I now have comprehensive data from the textbooks combined with my solid medical knowledge base on shock classification, hemodynamics, and management. Let me compile the full structured answer now.---
Shock in the Emergency Department - Clinical Assessment, Differentials, and Treatment in Resource-Limited Settings
The Physiological Framework - What Is Shock?
Shock is a state of tissue oxygen delivery insufficient to meet metabolic demand. It is not just "low blood pressure" - a patient can be in shock with a normal BP (compensated shock), and a hypotensive patient may not always have organ-level hypoperfusion.
The four types - and their haemodynamic fingerprints:
| Type | Cardiac Output | SVR | Filling Pressures | Peripheries |
|---|
| Cardiogenic | ↓ | ↑ (compensatory) | ↑ (congested) | Cold, clammy |
| Hypovolaemic | ↓ | ↑ (compensatory) | ↓ (empty) | Cold, clammy |
| Obstructive | ↓ (impeded) | ↑ | ↑ or ↓ (depends on cause) | Cold, clammy |
| Distributive (septic, anaphylactic, neurogenic) | ↑ or normal early | ↓↓ | ↓ | Warm, flushed (early) → cold (late) |
(Barash Clinical Anaesthesia 9e)
The Clinical Question in Your Scenario
Shock + cold peripheries + MI present + no obvious infection
This immediately narrows your focus: distributive shock is unlikely (no warm peripheries, no obvious infection). You are looking at the three "cold shock" types:
- Cardiogenic shock (MI is present - this is the most likely and most dangerous)
- Obstructive shock (PE, cardiac tamponade, tension pneumothorax)
- Hypovolaemic shock (haemorrhage, dehydration - look for a source)
The single most important clinical discriminator between these three is: the JVP (jugular venous pressure) / neck veins.
Part 1: The Bedside Framework - 5 Clinical Questions to Ask in Order
In a resource-limited setting with only clinical examination and basic investigations, this sequential 5-question approach will identify the type of shock in >90% of cases.
Q1: What do the peripheries feel like?
- Cold, clammy, mottled: Cardiogenic, hypovolaemic, or obstructive shock
- Warm, flushed, bounding pulse: Distributive (septic, anaphylactic, early neurogenic)
In your scenario: Cold peripheries → proceed to Q2
Q2: What are the neck veins (JVP) doing?
This is the single most powerful bedside differentiator in cold shock.
| JVP Finding | Suggests |
|---|
| Elevated / distended neck veins | Cardiogenic shock OR obstructive shock |
| Flat / collapsed neck veins | Hypovolaemic shock |
| Elevated + paradoxical rise on inspiration (Kussmaul's) | Cardiac tamponade, constrictive pericarditis, massive PE |
Q3: Are there signs of pulmonary oedema?
- Yes (bilateral basal crackles, orthopnoea, pink frothy sputum): Cardiogenic shock (left heart failure)
- No: Consider obstructive shock (PE, tamponade, tension pneumothorax) or right heart failure cardiogenic shock
Q4: Is the trachea midline? Are breath sounds equal?
- Trachea deviated + absent breath sounds on one side: Tension pneumothorax - immediate needle decompression
- Muffled heart sounds + elevated JVP + hypotension (Beck's Triad): Cardiac tamponade
Q5: Is there an obvious source of fluid loss?
- Bleeding (external, melaena, haematemesis)?
- Vomiting/diarrhoea, burns, polyuria?
- Recent surgery or trauma?
