I now have comprehensive information to provide a thorough answer. Let me compile it.
Clinical Analysis: Motor Weakness with Preserved Touch Sensation + History of Depression
The Key Clinical Pattern
This patient presents with:
- Motor deficit - unable to move hands and legs properly (tetraparesis / weakness of all 4 limbs)
- Preserved sensation - can feel touch normally
- Psychiatric history - prior depression
This dissociation between motor and sensory function, in the context of a psychiatric history, is the defining hallmark of Conversion Disorder (Functional Neurological Symptom Disorder - FND), which is the most likely diagnosis.
Most Likely Diagnosis: Conversion Disorder / FND
Conversion disorder presents with motor or sensory symptoms that are neurologically inconsistent. The symptoms are real to the patient - they are NOT fabricated or under conscious control.
"Persons with conversion disorder present with what appears to be a neurologic condition. The symptoms may be motor or sensory but are incompatible with known neurologic conditions. Often the illness is preceded by conflicts or other stressors." - Kaplan & Sadock's Synopsis of Psychiatry
Why the History of Depression Matters
Depression is a well-established comorbidity and predisposing factor:
"Depressive disorders, anxiety disorders, and somatic symptom disorder often occur alongside conversion disorder." - Kaplan & Sadock's Synopsis of Psychiatry
The Maudsley Guidelines also note that functional neurological disorder (FND) can emerge in the context of or following depressive illness.
DSM-5 Diagnostic Criteria (Conversion Disorder)
| Criterion | Description |
|---|
| A | One or more symptoms of altered voluntary motor or sensory function |
| B | Clinical findings provide evidence of incompatibility with recognized neurological or medical conditions |
| C | Symptom is not better explained by another medical or mental disorder |
| D | Causes clinically significant distress or functional impairment |
The motor subtype (weakness/paralysis) is the relevant specifier here - "with weakness or paralysis".
Important Examination Signs for Conversion Motor Weakness
1. Hoover Sign (most specific)
The patient is supine. Hip extension of the "paralyzed" leg is tested. In functional weakness, hip extension power:
- Is weak when tested directly
- Returns to normal when the contralateral leg is asked to flex against resistance (involuntary motor activation)
"If hip extension returns to normal during contralateral hip flexion against resistance, this demonstrates structural integrity of the motor pathways." - Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice
2. Inconsistency During Examination
- Patient who walks to the exam table but cannot raise the leg against gravity when lying
- Weakness of ankle movements but patient can stand on tips/heels
3. "Give-away" Weakness
- Transient normal power that suddenly gives way, sometimes before being touched
4. La Belle Indifference
- Inappropriate lack of concern about a seemingly profound disability (not always present, but suggestive)
Organic Differential Diagnoses to Rule Out First
Despite the psychiatric history, organic causes must be excluded. Up to 25-50% of patients initially diagnosed with conversion disorder are later found to have an organic neurological disease.
| Condition | Motor | Sensory | Distinguishing Feature |
|---|
| Anterior Cord Syndrome | Loss of voluntary motor below lesion | Pain/temp lost; touch and vibration preserved | Sudden onset, vascular; sphincter loss |
| Central Cord Syndrome | Upper extremity weakness > lower | Variable | Trauma/hyperextension in elderly |
| Multiple Sclerosis | Variable limb weakness | Variable | Relapsing-remitting; white matter plaques on MRI |
| Guillain-Barre Syndrome | Ascending weakness (legs first) | Intact in early stages | Areflexia, albuminocytologic dissociation in CSF |
| Myasthenia Gravis | Fatigable weakness, proximal | Intact | Ptosis, diplopia; improves with rest |
| Motor Neuron Disease (ALS) | Progressive UMN + LMN signs | Completely intact | Fasciculations, hyperreflexia, no sensory loss |
Note on Anterior Cord Syndrome: Loss of pain and temperature sensation with preserved proprioception and touch (dorsal columns spared), plus motor loss. This is an important organic mimic. - Rosen's Emergency Medicine
ALS/MND is particularly important to consider - purely motor weakness with completely preserved sensation is its hallmark, though it is progressive and lacks the acute/stress-related onset of conversion.
Workup
Recommended investigations to exclude organic disease:
- MRI brain and spine (with contrast) - rule out MS, cord lesion, structural pathology
- EMG/Nerve Conduction Studies - rule out GBS, MND, neuropathy
- Serum CK, anti-AChR antibodies - myopathy, MG
- CSF analysis if GBS or MS suspected
- Psychiatric assessment - history of stressors, trauma, depression severity
- Neuropsychological testing
Management of Conversion Disorder
Acute Phase
- Reassure the patient that investigations are normal - avoid implying malingering (very counterproductive)
- Explain the diagnosis clearly - show the patient their Hoover sign to demonstrate it is made on positive criteria, not exclusion
- Psychological interpretations do NOT work well early; focus on reassurance and prognosis
Treatment Modalities
| Modality | Role |
|---|
| Physiotherapy | First-line for motor symptoms; progressive exercises restore function |
| CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) | Address underlying psychological stressors |
| Antidepressants | Treat comorbid depression (SSRIs preferred) |
| Hypnosis / Sodium Amobarbital interview | Symptom resolution test and therapeutic |
| Biofeedback / Relaxation training | Adjunct |
| Inpatient multidisciplinary care | For chronic/severe cases |
"Many conversion syndromes have an acute, benign course and may remit spontaneously with understanding and support. Approximately 95% of acute cases remit spontaneously, usually within 2 weeks in hospitalized patients." - Kaplan & Sadock's Synopsis of Psychiatry
Prognosis
- Good prognostic factors: Acute onset, identifiable stressor, short duration before treatment, paralysis/aphonia presentation, above-average intelligence
- Poor prognostic factors: Tremor, seizures, symptoms >6 months (remission <50%)
- Depression when treated simultaneously improves FND outcomes
Summary
| Feature | This Patient |
|---|
| Motor deficit (all 4 limbs) | Yes |
| Sensory preserved (touch intact) | Yes |
| Psychiatric history (depression) | Yes |
| Most likely diagnosis | Conversion Disorder (FND) - motor type |
| Organic must-exclude | ALS, MS, anterior cord syndrome, GBS |
| First-line investigation | MRI brain + spine, EMG/NCS |
| First-line treatment | Physiotherapy + CBT + treat depression |
Key teaching point: Pure motor weakness with completely intact sensation - especially with a psychiatric background - should always raise conversion disorder first, but a thorough neurological workup is mandatory before confirming it, as organic diseases (especially ALS and MS) can present similarly and are found in 25-50% of initial conversion disorder diagnoses.
Sources: Kaplan & Sadock's Synopsis of Psychiatry; Rosen's Emergency Medicine; Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice