Here is the comprehensive, detailed coverage of Non-Communicable Diseases (NCDs) in Community Medicine, based primarily on Park's Textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine with current WHO data.
Non-Communicable Diseases (NCDs) in Community Medicine
1. DEFINITION AND CONCEPT
Non-communicable diseases (NCDs), also called chronic diseases or chronic non-communicable diseases (CNCDs), are diseases of long duration, generally slow progression, and are not passed from person to person. They are the result of a combination of genetic, physiological, environmental, and behavioural factors.
The term "chronic disease" is sometimes used interchangeably with NCD, though not all NCDs are strictly chronic (e.g., some cancers can be rapidly fatal). The WHO defines NCDs by four major characteristics:
- Long duration
- Slow progression
- Not infectious/communicable
- Multifactorial causation
2. MAGNITUDE AND GLOBAL BURDEN
Global Situation
- NCDs are the leading cause of death globally, accounting for approximately 74% of all deaths worldwide (WHO GBD 2021 data)
- Cardiovascular diseases account for most NCD deaths: 17.9 million/year
- Followed by cancers (9.3 million), chronic respiratory diseases (4.1 million), and diabetes (2 million)
- Three-quarters of all NCD deaths (32 million) occur in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs)
- SDG Target 3.4: Reduce premature NCD mortality by one-third by 2030
The Four Major NCDs (WHO Classification)
- Cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) - heart attacks, stroke
- Cancers
- Chronic respiratory diseases - COPD, asthma
- Diabetes mellitus
India-specific Burden
- NCDs accounted for 60% of all deaths in India in 2016 (Park's)
- India faces a dual burden: communicable diseases still high, while NCDs are rising sharply
- India has 77 million diabetics - second only to China
- CHD crude death rate: 121.5/100,000 population (2016)
- India's health system was historically focused on communicable diseases, creating a structural gap for NCD management
3. EPIDEMIOLOGICAL TRANSITION
The concept of epidemiological transition (Omran, 1971) describes the shift in disease patterns from predominantly infectious/nutritional diseases to chronic/degenerative diseases as countries develop.
Epidemiological Transition Level (ETL) is measured as the ratio of communicable to non-communicable disease mortality:
- ETL > 0.55 = Lowest transition level (still predominantly communicable)
- ETL 0.41-0.55 = Lower-middle ETL
- ETL 0.31-0.40 = Higher-middle ETL
- ETL < 0.30 = Highest ETL (predominantly NCDs)
India shows heterogeneous ETL across states - some states have highest ETL (like Kerala, Tamil Nadu), while others remain in lower ETL categories, creating a uniquely complex dual burden.
4. NATURAL HISTORY OF CHRONIC DISEASES - KEY CHALLENGES
Understanding NCDs in a community medicine framework is complicated by several gaps in natural history (Park's):
4.1 Absence of a Known Agent
Unlike communicable diseases with identified pathogens, many NCDs lack a single causative agent (e.g., CHD, essential hypertension). This makes specific prevention difficult.
4.2 Multifactorial Causation
Most NCDs result from cumulative effects of multiple risk factors - both environmental/behavioural and constitutional. The term "risk factors" replaces the concept of a single "agent."
4.3 Long Latent Period
A long period (years to decades) between first exposure and disease development makes it difficult to establish causation (e.g., cervical cancer following HPV exposure, lung cancer after smoking).
4.4 Prolonged Course of Illness
Chronic diseases may persist for decades, generating long-term care needs far exceeding those of acute infectious illnesses.
4.5 Functional Impairment and Disability
Many NCDs lead to disability rather than death (e.g., stroke leading to hemiplegia), adding a large disability burden to the mortality burden. DALYs (Disability-Adjusted Life Years) capture this combined toll.
