I now have sufficient textbook material. Let me write all 10 comprehensive DNB exam answers:
DNB Otorhinolaryngology — Paper 3 (Laryngology Focus)
Complete 10-Mark Exam Answers
Q1. [10 Marks]
a) Describe FEES. [3]
b) What are the advantages and disadvantages of FEES over video-fluoroscopy? [4]
c) Discuss the Mendelssohn maneuver for management of swallowing disorders. [3]
a) FEES — Flexible Endoscopic Evaluation of Swallowing [3 marks]
FEES (Flexible Endoscopic Evaluation of Swallowing) is a bedside instrumental procedure for assessing swallowing function using a flexible nasopharyngoscope.
Equipment: Flexible fiberoptic nasopharyngoscope (2.4–4 mm), light source, video recording system, food boluses of varied consistencies (thin liquid, nectar-thick, pudding, solid).
Procedure:
- Patient positioned upright; scope passed transnasally along the floor of the nose
- Scope positioned in the hypopharynx just above the epiglottis — allows clear view of larynx, hypopharynx, and piriform sinuses
- Pre-swallow assessment: Anatomy of larynx inspected — vocal fold mobility, secretion pooling, structural anomalies noted
- Swallowing trials: Patient given varied consistency boluses (food colored blue with food dye for contrast); examiner observes:
- Pharyngeal residue in valleculae and piriform sinuses
- Laryngeal penetration (bolus enters laryngeal vestibule above cords)
- Aspiration (bolus passes below vocal folds into trachea)
- Velopharyngeal closure
- Post-swallow: Cough, throat clear, residue, silent aspiration noted
- Sensory testing (FEESST): air-pulse stimulation of aryepiglottic folds assesses laryngopharyngeal sensory thresholds
The "White-out" phenomenon: During the actual swallow, the scope is blanked by pharyngeal wall contact — the pharyngeal phase cannot be seen (a key limitation). Assessment is of the pre- and post-swallow periods.
b) Advantages and Disadvantages of FEES over Video-Fluoroscopy (VFS/MBSS) [4 marks]
Advantages of FEES:
| Advantage | Detail |
|---|
| Bedside/portable | Can be done at ICU bedside, ward, or clinic; no radiology suite needed |
| No radiation | Safe for pregnant women, children, repeated studies |
| Real food used | Actual food/liquid used — more physiological; no barium bolus needed |
| Direct laryngeal view | Superior visualization of vocal folds, arytenoids, secretion pooling |
| Sensory testing | FEESST allows laryngopharyngeal sensory threshold testing (not possible with VFS) |
| Prolonged monitoring | Can observe over multiple meals; no radiation time limit |
| Immediate feedback | Results visible in real-time; biofeedback for therapy |
| Cost | Less expensive than formal VFS suite |
Disadvantages of FEES vs. Video-Fluoroscopy:
| Disadvantage | Detail |
|---|
| White-out | Cannot visualize the pharyngeal phase of swallowing (swallow itself obscured) |
| Oral phase not visible | Cannot assess tongue base, oral preparation, or esophageal phase |
| Cannot quantify aspiration | VFS allows quantification of bolus and timing of aspiration |
| Epiglottic inversion | Epiglottic movement during swallow not seen |
| Scope passage discomfort | Nasal passage discomfort; may alter swallow in some patients |
| VFS unique advantages | VFS visualizes entire swallow in real-time profile including esophageal phase, timing, hyoid/laryngeal excursion |
| Aspiration detection | Both are comparable; VFS may detect small amounts of aspiration not seen on FEES |
c) Mendelssohn Maneuver [3 marks]
Definition: A voluntary exercise in which the patient consciously holds the larynx at its maximally elevated position at the peak of the swallow for several seconds before allowing it to descend.
Physiological Basis:
- During swallowing, the larynx rises and moves anteriorly, which opens the upper esophageal sphincter (UES/cricopharyngeus) through hyolaryngeal traction
- Simultaneously, the epiglottis deflects posteriorly, protecting the airway
- In patients with reduced hyolaryngeal excursion, UES opening is incomplete → residue, aspiration
Technique:
- Patient is asked to swallow saliva and feel the Adam's apple (thyroid cartilage) rise and fall
- Once familiar, the patient is instructed: "When you feel your voice box go up during swallowing, squeeze and hold it up at the highest position for 2–3 seconds before letting it drop"
- Practiced first with saliva, then with food/liquid
Mechanism of Action:
- Prolonged laryngeal elevation → Prolonged opening of UES → More complete bolus transit through pharyngoesophageal segment
- Improved hyoid excursion → Better epiglottic deflection → Reduced laryngeal penetration/aspiration
- Increases duration and width of UES opening
Indications:
- Reduced laryngeal elevation and excursion (post-stroke, neurological dysphagia)
- Incomplete UES relaxation / cricopharyngeal dysfunction
- Post-total laryngectomy (tracheoesophageal voice, neoglottic phonation)
- Zenker's diverticulum (adjunct to surgical treatment)
- Post-radiotherapy pharyngeal weakness
Contraindications: Severe cognitive impairment (inability to follow instructions); severe respiratory compromise
Q2. [10 Marks]
a) Discuss the criteria for diagnosis of a subglottic stenosis in a term and preterm neonate. [3]
b) Describe the Cotton-Myer classification and management of type 4 subglottic stenosis. [4+3]
a) Criteria for Diagnosis of Subglottic Stenosis in Term and Preterm Neonate [3 marks]
Subglottic Stenosis (SGS) is defined as a narrowing of the subglottic lumen below the vocal folds and above the first tracheal ring.
Normal Subglottic Diameter:
- Term neonate (>37 weeks): 4.5–5.5 mm (≥4.5 mm is normal)
- Preterm neonate (<37 weeks): 3.0–4.0 mm depending on gestational age/weight
Definition of Subglottic Stenosis:
- Term neonate: Subglottic diameter <4.0 mm = subglottic stenosis
- Preterm neonate: Subglottic diameter <3.0 mm = subglottic stenosis
Clinical Criteria for Diagnosis:
-
History:
- Biphasic stridor (inspiratory > expiratory) — present from birth (congenital) or after prolonged intubation (acquired)
- Recurrent croup episodes (>2 attacks before age 3 years with no other cause)
- Difficulty with extubation after neonatal intubation
- Cyanotic episodes, feeding difficulties, failure to thrive
-
Endoscopic Diagnosis (Gold Standard):
- Direct laryngoscopy and bronchoscopy under general anesthesia (spontaneous ventilation maintained)
- Sizing with age-appropriate endotracheal tubes (ETT):
- The largest ETT that passes through the subglottis with a leak at ≤20 cm H₂O determines adequacy
- Stenosis graded if smaller-than-expected ETT is needed
- Measured with rigid telescope: Direct measurement of subglottic lumen
-
Radiological Criteria:
- Anteroposterior (AP) soft tissue neck X-ray: "steeple sign" (funnel-shaped subglottis)
- CT scan neck: measures subglottic lumen — CT is particularly useful for planned surgical intervention
- Airway fluoroscopy: dynamic airway assessment
-
Sizing Criteria by ETT (Clinical Rule):
- Normal term neonate should accept a 3.5 mm (ID) ETT
- If only a 2.5 mm or 3.0 mm ETT passes → at least Cotton-Myer Grade II–III SGS
b) Cotton-Myer Classification and Management of Type 4 Subglottic Stenosis [4+3 marks]
Cotton-Myer (Myer-Cotton) Classification of Subglottic Stenosis:
Based on the percentage of subglottic lumen obstruction, assessed by the largest ETT that passes at <20 cm H₂O leak pressure:
| Grade | % Obstruction | Lumen remaining | Description |
|---|
| Grade I | 0–50% | >50% | Mild; no airway compromise at rest |
| Grade II | 51–70% | 30–50% | Moderate; may have mild stridor |
| Grade III | 71–99% | 1–29% | Severe; stridor at rest, may require tracheostomy |
| Grade IV | 100% | 0% | Complete obstruction; no detectable lumen; requires tracheostomy |
Type 4 (Grade IV) SGS — Features:
- Complete or near-complete obliteration of subglottic lumen
- Soft (immature) or hard (mature, calcified) scar
- Always presents with severe airway compromise requiring tracheostomy
