Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1): Spotter Viva Questions with Answers
Moderate-level questions
1. What is your diagnosis?
Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1), also called von Recklinghausen disease, with multiple cutaneous neurofibromas.
2. What are the lesions seen in this patient?
They are cutaneous neurofibromas: soft, skin-colored to slightly hyperpigmented, sessile or pedunculated papules/nodules.
3. Describe a cutaneous neurofibroma.
It is a benign peripheral nerve-sheath tumour presenting as a soft, skin-colored, dome-shaped or pedunculated papule/nodule. It may be solitary or multiple and commonly appears during adolescence or adulthood.
4. What is the buttonhole sign?
On pressure, a soft cutaneous neurofibroma can be invaginated into the skin, like passing through a buttonhole. It is a useful clinical sign of neurofibroma.
5. What are the main types of neurofibroma?
- Localized cutaneous neurofibroma
- Subcutaneous neurofibroma
- Diffuse neurofibroma
- Plexiform neurofibroma
6. What is a plexiform neurofibroma?
A plexiform neurofibroma is a diffuse, often congenital tumour involving multiple fascicles of a nerve and its branches. It feels like a “bag of worms”, can cause major disfigurement and functional impairment, and is strongly associated with NF1.
7. What is the importance of plexiform neurofibroma?
It is highly suggestive of NF1 and has a risk of progression to atypical neurofibromatous neoplasm of uncertain biologic potential (ANNUBP) and malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumour (MPNST).
8. What are café-au-lait macules?
They are flat, uniformly light-brown to dark-brown hyperpigmented macules with smooth, well-defined borders. In NF1, they classically have a smooth “coast of California” border.
9. How many café-au-lait macules are significant in NF1?
Six or more:
- More than 5 mm in greatest diameter in a prepubertal child
- More than 15 mm in a postpubertal person
10. What is Crowe sign?
Axillary or inguinal freckling in NF1. It usually develops in early childhood and is diagnostically important.
11. What are Lisch nodules?
They are benign, melanocytic hamartomas of the iris. They are best detected by slit-lamp examination and do not typically affect vision.
12. Are Lisch nodules present at birth?
Usually no. Their frequency increases with age, so their absence in a young child does not rule out NF1.
13. What should you ask in history?
Ask about:
- Age at onset and progression of lesions
- Family history of similar lesions, pigmentary lesions, or known NF1
- Pain, rapid growth, hardening, or neurological symptoms in any tumour
- Visual symptoms, proptosis, squint, headache, seizures
- Learning difficulty, poor school performance, ADHD
- Bone pain, limb deformity, scoliosis
- Hypertension symptoms, palpitations, sweating, headache
- Menstrual/sexual precocity in children, suggesting optic/hypothalamic involvement
14. What should you examine apart from the visible lesions?
- Full skin examination for café-au-lait macules and neurofibromas
- Axillae and groins for freckling
- Eyes for Lisch nodules and visual impairment
- Spine for scoliosis
- Long bones for tibial bowing/pseudarthrosis
- Blood pressure
- Neurological examination
- Development, cognition, and school performance in children
- Breast examination and appropriate screening discussion in adult women
Diagnostic criteria
15. State the revised diagnostic criteria for NF1.
In a person without an affected parent, diagnosis requires two or more of:
- Six or more café-au-lait macules of appropriate size
- Axillary or inguinal freckling
- Two or more neurofibromas of any type, or one plexiform neurofibroma
- Optic pathway glioma
- Two or more Lisch nodules, or two or more choroidal abnormalities on appropriate imaging
- Distinctive osseous lesion: sphenoid dysplasia, anterolateral tibial bowing, or pseudarthrosis of a long bone
- A heterozygous pathogenic NF1 variant in normal tissue
If one parent meets NF1 diagnostic criteria, a child requires one of these features.
16. Is genetic testing mandatory for diagnosis?
No. NF1 is frequently diagnosed clinically. Genetic testing is useful when the phenotype is incomplete, in young children, in suspected mosaic disease, or for reproductive counselling.
17. Which gene is mutated in NF1?
The NF1 gene on chromosome 17q11.2.
18. What does the NF1 gene encode?
It encodes neurofibromin, a tumour-suppressor protein.
19. Explain the role of neurofibromin.
Neurofibromin normally acts as a RAS GTPase-activating protein, converting active RAS-GTP to inactive RAS-GDP. Loss of neurofibromin leads to excessive RAS-MAPK pathway signalling and predisposes to tumour development.