5. NCD RISK FACTORS
Most epidemiologists accept that a core set of modifiable risk factors drives the majority of NCD morbidity and premature mortality. (Park's, p.414)
5.1 Behavioural Risk Factors
| Risk Factor | Magnitude | Key NCDs Caused |
|---|
| Tobacco use | ~7 million deaths/year; 80% in LMICs | Lung cancer (71%), chronic respiratory disease (42%), CVD (10%) |
| Physical inactivity | ~1.6 million deaths/year | CVD, diabetes, breast/colon cancer, depression; 20-30% increased all-cause mortality risk |
| Harmful alcohol use | ~3.3 million deaths/year (5.9% of all deaths) | Cancers, CVD, liver cirrhosis, accidents |
| Unhealthy diet | Insufficient fruits/vegetables; excess salt | CVD, stomach/colorectal cancer, hypertension |
5.2 Metabolic/Physiological Risk Factors
| Risk Factor | Magnitude | Consequence |
|---|
| Overweight/obesity | 2.8 million deaths/year; 11% men, 15% women obese (2016) | CVD, diabetes, certain cancers |
| Raised blood pressure (hypertension) | Leading metabolic risk for death globally | CHD, stroke, renal failure |
| Raised blood glucose (diabetes) | 422 million worldwide | CHD risk 2-3x higher in diabetics |
| Raised cholesterol | 2.6 million deaths/year | CHD, stroke (LDL most directly linked) |
5.3 Environmental/Social Risk Factors
- Occupational hazards (asbestos → mesothelioma; silica → silicosis)
- Air and water pollution
- Cancer-associated infections: HPV (cervical cancer), Hepatitis B/C (liver cancer), H. pylori (gastric cancer) - account for 18% of global cancer burden (2 million cases/year)
- Poverty and low socioeconomic status
6. MAJOR NCDs - DETAILED COVERAGE
A. CORONARY HEART DISEASE (CHD) / ISCHAEMIC HEART DISEASE
Definition
"Impairment of heart function due to inadequate blood flow to the heart compared to its needs, caused by obstructive changes in the coronary circulation to the heart." (Park's, p.417)
Clinical Manifestations
- Angina pectoris of effort
- Myocardial infarction (most specific to CHD)
- Cardiac arrhythmias
- Cardiac failure
- Sudden death
Global Burden
- CHD is the modern "epidemic" - WHO terminology
- Responsible for 25-30% of deaths in most industrialized countries
- Death may occur in the first episode or after a long history
Risk Factors for CHD
| Non-Modifiable | Modifiable |
|---|
| Increasing age | Cigarette smoking |
| Male sex | High blood pressure |
| Family history/genetic factors | Elevated serum cholesterol (LDL) |
| Personality type A (?) | Diabetes mellitus |
| Obesity |
| Sedentary habits |
| Psychosocial stress |
Key lipid relationships:
- LDL cholesterol: most directly associated with CHD risk
- HDL cholesterol: protective - higher HDL = lower CHD risk (HDL should be >40 mg/dL)
- Total cholesterol/HDL ratio: goal <3.5 for CHD prevention
- VLDL: more associated with peripheral vascular disease
- Apolipoprotein-B (LDL marker) and Apolipoprotein-A-I (HDL marker) are better predictors than lipoprotein cholesterol measurements
Diabetes and CHD: Risk 2-3 times higher in diabetics; CHD responsible for 30-50% of deaths in diabetics over age 40 in industrialized countries.
CHD in India
- Urban areas: prevalence 6.4%; Rural areas: 2.5%
- Urban males: 6.1%; Urban females: 6.7%
- Rural males: 2.1%; Rural females: 2.7%
- 16,08,700 deaths from CHD in 2016 (10,00,800 men; 6,07,800 women)
- Steep urban rise driven by lifestyle westernization
Prevention of CHD (Three-Level Framework)
Primordial Prevention:
Novel approach - preventing the emergence and spread of risk factors in populations where they haven't appeared yet. Particularly important for developing countries. Goal: preserve traditional eating patterns and lifestyles associated with low CHD risk levels. (Park's, p.421)
Primary Prevention:
- Population strategy: Directed at the whole community - promoting healthy diet, physical activity, anti-smoking campaigns, mass media
- High-risk strategy: Identifying individuals at special risk through blood pressure and serum cholesterol screening, then bringing them under preventive care
Key trials validating primary prevention:
- MRFIT (Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial), USA
- Stanford Heart Disease Prevention Programme, California
- North Karelia Project, Finland - all demonstrated substantial reduction in CHD incidence
Secondary Prevention:
- Preventing recurrence and progression of established CHD
- Aspirin, beta-blockers, ACE inhibitors, statins
- Cardiac rehabilitation
- Lifestyle modification
B. DIABETES MELLITUS
Definition
"A group of metabolic disorders characterized by hyperglycaemia in the absence of treatment, due to defects in insulin secretion, insulin action, or both, with disturbances of carbohydrate, fat, and protein metabolism." (Park's, p.439)
Long-term Complications
- Microvascular: Retinopathy, Nephropathy, Neuropathy (the classic triad)
- Macrovascular: CHD, peripheral arterial disease, cerebrovascular disease
- Other: obesity, cataracts, erectile dysfunction, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, increased susceptibility to infections including TB
WHO Classification of Diabetes (2019)
| Type | Description |
|---|
| Type 1 diabetes | Beta-cell destruction (immune-mediated); absolute insulin deficiency; most common in childhood/early adulthood |
| Type 2 diabetes | Most common; variable beta-cell dysfunction + insulin resistance; associated with overweight/obesity |
| Hybrid forms | Slowly evolving immune-mediated diabetes of adults (formerly LADA); Ketosis-prone type 2 |
| Monogenic diabetes | MODY - specific gene mutations; neonatal diabetes |
| Diseases of exocrine pancreas | Pancreatitis, trauma, tumor causing hyperglycaemia |
| Endocrine disorders | Cushing's, acromegaly, pheochromocytoma |
| Drug/chemical induced | Glucocorticoids, thiazides, certain antivirals |
| Gestational diabetes | Diagnosed during pregnancy |
WHO Diagnostic Criteria for Diabetes (2019)
| Measurement | Diagnostic Cut-off |
|---|
| Fasting plasma glucose | ≥7.0 mmol/L (126 mg/dL) |
| 2-hour post-load plasma glucose | ≥11.1 mmol/L (200 mg/dL) |
| Random plasma glucose | ≥11.1 mmol/L (200 mg/dL) |
| HbA1c | ≥6.5% (48 mmol/mol) |
Epidemiology in India
- India has 77 million diabetics (second globally after China)
- Govt. of India Diabetic Retinopathy Survey 2019: 11.8% prevalence nationally
- Males: 12%; Females: 11.7% (no significant sex difference)
- Urban prevalence: 10.9-14.2%; Rural prevalence: 3.0-7.8% (age ≥20 years)
- ~40% of known diabetics were diagnosed 1-4 years prior
- In 2016: 75,900 males and 51,700 females aged 30-69 years died of diabetes
Screening for Diabetes
Whole-population screening is not considered cost-effective. High-risk group screening is recommended for:
- Age ≥40 years
- Family history of diabetes
- Obese individuals
- Women who delivered babies >4.5 kg (or >3.5 kg in small populations)
- Women with excess gestational weight gain
- Patients with premature atherosclerosis
Prevention of Diabetes
Primary Prevention:
- Population strategy: Promote healthy body weight through dietary modification and physical activity; high dietary fibre; avoid sweet foods; primordial prevention especially in LMICs
- High-risk strategy: Correct sedentary lifestyle, over-nutrition, obesity; avoid diabetogenic drugs (e.g., oral contraceptives in at-risk women); control atherosclerosis risk factors (smoking, hypertension, hypercholesterolaemia)
Secondary Prevention:
- Early detection through screening
- Tight glycaemic control to prevent microvascular complications
- Blood pressure control (target <130/80 mmHg in diabetics)
- Lipid management
Tertiary Prevention:
- Management of established complications
- Diabetic foot care programs
- Regular ophthalmological and renal function monitoring
C. HYPERTENSION
Definition and Classification (JNC / WHO)
Hypertension is defined as sustained elevation of blood pressure: systolic ≥140 mmHg and/or diastolic ≥90 mmHg in adults (classical definition used in NPCDCS referral guidelines).