- Almost never amenable to endoscopic management alone
- Associated with: prolonged intubation, trauma, high-dose steroid/radiation, granulomatosis with polyangiitis
Management of Grade IV Subglottic Stenosis:
Step 1: Secure Airway — Tracheostomy
- Performed as the initial emergency/elective procedure
- Provides stable airway, allows recovery, and prepares for definitive reconstruction
- Decannulation is the long-term goal
Step 2: Pre-operative Assessment
- CT scan of neck (3D reconstruction) — assesses length, level, and nature of stenosis
- Endoscopy under GA — assess length, softness, concurrent glottic or tracheal involvement
- Pulmonary function assessment
- Nutritional optimisation (NGT/PEG if needed)
- Control of GERD (a major contributor to scar recurrence)
Step 3: Definitive Surgical Reconstruction
A. Laryngotracheal Reconstruction (LTR) — Gold Standard for Grade IV:
- Single-stage LTR (without tracheostomy at end) vs. Double-stage LTR (tracheostomy maintained post-op)
- For Grade IV: double-stage LTR preferred
- Anterior and posterior cartilage grafting both usually needed:
- Anterior graft: Costal cartilage graft split and placed anteriorly via laryngofissure to expand the anterior subglottic lumen
- Posterior graft: Posterior costal cartilage graft to open posterior glottis/subglottis; technically demanding
- Graft held in place with stent (LT-mold, Montgomery T-tube, or endotracheal tube stent) for 4–6 weeks
- Success rate: 80–95% decannulation in experienced hands
B. Cricotracheal Resection (CTR) — Preferred for Isolated Subglottic Grade IV:
- Resection of the entire stenotic segment including the cricoid (partially or completely)
- End-to-end thyrotracheal or cricotracheal anastomosis
- Single-stage procedure with better outcomes in adults and older children
- Contraindicated if stenosis extends into glottis
C. Adjuncts:
- Mitomycin C (antimitotic) — applied topically to raw surfaces to prevent restenosis
- Intralesional steroids (triamcinolone) — at time of surgery or endoscopic dilation
- Anti-reflux therapy: PPI mandatory post-operatively
- Stenting with Montgomery T-tube for mature scars
Outcome for Grade IV SGS:
- Decannulation rate: ~70–80% with LTR; ~85–90% with CTR
- Multiple procedures often needed
- Phonation and swallowing rehabilitation essential post-decannulation
Q3. [10 Marks]
How is laryngopharyngeal reflux (LPR) different from gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)? Describe the various clinical features of LPR and its diagnosis and management. [2+(2+3+3)]
Differences Between LPR and GERD [2 marks]
| Feature | GERD | LPR |
|---|
| Primary symptom | Heartburn, regurgitation | Throat symptoms: globus, dysphonia, cough |
| Heartburn | Present in >80% | Present in only 25–35% |
| Mechanism | Lower esophageal sphincter (LES) dysfunction; supine reflux | Failure of upper esophageal sphincter (UES) + LES; upright reflux |
| Position | Worse supine (night) | Worse upright (daytime activity) |
| Esophageal injury | Esophagitis, Barrett's esophagus common | Uncommon — laryngopharyngeal mucosa less protected |
| pH monitoring | Distal esophageal pH monitoring adequate | Requires dual-probe (distal + proximal/pharyngeal) pH monitoring |
| Response to PPI | Rapid (4–8 weeks) | Slow — often requires 3–6 months of twice-daily PPI |
| Bolus type | Predominantly acid (liquid) | Acid, non-acid, gaseous reflux |
| Laryngeal damage | Rare | Posterior laryngitis, edema, granulomas, leukoplakia |
Clinical Features of LPR [2 marks]
Symptoms (Major):
- Globus pharyngeus — sensation of lump or foreign body in the throat (most common)
- Dysphonia / Hoarseness — worse in the morning (irritation of vocal folds overnight)
- Chronic throat clearing — due to posterior pharyngeal irritation/mucus
- Chronic cough — dry, nonproductive; often triggers on talking/eating
- Dysphagia — mild; due to posterior pharyngeal edema
- Excess mucus/postnasal drip sensation
- Odynophagia — throat pain, especially in the morning
Reflux Symptom Index (RSI): Validated 9-item questionnaire; score >13 = significant LPR
Laryngoscopic Signs (Endoscopic — Reflux Finding Score/RFS):
- Subglottic edema ("pseudosulcus vocalis") — edema extending below vocal folds — highly specific for LPR
- Posterior commissure hypertrophy — cobblestoning of posterior glottis
- Vocal fold edema (Reinke's edema in chronic cases)
- Diffuse laryngeal edema
- Erythema/hyperemia — arytenoids, posterior glottis
- Interarytenoid swelling — "pachydermia laryngis"
- Thick endo-laryngeal mucus
- Granuloma — at vocal process of arytenoid (contact granuloma)
- RFS > 7 = significant laryngoscopic evidence of LPR
Diagnosis of LPR [3 marks]
1. Clinical Diagnosis:
- RSI ≥ 13 + RFS ≥ 7 → Empiric treatment with PPI is both diagnostic and therapeutic
2. Ambulatory 24-hour pH Monitoring (Gold Standard):
- Dual-probe pH monitoring: Distal (5 cm above LES) and proximal/hypopharyngeal (1 cm above UES) sensors
- LPR diagnosed if proximal pH < 4.0 for >0.9% of monitoring time (Koufman criterion)
- pH-impedance monitoring: Detects both acid and non-acid (weakly acidic, weakly alkaline) reflux events throughout the esophagus — current gold standard as ~40% of LPR events are non-acid
3. Pharyngeal pH Monitoring (Restech Dx-pH):
- Probe placed transnasally at oropharyngeal level
- Detects liquid and aerosolized acid droplets above the UES
- Normal: pH < 4.0 for <0.9% upright time, <0% supine time
- Non-invasive but clinical utility still being validated
4. Flexible Laryngoscopy: Visualizes posterior laryngeal changes as above (RFS scoring)
5. Upper GI Endoscopy: Rules out Barrett's esophagus, hiatal hernia, esophagitis (more relevant for GERD; only 10–15% of LPR patients have esophagitis on EGD)
6. Esophageal Manometry: Assesses UES and LES pressures; helps identify hypotonic sphincters
Management of LPR [3 marks]
I. Lifestyle and Dietary Modification (First-line adjunct):
- Avoid: coffee, alcohol, carbonated drinks, fatty/spicy food, chocolate, mint
- Avoid eating 3 hours before bedtime
- Weight loss (obese patients)
- Elevate head of bed 30°
- Avoid tight clothing
- Stop smoking
II. Medical Management:
1. Proton Pump Inhibitors (PPIs) — Mainstay:
- Omeprazole 20 mg or Esomeprazole 40 mg, twice daily (30 min before breakfast AND dinner) — twice daily essential in LPR (unlike GERD)
- Duration: Minimum 3–6 months (longer than GERD)
- Monitored with RSI and RFS at 3 months
- If no response after 3 months on maximum PPI → consider pH-impedance study
2. H₂ Receptor Antagonists:
- Ranitidine or famotidine at bedtime — added for nocturnal acid breakthrough
3. Alginate preparations: Gaviscon Advance — forms a physical raft preventing reflux
4. Prokinetics: Domperidone, metoclopramide — improve LES tone and gastric emptying (adjuncts)
5. Sucralfate: Coats the laryngeal mucosa; useful for laryngeal granulomas
III. Surgical Management:
- Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication — indicated when:
- Confirmed LPR on pH-impedance study
- Failure of maximum medical therapy after 6+ months
- Non-acid/alkaline reflux causing laryngeal injury (PPIs ineffective)
- Effective in 70–80% for LPR symptoms after failed medical therapy
IV. Management of LPR-related Lesions:
- Contact granuloma → PPI + voice rest; if persistent >6 months → micro-suspension laryngoscopy + excision
- Reinke's edema → Smoking cessation + reflux control + microsurgery (decortication) if persistent
- Vocal fold leukoplakia → Biopsy mandatory; reflux control + close surveillance
Q4. [10 Marks]
a) Management of laryngomalacia in a child with failure to thrive. [5]
b) Spreader graft in rhinoplasty. [5]
a) Management of Laryngomalacia with Failure to Thrive [5 marks]
Background: Laryngomalacia (LM) is the most common cause of neonatal stridor, caused by dynamic inspiratory collapse of the supraglottic structures (omega-shaped epiglottis, redundant aryepiglottic folds, bulky arytenoids).
