I now have comprehensive material from multiple authoritative sources. Here is the full differential diagnosis:
Differential Diagnosis of Convulsions in Pediatric Case Presentation
The differential falls into two major tiers:
- Is this truly a seizure? (epileptic vs. non-epileptic mimics)
- If it is a seizure, what is the cause? (provoked vs. unprovoked, and the underlying etiology)
TIER 1 - Is It a True Epileptic Seizure?
Non-Epileptic Mimics ("Not All That Shakes Is a Seizure")
These must be excluded first because management differs completely.
1. Febrile Seizure (Simple or Complex)
Reason to consider: Most common seizure type in children aged 6 months to 6 years. Child has fever (≥38°C), generalized tonic-clonic episode lasting <15 minutes, single episode in the illness, fully normal neurologically afterward.
- For simple febrile seizure: No further investigation needed; benign, self-limited
- For complex febrile seizure: Focal features, duration >15 minutes, or recurrence within 24 hours - must investigate further to exclude meningitis, encephalitis, or underlying epilepsy
- Key distinguishing feature: Temperature documented, age range 6 months-6 years, no CNS signs
2. Breath-Holding Spell
Reason to consider: Very common in toddlers aged 6 months to 5 years. Triggered by pain, fright, or frustration. Child cries briefly, then holds breath, becomes cyanotic (cyanotic type) or pale (pallid/reflex anoxic type), loses consciousness, and may develop brief tonic-clonic jerks from cerebral anoxia.
- Distinguishes from epileptic seizure: Always has a clear trigger (emotional/painful stimulus), starts with crying, involuntary jerks come AFTER the loss of consciousness from anoxia (not before), full recovery is rapid, EEG is normal, no postictal drowsiness
- Danger of over-diagnosis: Parents and physicians may interpret this as epilepsy; the key is the trigger and the crying-then-apnea sequence
3. Syncope (Vasovagal / Reflex Anoxic)
Reason to consider: In older children and adolescents, prolonged standing, pain, heat, or emotional stress causes vasovagal response with loss of consciousness. The fall may be accompanied by a few tonic jerks or myoclonic movements from cerebral hypoperfusion ("convulsive syncope").
- Distinguishes from seizure: Pallor and diaphoresis precede the event; occurs while upright; rapid recovery (no postictal confusion); may have prodrome of dizziness, nausea, visual graying; normal EEG and ECG (or bradycardia on ECG)
- Key clue: If the child is laid flat, recovery is almost immediate
4. Absence Seizure vs. Daydreaming / Inattention
Reason to consider: Brief staring spells in school-age children are common. True childhood absence epilepsy (CAE) causes sudden brief arrests of consciousness (5-30 seconds), dozens of times per day, with abrupt termination and NO postictal confusion. Daydreaming looks similar but can be interrupted by calling the child's name.
- True absence: Cannot be interrupted; hyperventilation for 3 minutes can often provoke a spell in the clinic; EEG shows classic 3 Hz spike-and-wave; no postictal phase
- Distinguishes from complex focal seizure: Absence has no aura, no automatisms (or only brief lip smacking), instantaneous recovery; complex focal seizures have longer duration, more prominent automatisms, and postictal confusion
- Distinguishes from daydreaming: Daydreaming child responds to their name; absence child does not
5. Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizure (PNES)
Reason to consider: More common in adolescent girls; events look like generalized convulsions but have a psychological basis. Often occur in front of an audience, may be prolonged, patient resists eye opening, back-arching (opisthotonus), pelvic thrusting, side-to-side head movements.
- Key distinguishing features: Eyes typically remain closed (epileptic seizures - eyes usually open); out-of-phase limb movements; lack of postictal state despite apparent severity; normal prolactin levels post-ictally; normal EEG during the event
- Important: Many patients with PNES also have true epilepsy - the two can coexist
6. Hypnic Jerks (Sleep Myoclonus)
Reason to consider: Normal phenomenon - sudden brief jerks of the limbs at the transition from wakefulness to sleep. Benign, symmetric, single or few jerks, no loss of consciousness.
- Distinguishes from seizure: Occurs only at sleep onset, child wakes up, no other features, occurs in all ages; no EEG abnormality
7. Tics and Stereotypies
Reason to consider: In children with autism spectrum disorder or Tourette syndrome, repetitive movements (motor tics, head shaking) may be mistaken for seizures.