Classification:
| Category | Systolic (mmHg) | Diastolic (mmHg) |
|---|
| Normal | <120 | <80 |
| Pre-hypertension | 120-139 | 80-89 |
| Stage 1 hypertension | 140-159 | 90-99 |
| Stage 2 hypertension | ≥160 | ≥100 |
| Isolated systolic hypertension | ≥140 | <90 |
Epidemiological Importance
- Hypertension is the single most important modifiable risk factor for cardiovascular disease globally
- Leading cause of CHD, stroke, heart failure, chronic kidney disease, and aortic dissection
- "Silent killer" - often asymptomatic for years/decades
- Prevalence in India: ~29.8% of adults (higher in urban areas)
Risk Factors
- Non-modifiable: age, sex, race, family history
- Modifiable: high salt intake, obesity, physical inactivity, alcohol, smoking, stress, low potassium/calcium intake
Community Management
- NPCDCS referral threshold: systolic BP >140 or diastolic BP >90 mmHg
- Once diagnosed: month's drug supply from PHC; stable patients receive 3-month supply
- ASHA/ANM visits monthly for compliance, diet, lifestyle monitoring, BP re-measurement
D. CANCER
Epidemiological Importance
- Cancer is the second leading NCD killer globally (9.3 million deaths/year)
- 80% of cancers may be due to environmental factors (Park's)
- 18% of cancers are attributable to chronic infections (HPV, HBV, HCV, H. pylori)
Common Cancers in India
- Males: Oral cavity, lung, colorectal, stomach, oesophagus, lymphoma
- Females: Cervix, breast, oral cavity, colorectal, ovary
Preventable Causes
- Tobacco: lung, oral, larynx, oesophagus, bladder, kidney cancers
- HPV infection: cervical cancer (>99% of cases)
- HBV/HCV: hepatocellular carcinoma
- H. pylori: gastric cancer
- Alcohol: liver, oral, oesophageal, breast cancer
- Aflatoxin contamination: liver cancer
- Occupational: asbestos (mesothelioma, lung cancer), benzene (leukaemia)
- UV radiation: skin cancer
Cancer Prevention Strategies in Community Medicine
Primordial/Primary Prevention:
- Tobacco control (COTPA legislation, FCTC)
- HPV vaccination (recommended 9-14 years girls; 2-dose schedule)
- Hepatitis B vaccination (universal infant immunization since 1992 in India's EPI)
- Dietary modifications: increase fruits/vegetables, reduce processed meat, limit alcohol
- Occupational hazard control (asbestos ban, radiation protection)
Secondary Prevention (Screening Programs):
| Cancer | Recommended Screening | Method |
|---|
| Cervical cancer | Women 30-65 years | Pap smear, VIA (visual inspection with acetic acid), HPV testing |
| Breast cancer | Women 40-65 years | Clinical breast examination (CBE), mammography |
| Oral cancer | Tobacco/alcohol users | Visual oral examination |
| Colorectal | Age >50 years | FOBT (Fecal Occult Blood Test), colonoscopy |
Under NPCDCS, screening for oral, cervical, and breast cancer is included.
E. CHRONIC RESPIRATORY DISEASES - COPD and ASTHMA
COPD (Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease)
- Characterized by persistent airflow limitation due to abnormal inflammatory response in the airways/lung to noxious particles and gases
- Main cause: tobacco smoking (causes ~42% of chronic respiratory disease globally - Park's)
- Other causes: biomass fuel exposure (indoor cooking with wood/coal - affects millions of women in LMICs), occupational dusts, air pollution
- GOLD staging (Grade I-IV) based on FEV1/FVC ratio and FEV1% predicted
Asthma
- Chronic inflammatory airway disease with variable airflow limitation
- Environmental triggers: allergens, tobacco smoke, air pollution, occupational sensitizers
- Rising prevalence in children in both developed and developing nations
Community Prevention
- Primary: tobacco cessation, clean cooking fuel programs (India's Ujjwala Yojana), reducing indoor air pollution
- Early case finding through spirometry screening in high-risk groups
- Occupational surveillance programs
7. PREVENTION AND CONTROL STRATEGIES FOR NCDs
7.1 The Three-Level Prevention Framework Applied to NCDs
| Level | Definition | NCD Examples |
|---|
| Primordial | Prevent emergence of risk factors in society | Preserving traditional diets; preventing westernization of lifestyle |
| Primary | Prevent disease onset in healthy people | Anti-smoking campaigns; promoting physical activity; healthy diet campaigns |
| Secondary | Early detection + treatment of disease | Mass screening programs for diabetes, hypertension, cancer |
| Tertiary | Limiting disability, rehabilitation | Cardiac rehabilitation; diabetic foot care; cancer palliative care |
7.2 WHO's "Best Buy" Interventions - Cost-Effective NCD Interventions
Population-wide (structural):
- Protect people from tobacco smoke and ban smoking in public places
- Warn about the dangers of tobacco (graphic health warnings, FCTC)
- Raise taxes on tobacco
- Restrict access to alcohol; raise alcohol taxes
- Replace trans-fats with unsaturated fats
- Reduce salt/sodium intake through food policy
- Promote awareness about diet and physical activity through mass media
Additional cost-effective measures:
- Nicotine dependence treatment
- Enforcing drink-driving laws
- Food taxes and subsidies for healthy diet promotion
- Healthy nutrition environments in schools
- National physical activity guidelines
- School-based physical activity programs
- Vaccination against HBV (liver cancer prevention) and HPV (cervical cancer)
7.3 WHO STEPS NCD Risk Factor Surveillance
WHO developed STEPS (STEPwise approach to Surveillance) - a standardized methodology for NCD risk factor surveys to help countries establish NCD surveillance systems.