Failure to Thrive (FTT) in LM occurs due to:
- Increased work of breathing → caloric expenditure
- Feeding difficulty — interrupts feeds to breathe; poor suck-swallow-breathe coordination
- Obstructive sleep apnea → poor sleep → growth hormone deficiency
- Aspiration → recurrent chest infections
FTT is an absolute indication for surgical intervention (supraglottoplasty).
Pre-operative Assessment:
- Flexible nasopharyngoscopy (awake) — confirms supraglottic collapse pattern
- Direct microlaryngoscopy and bronchoscopy (MLB) under GA — gold standard:
- Confirms diagnosis
- Assesses severity
- Rules out synchronous airway lesions (secondary airway anomalies in 15–58% of severe LM)
- Assess for GERD (associated in 65–100% of severe LM) → pre-op pH study
- Polysomnography (PSG) — if OSA suspected
- Nutritional assessment — may need pre-op NG feeding to optimize condition
Surgical Management — Supraglottoplasty (Laser/Cold Steel):
Technique:
- General anesthesia, spontaneous breathing maintained; patient supine with neck extended
- Rigid laryngoscope (Lindholm or Dedo) suspends larynx; operating microscope used
- Procedure depends on anatomical type:
- Short aryepiglottic (AE) folds (most common): Division of AE folds bilaterally (releases epiglottic tethering)
- Redundant mucosa over arytenoids: Excision of redundant cuneiform/corniculate cartilage tissue with cold microscissors or CO₂ laser
- Omega-shaped epiglottis: AE fold division usually corrects epiglottic folding; direct epiglottoplasty only if fold division alone insufficient
- CO₂ laser or cold steel + bipolar — cold steel preferred to reduce edema
- Avoid bilateral posterior glottic trauma → risk of posterior glottic stenosis
- Hemostasis with adrenaline soaked pledgets; larynx inspected after each step
Post-operative Management:
- Observation in ICU overnight; stridor typically improves within 24–48 hours
- Decadron (dexamethasone) IV — reduces edema
- High-flow humidified oxygen; pulse oximetry monitoring
- Resumption of oral feeds when stridor settles (usually 24–48 hrs)
- Aggressive GERD treatment: Omeprazole + ranitidine post-operatively (GERD worsens post-supraglottoplasty if untreated)
- Follow-up laryngoscopy at 6–8 weeks
- Nutritional support — dietitian; catch-up growth monitoring
Results: >90% improvement in stridor and feeding; catch-up growth in FTT patients seen within weeks to months. Tracheostomy rarely required (<1%) in severe cases.
b) Spreader Graft in Rhinoplasty [5 marks]
Definition: A spreader graft is a rectangular piece of cartilage interposed between the upper lateral cartilage (ULC) and the dorsal septal edge, placed bilaterally, to widen and stabilize the internal nasal valve and middle vault.
Anatomy:
- The internal nasal valve = the narrowest point of the nasal airway; angle between the ULC and dorsal septum (normally 10–15°)
- In rhinoplasty (particularly after dorsal hump removal), the ULCs collapse medially → internal nasal valve stenosis → nasal obstruction
- Spreader grafts prevent and correct this collapse
Indications:
Functional (Reconstructive):
- Internal nasal valve stenosis — angle <10° causing nasal obstruction
- Post-rhinoplasty middle vault collapse — inverted-V deformity correction
- Dorsal septal deviation involving middle vault
- Narrowed middle vault (narrow nose/tension nose) — primary rhinoplasty
- After dorsal hump reduction — restores middle vault width
- Crooked nose correction — asymmetric spreader grafts straighten the dorsum
Aesthetic:
7. Widening the dorsal aesthetic lines
8. Smoothing the dorsal profile after hump removal
Graft Material:
- Septal cartilage — ideal; firm, straight; harvested from posterior septum (L-strut preserved: ≥15 mm dorsal, ≥10 mm caudal strut)
- Conchal cartilage — if septal insufficient; may be slightly curved
- Costal cartilage — for revision cases or large grafts needed
Technique:
- Approach: Open (external) rhinoplasty preferred (better visualization); can be closed
- Mucoperichondrial tunnels created between dorsal septum and ULC bilaterally
- Graft dimensions: typically 20–30 mm long × 3–5 mm wide × 2–3 mm thick (depending on nasal length and degree of correction needed)
- Graft slid into tunnel between ULC and dorsal septum; sits flush with or just below the dorsal septal edge
- Secured with 4-0 PDS or Vicryl sutures (mattress or simple interrupted through the septum, ULC, and spreader graft)
- One or both sides may be used (bilateral most common for functional indications)
- Asymmetric spreader grafts used for crooked nose — thicker on concave side to push deviation toward midline
Functional Mechanism:
- Widens internal nasal valve angle → reduces nasal resistance (Poiseuille's Law — resistance ∝ 1/r⁴)
- Restores dorsal width and support to ULC
- Prevents scar-mediated middle vault collapse post-operatively
Complications:
- Asymmetry if grafts placed at different levels
- Palpable/visible graft edge
- Infection (rare)
- Inadequate correction requiring revision
- Over-widening → aesthetically unpleasant broad nose
Q5. [10 Marks]
a) Describe the Hirano's body cover theory of phonation. [3]
b) Describe the various benign lesions of the vocal fold. [3]
c) Discuss the management of vocal nodules. [4]
a) Hirano's Body-Cover Theory of Phonation [3 marks]
Proposed by: Minoru Hirano (1974) — the body-cover model of vocal fold vibration.
Histological Layers of the Vocal Fold:
| Layer | Component | Structure |
|---|
| Epithelium | Stratified squamous epithelium | Cover |
| Lamina propria — Superficial layer (Reinke's space) | Loose fibrous tissue, elastin; few collagen fibres | Cover |
| Lamina propria — Intermediate layer | Dense elastin fibres | Transition (Vocal ligament) |
| Lamina propria — Deep layer | Dense collagen fibres | Transition (Vocal ligament) |
| Vocalis muscle (Thyroarytenoid) | Muscle tissue | Body |
Two-Compartment Model:
- Cover: Epithelium + superficial layer of lamina propria (SLP/Reinke's space) — pliable, wave-propagating layer
- Body: Vocalis muscle — provides the tension and stiffness for pitch control
- Transition: Intermediate + deep layers of lamina propria (vocal ligament) — intermediate stiffness
Mucosal Wave Theory:
- During phonation, expiratory air pressure forces the vocal folds apart
- A traveling mucosal wave propagates upward along the cover (from inferior to superior vocal fold surface) with each vibratory cycle
- The cover (pliable Reinke's space) moves independently of the stiffer body below
- The interface between cover and body allows differential vibration
- Bernoulli effect — airflow between cords creates negative pressure drawing them back together
Pitch Control:
- High pitch: CT muscle contracts → vocal fold elongated and thinned → cover stretched → cover stiffer → higher frequency vibration
- Low pitch: TA muscle contracts → folds shortened/thickened → cover becomes slacker → lower frequency
- Loudness: Increased subglottic pressure → larger amplitude of vibration
Clinical Relevance:
- Lesions in Reinke's space (nodules, polyps, Reinke's edema) alter the mucosal wave → dysphonia
- Stroboscopy assesses mucosal wave propagation — gold standard for diagnosis
- Microlaryngoscopy must preserve Reinke's space to restore normal phonation
b) Benign Lesions of the Vocal Fold [3 marks]
1. Vocal Fold Nodules (Singer's Nodes):
- Bilateral, symmetric, sessile swellings at the junction of anterior 1/3 and posterior 2/3 of vocal folds (maximum vibration point)
- Cause: vocal abuse/misuse; reactive fibrosis in Reinke's space
- Stroboscopy: Bilateral mucosal wave reduction; hourglass glottic closure
- Management: voice therapy (first-line); microlaryngoscopy if refractory
2. Vocal Fold Polyp:
- Usually unilateral; pedunculated or sessile; at anterior 1/3
- Cause: acute vocal trauma (single event — shouting, coughing); vascular rupture in Reinke's space
- Subtypes: edematous, fibrous, hyaline, hemorrhagic
- Management: Microlaryngoscopy + cold steel excision (mainstay); not responsive to voice therapy alone
3. Reinke's Edema (Polypoid Corditis):
- Bilateral diffuse edema of the SLP (Reinke's space) — "wet-fish" appearance
- Cause: smoking (most important) + voice abuse + GERD + hypothyroidism
- Voice: low-pitched, rough, "masculine" voice in women
- Management: Smoking cessation + acid control + microsurgery (decortication — remove epithelium, drain edema, redrape)
4. Vocal Fold Cyst:
- Mucous retention cyst or epidermoid cyst within vocal fold
- Unilateral; appears as a smooth submucosal swelling; normal overlying epithelium
- Stroboscopy: Mucosal wave reduced on affected side
- Management: Microlaryngoscopy + complete excision (marsupialisation or enucleation)
5. Contact Granuloma (Contact Ulcer):
- At vocal process of arytenoid (posterior glottis)
- Cause: GERD (most common), vocal abuse, intubation trauma
- Bilateral or unilateral; pink/erythematous granulation tissue
- Management: PPI + voice rest; surgery only if persists > 6 months + biopsy to exclude malignancy
6. Recurrent Respiratory Papillomatosis (RRP):
- HPV-6 and HPV-11 (low-risk); warty growths on vocal folds and elsewhere
- Management: CO₂ laser or microdebrider debulking (not curative); cidofovir, bevacizumab as adjuvants
7. Intubation Granuloma: Post-intubation injury at vocal process → granuloma
c) Management of Vocal Nodules [4 marks]
Vocal nodules are bilateral, benign, reactive lesions caused by vocal abuse/misuse and are primarily managed conservatively.