Part 2: History - What to Ask in the First 2 Minutes
| Domain | Questions | Points To |
|---|
| Cardiac | Chest pain (onset, character, radiation)? Prior MI, angina, heart failure? | Cardiogenic shock from MI/ACS |
| Respiratory | Sudden dyspnoea? Pleuritic chest pain? Leg swelling? Long travel/immobility? | PE |
| Pericardial | Recent viral illness? Pericarditis? Cancer? Renal failure? Chest trauma? | Tamponade |
| Bleeding | Vomiting blood? Dark stools? Trauma? Haematuria? Recent surgery? | Hypovolaemic shock |
| Allergy | Insect sting, new medication, food ingestion before collapse? | Anaphylactic shock |
| Medications | Beta-blockers, calcium channel blockers, digoxin overdose? | Drug-induced cardiogenic shock |
| Endocrine | Steroid use (Addisonian crisis)? Diabetes (DKA)? Known thyroid disease? | Adrenal crisis, myxoedema coma |
| Spinal/Neurological | Recent fall? Trauma to back/neck? New neurological symptoms? | Neurogenic shock |
Part 3: Clinical Examination - Systematic Approach in Shock
General Inspection (5 seconds)
- Level of consciousness: GCS/AVPU (tissue hypoperfusion → confusion → coma)
- Skin colour: Pale, mottled, cyanotic → cold shock; flushed, erythematous → distributive
- Diaphoresis (sweating): Suggests high sympathetic activity → cardiogenic or hypovolaemic
- Urticaria, angioedema, stridor → anaphylaxis
Vital Signs (30 seconds)
- BP both arms (significant difference >15 mmHg → aortic dissection)
- Heart rate: Tachycardia is universal; bradycardia in shock = very bad sign (vagal, high spinal injury, complete heart block, beta-blocker OD, right coronary MI)
- Respiratory rate: Fast in all shock states; slow + laboured = respiratory failure complication
- SpO₂: Desaturating → PE, ARDS complication, tension pneumothorax, pulmonary oedema
- Temperature: Fever → sepsis; hypothermia → severe sepsis, adrenal crisis, myxoedema
Capillary Refill Time (CRT)
- Normal <2 seconds. Prolonged CRT reflects poor peripheral perfusion
- Check on sternum (central CRT) - more reliable than fingers in cold environments
- Central CRT >3 seconds = significant shock
JVP Assessment (Critical Step)
Examine in 45° position, in adequate lighting:
- Flat/not visible at 45° → hypovolaemia (empty tank)
- Visible above clavicle at 45° → elevated JVP (congested)
- Kussmaul's sign (JVP rises on inspiration) → tamponade, PE, right heart failure
Chest Examination
- Auscultation: Bilateral fine crackles (pulmonary oedema - LV failure); absent breath sounds + hyper-resonance (tension pneumothorax); wheeze (anaphylaxis, cardiogenic asthma)
- Tracheal position: Deviation away from affected side → tension pneumothorax
- Percussion: Hyper-resonance → pneumothorax; dullness → haemothorax, pleural effusion
- Respiratory pattern: Kussmaul breathing (deep, rapid) → metabolic acidosis from shock
Cardiac Examination
- S3 gallop (third heart sound) → left ventricular failure, volume overload
- S4 → stiff ventricle, MI, hypertrophic disease
- Muffled/distant heart sounds → pericardial effusion/tamponade
- New murmur:
- Pan-systolic murmur at apex → acute mitral regurgitation (papillary muscle rupture post-MI)
- Pan-systolic murmur at lower sternal edge → ventricular septal defect (VSD) - mechanical complication of MI
- Soft Aortic area murmur → aortic stenosis (cause of cardiogenic shock)
Abdominal Examination
- Pulsatile epigastric mass → ruptured AAA (hypovolaemic shock)
- Peritonism → intraperitoneal haemorrhage, ischaemic bowel
- Rectal examination / check for melaena → upper GI bleed
Peripheral Examination
- Ankle/sacral oedema → chronic heart failure (supports cardiogenic shock diagnosis)
- Asymmetric leg swelling + calf tenderness → DVT → PE source
