clinical content from Bailey & Love, Mulholland, and Current Surgical Therapy. Let me compile the complete clinical viva Q&A:
🏥 BREAST - CLINICAL VIVA QUESTIONS (Complete)
Sources: Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery 28th ed., Schwartz's 11th ed., Mulholland Surgery 7th ed., Current Surgical Therapy 14th ed.
🔴 SCENARIO 1: PATIENT WITH A BREAST LUMP
Q. A 35-year-old woman presents with a painless lump in the right breast. How will you approach her?
Start with a thorough history, then clinical examination, followed by investigations (Triple Assessment).
History should include:
- Duration, size change, pain, skin changes
- Nipple retraction/discharge (color, unilateral/bilateral)
- Relation to menstrual cycle
- Age at menarche, parity, age at first birth, lactation history
- Family history of breast/ovarian cancer
- Use of OCP, HRT
- Previous breast biopsies/lumps
Q. How do you perform clinical breast examination (CBE)?
Performed in 2 positions: sitting (upright) then supine.
Inspection (sitting, arms at side):
- Compare bilateral breasts for size, shape, asymmetry
- Skin: dimpling, peau d'orange, erythema, ulceration, satellite nodules
- Nipple: symmetry, retraction (new vs old), eczematous change, discharge
- Arms raised: inspect lower breast
- Hands on hips + pectoral contraction: reveals tethering by deep tumors involving Cooper's ligaments
Palpation (sitting):
- Regional lymph nodes: axillary (support ipsilateral arm), supraclavicular, infraclavicular, cervical
- Note: size, consistency (soft/firm), mobility (mobile/matted/fixed), tenderness of nodes
Palpation (supine, ipsilateral arm raised above head):
- Palpate systematically - all 4 quadrants + axillary tail + subareolar region
- Describe lump: site (quadrant + relation to nipple), size, shape, surface, edge, consistency, tenderness, mobility/fixity (to skin, underlying muscle), transillumination
Q. How do you describe a breast lump in a viva/clinical exam?
Describe using the surgical sieve:
- Site - quadrant (UOQ, UIQ, LOQ, LIQ, central), clock-face position, distance from nipple
- Size - cm in 2 dimensions
- Shape - round/oval/irregular
- Surface - smooth/nodular/irregular
- Edge - well-defined/ill-defined/spiculated
- Consistency - soft/firm/hard/rubbery
- Tenderness - tender/non-tender
- Mobility - mobile in all directions / tethered to skin / fixed to chest wall
- Skin over lump - dimpling, tethering, peau d'orange, ulceration
- Nipple - retracted, normal, discharge
- Regional lymph nodes - axillary, supraclavicular
Q. What are the features that suggest a lump is malignant?
| Feature | Malignant |
|---|
| Consistency | Hard, stony |
| Edge | Irregular, spiculated |
| Surface | Irregular, nodular |
| Mobility | Fixed/tethered to skin or deep fascia |
| Skin | Dimpling, peau d'orange, ulceration |
| Nipple | Retraction (new onset), blood-stained discharge |
| Nodes | Hard, fixed, matted axillary nodes |
| Tenderness | Usually non-tender |
Q. How does skin dimpling occur in breast cancer?
Tumor infiltration causes desmoplastic reaction - tumor cells secrete FGF, TGFα/β, VEGF → adjacent fibrocytes → fibroblasts → lay down collagen → Cooper's ligaments shorten → pull skin inward = dimpling/tethering/nipple retraction.
Q. What is peau d'orange? What does it signify clinically?
Orange-peel appearance of breast skin due to obstruction of cutaneous lymphatics by tumor emboli → skin lymphedema with tethering at sweat gland orifices (held down by Cooper's ligaments).
Clinically signifies locally advanced breast cancer (T4b). Also seen in inflammatory breast cancer (involves >1/3 of breast surface = T4d).
Q. What is the most common site of breast cancer?
Upper Outer Quadrant (UOQ) - 50% of TDLUs (terminal duct lobular units) are located here → 50% of breast cancers arise here. Also has the axillary tail of Spence.
🔴 SCENARIO 2: INVESTIGATING A BREAST LUMP
Q. What investigations would you order for a breast lump?
Triple Assessment - the gold standard (PPV approaches 100% when all 3 are concordant):
- Clinical examination
- Imaging: Mammography (≥35 yrs) / Ultrasound (<35 yrs or dense breasts); MRI if indicated
- Tissue sampling: Core needle biopsy (preferred) or FNA
If all 3 are concordant (agree) → confident diagnosis
If any 2 are discordant → proceed to excisional biopsy
Q. What is BI-RADS classification on mammography?
| BI-RADS | Interpretation | Action |
|---|
| 0 | Incomplete - needs further imaging | Recall |
| 1 | Negative - normal | Routine screening |
| 2 | Benign finding | Routine screening |
| 3 | Probably benign (<2% malignancy) | 6-month follow-up |
| 4 | Suspicious (2-95%) | Biopsy |
| 5 | Highly suggestive (>95%) | Biopsy |
| 6 | Known biopsy-proven malignancy | Management |
Q. When do you choose USS over mammography? When do you use MRI?
Ultrasound preferred:
- Young women (<35 years, dense breast tissue)
- Differentiating cyst vs solid lump
- Guiding biopsy (USS-guided core biopsy)
- Pregnant/lactating women
- Evaluating axillary lymph nodes
MRI indications:
- Screening BRCA mutation carriers (annual MRI from age 25)
- Assessing response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy
- Suspected multicentric/multifocal disease
- Breast implant assessment
- Occult primary breast cancer (positive axillary nodes, no mammographic lesion)
- Discordant triple assessment
Q. Which biopsy is preferred for a breast lump - FNA or core needle biopsy?
Core needle biopsy (14G Tru-Cut) is preferred because:
- Gives histology (not just cytology like FNA)
- Can determine invasion (in situ vs invasive)
- Provides ER, PR, HER2 status for treatment planning
- Allows surgeon and patient to plan surgery before theatre
- FNA gives cytology only - cannot assess basement membrane
Q. When would you use FNA?
- For palpable cysts (aspirate and assess if bloody; re-examine if cyst refills)
- When rapid on-site cytology is available and core unavailable
- For axillary lymph node assessment (USS-guided FNA)
- As part of triple assessment when other modalities suggest benign
🔴 SCENARIO 3: NIPPLE DISCHARGE
Q. A 45-year-old woman has blood-stained nipple discharge from one duct. What do you think and how do you manage?
Blood-stained, unilateral, single-duct discharge is significant - must exclude malignancy.
Causes of blood-stained discharge (in order of frequency):
- Intraductal papilloma (most common - 50%) - benign
- Ductal ectasia/periductal mastitis
- DCIS - must rule out
- Invasive carcinoma
Management:
- Triple assessment (examination + mammogram + USS)
- Ductoscopy / galactography (ductogram) to localise the bleeding duct
- If no lesion found on imaging + single duct discharge → microdochectomy (excision of the discharging duct)
- If DCIS/cancer found → treat accordingly
Cytology of discharge - send for malignant cells but low sensitivity.
Q. What is the significance of different types of nipple discharge?
| Type | Significance |
|---|
| Milky (galactorrhoea), bilateral | Hyperprolactinemia (prolactinoma, drugs: metoclopramide, antipsychotics), hypothyroidism |
| Green/brown/dark, bilateral, multiple ducts | Duct ectasia / fibrocystic change - normal variant |
| Clear/yellow serous | Can be normal; investigate if persistent/unilateral |
| Blood-stained, unilateral, single duct | Must exclude malignancy - most important |
| Serosanguinous | Intraductal papilloma, DCIS |
Q. What is microdochectomy? What is total duct excision (Hadfield's operation)?
Microdochectomy: Excision of a single duct - for unilateral, single-duct, persistent discharge to exclude/treat intraductal papilloma.
Total duct excision (Hadfield's operation): Excision of all major subareolar ducts behind the nipple - for duct ectasia, periductal mastitis, or bilateral/multi-duct discharge. Nipple is everted during the procedure.
🔴 SCENARIO 4: BREAST ABSCESS
Q. A 28-year-old breastfeeding woman presents with a painful, red, fluctuant swelling in her right breast. Diagnosis and management?
Lactational (puerperal) breast abscess - most common type.
Features: Painful, red, warm, fluctuant swelling + fever; may have pus discharging. Occurs 2-4 weeks postpartum.
Pathogen: Staphylococcus aureus (most common)
Management:
- USS to confirm abscess and assess size/depth
- Antibiotics (Flucloxacillin/Co-amoxiclav) for early cellulitis/mastitis
- Needle aspiration (USS-guided) - first-line for small abscesses (<3 cm); repeat as needed
- Incision and Drainage (I&D) - for large/loculated/failed aspiration; radial incision (to avoid ducts); avoid periareolar incision; break loculations with finger
- Continue breastfeeding (or regular expression of milk) - reduces risk of recurrence; milk safe for baby
Q. How does non-lactational breast abscess differ?
Non-lactational (periductal mastitis):
- Occurs in smokers, overweight women, young non-pregnant women
- Subareolar location
- Mixed organisms - anaerobes + Staph/Strep
- Can lead to mammary duct fistula (Zuska's disease/subareolar fistula) - track between duct and skin
- Treatment: antibiotics (Metronidazole + Flucloxacillin) + USS-guided aspiration or I&D; for recurrent: excision of fistula tract
- Stop smoking - smoking causes squamous metaplasia of lactiferous ducts → obstruction → secondary infection
Q. What is the incision for breast abscess I&D?
Radial incision - to avoid dividing the lactiferous ducts.
Periareolar incision can be used for subareolar abscesses.
Avoid transverse incisions in the breast.
🔴 SCENARIO 5: POSTMASTECTOMY COMPLICATIONS
Q. What are the complications of axillary lymph node dissection (ALND)?
Immediate:
- Bleeding/haematoma
- Wound infection, seroma (most common early complication)
Early:
- Seroma (most common overall complication of ALND) - treat by aspiration
Late:
- Lymphedema (most important/common late complication) - arm swelling; risk ~20-30%
- Winged scapula - long thoracic nerve injury → serratus anterior paralysis
- Weakness in arm adduction/extension - thoracodorsal nerve injury → latissimus dorsi paralysis
- Numbness/paraesthesia of inner arm - intercostobrachial nerve (T2) - often deliberately divided
- Shoulder stiffness - frozen shoulder
- Cording (axillary web syndrome)
- Winging of scapula
Q. A patient develops arm swelling 6 months after mastectomy + ALND. What is the diagnosis and management?
Lymphedema (secondary) due to disruption of axillary lymphatics.
Management:
- Complex Decongestive Therapy (CDT) = gold standard
- Manual Lymphatic Drainage (MLD) by physiotherapist
- Multi-layer compression bandaging
- Specific exercises
- Skin care
- Compression sleeve (long-term)
- Avoid: blood pressure cuffs, venipuncture, infections in affected arm
- Surgical options: lymphovenous anastomosis, vascularized lymph node transfer (selected cases)
Q. What is seroma? How do you manage it after mastectomy?
Collection of lymphatic fluid/serous fluid under the mastectomy skin flap. Most common complication after mastectomy and ALND.
Prevention: Closed suction drainage (Jackson-Pratt/Redivac drain)
Treatment: Repeated aspiration in clinic (usually resolves within weeks)
Complications of untreated seroma: Infection, skin flap necrosis, delayed wound healing
🔴 SCENARIO 6: LOCALLY ADVANCED / INFLAMMATORY BREAST CANCER
Q. A 50-year-old woman presents with a rapidly enlarging, red, warm, edematous breast with peau d'orange involving >1/3 of the breast. What is your diagnosis and treatment?
Inflammatory Breast Cancer (IBC) - T4d; Stage IIIB minimum.
Key points:
- Clinical diagnosis (NOT histological type)
- Due to dermal lymphatic invasion by tumor emboli
- No discrete palpable mass in ~50%
- Must differentiate from mastitis (IBC does NOT respond to antibiotics)
Treatment sequence:
- Neoadjuvant chemotherapy (NACT) FIRST (anthracycline + taxane based)
- Modified Radical Mastectomy (BCT/lumpectomy is CONTRAINDICATED)
- Post-mastectomy radiation (mandatory)
- Targeted therapy if HER2+; endocrine therapy if ER+
Q. What are indications for neoadjuvant chemotherapy (NACT)?
- Locally Advanced Breast Cancer (T3, T4 / N2, N3) - to downsize tumor
- To convert inoperable → operable disease
- To downsize tumor and enable BCS in cases initially requiring mastectomy
- HER2-positive tumors (>5 mm)
- Triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC)
- Premenopausal women with high-risk features
- Axillary node metastasis (to assess treatment response)
- Inflammatory breast cancer (mandatory before surgery)
🔴 SCENARIO 7: CLINICAL VIVA - SPOT DIAGNOSIS
Q. On examination of a breast lump: hard, irregular, fixed to skin (dimpling) with hard, fixed matted axillary nodes. Diagnosis?
Carcinoma of the breast - T4b (skin involvement), N2 (fixed/matted nodes). Locally advanced breast cancer.
Q. Young woman, 22 years, smooth, firm, mobile, well-defined lump in upper outer quadrant, non-tender. Diagnosis?
Fibroadenoma - the "breast mouse" (extremely mobile). Triple assessment → USS (solid, benign features). If <3 cm with concordant benign triple assessment → reassurance + 6-month follow-up.
Q. 40-year-old woman, bilateral cyclical mastalgia, multiple lumpy areas both breasts, worse premenstrually. Diagnosis?
Fibrocystic disease / ANDI. Management: reassurance, evening primrose oil (GLA), danazol/bromocriptine in severe cases; cycle-mapped follow-up.
Q. 50-year-old woman, single large (7 cm) rapidly growing smooth lump, rubbery, fills the breast, mobile. Diagnosis?
Phyllodes tumor (cystosarcoma phyllodes). Triple assessment → Core biopsy. Treatment: Wide local excision with 1 cm clear margins (NOT enucleation). Large tumors → simple mastectomy. No axillary clearance needed.
