A stool that starts thicker and then becomes ribbon-like can happen from normal variation in stool softness, rectal/anal muscle contraction, posture, and how the stool exits. A single stool diameter of about 0.5-1 cm is not enough by itself to diagnose a blockage or cancer.
Your lack of abdominal pain, bleeding, unexplained weight loss, persistent constipation/diarrhea, feeling incompletely emptied, or a progressive change in bowel habit is reassuring. A colonoscopy in December 2023 that found only a perianal fissure is also reassuring, especially if the colonoscopy was complete and the preparation was adequate.
An anal fissure is a painful tear and can be associated with anal sphincter spasm, which can temporarily narrow the outlet. However, fissures usually cause pain during/after passing stool and sometimes bright-red blood, so an old fissure without current pain is not a clear explanation for the current shape. Pfenninger and Fowler's Procedures for Primary Care, p. 689, describes fissures as typically painful and associated with sphincter spasm.
What to do
- Keep stools soft: adequate fluids, dietary fibre increased gradually, regular activity, and avoid straining.
- Observe the overall pattern, rather than measuring individual stools.
- Arrange a routine appointment with a GP or gastroenterologist if this is a new, persistent shape change lasting more than about 3 weeks, becomes progressively narrower, or you are worried. They can review the prior colonoscopy report and decide whether an examination, blood count, FIT stool test, or further assessment is appropriate. The NHS bowel-cancer symptom guidance recommends assessment for concerning bowel symptoms, while also noting these symptoms commonly have non-cancer causes.
Seek prompt medical care if you develop:
- blood in or on stool, or black stool
- new constipation or diarrhea that persists
- unexplained fatigue or iron-deficiency anemia
- unintentional weight loss
- persistent abdominal pain, bloating, vomiting, inability to pass gas/stool
- a strong family history of colorectal cancer or polyps, especially at a young age.
So, based on what you described, this does not sound like an emergency and may be normal variation, but I cannot confirm that remotely. If it is genuinely a new ongoing pattern, a non-urgent clinician review is sensible.