- Track marks/IV drug use → endocarditis, infective shock
- Skin turgor, dry mucosae → dehydration/hypovolaemia
- Ecchymoses, trauma marks → haemorrhagic shock
Part 4: Investigations Available in Resource-Limited Settings
Tier 1 - Always available (basic ward/ED)
| Test | What it tells you |
|---|
| 12-lead ECG | MI (STEMI, NWMI), arrhythmia, PE (S1Q3T3, RV strain), pericarditis |
| Urine output monitoring | Organ perfusion marker - target >0.5 mL/kg/hr |
| SpO₂ | Oxygenation, PE, pulmonary oedema |
| Blood glucose (glucometer) | Hypoglycaemia, DKA contributing |
| Urine dipstick | Infection, renal failure, diabetes |
Tier 2 - Usually available at district/secondary level
| Test | What it tells you |
|---|
| FBC | Anaemia (haemorrhagic shock), leucocytosis/leucopenia (sepsis) |
| U&E/Creatinine | AKI from shock, hyperkalaemia (MI) |
| Blood glucose (formal) | DKA, HONK |
| Arterial/venous blood gas | Lactate (shock severity), acidosis, oxygenation, PCO₂ |
| Troponin (if available) | Confirms/excludes MI |
| CXR (chest X-ray) | Pulmonary oedema, pneumothorax, wide mediastinum (dissection), cardiomegaly |
| Serum lactate | Best single marker of tissue hypoperfusion severity (>2 mmol/L = concerning; >4 = severe) |
Tier 3 - Ideal but may not be available
- Echocardiography (point-of-care): Most valuable single tool in undifferentiated shock - can show LV function, effusion/tamponade, RV dilatation (PE), volume status (IVC size)
- D-dimer: Low sensitivity at very high pre-test probability of PE in shock
- BNP/NT-proBNP: Elevated in cardiogenic shock
Part 5: Differential Diagnoses in Detail - With Treatment
1. CARDIOGENIC SHOCK FROM ACUTE MI (Your Primary Diagnosis to Manage First)
Pathophysiology: Extensive MI → pump failure → low CO → compensatory vasoconstriction → cold, clammy peripheries → pulmonary congestion (if LV failure).
Mortality 70-80% without intervention (Barash Clinical Anaesthesia 9e)
Clinical profile:
- History: Chest pain (crushing, radiating to arm/jaw), preceding angina, risk factors (diabetes, hypertension, smoking, hyperlipidaemia)
- Diaphoresis, pallor, anxiety
- Cold, clammy skin (compensatory vasoconstriction)
- Elevated JVP (if RV involved or biventricular failure)
- Bilateral basal crackles (LV failure → pulmonary oedema)
- S3 gallop, tachycardia
- ECG: STEMI, LBBB, ST depression (NSTEMI), Q waves
Watch for mechanical complications of MI (new murmurs):
| Complication | Timing | Murmur | Other |
|---|
| Acute MR (papillary muscle rupture) | 2-7 days post-MI | Pan-systolic at apex | Acute pulmonary oedema |
| VSD (septal rupture) | 3-5 days post-MI | Harsh pan-systolic at LLSE + thrill | Step-up in O₂ in RV |
| Free wall rupture | 3-7 days | No murmur | Sudden death/tamponade |
| RV infarction | Acute | No specific murmur | Hypotension + elevated JVP, clear lungs |
RV infarction deserves special mention:
- Occurs with inferior STEMI (right coronary artery)
- Hypotension + elevated JVP + clear lungs (no pulmonary oedema)
- ECG: ST elevation in V4R (right-sided leads - always check in inferior MI)
- Treat with fluids (the RV needs preload) - NOT diuretics
- Avoid nitrates and diuretics (they reduce preload and worsen shock)
Treatment - Cardiogenic Shock from MI:
Step 1 - Immediate stabilisation:
- Oxygen: titrate to SpO₂ ≥94% (avoid hyperoxia in acute MI)
- IV access × 2, send bloods (troponin, FBC, U&E, lactate)
- 12-lead ECG immediately + continuous monitoring
- Aspirin 300 mg stat (chew/crush) + P2Y12 inhibitor (ticagrelor 180 mg or clopidogrel 600 mg loading dose)
- Anticoagulation: Heparin 5,000 units IV bolus
Step 2 - Haemodynamic support:
- If hypotensive (SBP <90 mmHg): Norepinephrine (noradrenaline) is the vasopressor of choice (start at 0.1-0.2 mcg/kg/min, titrate to MAP ≥65 mmHg)