- Distinguishes from seizure: Tics are brief, stereotyped, semi-voluntary, partially suppressible, and consciousness is fully preserved throughout; no postictal phase; often associated with a premonitory urge
8. Benign Paroxysmal Vertigo of Childhood
Reason to consider: Young children (1-4 years) suddenly become frightened, grab onto an object, appear pale and ataxic for seconds to minutes with no loss of consciousness. No tonic-clonic movements.
- Distinguishes from seizure: No loss of consciousness; child is frightened but alert; nystagmus may be present; resolves completely; a migraine variant
9. Shuddering Attacks
Reason to consider: Infants and toddlers develop brief shivering/trembling episodes lasting 1-2 seconds during feeding or emotional states.
- Distinguishes from seizure: No loss of consciousness; very brief; child continues normal activity; EEG is normal; may represent early essential tremor
10. Sandifer Syndrome
Reason to consider: Infants with gastro-oesophageal reflux (GORD) may develop dystonic posturing (neck extension, head rotation, back arching) during or after feeds - can easily be mistaken for infantile spasms or seizures.
- Distinguishes from seizure: Occurs peri-prandially; associated with feeding difficulties, vomiting; improvement with anti-reflux treatment; no EEG abnormality
TIER 2 - If It IS a Seizure: What Is the Cause?
A. PROVOKED (Acute Symptomatic) Seizures
These are caused by an identifiable acute insult. They carry a lower risk of recurrent epilepsy than unprovoked seizures.
1. Febrile Seizure
- Already described above - the most common provoked seizure
2. Meningitis / Encephalitis
Reason to consider - RED FLAG: Fever + seizure + signs of meningeal irritation (neck stiffness, photophobia, Kernig's/Brudzinski's sign) or altered consciousness must trigger immediate evaluation for CNS infection.
- Bacterial meningitis (Neisseria meningitidis, Streptococcus pneumoniae, Listeria): Rapid deterioration, purpuric rash (meningococcal), bulging fontanelle in infants, toxic appearance
- Viral encephalitis (HSV, enterovirus): Behavioral change, focal neurological signs, CSF pleocytosis
- Tuberculous meningitis: Subacute onset, low-grade fever, cranial nerve palsies, contact history
- Key distinguishing feature from simple febrile seizure: Child does NOT return to normal between or after seizures; persistent altered consciousness; meningeal signs
3. Metabolic Causes
Reason to consider: Particularly in neonates and infants; also in any child with a systemic illness.
| Metabolic Cause | Reason / Clue |
|---|
| Hypoglycemia | Jitteriness, pallor, sweating; first presentation of diabetes, inborn error of metabolism, or insulinoma; glucose <2.6 mmol/L |
| Hyponatremia | Diarrhoeal illness with excess free water intake, SIADH, salt-wasting; serum Na <125 mEq/L |
| Hypernatremia | Severe dehydration, salt poisoning; high serum Na |
| Hypocalcemia | Neonatal period (transient hypoparathyroidism), rickets, DiGeorge syndrome; tetany, carpopedal spasm, prolonged QT on ECG |
| Hypomagnesemia | Often coexists with hypocalcemia; refractory seizures |
| Pyridoxine (B6) deficiency | Neonatal seizures refractory to all anticonvulsants - dramatic response to IV pyridoxine |
- Rosen's Emergency Medicine; Harrison's 22E
4. Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE)
Reason to consider: Neonates with perinatal asphyxia, low Apgar scores, cord prolapse, or placental abruption. Seizures within the first 12-24 hours of life.
- Clue: Documented intrapartum complication; encephalopathic infant (hypotonia, poor feeding, abnormal cry); seizures may be subtle (lip smacking, eye deviation, bicycling)
5. CNS Infection - Cerebral Abscess / Neurocysticercosis
Reason to consider:
- Cerebral abscess: Immunocompromised child, cyanotic congenital heart disease (paradoxical emboli), sinusitis, mastoiditis; focal seizures + headache + fever
- Neurocysticercosis: Endemic regions (Asia, Africa, Latin America); calcified cysts visible on CT; common cause of new-onset epilepsy in older children in endemic areas
6. Head Trauma
Reason to consider:
- Immediate (impact) seizures: Within seconds of head injury
- Early post-traumatic seizures: Within first 7 days - reflect acute brain injury
- Late post-traumatic epilepsy: >7 days after injury - true epileptogenesis; risk is 30-50% with penetrating injury
- Non-accidental injury (NAI): In infants with seizures, always consider subdural haematoma from shaken baby syndrome; look for retinal haemorrhages, unexplained bruising, inconsistent history
7. Toxic Ingestion / Drug Poisoning
Reason to consider: In toddlers who have access to household medications or toxins.