I. Voice Therapy (Primary Treatment — First-line):
A. Vocal Hygiene Counselling:
- Adequate hydration (8 glasses water/day; steam inhalation)
- Avoid vocal abuse: shouting, excessive talking, loud singing while unwell
- Voice rest during acute laryngitis
- Avoid whispering (forced abduction is as traumatic as loud voice)
- Reduce caffeine and alcohol (dry vocal folds)
- Treat GERD aggressively
B. Indirect Voice Therapy (Education):
- Voice amplifiers for teachers/professionals
- Avoid background noise competition
- Reduce telephone use (muscular tension increases on phone)
C. Direct Voice Therapy Techniques:
- Resonance/forward-focused voice therapy — Lessac-Madsen Resonant Voice Therapy (LMRVT): trains easy phonation with vibration felt at lips/face, reducing vocal fold collision forces
- Semi-occluded vocal tract exercises (SOVT): Lip trills, tongue trills, straw phonation — reduces collision impact
- Confidential voice technique: Very soft, breathy phonation at a conversational volume — reduces fold impact
- Lee Silverman Voice Treatment (LSVT): High-effort phonation — for hypofunctional dysphonia (not for nodules)
- Manual circumlaryngeal massage therapy — reduces laryngeal muscle tension
Duration: 6–8 weeks of intensive voice therapy (2–3 sessions/week)
Response to Therapy:
- Children: >90% resolution with voice therapy alone (nodules in children are hyaline/immature)
- Adults: 60–80% resolution or significant improvement
- Persistent or fibrous/mature nodules in adults may require surgery
II. Medical Management:
- GERD treatment: PPI bid (if reflux component identified)
- Nasal steroids/antihistamines if allergy-related postnasal drip causing chronic throat clearing
- Nebulized saline/steam inhalation for vocal fold hydration
- Oral mucolytics (guaifenesin)
III. Surgical Management (Last Resort — only when voice therapy fails):
Indications:
- Mature, fibrous nodules not responding to 6–8 weeks of voice therapy
- Lesion causing significant professional disability (singers, teachers, actors)
- Suspicion of malignancy (biopsy needed)
- Unusually large nodules
Technique — Microlaryngoscopy:
- GA with microlaryngoscopy setup (Kleinsasser or Lindholm laryngoscope)
- Operating microscope (×400 magnification)
- Cold steel technique preferred (micro-scissors, micro-cup forceps):
- Minimal incision at the free edge
- Subepithelial dissection to preserve Reinke's space
- Avoid excessive resection (risk of scarring/dysphonia)
- CO₂ laser — used in some centers; risk of thermal damage to Reinke's space
- Bilateral lesions: Operated one side at a time to prevent anterior commissure webbing (avoid bilateral anterior commissure incisions)
Post-operative care:
- Complete voice rest 5–7 days
- Voice therapy resumed 2 weeks post-op (essential to prevent recurrence)
- Stroboscopy at 6 weeks post-op
- Nodules recur in up to 50% without behavioural change
Q6. [10 Marks]
Enumerate various causes of bilateral vocal fold paralysis. Discuss the clinical features, diagnosis and management of bilateral vocal fold paralysis. [2+(2+3+3)]
Causes of Bilateral Vocal Fold Paralysis (BVFP) [2 marks]
Bilateral RLN/vagal paralysis causes:
1. Surgical Trauma (most common):
- Thyroidectomy — most common cause; risk highest in total thyroidectomy, reoperations, cancer surgery
- Cervical spine surgery (anterior approach)
- Mediastinal surgery (thymectomy, esophagectomy)
- Cardiac surgery (PDL ligation, aortic arch procedures)
2. Malignancy:
- Thyroid carcinoma — direct invasion of RLN
- Esophageal cancer — mediastinal spread
- Lung cancer (bilateral mediastinal lymph nodes)
- Mediastinal lymphoma
- Base of skull tumors
3. Neurological:
- Arnold-Chiari malformation — vagal nucleus compression
- Multiple sclerosis — brainstem demyelination
- Brainstem stroke (rare — other cranial nerves usually affected)
- Syringobulbia
4. Intubation Trauma:
- Prolonged intubation → cricoarytenoid joint subluxation/ankylosis (mechanical fixation mimicking paralysis)
5. Inflammatory/Infectious:
- Lyme disease, sarcoidosis, syphilis
- Viral: Epstein-Barr virus, herpes zoster (Ramsay Hunt involving vagus)
6. Idiopathic: ~10–15% — diagnosis of exclusion
7. Congenital:
- Arnold-Chiari in neonates (most common cause in infants)
- Hydrocephalus
- Birth trauma
Clinical Features of BVFP [2 marks]
Critical Determinant: Position of Paralyzed Folds
Medialized folds (folds near midline — most common acutely):
- Stridor — predominantly inspiratory; biphasic in severe cases
- Dyspnea — worse with exertion; may present as acute respiratory emergency
- Good voice quality (folds in midline → near-complete glottic closure → adequate voice)
- Cyanosis in severe bilateral median position
- No significant aspiration (glottis closes well)
Lateralized folds (folds abducted):
- Aphonia or severe dysphonia — weak, breathy voice
- Aspiration — inadequate glottic protection during swallowing
- Dysphagia
- Minimal or no stridor (airway open)
General:
- Acute post-thyroidectomy bilateral RLN palsy = emergency (stridor/respiratory distress)
- Recurrent aspiration pneumonia
- Voice fatigue
Diagnosis of BVFP [3 marks]
1. Flexible Nasopharyngoscopy (First-line):
- Visualizes bilateral fold immobility
- Assesses fold position (paramedian, median, lateral)
- Rules out supraglottic pathology
2. Microlaryngoscopy under GA:
- Palpation of arytenoid cartilages — differentiates true paralysis from cricoarytenoid joint fixation (mechanical)
- Joint fixation → resistance to passive arytenoid movement
3. Laryngeal EMG (LEMG):
- Needle electrode into thyroarytenoid and posterior cricoarytenoid muscles
- Differentiates: paralysis (denervation potentials, absent volitional activity) vs. fixation (normal EMG)
- Assesses reinnervation potential — predicts prognosis
- Absent voluntary MUAPs + fibrillation = complete denervation
- Synkinetic activity = reinnervation without function
4. CT Scan (Neck, Thorax, Head):
- Identifies structural cause: thyroid mass, mediastinal nodes, lung apex tumor, base of skull lesion
- Mandatory if no obvious surgical cause
5. MRI Brain/Brainstem: If central cause suspected (Arnold-Chiari, MS, stroke)
6. Stroboscopy: Mucosal wave present bilaterally confirms neural cause is not the only issue
7. Ancillary Tests:
- Thyroid function tests, serology (Lyme, syphilis, ANA), ACE level (sarcoid)
- Chest X-ray
- ENT assessment of aspiration (FEES, VFS)
Management of BVFP [3 marks]
Goals: Secure airway AND preserve voice AND prevent aspiration — often mutually exclusive; balance is key.
I. Immediate/Acute Management:
Acute Post-operative Bilateral RLN Palsy:
- Emergency reintubation or emergency tracheostomy if severe respiratory distress
- IV dexamethasone reduces post-operative oedema (may improve marginal cases)
- Wait and watch for 6–12 months — spontaneous recovery occurs in up to 60–70% if injury was neuropraxia (stretching/thermal, not transection)
- If known complete nerve section intraoperatively → immediate nerve repair at same sitting
II. Temporary/Bridging Measures:
- Tracheostomy — gold standard for securing airway; allows time for recovery; maintains voice capability with Passy-Muir valve
- Bilateral injection laryngoplasty (temporary) — NOT used in BVFP (worsens airway)
III. Definitive Surgical Management (after waiting 9–12 months for spontaneous recovery):
A. Unilateral Posterior Cordotomy / Transverse Cordotomy (Kashima):
- CO₂ laser section of the posterior 1/3 of one vocal fold
- Enlarges posterior glottis → airway improved
- Advantage: Voice relatively preserved; reversible partial procedure
- Risk: Permanent voice change; hoarseness
B. Arytenoidectomy (Endoscopic or External):
- Removal of one arytenoid cartilage (or mucosa covering it) → lateralizes that fold
- Subtotal endoscopic arytenoidectomy with CO₂ laser
- Lateralization suture (King procedure): Suture passed externally to pull arytenoid laterally — reversible; preserves mucosa
- Risk: Irreversible; aspiration if too much tissue removed
C. Lateralization Procedures:
- Woodman's operation (external arytenoidectomy via external approach) — historical
- Thornell's endoscopic arytenoidectomy
D. Laryngeal Pacemaker / Reinnervation:
- Experimental; ansa cervicalis to PCA reinnervation to restore abductor function
IV. Management of Associated Problems:
- Aspiration: Swallowing therapy, thickened feeds, PEG if severe aspiration
- Dysphonia: Voice therapy; unilateral medialization if lateral fold (paradoxically improves both voice and swallowing)
- Decannulation goal: Achieved after definitive arytenoidectomy in most cases (70–85%)
Q7. [10 Marks]
a) Clinical features, diagnosis and management of type 1 laryngeal cleft. [5]
b) First aid and management of disc battery ingestion in oesophagus. [5]
a) Type 1 Laryngeal Cleft — Clinical Features, Diagnosis and Management [5 marks]
Definition: A laryngeal cleft is a midline posterior defect between the larynx and esophagus due to failure of fusion of the tracheoesophageal septum during embryological development.
Benjamin-Inglis Classification:
| Type | Extent of Cleft |
|---|
| Type 1 | Above the interarytenoid muscle level; supraglottic cleft (interarytenoid cleft only) |
| Type 2 | Extends into the posterior cricoid lamina (partial cricoid involvement) |
| Type 3 | Extends through the entire cricoid into the cervical trachea |
| Type 4 | Extends into the thoracic trachea and may reach the carina |
Type 1 — the most common and mildest form.
Clinical Features of Type 1:
- Presentation in neonates/infants
- Aspiration with feeds — most characteristic: coughing, choking, cyanotic spells during feeding
- Stridor — inspiratory; due to supraglottic collapse/laryngomalacia-like picture (may coexist)
- Recurrent aspiration pneumonia / recurrent chest infections
- Weak cry — due to posterior glottic incompetence
- Gastroesophageal reflux (very common association — 60–80%)
- Failure to thrive — from aspiration and feeding difficulties
- Association with other anomalies: VACTERL sequence, H-type TEF, esophageal atresia, cleft palate
Subtle presentation: Type 1 may be very subtle and missed; diagnosed later as "recurrent pneumonia" or "feeding difficulties"
Diagnosis:
- Flexible Nasopharyngoscopy: May reveal interarytenoid gap; mucus pooling in larynx; laryngomalacia-like picture
- Direct Microlaryngoscopy and Bronchoscopy (MLB) — Gold Standard:
- Under GA; spontaneous ventilation maintained
- Palpation of the interarytenoid region: a probe (suction catheter or probe) can be passed posteriorly into the esophagus if a cleft exists
- The interarytenoid mucosa is retracted anteriorly to visualize the cleft depth
- Video Fluoroscopic Swallow Study (VFSS): Aspiration demonstrated; contrast may enter larynx
- FEES (FEESST): Aspiration with feeds; laryngeal sensory threshold elevated
- CT Neck: Structural anatomy; rarely needed for Type 1 but useful for Types 3–4
- Barium swallow: H-type TEF or esophageal anomaly excluded
- Echocardiogram + renal USS — associated anomalies
Management of Type 1 Laryngeal Cleft:
Conservative (first-line for Type 1):
- Majority of Type 1 clefts are managed conservatively, especially if mild aspiration
- Thickened feeds (nectar/honey consistency) — reduces aspiration
- Upright feeding position (45°)
- Anti-reflux therapy: Omeprazole + ranitidine (GERD exacerbates aspiration)
- Speech-language therapy for feeding strategies
- Many Type 1 clefts improve spontaneously with maturation by 12–18 months
- Serial FEES/VFS monitoring
Surgical Management (if conservative fails or aspiration pneumonia persists):
- Endoscopic repair under microlaryngoscopy:
- Interarytenoid mucosa freshened bilaterally (laser or cold steel)
- Closure with absorbable sutures (5-0 Vicryl) in two layers (mucosal and muscular)
- Bilateral approach: right and left sides sutured separately
- Injection laryngoplasty (Gelfoam or calcium hydroxyapatite) into the interarytenoid region — less invasive; temporarily augments interarytenoid area
- External approach (open surgery via laryngofissure) — for failed endoscopic repair or Types 2–4
Prognosis:
- Type 1: Excellent with conservative or endoscopic repair; most children feed normally by 2 years
- Surgical success rate ~80–90% for endoscopic repair
b) Disc Battery Ingestion in Oesophagus — First Aid and Management [5 marks]
Disc battery (button battery) ingestion is a medical emergency, especially when lodged in the esophagus, and requires immediate intervention (within 2 hours).
Why so dangerous?
- Disc batteries generate hydroxide ions via electrolysis (even if partially discharged): creates tissue liquefactive necrosis (alkali burn)
- Induces local tissue injury via:
- Electric current (low-voltage electrical burn) — direct current causes tissue electrolysis
- Alkali injury — OH⁻ generation → saponification of cell membranes
- Pressure necrosis — direct pressure on esophageal wall
- Mercury/heavy metal toxicity (older batteries)
- Esophageal perforation can occur within 2 hours; aortoesophageal fistula (catastrophic hemorrhage) in 4–6 hours
First Aid / Immediate Actions:
- Honey administration (age ≥ 1 year, NOT infants <12 months — risk of botulism):
- Give 2 teaspoons (10 mL) honey every 10 minutes while en route to hospital
- Honey coats the battery, dilutes the alkali, and significantly reduces necrosis depth
- Sucralfate — 10 mL liquid sucralfate can also be given (any age, including infants)
- These are the ONLY substances to give; do NOT give water or other fluids
- Do NOT induce vomiting — risk of aspiration
- Immediate transfer to hospital — no delay; call emergency services
- NPO (nil per os) — no food or other liquids except honey/sucralfate
Diagnosis in Emergency Department:
- Immediate Plain X-ray (AP chest + lateral) — if ingestion history:
- Disc battery: bilaminar appearance — "double ring" or "halo sign" on AP view (the step-off on lateral view)
- Differentiates from coin (coin is uniform density; battery has halo)
- Location: esophagus (most dangerous), stomach, or lower GI tract
Management:
If battery is in the ESOPHAGUS:
- EMERGENCY — Remove within 2 hours (ideally within 1 hour)
- Rigid oesophagoscopy under GA — gold standard for esophageal battery removal:
- Rigid esophagoscope allows safe grasping and removal
- Direct visualization of esophageal mucosa post-removal
- Assess injury: redness, ulceration, perforation, bleaching
- Flexible endoscopy — can be used if rigid not available; use Roth net or rat-tooth forceps
- Post-removal: Inspect esophageal mucosa; assess depth of injury
- If Grade 2b or 3 injury (deep ulcer, perforation) → nasogastric tube, IV antibiotics, NPO, contrast esophagram at 48–72 hours; surgical consultation
- CT angiography of chest if proximity to aorta noted — risk of aortoesophageal fistula
If battery is in the STOMACH (no esophageal symptoms, asymptomatic):
- Children <5 years or battery >20 mm diameter: Remove within 24 hours via upper endoscopy
- Older children/adults with battery in stomach: Serial X-rays every 24 hours; if not passed in 48 hours → endoscopic removal
If battery has passed beyond pylorus (intestinal):
- Usually passes spontaneously; serial X-rays to confirm passage
- Surgical extraction if not passed in 5–7 days or symptomatic
Post-removal Complications to Monitor:
- Esophageal stricture (weeks to months later) — serial dilation needed
- Tracheoesophageal fistula — late complication
- Aortoesophageal fistula — catastrophic; CT angiography if blood in gastric aspirate
- Vocal fold palsy — RLN injury from esophageal necrosis
- Follow-up esophagram at 4–6 weeks even if asymptomatic
Q8. [10 Marks]
Describe the aetiopathogenesis of oral submucous fibrosis. Discuss the medical and surgical management of oral submucous fibrosis. [3+(3+4)]
Aetiopathogenesis of Oral Submucous Fibrosis (OSMF) [3 marks]
Definition: OSMF is a chronic, insidious, potentially malignant disorder of the oral cavity (and sometimes oropharynx and upper esophagus), characterized by progressive submucosal fibrosis leading to limited mouth opening and blanching of the oral mucosa.
Etiology:
-
Areca nut (Betel nut) — the single most important and well-established etiological factor
- Arecoline (major alkaloid) stimulates fibroblast proliferation and collagen synthesis
- Arecoline inhibits collagenase → failure of collagen remodeling → excessive accumulation
- Other areca alkaloids: arecolidine, guvacine, isoguvacine
- Tobacco (when combined with areca in pan) — synergistic carcinogenic effect
- Slaked lime (Ca(OH)₂) — generates reactive oxygen species, enhances mucosal penetration of arecoline
-
Nutritional Deficiencies:
- Iron, vitamins B, C, and A deficiencies → impaired mucosal immunity and repair
- Micronutrient deficiency worsens fibroblast dysfunction
-
Immunological / Autoimmune Mechanism:
- Elevated IgA, IgG, IgM; autoantibodies against fibroblasts
- HLA-DR association (HLA-DR3, HLA-DR7)
- CD4+ T-cell mediated chronic inflammation in submucosa
-
Genetic Susceptibility:
- Mutations in collagen genes (COL1A1/2)
- Cytokine polymorphisms (TGF-β1 overexpression → the key mediator of fibrosis)
Pathogenesis:
Areca alkaloids (especially arecoline) → TGF-β1 upregulation → stimulates fibroblast proliferation and collagen synthesis (types I and III) → simultaneously inhibits collagenase (MMP) activity → net accumulation of dense, mature fibrous tissue in the submucosa → avascular hyalinized fibrosis → progressive obliteration of blood vessels → mucosal ischemia → blanching → progressive trismus (fibrotic bands in buccinator/pterygomandibular raphe region)
Histopathology:
- Epithelial atrophy ± dysplasia (in advanced lesions)
- Juxta-epithelial hyalinization of connective tissue
- Dense hypocellular collagen bundles
- Reduction in vascularity
- Inflammatory infiltrate (T-lymphocytes, mast cells, macrophages)
- Ossification in advanced cases
Malignant Transformation:
- 7–30% risk of transformation to oral squamous cell carcinoma
- OSMF classified as a potentially malignant disorder (PMD) by WHO
Medical Management of OSMF [3 marks]
1. Cessation of Habit (Most Important):
- Areca nut, tobacco, pan cessation — de-addiction counselling, NRT (nicotine replacement therapy)
- Spontaneous partial improvement may occur with early-stage disease after habit cessation
2. Nutritional Supplementation:
- Iron, vitamins B-complex, A, C, E, zinc — correct deficiencies
- Lycopene (antioxidant) — 8 mg twice daily × 3 months → reduces burning sensation
3. Intralesional Injections (Main Medical Treatment):
A. Intralesional Corticosteroids:
- Triamcinolone acetonide 40 mg/mL or Dexamethasone 4 mg/mL
- Injected into fibrotic bands bilaterally, 1–2 mL per side per session
- Mechanism: Reduces inflammation, inhibits fibroblast activity
- Frequency: Weekly × 10–20 sessions
- Limitation: temporary relief; does not cure fibrosis
B. Intralesional Hyaluronidase:
- 1500 IU in 1 mL normal saline; depolymerizes hyaluronic acid in fibrous bands → softening
- Used alone or combined with steroids
- Results: modest improvement in mouth opening
C. Intralesional Placentrex (Placental extract):
- Contains hyaluronidase + growth factors → promotes angiogenesis and reverses ischemia
- Injected weekly × 10 sessions; improves mouth opening and burning sensation
4. Other Agents:
- Oxypentifylline (Pentoxifylline): Reduces fibrosis, improves microvascular flow; oral
- Colchicine: Anti-inflammatory; inhibits collagen cross-linking
- Interferon-γ: Downregulates TGF-β1; used in refractory cases
- Topical steroids (triamcinolone acetonide paste) for burning sensation
Surgical Management of OSMF [4 marks]
Surgery is indicated for moderate-to-severe trismus (mouth opening < 20 mm) that fails to respond to medical treatment.
Gupta Classification of OSMF (Clinical Staging):
- Stage I: Burning sensation; no fibrosis; mouth opening >40 mm
- Stage II: Fibrotic bands, restricted opening 20–40 mm
- Stage III: Severe trismus <20 mm; dysphonia, dysphagia
- Stage IV: OSMF with malignancy
Surgical Procedures:
1. Fibrotomy (Release of Fibrotic Bands):
- Simple incision of the fibrotic bands via:
- Scalpel/scissors — limited access; risk of bleeding
- CO₂ laser — precise; simultaneous hemostasis; reduced post-op scarring
- KTP laser
- Limitation: Exposed raw area scarring leads to recurrence (50–80% without coverage)
- Must always be combined with a reconstructive procedure
2. Fibrotomy + Split Thickness Skin Graft (STSG):
- After band release, raw mucosal defect is covered with STSG (harvested from thigh)
- Historically used; poor results — skin graft contracts and keratinizes inappropriately in the oral cavity
3. Fibrotomy + Buccal Fat Pad Graft (BFP) — Preferred:
- After bilateral fibrotomy → the buccal fat pad is exposed and advanced to cover the defect
- BFP is vascularized, undergoes spontaneous re-epithelialization with oral mucosa
- Excellent outcomes; donor site morbidity minimal
- Increases mouth opening by 15–25 mm
4. Fibrotomy + Tongue Flap:
- Inferiorly based tongue flap used to cover the defect
- Limited by tongue mobility post-op; used when BFP is inadequate/unavailable
5. Fibrotomy + Nasolabial Flap:
- Superiorly based nasolabial flap tunneled intraorally
- Pedicled random-pattern flap; good for anterior defects
- Two-stage procedure (pedicle division at 3 weeks)
6. Fibrotomy + Radial Forearm Free Flap:
- For extensive bilateral defects in severe stage III OSMF
- Thin, pliable, well-vascularized; allows wide resurfacing
- Used in centers with microvascular expertise
7. Temporalis Muscle Flap:
- For extreme trismus with inadequate condylar movement
- Coronoid process resection may be combined with temporalis flap
Post-operative Rehabilitation:
- Mouth exercises/physiotherapy: Forced mouth opening with Heister's dilator or tongue depressors from day 3–4 post-op
- Minimum 2–3 cm opening should be maintained with daily exercises
- Continuation of anti-fibrotic medications
- Regular surveillance (3–6 monthly) for malignant transformation — biopsy any suspicious areas
Prognosis:
- Disease is progressive; recurrence after surgery possible especially if habit not stopped
- Malignant transformation in 7–30% — lifelong surveillance mandatory
Q9. [10 Marks]
a) Discuss the pattern of spread of glottic laryngeal cancer. [3]
b) How is the management of T3 glottic cancer as per the latest guidelines? [3]
c) Discuss the role of salvage laryngectomy in management of such a lesion. [4]
a) Pattern of Spread of Glottic Laryngeal Cancer [3 marks]
Glottic carcinoma arises from the true vocal folds, most commonly the anterior 1/3 (maximum vibration point).