- Add Dobutamine 2-20 mcg/kg/min if low output state persists (inotrope)
- Avoid:
- Beta-blockers acutely in shock (negative inotrope)
- Nitrates in RV infarction or significant hypotension
- Large fluid boluses in LV failure (worsen pulmonary oedema)
Step 3 - Reperfusion (most important):
- STEMI: Primary PCI is gold standard. If unavailable → Thrombolysis (streptokinase or alteplase) if no contraindications
- NSTEMI with shock: Urgent PCI
- Thrombolysis contraindications: Prior haemorrhagic stroke, active bleeding, recent surgery, uncontrolled hypertension (>180/110)
Step 4 - Diuresis (only for pulmonary oedema with adequate BP):
- Furosemide 40 mg IV if pulmonary oedema present and MAP adequate
- Do not diurese in RV infarction
Step 5 - Treat complications:
- Arrhythmias: VF/VT → immediate defibrillation; complete heart block → atropine, then temporary pacing
- Mechanical complications → urgent surgical/catheter intervention
2. CARDIOGENIC SHOCK FROM OTHER CAUSES
Acute Decompensated Heart Failure (non-ischaemic)
- Dilated cardiomyopathy, myocarditis, severe hypertension
- History: Known heart failure, viral prodrome (myocarditis in young), extreme hypertension
- Same clinical picture as above but no acute ECG changes of MI
- Treatment: Dobutamine + diuresis; treat precipitant; avoid beta-blockers acutely
Severe Valvular Disease
- Acute severe aortic stenosis, acute severe MR (chordal rupture)
- Murmur on examination
- Treatment: Stabilise with vasopressors, urgent surgical/catheter intervention
Arrhythmia-Induced Cardiogenic Shock
- Rapid AF, VT, complete heart block, extreme bradycardia
- ECG is diagnostic
- Treatment: Cardioversion (if VT/rapid AF with haemodynamic compromise), pacing (if complete heart block), atropine 0.5-1 mg IV for symptomatic bradycardia
3. OBSTRUCTIVE SHOCK - CARDIAC TAMPONADE
Pathophysiology: Fluid in pericardial space compresses cardiac chambers → impaired ventricular filling → low CO → cold shock.
Causes: Malignancy (most common in adults), uraemia, post-MI (haemorrhagic or Dressler's), viral pericarditis, TB, iatrogenic (post-cardiac procedure), aortic dissection (retrograde).
Clinical profile - Beck's Triad (classic but only present in 10-40%):
- Hypotension
- Elevated JVP (distended neck veins)
- Muffled/distant heart sounds
Additional features:
- Pulsus paradoxus (>10 mmHg fall in SBP during inspiration) - the most sensitive bedside sign; palpate the pulse while asking patient to breathe normally - pulse disappears on inspiration in significant tamponade
- Tachycardia (often >120)
- Kussmaul's sign (JVP rises on inspiration)
- No pulmonary oedema (lungs are clear - the problem is filling, not ejection failure)
- Hypotension worsens with any nitrates or diuretics
- ECG: Low-voltage complexes, electrical alternans (alternating QRS height - pathognomonic), sinus tachycardia
- CXR: Flask-shaped enlarged cardiac silhouette (globular heart)
Treatment:
- Pericardiocentesis (needle aspiration of pericardium) - immediate; life-saving
- Subxiphoid approach: 45° angle toward left shoulder, aspirate until haemodynamics improve
- Even 50 mL removal can dramatically improve BP
- While preparing: IV fluid bolus (250-500 mL NS) to increase preload temporarily
- Do NOT give diuretics or nitrates (fatal)
- Avoid positive pressure ventilation if possible (reduces venous return, worsens tamponade)
- Send fluid for cytology, culture, AFB (to identify cause)
- Aortic dissection tamponade: Do NOT give thrombolytics - emergent surgery
4. OBSTRUCTIVE SHOCK - TENSION PNEUMOTHORAX
Most immediately reversible form of obstructive shock - treat before confirming radiologically.