Q. Male, 60 years, hard lump behind right nipple with skin tethering. Diagnosis?
Male breast carcinoma. Treatment: Modified radical mastectomy + SLNB. ~80% ER+; adjuvant tamoxifen.
Q. 30-year-old woman, eczematous rash of nipple not responding to steroids, unilateral. Diagnosis?
Paget's disease of the nipple. Nipple biopsy → Paget cells (large, pale, vacuolated), CEA+, EMA+. Underlying DCIS/invasive cancer must be excluded with mammogram + MRI.
🔴 SCENARIO 8: MASTECTOMY CLINICAL VIVA
Q. What are the steps of Modified Radical Mastectomy (MRM)?
- Position: Supine, arm extended on arm board
- Incision: Transverse elliptical incision encompassing nipple-areolar complex and biopsy scar (Stewart's transverse incision - cosmetically superior); or oblique Halsted-type incision
- Raise skin flaps (superior + inferior) - 5-8 mm of subcutaneous fat left on flap
- Mastectomy: Dissect breast from pectoralis major fascia (preserve both pectoral muscles)
- Axillary dissection: Identify and preserve:
- Long thoracic nerve (medially, on chest wall)
- Thoracodorsal nerve (laterally, on latissimus dorsi)
- Thoracodorsal vessels
- Medial/lateral pectoral nerves
- Axillary vein (superior boundary)
- Remove specimen (breast + axillary contents Level I & II)
- Drains: 2 closed suction drains (axillary + mastectomy flap)
- Closure
Q. What is the difference between Patey, Scanlon, and Rotter-Handley operations?
| Operation | Pec Major | Pec Minor | Axilla |
|---|
| Halsted radical | Removed | Removed | Level I-III |
| Patey's MRM | Preserved | Removed | Level I-II (III accessible) |
| Scanlon's MRM | Preserved | Divided (not removed) | Level I-II |
| Modified MRM (standard today) | Preserved | Preserved | Level I-II |
| Rotter-Handley | Preserved | Preserved | Level II (through gap) |
| Simple/total mastectomy | Preserved | Preserved | No dissection |
Q. What are the boundaries of axillary dissection in ALND?
- Superiorly (roof): Axillary vein
- Medially: Chest wall (serratus anterior) and long thoracic nerve
- Laterally: Latissimus dorsi and thoracodorsal nerve
- Anteriorly: Pectoralis major/minor
- Inferiorly: Axillary tail of breast (tail of Spence)
Q. You find the sentinel node positive on frozen section intraoperatively. What do you do?
Based on ACOSOG Z-0011 trial criteria: If the patient has 1-2 positive sentinel nodes + BCS + whole-breast radiation planned → NO completion ALND needed (no survival difference, less morbidity).
ALND is still indicated if: >2 positive sentinel nodes, mastectomy, clinically positive nodes, neoadjuvant chemotherapy setting (ALLIANCE trial - some centres).
🔴 COMMON SHORT NOTES / ONE-LINERS
| Condition | Key Point |
|---|
| Most common benign tumor | Fibroadenoma |
| Most common benign condition | Fibrocystic disease |
| Most common malignant breast tumor | Invasive ductal carcinoma (80%) |
| Most common site of breast cancer | Upper Outer Quadrant (50%) |
| Most common type of nipple discharge | Milky (physiological) |
| Most common cause of blood-stained discharge | Intraductal papilloma |
| Most common complication of ALND | Seroma (early); Lymphedema (late) |
| Nerve for winged scapula | Long thoracic nerve (C5,6,7) |
| Nerve for arm adduction weakness | Thoracodorsal nerve |
| Nerve for inner arm numbness | Intercostobrachial nerve (T2) |
| Breast cancer spreads to bone in what order? | Lumbar vertebrae → neck of femur → thoracic vertebrae → ribs → skull |
| Bone mets are? | Osteolytic (mainly); can be osteosclerotic or mixed |
| Triple-negative → associated mutation | BRCA1 |
| HER2+ targeted therapy | Trastuzumab (Herceptin) |
| Standard margin for lumpectomy | "No tumor on ink" (SSO/ASTRO) |
| ACOSOG Z-0011 significance | 1-2 +ve SLN + BCT + RT → no ALND needed |
| Phyllodes spreads via | Haematogenous (NOT lymphatics) |
| Inflammatory breast cancer treatment | NACT first → MRM → RT (no BCT) |
| pCR after NACT = | Best prognostic marker for LABC |
| Paget cells stain | CEA+, EMA+ (S100 negative - unlike melanoma) |
| Gynecomastia drugs mnemonic | DISCO - Digoxin, Isoniazid, Spironolactone, Cimetidine, OCP/estrogen |
Sources: Bailey & Love's 28th ed., Schwartz's Principles of Surgery 11th ed., Mulholland Surgery 7th ed., Current Surgical Therapy 14th ed.