What is demonetisation its causes reasons positive points and negative points explain it in detail
Searching the Web
demonetisation definition causes effects positive negative points detailed
Searching the Web
India demonetisation 2016 impact analysis pros cons economy
Here is a detailed breakdown of demonetisation:
Demonetisation - A Complete Overview
What is Demonetisation?
Demonetisation is the act of stripping a currency denomination of its legal tender status - meaning it can no longer be used for transactions. It may involve replacing old notes/coins with new ones, or completely retiring a currency unit. The term also refers to situations where a country adopts a new currency altogether (e.g., when European nations replaced national currencies with the Euro).
The most discussed modern example is India's demonetisation on November 8, 2016, when Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced that Rs. 500 and Rs. 1,000 notes - which made up 86% of all currency in circulation (worth Rs. 15.44 trillion) - would cease to be legal tender at midnight.
India had done this before: in 1946 (high-value notes) and 1978 (Rs. 1,000, 5,000 and 10,000 notes), though both had limited success.
Causes / Reasons Behind Demonetisation
These are the primary reasons governments undertake demonetisation:
1. To Combat Black Money
A massive amount of unaccounted, untaxed "black money" circulated outside the formal banking system, hoarded in cash form. Demonetisation forced holders of black money to either declare it or lose its value, since old notes had to be deposited in banks (triggering scrutiny).
2. To Eliminate Counterfeit Currency
Fake currency notes (especially high-denomination ones) were being used to destabilise the economy. New notes with better security features were introduced to make counterfeiting harder.
3. To Curb Terror Financing and Hawala Transactions
Terror networks and criminal organisations operated largely through high-denomination untraceable cash. Invalidating those notes disrupted the financial networks of such groups.
4. To Expand the Tax Base
A large portion of the Indian economy was "informal" - transactions happened in cash with no record, allowing massive tax evasion. Demonetisation was intended to bring more people into the formal financial system and increase direct/indirect tax collections.
5. To Promote a Cashless / Digital Economy
India had a very cash-heavy economy. Demonetisation was seen as a push toward digital payments, mobile wallets, and banking - aligning with the "Digital India" initiative.
6. To Control Inflation
Excess unaccounted cash in the system can fuel inflation. Demonetisation removes idle hoarded currency from circulation, potentially reducing inflationary pressure.
7. To Clean Up Real Estate and Other Sectors
Real estate transactions in India were notorious for large cash components that bypassed official records. Demonetisation targeted this by drying up the black money funding such deals.
Positive Effects of Demonetisation
1. Surge in Digital Payments
This is one of the clearest measurable benefits. Mobile wallet transactions (like Paytm) doubled between October and December 2016. UPI transactions grew dramatically. India's digital payment infrastructure expanded rapidly in the years following demonetisation, per NBER research.
2. Increase in Bank Deposits and Financial Inclusion
Millions of people deposited money into banks for the first time. This swelled bank deposits, improved banking penetration, and lowered interest rates in the short-to-medium term as banks had more liquidity. Many Jan Dhan accounts (basic bank accounts for the poor) saw activation.
3. Widening of the Tax Base
The number of income tax return filers rose from 43.3 million to 52.9 million between FY2016 and FY2017. Tax collection improved, particularly through the Income Disclosure Scheme 2016, which allowed declaration of previously undisclosed income.
4. Curbing of Fake Currency
New notes had advanced security features that made counterfeiting significantly harder. The volume of counterfeit currency in circulation dropped after the old notes were invalidated.
5. Disruption of Terror and Criminal Financing
Hawala operators, terrorist funding networks, and organised crime groups that operated in cash faced severe disruption. The sudden invalidation of large notes made stockpiled cash worthless overnight.
6. Real Estate Sector Reform
Property prices - especially in markets inflated by black money - corrected after demonetisation, making housing slightly more affordable. Cash-driven under-reporting of property prices decreased.
7. Benefits for Poorer Regions
A Science Direct study found that poorer districts and households experienced 11% greater GDP growth relative to richer ones in the year and a half following demonetisation, suggesting some redistributive benefit.