Causes: Trauma (rib fracture, penetrating injury), mechanical ventilation, central line insertion, spontaneous (tall thin young male with Marfan's).
Clinical profile:
- Tachycardia + hypotension (shock)
- Tracheal deviation away from affected side (late sign)
- Absent/markedly reduced breath sounds on one side
- Hyper-resonance to percussion on affected side
- Elevated JVP (mediastinal shift impedes venous return)
- Worsening hypoxia and respiratory distress
- In ventilated patients: rapidly rising peak airway pressures
Treatment - DO NOT WAIT FOR CXR:
- Needle decompression immediately:
- 2nd intercostal space, mid-clavicular line, large-bore cannula (14G)
- Hiss of air = confirms diagnosis
- Followed by chest tube insertion (5th ICS, mid-axillary line) as definitive treatment
- Oxygen high flow
5. OBSTRUCTIVE SHOCK - MASSIVE PULMONARY EMBOLISM
Pathophysiology: Clot burden blocks main pulmonary artery → acute RV failure → low CO → cold shock.
Clinical profile:
- History: DVT risk factors (immobility, surgery, malignancy, pregnancy, OCP), sudden onset dyspnoea, pleuritic chest pain, haemoptysis
- Elevated JVP (RV outflow obstruction + acute RV failure)
- Clear lungs (no pulmonary oedema)
- Tachycardia, tachypnoea, hypoxia
- ECG: Sinus tachycardia (most common); S1Q3T3 pattern (S wave in lead I, Q wave and inverted T in lead III); new right bundle branch block; RV strain pattern (T wave inversion in V1-V4)
- CXR: Usually normal; may show Westermark sign (oligaemia), Hampton's hump (wedge infarct)
- D-dimer: Elevated but non-specific; in massive PE with shock, pre-test probability is so high D-dimer testing is unhelpful
- Pulsus paradoxus absent (differentiates from tamponade)
Treatment:
- Oxygen, IV access, monitor
- Anticoagulation: Unfractionated heparin 80 units/kg IV bolus then 18 units/kg/hr infusion
- Thrombolysis (in haemodynamically unstable/massive PE):
- Alteplase 100 mg IV over 2 hours (or 0.6 mg/kg if cardiac arrest)
- Streptokinase 1.5 million units over 2 hours
- Contraindications: Active bleeding, recent surgery (<10 days), prior intracranial bleed
- Vasopressors: Norepinephrine to maintain MAP ≥65
- Cautious fluid: Small bolus only (250-500 mL) - do not overload (worsens RV dilation)
- If thrombolysis contraindicated: Surgical embolectomy or catheter-directed therapy
6. HYPOVOLAEMIC SHOCK
Pathophysiology: Low intravascular volume → low preload → low CO → compensatory vasoconstriction → cold extremities.