20. What is the inheritance pattern?
It is autosomal dominant with near-complete penetrance but marked variable expressivity.
21. What is the recurrence risk for offspring of an affected person?
Each child has a 50% chance of inheriting the pathogenic NF1 variant.
22. How often is NF1 a new mutation?
Approximately half of cases are due to a de novo pathogenic variant.
23. Can severity be predicted from the severity in the parent?
No. Even within the same family, clinical expression can vary greatly.
Differential diagnosis
24. What is the differential diagnosis of multiple skin-colored papules/nodules on the face?
- Multiple cutaneous neurofibromas in NF1
- Multiple schwannomas
- Multiple trichoepitheliomas
- Fibrofolliculomas, such as in Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome
- Angiofibromas of tuberous sclerosis
- Syringomas
- Skin tags, if pedunculated
- Leiomyomas, usually firmer and may be painful
25. What is the differential diagnosis of multiple café-au-lait macules?
- NF1
- Legius syndrome
- McCune-Albright syndrome
- Constitutional mismatch repair deficiency syndrome
- Noonan syndrome with multiple lentigines
- Watson syndrome
- Isolated familial café-au-lait macules
26. Differentiate NF1 from Legius syndrome.
| Feature | NF1 | Legius syndrome |
|---|
| Gene | NF1 | SPRED1 |
| Café-au-lait macules | Present | Present |
| Axillary freckling | Present | May occur |
| Neurofibromas | Present | Absent |
| Lisch nodules | May occur | Absent |
| Optic pathway glioma | May occur | Absent |
| Major tumour predisposition | Present | Not characteristic |
Key answer: Legius syndrome may mimic early NF1 due to café-au-lait macules and freckling, but it lacks neurofibromas, Lisch nodules, optic glioma, and characteristic osseous lesions.
27. What is segmental or mosaic NF1?
It is NF1 caused by a post-zygotic pathogenic variant, producing features restricted to one body segment or region. The distribution often follows a unilateral or segmental pattern and may not cross the midline.
28. Can a patient with segmental NF1 transmit generalized NF1 to their children?
Yes. If gonadal cells carry the pathogenic variant, there is a risk of transmission. This is termed gonadal mosaicism.
29. Differentiate NF1 from NF2-related schwannomatosis.
NF1 is characterized by café-au-lait macules, axillary freckling, cutaneous and plexiform neurofibromas, Lisch nodules, optic pathway gliomas, and skeletal lesions.
NF2-related schwannomatosis is characterized mainly by bilateral vestibular schwannomas, other cranial/spinal schwannomas, meningiomas, ependymomas, and juvenile cataracts. Cutaneous findings are much less prominent.
Hard questions: complications
30. Name the important complications of NF1.
- Plexiform neurofibroma
- MPNST
- Optic pathway glioma
- Other low-grade gliomas
- Learning disability, ADHD, developmental delay
- Skeletal abnormalities: scoliosis, tibial pseudarthrosis, sphenoid wing dysplasia
- Hypertension due to renal artery stenosis, coarctation, or pheochromocytoma
- Pheochromocytoma/paraganglioma
- Gastrointestinal stromal tumour
- Glomus tumours
- Juvenile myelomonocytic leukaemia, especially in children
- Increased breast cancer risk in women
- Cerebrovascular abnormalities, including moyamoya vasculopathy
31. Which tumour is most feared in NF1?
Malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumour, or MPNST.
32. What features suggest malignant transformation of a plexiform neurofibroma?
Red flags are:
- Rapid increase in size or change in growth rate
- New, persistent, severe, or nocturnal pain
- New hard area within a previously soft lesion
- New motor weakness, sensory loss, or neuropathic symptoms
- Bladder/bowel dysfunction, dysphagia, or respiratory compromise depending on location
33. What is the work-up if you suspect MPNST?
- Urgent assessment by an NF1/sarcoma multidisciplinary team
- Regional MRI to define the lesion
- FDG-PET/CT or FDG-PET/MRI to identify metabolically active suspicious areas
- Image-guided core biopsy targeting the suspicious region, planned with the sarcoma team
- Staging imaging if malignancy is confirmed
34. Why should an incisional biopsy not be done casually in suspected MPNST?
Poorly planned biopsy may contaminate tissue planes and compromise definitive limb-sparing or oncologic surgery. Biopsy should be planned by the specialist sarcoma team.
35. What is ANNUBP?
Atypical neurofibromatous neoplasm of uncertain biologic potential is an intermediate lesion between benign plexiform neurofibroma and MPNST. It shows atypical features but does not fulfill criteria for malignancy.
36. What is an optic pathway glioma?
A usually low-grade glioma affecting the optic nerve, optic chiasm, optic tract, or related pathways. It is associated with NF1, often arises in childhood, and may be asymptomatic.
37. Does every child with NF1 need screening MRI of brain and orbits?
No. Routine screening MRI in asymptomatic children is not generally recommended. Regular clinical and ophthalmological assessment is preferred. MRI is indicated for visual symptoms, concerning examination findings, or when adequate ophthalmic assessment cannot be performed.
38. Which child with NF1 is at risk of precocious puberty?
A child with an optic pathway glioma involving or affecting the chiasm/hypothalamic region.
39. What are the skeletal manifestations of NF1?
- Scoliosis, both dystrophic and non-dystrophic
- Anterolateral bowing of tibia
- Tibial pseudarthrosis
- Sphenoid wing dysplasia
- Vertebral scalloping
- Short stature and reduced bone mineral density in some patients
40. Why should blood pressure be checked at every visit?
NF1 can be associated with hypertension due to:
- Essential hypertension
- Renal artery stenosis
- Coarctation of the aorta
- Pheochromocytoma or paraganglioma
- Other NF1-associated vasculopathies
41. When should you suspect pheochromocytoma in NF1?
In an NF1 patient with hypertension, episodic headache, palpitations, sweating, tremor, pallor, or an adrenal mass. Test plasma free metanephrines or urinary fractionated metanephrines.
42. What malignancy screening issue is important in adult women with NF1?
Women with NF1 have increased risk of early breast cancer. They require early individualized breast-cancer surveillance, commonly including annual breast MRI from around age 30 according to local guideline practice.
Histopathology and very hard questions
43. What is the histopathology of a neurofibroma?
A non-encapsulated dermal or subcutaneous proliferation of spindle cells with wavy, serpentine nuclei in a loose myxoid collagenous stroma. It contains Schwann cells, fibroblasts, mast cells, and perineurial-like cells, often with entrapped axons.
44. Why is a neurofibroma usually non-encapsulated?
Because it infiltrates the parent nerve and surrounding tissue rather than being a sharply circumscribed tumour.
45. How is neurofibroma differentiated from schwannoma histologically?
| Neurofibroma | Schwannoma |
|---|
| Usually non-encapsulated | Usually encapsulated |
| Entraps axons | Typically displaces axons outside the tumour |
| Mixed cell population | Predominantly Schwann cells |
| Wavy spindle cells in myxoid background | Antoni A and Antoni B areas, Verocay bodies |
| Can be plexiform in NF1 | Plexiform schwannoma is distinct and not typical of NF1 |
46. Which immunohistochemical markers are useful?
- S100 and SOX10: positive in Schwann-cell component, often patchy in neurofibroma
- CD34: highlights fibroblastic component
- Neurofilament protein: highlights entrapped axons
- EMA: may highlight perineurial cells
- Ki-67: helps evaluate proliferative activity in atypical or malignant lesions
- H3K27me3 loss can support MPNST in the appropriate pathological context
47. Why do neurofibromas develop in NF1 although every cell carries one altered NF1 allele?
Tumour formation generally follows a two-hit mechanism: a germline pathogenic NF1 variant is followed by somatic loss of the remaining functional allele in susceptible cells, especially Schwann-cell lineage cells.
48. What is the role of mast cells in neurofibroma formation?
NF1-deficient Schwann cells influence the tumour microenvironment, recruiting mast cells and other stromal cells. These cells support tumour development through growth factors, cytokines, matrix remodelling, and angiogenic signalling.
49. Why are cutaneous neurofibromas common in adolescence and pregnancy?
Hormonal influences may contribute to growth of neurofibromas. Lesion number and size can increase during puberty and pregnancy, although the degree of change varies.
50. Are cutaneous neurofibromas premalignant?
No. Cutaneous neurofibromas are benign and generally do not transform into MPNST. The important precursor lesion for MPNST is usually a deep plexiform neurofibroma.