- Common culprits: antihistamines, tricyclic antidepressants, theophylline, camphor, organophosphates, isoniazid, cocaine, alcohol
- Clue: Acute onset in a previously well toddler with no fever; pupillary changes, autonomic instability, other toxidrome features
8. Electrolyte Disturbance from Dehydration
Reason to consider: Most common acute electrolyte cause in children - gastroenteritis with severe dehydration causing hyper- or hyponatremia.
- Clue: Preceding diarrhoea/vomiting, signs of dehydration (dry mucosa, sunken fontanelle, reduced skin turgor), electrolytes confirm the diagnosis
B. UNPROVOKED Seizures - Epilepsy Syndromes
When no acute cause is found, consider specific epilepsy syndromes (age-stratified):
| Age | Epilepsy Syndrome | Key Features |
|---|
| Neonates | Benign neonatal familial convulsions | 2nd-3rd day of life; strong family history; self-limiting |
| Infants 3-12 months | West Syndrome (Infantile spasms) | Clusters of flexion spasms on waking, developmental regression, hypsarrhythmia on EEG |
| 1-5 years | Dravet Syndrome | Prolonged febrile hemiconvulsions, refractory, SCN1A mutation; normal early development then regression |
| 3-12 years | Childhood Absence Epilepsy | Multiple daily absences, 3 Hz spike-wave, excellent prognosis |
| 5-15 years | Self-Limited Epilepsy with Centrotemporal Spikes (BECTS/Rolandic) | Nocturnal focal motor seizures of face/mouth, hemisensory symptoms, normal development, outgrown by adolescence |
| Childhood | Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome | Multiple seizure types (tonic, atonic, atypical absence), intellectual disability, slow spike-wave on EEG, poor prognosis |
| Adolescence | Juvenile Myoclonic Epilepsy (JME) | Morning myoclonic jerks, GTC on awakening, absence; precipitated by sleep deprivation; lifelong but well-controlled |
C. STRUCTURAL / LESIONAL Causes
Consider in any child with:
- Focal seizures or focal neurological signs
- Seizures refractory to first-line treatment
- Abnormal head circumference (macro/microcephaly)
- Neurocutaneous stigmata on skin examination
| Cause | Clue |
|---|
| Cortical dysplasia / malformation of cortical development | MRI abnormality; early-onset focal epilepsy |
| Tuberous Sclerosis | Ash-leaf spots, shagreen patches, facial angiofibromas; infantile spasms |
| Sturge-Weber Syndrome | Port-wine stain on face (V1), contralateral focal seizures, tram-track calcifications on skull X-ray |
| Neurofibromatosis | Café-au-lait spots, learning difficulties, neurofibromas |
| CNS Tumour | Progressive focal seizures, raised ICP, papilloedema, morning headaches/vomiting |
| Hippocampal sclerosis | History of prolonged febrile seizure; temporal lobe epilepsy; MRI shows hippocampal atrophy and signal change |
- Rosen's Emergency Medicine; Harrison's 22E
Summary Differential Framework for Case Presentation
When listing differentials in a case, structure them as follows:
1. Most Likely (given the clinical features)
→ e.g., "Simple febrile seizure in view of: age 2 years, fever,
generalized tonic-clonic <15 min, single episode, full recovery"
2. Must Not Miss (dangerous if overlooked)
→ Bacterial meningitis / viral encephalitis
→ Hypoglycemia
→ Non-accidental injury (if infant)
→ Status epilepticus
3. Other Causes to Consider
→ Complex febrile seizure (if focal or prolonged)
→ Metabolic (hyponatremia, hypocalcemia)
→ Epilepsy syndrome (if recurrent or unprovoked)
→ Seizure mimic (breath-holding spell if triggered; PNES if adolescent)
For each differential, give a "reason for" and "reason against" based on the specific case history - this is what examiners and seniors expect.
Key references:
- Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine 22E (2025) - causes by age, Table 436-4
- Rosen's Emergency Medicine - acute symptomatic causes in children
- Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice - febrile seizures, epilepsy syndromes
- Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine - simple vs. complex febrile, PNES