Clinical profile:
- Flat JVP (empty tank - the key differentiator from cardiogenic/obstructive)
- Clear lungs (no pulmonary oedema)
- History of fluid loss (bleeding, vomiting, diarrhoea, burns, polyuria, fistulae)
- No muffled heart sounds, normal trachea position, equal breath sounds
- Skin turgor reduced (dehydration)
- HR rises, BP falls progressively with blood loss
Classes of Haemorrhagic Shock (ATLS Framework):
| Class | Blood Loss | HR | SBP | Mental Status |
|---|
| I | <750 mL (<15%) | <100 | Normal | Normal |
| II | 750-1500 mL (15-30%) | 100-120 | Normal | Anxious |
| III | 1500-2000 mL (30-40%) | >120 | Decreased | Confused |
| IV | >2000 mL (>40%) | >140 | Very low | Unconscious |
Sources to identify:
- Upper GI bleed: melaena, haematemesis, epigastric pain, known ulcer/varices/NSAIDs
- Ruptured AAA: pulsatile abdominal mass, tearing back pain (classic triad)
- Ectopic pregnancy: woman of childbearing age, pelvic pain (always check pregnancy test)
- Intra-abdominal injury: trauma, peritonism
- Non-haemorrhagic: severe D&V, burns, diabetic ketoacidosis, Addisonian crisis
Treatment:
- Two large-bore IV cannulae (16G or larger)
- Warm IV fluids: 1-2L crystalloid rapidly (0.9% saline or Ringer's lactate); reassess after each bolus
- Blood transfusion for haemorrhagic shock (O-negative if cross-match unavailable)
- For massive haemorrhage: 1:1:1 ratio of packed RBC : FFP : platelets
- Source control: Treat the bleeding source (pressure, surgery, endoscopy, embolisation)
- Vasopressors (norepinephrine) only as bridge while volume being replaced - don't rely on vasopressors alone in hypovolaemia
- Avoid NSAIDS, anticoagulants
- Treat underlying cause: PPI + endoscopy (GI bleed), surgical referral (ruptured AAA)
7. DISTRIBUTIVE SHOCK - Late/Cold Septic Shock
Important caveat: In resource-limited settings, late/decompensated septic shock can present with cold peripheries - the warm phase has passed and vasodilation is no longer compensating, or the patient is already in multi-organ failure.
Clinical clues despite cold peripheries:
- Fever or hypothermia (<36°C or >38.5°C)
- Source of infection (cellulitis, wound, chest sounds, urinary symptoms, abdominal tenderness)
- Known immunosuppression (HIV, diabetes, steroids, chemotherapy)
- Leucocytosis or leucopenia on FBC
Treatment: See Surviving Sepsis principles - broad-spectrum antibiotics within 1 hour, 30 mL/kg IV crystalloid, vasopressors (norepinephrine first line), source control
8. ADRENAL CRISIS (Addisonian Crisis) - Must Not Miss
Commonly missed cause of shock, especially in resource-limited settings.
Causes: Known Addison's disease (missed steroid dose, intercurrent illness), patient on chronic steroids who stopped suddenly, TB of adrenal glands (important in endemic regions), bilateral adrenal haemorrhage (Waterhouse-Friderichsen syndrome in meningococcaemia), post-pituitary surgery.
Clinical profile:
- Severe hypotension, often unresponsive to fluids and vasopressors
- Profound weakness, lethargy, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain
- Skin hyperpigmentation (buccal mucosa, palmar creases, pressure points) - in Addison's disease
- Hyponatraemia, hyperkalaemia (on U&E)
- Hypoglycaemia (on glucose)
- Eosinophilia on FBC (unusual in shock states which typically cause eosinopenia)
- History of steroid use
Treatment:
- Hydrocortisone 100 mg IV STAT - do not wait for cortisol levels if clinical suspicion high
- Repeat hydrocortisone 100 mg IV 6-8 hourly
- IV 0.9% saline + 5% dextrose (correct dehydration + hypoglycaemia)
- Do NOT give fludrocortisone acutely (hydrocortisone at high doses has sufficient mineralocorticoid effect)
- Treat precipitant (infection, etc.)
- Cortisol level - take blood sample BEFORE giving steroids if possible, but do not delay treatment
9. ANAPHYLACTIC SHOCK
May lack obvious warmth/flushing in delayed presentation.
History: Recent drug administration, insect sting, food ingestion.
Features: Urticaria, angioedema, bronchospasm, stridor, severe hypotension.
Treatment:
- Adrenaline (epinephrine) 0.5 mg IM (0.5 mL of 1:1000) - immediate, in anterolateral thigh
- Repeat every 5 minutes if no response
- IV fluids 1-2L rapidly
- Antihistamines (chlorphenamine 10 mg IV) + hydrocortisone 200 mg IV
- Salbutamol nebulisation if bronchospasm
Part 6: The Clinical Decision Tool - Bedside Algorithm for Cold Shock
PATIENT IN SHOCK WITH COLD PERIPHERIES
↓
ASSESS JVP / NECK VEINS
________________________
| |
LOW JVP ELEVATED JVP
| |
HYPOVOLAEMIC ________________________
SHOCK | | |
- Find | LUNGS CLEAR? |
source | | |
- IV fluids YES NO MUFFLED HEART SOUNDS?