Management questions
51. How do you manage a patient with NF1?
Management is lifelong, multidisciplinary, and individualized:
- Clinical diagnosis and genetic counselling
- Education about red-flag symptoms
- Annual or periodic clinical review depending on age and complications
- Full skin, neurologic, skeletal, visual, and blood-pressure assessment
- Ophthalmology surveillance in children
- Developmental, behavioural, and educational support
- Targeted imaging only when clinically indicated
- Referral to relevant specialties for tumours or complications
52. How are asymptomatic cutaneous neurofibromas managed?
Reassurance and observation are appropriate. Treatment is indicated for symptoms such as pain, pruritus, bleeding, recurrent trauma, functional impairment, or significant cosmetic distress.
53. What treatment options exist for cutaneous neurofibromas?
- Surgical excision
- Shave excision
- Electrosurgery/electrodessication
- Laser treatment in selected cases
- Radiofrequency ablation in selected settings
The method depends on lesion number, size, site, scarring risk, and local expertise.
54. How is a plexiform neurofibroma managed?
- Assess by an NF1 multidisciplinary team
- MRI for anatomy, extent, and serial follow-up when indicated
- Surgery if complete resection is feasible and morbidity is acceptable
- Observe stable asymptomatic lesions
- Consider a MEK inhibitor, such as selumetinib, for selected symptomatic, inoperable plexiform neurofibromas, especially in paediatric patients where locally approved
55. What is selumetinib and how does it work?
Selumetinib is an oral MEK1/2 inhibitor. It reduces signalling through the RAS-RAF-MEK-ERK pathway, which is overactive after loss of neurofibromin in NF1.
56. What adverse effects should be monitored with selumetinib?
- Acneiform or other rash
- Diarrhoea
- Nausea/vomiting
- Elevated creatine kinase
- Paronychia
- Ocular toxicity, including retinal changes
- Reduced left ventricular ejection fraction
Monitoring includes clinical review, echocardiography, ophthalmological assessment, and relevant laboratory tests. Evidence for selumetinib in inoperable plexiform neurofibromas is supported by a
2024 systematic review and meta-analysis.
57. What counselling should be provided?
- NF1 is autosomal dominant
- Each child has a 50% transmission risk if the parent has a germline pathogenic variant
- Severity cannot be reliably predicted in offspring
- Offer genetic counselling before conception
- Discuss testing options according to local laws and services
- Counsel on warning symptoms of MPNST and need for lifelong follow-up
Rapid-fire very hard viva
58. Why are café-au-lait macules not specific for NF1?
They occur in multiple genetic and non-genetic conditions. Their diagnostic significance depends on number, size, distribution, associated signs, and family history.
59. Why are the borders of NF1 café-au-lait macules described as coast of California?
They are typically smooth and regular. In contrast, McCune-Albright syndrome tends to have irregular, jagged “coast of Maine” borders, often respecting the midline.
60. What is the difference between generalized NF1 and mosaic NF1 genetically?
Generalized NF1 results from a pathogenic variant present in the germline, so it is in essentially all cells. Mosaic NF1 results from a post-zygotic mutation and is present only in a subset of cells.
61. Why can a blood NF1 genetic test be negative in mosaic NF1?
The pathogenic variant may be absent or present at a very low level in circulating blood leukocytes. Testing affected tissue may be required.
62. Is NF1 the same as “elephant man disease”?
No. This is a common misconception. Joseph Merrick, historically called the Elephant Man, is now thought to have had Proteus syndrome, not NF1.
63. Which tumour is more associated with NF1: schwannoma or neurofibroma?
Neurofibroma, especially plexiform neurofibroma. Multiple schwannomas are more characteristic of NF2-related schwannomatosis or other schwannomatoses.
64. What is the significance of a solitary neurofibroma?
A solitary localized neurofibroma is common and usually sporadic. It does not by itself imply NF1.
65. Is every patient with NF1 equally likely to develop MPNST?
No. Risk is higher in patients with extensive internal tumour burden, plexiform neurofibromas, atypical neurofibromas/ANNUBP, previous radiotherapy, and certain genotype-phenotype associations.
66. Why should radiotherapy be avoided where possible in NF1?
People with NF1 have a predisposition to tumours and may be at increased risk of radiation-associated secondary malignancies, including MPNST. Decisions require specialist multidisciplinary input.
67. What is the most appropriate single sentence to end your spotter presentation?
“This patient has multiple facial cutaneous neurofibromas, and my provisional diagnosis is neurofibromatosis type 1; I would complete the diagnostic assessment by looking for pigmentary, ocular, skeletal, neurological, and familial features, while specifically excluding a plexiform neurofibroma or features of malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumour.”