8. Long-Term Formalisation of the Economy
Demonetisation nudged businesses toward formal accounting, GST registration, and banking - contributing to long-term formalisation of India's economy, which benefits tax collection and governance.
Negative Effects of Demonetisation
1. Severe Short-Term Economic Disruption
Economic activity fell by at least 3 percentage points in November-December 2016, per NBER/CEPR research. GDP growth for FY2016-17 dropped to 7.1% from 8% the prior year. Quarterly growth fell to 6.1% in Q4 FY17 against a forecast of 7.1%.
2. Job Losses
CMIE data showed employment fell by approximately 1.5 million people after demonetisation. The informal and unorganised sectors - daily wage workers, small vendors, agricultural labourers - bore the heaviest burden since their entire income was in cash.
3. Cash Crunch and Hardship for Ordinary Citizens
Long queues at banks and ATMs stretched for weeks. Hospitals, pharmacies, and small shops suffered as people could not access currency. Farmers couldn't buy seeds or pay labourers. Weddings and funerals were disrupted.
4. Failure to Substantially Destroy Black Money
This is the most pointed criticism. The RBI reported that 99% of the demonetised currency was returned to banks, meaning the expected destruction of black money held in cash did not happen on the scale anticipated. Most black money is stored in gold, real estate, and foreign accounts - not as cash.
5. Credit Contraction
The quarterly credit growth rate fell by 2 percentage points in Q4 2016, per CEPR research. This tightened lending and hurt small businesses and farmers who depended on informal credit.
6. Agricultural Sector Damage
The harvest season of late 2016 coincided with demonetisation. Farmers couldn't sell produce easily, couldn't pay workers, and faced severe disruption. Agricultural output was significantly impacted.
7. Damage to the Informal / Unorganised Sector
India's informal sector - which employs the vast majority of workers - runs almost entirely on cash. The sudden cash withdrawal hit street vendors, daily labourers, small manufacturers, and small traders extremely hard.
8. Psychological and Social Stress
A PMC article documented anecdotal evidence of significant psychological distress, particularly among the middle class and small business owners, who faced uncertainty about savings and livelihoods.
9. High Implementation Cost
Printing and distributing new currency, recalibrating ATMs, managing bank queues, and deploying administrative resources cost the government and RBI substantially - some estimates suggest this partially offset fiscal gains.
10. Temporary Nature of Benefits
Most of the short-term disruptions were real and immediate, while some claimed long-term benefits (like eliminating black money) proved elusive or modest. NBER research confirmed effects began dissipating by March 2017, and the cash shortage was mostly resolved by June 2017.
Summary Table
| Aspect | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|
| Black Money | Forced disclosure and taxation | 99% of cash returned; most black money wasn't in cash |
| Digital Payments | Massive boost to UPI, wallets | Temporary - some users reverted to cash |
| Tax Base | More filers, more collections | Increase was modest, not transformative |
| Employment | Long-term formal sector growth | 1.5 million jobs lost short-term |
| GDP | Long-term formalisation | 0.5-3% reduction in growth forecast |
| Informal Sector | Some formalisation over time | Devastating short-term impact |
| Banking | Record deposits, lower rates | Credit contracted by 2% |
| Counterfeit Currency | Eliminated old fakes | New counterfeits appeared over time |
Global Examples of Demonetisation
- European Union (2002): Countries replaced national currencies with the Euro - a successful large-scale demonetisation through careful planning.
- Zimbabwe (2015): Demonetised the Zimbabwean dollar after hyperinflation rendered it worthless.
- Nigeria (1984): Military government demonetised currency to fight corruption.
- Soviet Union (1991): Demonetised large ruble notes to curb black market activity.
Bottom Line
Demonetisation is a powerful but disruptive policy tool. India's 2016 experience shows it can achieve some of its goals - digital payments growth, banking inclusion, short-term tax gains - but falls short on others, especially eliminating black money, since most illicit wealth is not held in cash. The immediate economic pain was real and fell disproportionately on the poor and informal workers, while the long-term benefits were more diffuse and harder to attribute solely to demonetisation.
This is a shared conversation. Sign in to Orris to start your own chat.