- Treat (Obstructive) (Cardiogenic) |
cause | Pulm oedema YES → TAMPONADE
___________ → Pericardiocentesis
| |
TRACHEA JVP + CLEAR
DEVIATED? LUNGS + NO
ABSENT BS? TRACHEAL DEV?
| |
YES YES
↓ ↓
TENSION MASSIVE PE
PNEUMO- (Check ECG -
THORAX RBBB, S1Q3T3)
↓ ↓
IMMEDIATE THROMBOLYSIS
NEEDLE DECOM- + HEPARIN
PRESSION
Also consider in any cold shock:
- RV infarction (inferior MI + clear lungs + elevated JVP)
- Adrenal crisis (steroid history + hyponatraemia + hyperkalaemia + unresponsive shock)
- Late/decompensated septic shock (fever history, source of infection)
Part 7: The Key Bedside Tests Available Without Invasive Monitoring
| Tool | Availability | Key Use |
|---|
| ECG | Everywhere | MI, arrhythmia, PE, tamponade (electrical alternans) |
| Chest X-ray | Most resource-limited settings | Pulmonary oedema, pneumothorax, cardiomegaly |
| Urine output (catheter) | Always | Best organ perfusion marker |
| Blood glucose | Always (glucometer) | Hypoglycaemia, DKA, Addisonian crisis |
| JVP assessment | Bedside, free | Differentiates cardiogenic/obstructive vs. hypovolaemic |
| Peripheral skin temp | Bedside, free | Warm = distributive; cold = cardiogenic/hypovolaemic/obstructive |
| Fluid challenge response | Bedside | 250 mL bolus: BP improves → hypovolaemia; BP worsens/oedema worsens → cardiogenic |
| Capillary refill time | Bedside, free | >3s central CRT = significant hypoperfusion |
| Pulsus paradoxus | BP cuff only | >10 mmHg drop in systole with inspiration → tamponade |
Quick Memory Aid: "The 5 JVP Questions in Cold Shock"
JVP flat → Hypovolaemia → Fill the tank
JVP up + wet lungs → LV cardiogenic → Support the pump
JVP up + dry lungs + muffled sounds → Tamponade → Poke the pericardium
JVP up + dry lungs + no breath sounds + deviated trachea → Tension pneumo → Needle it
JVP up + dry lungs + tachycardia + ECG changes → Massive PE → Lyse it
Normal JVP + shock + no fluid loss → Addisonian crisis → Hydrocortisone
Sources:
- Barash, Cullen & Stoelting's Clinical Anaesthesia 9e - Types of Shock, Haemodynamic Monitoring
- Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine 22E - Shock chapter
- Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine - Shock and Resuscitation
- Schwartz's Principles of Surgery - Haemorrhagic and Obstructive Shock
- Surviving Sepsis Campaign Guidelines (adapted)This is a complete, ward-ready and ED-ready guide. Here are the key takeaways tailored for resource-limited settings:
The 3 things to do in the first 90 seconds of cold shock:
- Feel the neck veins (JVP) - this one sign divides your differential in half immediately
- Listen to the chest (pulmonary oedema vs. clear vs. absent breath sounds)
- Check the ECG - STEMI/LBBB = reperfuse; S1Q3T3/RBBB = PE; electrical alternans = tamponade; bradycardia/complete heart block = pacemaker
The most dangerous mistake in cold shock with elevated JVP is giving large IV fluid boluses reflexively - if the patient has cardiogenic shock or tamponade, fluids can precipitate fatal pulmonary oedema or worsen cardiac compression.
The most commonly missed cause in resource-limited settings is adrenal crisis - give hydrocortisone empirically in any shock unresponsive to standard treatment, especially if the patient is on steroids or from a TB-endemic region.