Factors Limiting Early Spread:
- Poor lymphatic drainage of true vocal folds → late nodal metastasis in early glottic cancer (N0 in T1/T2 ~90%)
- Conus elasticus and quadrangular membrane — anatomical barriers to inferior and superior spread
- Thyroid cartilage — barrier to extralaryngeal spread
Patterns of Spread:
1. Anterior Spread:
- Toward the anterior commissure — the most critical point
- Anterior commissure has poor soft tissue barrier → cancer crosses to contralateral fold early
- From anterior commissure → invades thyroid cartilage at Broyle's tendon (no perichondrium here) → thyroid cartilage erosion → T4a disease
2. Posterior Spread:
- Toward the posterior commissure and arytenoid cartilage
- Involvement of arytenoid → vocal fold fixation (T3 disease)
- Posterior commissure → subglottis → cricoid cartilage → T4a
3. Superior Spread (Supraglottic extension):
- Through the ventricle toward the false cord and epiglottis
- Raises N-stage: supraglottic spread → nodes at Level II–III → higher N-positivity
4. Inferior Spread (Subglottic extension):
- Downward through the conus elasticus into the subglottis
- Defined as extension >10 mm anteriorly or >5 mm posteriorly below the glottis
- Subglottic extension → paratracheal nodal metastasis (level VI) → risk of tracheostomal recurrence post-laryngectomy
5. Deep Spread (Paraglottic Space):
- Into the paraglottic space — between the thyroid cartilage and the glottic/supraglottic mucosa
- Paraglottic space involvement → T3 disease (fixes fold via involvement of cricothyroid joint or direct muscle infiltration)
- From paraglottic space → preepiglottic space → supraglottis
6. Cartilage Invasion:
- Thyroid cartilage: anterior commissure → Broyle's tendon → cartilage erosion → T4a
- Cricoid cartilage: subglottic extension → T4a
- Ossified cartilage is more susceptible to invasion
7. Lymphatic Spread:
- T1/T2 glottic: N0 in ~90%
- T3/T4 glottic: N+ in ~20–30% (increases with paraglottic space, supraglottic extension)
- Drainage: Level II, III, IV (jugular chain); Level VI (paratracheal) for subglottic involvement
8. Distant Metastasis:
- Lung > bone > liver (late finding in advanced T3/T4)
b) Management of T3 Glottic Cancer — Latest Guidelines [3 marks]
T3 Definition (AJCC 8th Edition):
T3 = Tumor limited to the larynx with vocal fold fixation AND/OR invasion of the paraglottic space AND/OR inner cortex of the thyroid cartilage
Management Options for T3 Glottic Cancer:
I. Organ-Preservation (Preferred, where feasible):
A. Concurrent Chemoradiotherapy (CRT) — Standard of Care:
- Platinum-based chemotherapy (Cisplatin 100 mg/m² on days 1, 22, 43) + Radiotherapy (70 Gy in 35 fractions over 7 weeks)
- Based on VA Larynx Trial (1991) and RTOG 91-11 (2003) — CRT superior to induction CT + RT for organ preservation
- RTOG 91-11 conclusion: Concurrent CRT > sequential (induction CT → RT) > RT alone for laryngeal preservation
- Laryngeal preservation rate: ~85% at 2 years
- Overall survival comparable to total laryngectomy (TL) in most T3 cases
- Cetuximab + RT — alternative in cisplatin-ineligible patients (BONNER trial)
B. Induction Chemotherapy (TPF Protocol) → RT:
- TPF (Docetaxel + Cisplatin + 5-FU) × 2–3 cycles → evaluate response
- Complete/partial responders proceed to definitive RT (66–70 Gy)
- Non-responders → proceed to TL
- TAX 324 and GORTEC trials — TPF superior to PF induction for organ preservation
C. Partial Laryngectomy (Selected Cases):
- Supracricoid partial laryngectomy with Cricohyoidoepiglottopexy (SCPL-CHEP):
- Appropriate for selected T3 (unilateral fold fixation, no subglottic extension, no cartilage erosion)
- Removes entire thyroid cartilage, false cords, paraglottic space bilaterally
- Preserves one arytenoid → maintains phonation and swallowing
- No permanent tracheostomy required
- Oncological outcomes equivalent to TL for appropriately selected T3
II. Total Laryngectomy (TL) + Post-op Radiotherapy:
- Indications:
- T3 with cartilage invasion (inner cortex — still T3; outer cortex = T4a)
- Bilateral arytenoid fixation
- Significant subglottic extension
- Failure of CRT (salvage laryngectomy — see below)
- Poor lung function (high aspiration risk with partial laryngectomy)
- Patient preference for definitive surgery
- TL followed by adjuvant radiotherapy (60–66 Gy) or adjuvant CRT (positive margins, pN2+, perineural invasion, lymphovascular invasion)
N0 Neck Management in T3 Glottic:
- CRT: Radiation covers elective nodal volumes bilaterally (Level II–IV, VI)
- Surgery: Selective neck dissection (Level II–IV) at time of TL or as post-CRT planned surgery
c) Role of Salvage Laryngectomy [4 marks]
Definition: Salvage laryngectomy is total laryngectomy performed for persistent or recurrent laryngeal carcinoma following previous organ-preservation treatment (CRT or RT).
Indications for Salvage Laryngectomy:
- Residual disease — failure to achieve complete response 6–8 weeks after completing CRT/RT
- Local recurrence after complete CRT response (most common indication)
- Chondroradionecrosis — severe, non-resolving necrosis of laryngeal cartilage post-radiation
- Aspiration larynx — non-functional, chronically aspirating larynx after CRT
- Recto-laryngeal fistula or severe late radiation complications
Pre-operative Assessment:
- CT/MRI/PET-CT scan — defines extent of recurrence, cartilage invasion, lymph node status, skip lesions
- PET-CT (3 months post-CRT): Standard for response assessment; guides salvage decision
- Biopsy under GA — histological confirmation of recurrence (post-radiation fibrosis can mimic tumor on imaging)
- Nutritional assessment — most patients are malnourished post-CRT
- Dental review — pre-operative dental extractions if mandibular osteoradionecrosis risk
Surgical Principles:
- Total laryngectomy is performed as a minimum; often extended resection needed
- Pharyngolaryngectomy if hypopharyngeal involvement
- Neck dissection: Selective or modified radical neck dissection (at minimum Level II–IV; extend to Level VI for subglottic)
- Tracheostomy becomes permanent (stoma formed at base of neck)
- Primary tracheoesophageal voice puncture (TEP) can be performed at time of salvage laryngectomy
- Wound closure:
- Pectoralis major myocutaneous flap (PMMF): Most commonly used for pharyngeal closure and wound protection in the irradiated field; reduces fistula rates
- Alternatively: Radial forearm free flap, anterolateral thigh (ALT) flap for pharyngeal reconstruction
- Direct primary closure — acceptable if pharyngeal defect is small and radiation was not excessive
Challenges and Complications (Higher than Primary TL):
- Pharyngocutaneous fistula (PCF) — most significant complication; rate 20–50% in salvage vs. <5% in primary TL; due to:
- Radiation-induced vascular insufficiency
- Poor wound healing in irradiated tissue
- Salivary contamination
- Management: NPO, IV antibiotics, wound packing; surgical closure if not healing
- Wound breakdown and infection
- Carotid artery blowout (1–3%) — erosion of carotid in infected/irradiated field; emergency
- Chyle fistula
- Hypothyroidism — post-total laryngectomy + prior irradiation to thyroid
- Neopharyngeal stenosis — leads to dysphagia; requires dilation
- Failure of TEP voice prosthesis — irradiated tissue
Outcomes of Salvage Laryngectomy:
- 5-year OS: ~35–45% (lower than primary TL)
- Disease-specific survival: ~50–60%
- Local control: ~60–70%
- Complication rate significantly higher than primary TL
- Quality of life: Despite complications, most patients who achieve disease control have acceptable QoL with tracheoesophageal voice
Patient Selection for Salvage:
- Best candidates: rT1–rT2 recurrence, > 6 months after completion of CRT, no distant metastasis, good performance status (ECOG 0–1), adequate nutritional status
Q10. [10 Marks]
a) Describe the various types of prosthesis available for post-laryngectomy voice rehabilitation. [2]
b) How is a hypertonic pharyngoesophageal (PE) segment diagnosed and managed? [2+2]
c) Discuss the various causes and management of central leak and peripheral leak from the voice prosthesis. [2+2]
a) Types of Prosthesis for Post-Laryngectomy Voice Rehabilitation [2 marks]
After total laryngectomy, the larynx is removed and the trachea is brought to the neck as a permanent stoma. Voice rehabilitation options include:
I. Tracheoesophageal Voice Prosthesis (TEP) — Gold Standard:
A one-way valve placed in a surgically created tracheoesophageal fistula (TEF/voice puncture) between the posterior tracheal wall and the anterior esophageal wall. During phonation, the patient occludes the stoma (finger, HME, hands-free valve) → air flows through the prosthesis → vibrates the PE segment → generates voice.
Types of Prostheses:
| Category | Examples |
|---|
| Non-indwelling (patient-changeable) | Blom-Singer Classic, Provox NiD — removed, cleaned, and replaced by patient; smaller diameter; lasts 3–6 months |
| Indwelling (clinician-changeable) | Provox 2, Provox Vega (Atos Medical); Blom-Singer Indwelling — inserted by clinician/SLP; larger flange prevents dislodgement; lasts 3–6 months; preferred |
| Low-resistance prosthesis | Provox ActiValve — magnetic valve for patients with high PE segment pressure or frequent aspiration |
| Extended-wear | Provox Life — designed for hands-free phonation |
Key Components: Duck-bill or slit valve (opens with air pressure, closes to prevent aspiration of food/liquid)
II. Electrolarynx (Electronic Larynx):
- Battery-powered vibrating device held against the neck or cheek
- Produces monotone, robotic-quality voice
- Used when TEP is not feasible or as immediate post-laryngectomy voice
- Types: Servox, TruTone, Western Electric (neck-type, intraoral)
III. Oesophageal Voice:
- Patient swallows and traps air in the esophagus → releases it in a controlled manner to vibrate the PE segment
- Completely hands-free; no device needed
- Requires intensive speech therapy (months); success rate ~25–35%
- Poor voice quality; limited to ~3–6 words per breath
b) Hypertonic PE Segment — Diagnosis and Management [2+2 marks]
Definition: Hypertonicity of the pharyngoesophageal (PE) segment = excessive tension/spasm of the cricopharyngeus and inferior pharyngeal constrictor muscles at the neopharyngeal reconstructed segment → impedes airflow through the prosthesis → poor/absent TEP voice.
Diagnosis:
-
Clinical: Patient unable to produce voice or produces strained, effortful voice despite correct prosthesis placement and patent valve; occlusion test: patient occludes stoma, phonates → no voice or minimal voice despite adequate pulmonary air reserve
-
Insufflation Test (Taub test): A catheter is passed transnasally into the esophagus → air insufflated at different rates → patient asked to sustain "ahhh":
- Normal: fluent voice at low insufflation pressures (5–10 cm H₂O)
- Hypertonic PE segment: voice only at high pressures (>20 cm H₂O) or no voice at all
-
Videofluoroscopy: Barium swallow in AP and lateral — reveals incomplete relaxation of PE segment; column of barium halted at the level of cricopharyngeus during phonation
-
Nasopharyngoscopy/Rigid endoscopy: Visualizes the neopharynx; narrowed/spastic segment
Management of Hypertonic PE Segment:
-
Botulinum Toxin Injection (First-line):
- Botulinum toxin A (50–100 units) injected into the cricopharyngeus bilaterally
- Transcervical approach (EMG-guided) or transoral endoscopic injection
- Results: Voice improvement in 70–80%; duration 3–6 months; repeatable
- Trial used to predict response to surgery
-
Pharyngeal Plexus Neurectomy:
- Division of pharyngeal plexus branches to cricopharyngeus via external cervical approach
- Permanent; success rate ~70%
-
Myotomy:
- Cricopharyngeal myotomy — surgical division of the cricopharyngeus muscle
- External approach; most definitive surgical option
- May be combined with constrictor myotomy
- Success rate ~75–85%
-
Endoscopic Dilation: Pneumatic dilation of the PE segment — less effective for hypertonicity (better for stricture)
c) Central Leak and Peripheral Leak from Voice Prosthesis [2+2 marks]
Central Leak (Through the prosthesis):
Definition: Liquid/food passes through the prosthesis valve itself (through the lumen of the prosthesis into the trachea) — the valve is incompetent.
Causes:
- Candidal biofilm accumulation on the valve — most common cause; fungal deposits prevent complete valve closure
- Prosthesis lifetime exceeded — valve wear and degradation
- Encrustation of valve by mineral deposits (calcium) — prevents closure
- Wrong prosthesis length — excessive length → tip sits in posterior pharynx → valve held open
- Reflux — acid degrades valve material faster
Management of Central Leak:
- Antifungal prophylaxis: Nystatin oral suspension (swish and swallow) or fluconazole → treats candidal biofilm
- Prosthesis replacement — elective or urgent depending on aspiration severity
- Prosthesis brushing — specialized brush kit; patient cleans prosthesis daily
- Acidic oral gel (Bepanthen, citric acid gel) — applied to prosthesis head to reduce biofilm
- Switch to higher-resistance valve (e.g., Provox ActiValve) — magnetic valve more resistant to reflux/fungal colonization
- NPO temporarily — if heavy aspiration risk
Peripheral Leak (Around the prosthesis):
Definition: Liquid/food passes around the outside of the prosthesis, between the prosthesis flange and the TE fistula tract wall, into the trachea.
Causes:
- Oversized fistula — fistula tract wider than prosthesis diameter (dilated/enlarged tract)
- Wrong prosthesis size — too short or too narrow for the tract
- Fistula granulation tissue — prevents sealing
- Radiation-induced TE fistula enlargement — poor tissue integrity in the irradiated field
- Excessive coughing/trauma — mechanical widening of tract
- Weight loss — tissue volume reduction → fistula enlarges
Management of Peripheral Leak:
- Upsizing the prosthesis diameter — use a wider-diameter prosthesis to fill the enlarged fistula
- Longer prosthesis — if TEF length is greater than estimated
- Temporary prosthesis removal + fistula downsizing:
- Catheter/Red Robinson catheter placed to maintain patency while tract contracts
- Allow 24–48 hours for spontaneous narrowing; then resize prosthesis
- Granulation tissue removal: Endoscopic or chemical cauterization (silver nitrate)
- Surgical TEF revision:
- If fistula is severely dilated → surgical closure and re-puncture at new site
- Reinforcement with dermal matrix or local flap around the prosthesis
- Pectoralis major myocutaneous or pedicled flap reinforcement — for severely irradiated tissues with persistent leak
- Gelatin sponge (Gelfoam) packing around the prosthesis temporarily
All answers are based on Cummings Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery (6th ed.) and KJ Lee's Essential Otolaryngology, with reference to RTOG/ASCO/NCCN guidelines for oncology questions.