Three steps:
- Step 1: Questionnaire (socio-demographic, behavioral risk factors - tobacco, alcohol, diet, physical activity)
- Step 2: Physical measurements (height, weight, waist circumference, blood pressure)
- Step 3: Biochemical measurements (blood glucose, cholesterol, serum lipids)
India conducted STEPS surveys from April 2003 to March 2005 (district-level data).
7.4 Integrated Approach to NCD Control
The key principle in contemporary community medicine is that NCDs share common risk factors - tobacco, physical inactivity, unhealthy diet, and harmful alcohol use underlie all four major NCDs. Therefore, integrated programs targeting multiple risk factors simultaneously are more efficient than disease-specific programs.
This is the WHO Global Action Plan for the Prevention and Control of NCDs 2013-2030 approach.
8. NATIONAL PROGRAMME FOR PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF CANCER, DIABETES, CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES AND STROKE (NPCDCS) - India
Background
Launched by Government of India recognizing the rising NCD burden. Originally the National Programme for Prevention and Control of Diabetes, CVD and Stroke; later integrated with the National Cancer Control Programme to form NPCDCS. (Park's, p. Block 7)
Objectives
- Prevent and control common NCDs through behaviour and lifestyle changes
- Provide early diagnosis and management of common NCDs
- Build capacity at various levels of healthcare for prevention, diagnosis, and treatment
- Train human resources (doctors, paramedics, nurses) to cope with the NCD burden
- Establish and develop capacity for palliative and rehabilitative care
Implementation Structure
- Implemented in all 36 states/UTs (as of 2015)
- 20,000 sub-centres and 700 CHCs across 100 districts initially
- NCD Clinics at CHC and District levels established
- Integration with primary health care system is core strategy
| Facility | 2014 | 2015 |
|---|
| State NCD Cells | 21 | 36 |
| District NCD Cells | 96 | 195 |
| District NCD Clinics | 95 | 201 |
| District CCU Facilities | 51 | 65 |
| CHC NCD Clinics | 204 | 1362 |
Strategies
- Promoting healthy lifestyle through mass media and health education
- Opportunistic screening of persons above age 30 years
- Screening for hypertension (BP), diabetes (blood sugar), and cancer (oral, cervical, breast)
- Community education and interpersonal communication for behavioural change
- ASHA/ANM-led community outreach for follow-up and compliance
Referral Guidelines (2016 Operational Guidelines)
- Systolic BP >140 or Diastolic BP >90 mmHg → Refer to Medical Officer at nearest facility
- Random blood sugar ≥140 mg/dL → Refer to Medical Officer
- Positive cancer/pre-cancerous lesion screen → Refer to PHC/CHC/District Hospital
- Diagnosed hypertension/diabetes: minimum 1-month drug supply from PHC; once stable, 3-month supply with monthly ASHA/ANM monitoring
New Initiatives Under NPCDCS
- Intervention for prevention and control of Rheumatic Heart Disease under NPCDCS + RBSK
- Integration of AYUSH with NPCDCS
- Integration of RNTCP with NPCDCS - national strategy for TB-Diabetes comorbidity management in India
9. SPECIAL TOPICS IN NCD COMMUNITY MEDICINE
9.1 TB-Diabetes Comorbidity
A critical and growing challenge in India:
- Diabetics are 3x more likely to develop active TB
- Diabetes worsens TB treatment outcomes (delayed sputum conversion, higher relapse rates)
- India has both the highest TB burden AND one of the largest diabetes burdens globally
- RNTCP-NPCDCS integration mandates bidirectional screening - all TB patients screened for diabetes; all diabetics screened for TB symptoms
9.2 Urban-Rural Divide in NCDs
- CHD prevalence: Urban 6.4% vs. Rural 2.5% (India)
- Diabetes prevalence: Urban 10.9-14.2% vs. Rural 3.0-7.8%
- Urban risk driven by: physical inactivity, processed food diets, stress, air pollution, occupational sitting
- Rural risk rising due to: rapid urbanization, shift from traditional diets, tobacco chewing (rural predominance)
9.3 NCD and Poverty - A Bidirectional Relationship
- Poverty increases NCD risk (less healthy food, more tobacco and alcohol, polluted environments, less healthcare access)
- NCDs worsen poverty (catastrophic health expenditure, loss of productive years, treatment costs)
- NCDs are not diseases of affluence alone - 75% of NCD deaths occur in LMICs
- WHO recognizes this as a development issue, not merely a health issue
9.4 Cancer-Infectious Agent Nexus (Unique Prevention Opportunity)
- 18% of cancers are preventable through vaccination and infection control:
- HBV vaccine → prevents hepatocellular carcinoma
- HPV vaccine → prevents cervical, oropharyngeal, anal cancers
- H. pylori treatment → reduces gastric cancer risk
- Schistosomiasis control → reduces bladder cancer in endemic areas
9.5 NCD and Mental Health
- Depression and anxiety are increasingly recognized as NCDs themselves
- Strong bidirectional relationship: NCDs increase depression risk; depression worsens NCD adherence and outcomes
- Global Action Plan 2013-2030 now includes mental health as part of the NCD agenda
10. SURVEILLANCE AND MONITORING OF NCDs
Key Indicators
- Premature mortality from NCDs (defined as deaths between ages 30-70): Target = reduce by 1/3 by 2030 (SDG 3.4)
- Prevalence of risk factors (tobacco use, physical inactivity, unhealthy diet, harmful alcohol)
- Metabolic risk factor prevalence (hypertension, diabetes, obesity, raised cholesterol)
- NCD healthcare coverage and treatment rates
Surveillance Tools
- WHO STEPS surveys (standardized nationally and sub-nationally)
- NFHS (National Family Health Survey) in India - includes NCD risk factor data
- ICMR-INDIAB study (India Diabetes study) - largest diabetes prevalence data
- Sample Registration System (SRS) - cause of death data in India
- Cancer registries - NCRP (National Cancer Registry Programme) India
11. SUMMARY TABLE - KEY FACTS FOR EXAM PURPOSES
| Disease | Global Deaths/Year | Key Risk Factors | Primary Prevention | India-specific Data |
|---|
| CVD/CHD | 17.9 million | Smoking, hypertension, cholesterol, diabetes, obesity | Population strategy + high-risk strategy; MRFIT, North Karelia, Stanford trials | 121.5/100,000 CDR; 6.4% urban, 2.5% rural prevalence |
| Cancer | 9.3 million | Tobacco, HPV, HBV, alcohol, diet, occupation | HPV/HBV vaccination, tobacco control, dietary modification | NPCDCS cancer screening; NCRP data |
| COPD/Respiratory | 4.1 million | Tobacco (42%), biomass fuel, air pollution | Smoking cessation, clean cooking fuels | Ujjwala Yojana for LPG access |
| Diabetes | 2 million | Obesity, physical inactivity, diet, genetics | Population: weight control, exercise; High-risk: lifestyle modification | 77 million cases; 11.8% prevalence; NPCDCS |
| Hypertension | - (leading risk factor, not primary death cause) | Salt, obesity, alcohol, stress | Salt reduction, DASH diet, exercise, alcohol restriction | Referral threshold BP >140/90 in NPCDCS |
Sources: Park's Textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine (23rd edition) - Chapters on CHD (p.417-421), Diabetes Mellitus (p.439-449), NCD Risk Factors (p.414), NPCDCS (Block 7); WHO Global NCD Fact Sheet 2024; GBD 2021 (IHME); SDG Target 3.4.