ORTHOPAEDIC SHOULDER ASSESSMENT
Patient Position for Examination
The patient must be stripped to the waist and examined against good daylight. Both shoulders must always be compared simultaneously - the examiner stands behind the patient who is seated on a stool.
References: S. Das - A Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th Ed; Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th Ed 2026; Miller's Review of Orthopaedics, 9th Ed; Firestein & Kelley's Textbook of Rheumatology; Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Ed
1. OBSERVATION (Inspection)
A. Attitude / Posture at Rest
- Fracture clavicle: Patient typically enters supporting the flexed elbow of the injured side with the opposite hand.
- Anterior dislocation of shoulder: Patient supports the flexed elbow with the other hand; elbow held slightly away from the body.
- Note drooping of the shoulder, asymmetry, or guarded posture.
(Das, Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th Ed)
B. Contour and Deformity
Inspect from anterior, posterior, and lateral aspects:
| Finding | Significance |
|---|
| Flattening/loss of roundness just below acromion | Dislocation of shoulder (subcoracoid type) - greater tuberosity displaced medially |
| Swelling on line of clavicle (junction of lateral 1/3 and medial 2/3) | Fracture clavicle |
| Undue prominence at acromial end of clavicle | Acromioclavicular (AC) dislocation |
| Undue prominence at sternal end of clavicle | Sternoclavicular dislocation |
| Swelling in deltopectoral groove + prominent acromion | Subcoracoid dislocation |
| Drooping + lengthening of arm | Fracture neck of scapula |
| Diffuse swelling without loss of roundness | Fracture neck of humerus |
| Lowering of anterior axillary fold | Anterior dislocation |
C. Muscle Wasting
- Compare bulk of deltoid, supraspinatus fossa, and infraspinatus fossa bilaterally.
- Deltoid wasting = apparent flattening (but greater tuberosity still palpable, unlike true dislocation).
- Supraspinatus/infraspinatus wasting suggests rotator cuff pathology or suprascapular nerve injury.
- Ecchymosis over shoulder may suggest rotator cuff rupture or long head of biceps rupture.
(Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th Ed 2026)
D. Scapular Winging
- Ask patient to push against a wall with arms outstretched.
- Winging = serratus anterior weakness (long thoracic nerve palsy).
2. GONIOMETRY - Range of Motion
Instrument Setup
- Use a standard 360° goniometer.
- Stationary arm aligned with trunk/bony landmark; moving arm follows the limb segment.
- Measure both Active ROM (AROM) and Passive ROM (PROM); note any painful arc.
Normal Values
| Motion | Normal ROM | Functional ROM | Measurement Position |
|---|
| Flexion | 180° | 120° | Arm raised forward in sagittal plane |
| Extension | 45-60° | - | Arm moved posteriorly |
| Abduction | 150-180° | 90° | Arm raised in coronal plane |
| Adduction | 30-45° | - | Arm across body |
| External Rotation (ER) | 60-90° | - | Elbow at 90°, arm at side; forearm swings outward |
| Internal Rotation (IR) | 60-90° | - | Elbow at 90°, arm at side; forearm swings inward |
| IR (behind back) | Thumb reaches T7 (inferior scapular border) | - | Hand reaching up the spine |
(Firestein & Kelley's Textbook of Rheumatology; Miller's Review of Orthopaedics, 9th Ed)
Clinical Notes on ROM
- Active and passive ROM are assessed in all planes.
- When active deficit cannot be improved passively: suggests capsular contracture or glenohumeral arthritis.
- Stabilize the scapula to isolate glenohumeral motion from scapulothoracic motion.
- Internal rotation is clinically assessed by asking the patient to bring the hand up behind the back, recording the highest vertebral level reached (normal = approx. T7/inferior scapular border level).
- For rotation assessment at 90° abduction: measure with shoulder abducted and elbow at 90°.
- When Hawkins-Kennedy test, painful arc sign, AND infraspinatus (Jobe) test are ALL positive, likelihood of impingement exceeds 95%. If all three negative, likelihood drops below 24%.
(Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th Ed 2026)
Painful Arc
- Pain between 60°-120° of abduction = subacromial impingement or rotator cuff pathology.
- Sensitivity: 73.5%, Specificity: 81.1% for impingement (PPV 88.2%).
3. MANUAL MUSCLE TESTING (MMT)
Grading Scale - MRC Scale (Medical Research Council)
| Grade | Description |
|---|
| 0 | No contraction |
| 1 | Flicker/trace of contraction - insufficient to produce movement |
| 2 | Active movement with gravity eliminated |
| 3 | Active movement against gravity (full ROM, no added resistance) |
| 3+ | Movement against gravity + minimal resistance before giving way |
| 4 | Active movement against gravity and some resistance |
| 4+/4- | Used to denote gradations within grade 4 (mild-to-moderate weakness) |
| 5 | Normal power - movement against full resistance |
(Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice; Sabiston Textbook of Surgery)
Shoulder Muscle Testing
| Muscle | Test Position | Movement Resisted | Nerve/Root |
|---|
| Supraspinatus | Arm abducted 90°, forward flexed 30° (scapular plane), IR (thumb pointing down) - "Empty Can" | Resist abduction/elevation | Suprascapular nerve, C5-C6 |
| Infraspinatus | Elbow at 90°, arm at side | Resist external rotation | Suprascapular nerve, C5-C6 |
| Teres Minor | Elbow at 90°, arm at side | Resist external rotation | Axillary nerve, C5-C6 |
| Subscapularis | Hand behind back (Gerber's Lift-Off position) | Resist lifting hand off back (internal rotation) | Subscapular nerve, C5-C6 |
| Deltoid (all heads) | Arm at side | Resist abduction (middle), flexion (anterior), extension (posterior) | Axillary nerve, C5-C6 |
| Biceps brachii | Elbow at 90°, forearm supinated | Resist elbow flexion | Musculocutaneous nerve, C5-C6 |
| Serratus Anterior | Push against wall | Observe scapular winging | Long thoracic nerve, C5-C7 |
Key tip: Always compare with the contralateral side. Resisted movements produce isolated isometric contractions to identify specific muscle/tendon involvement.
(Firestein & Kelley's Textbook of Rheumatology; Firestein's 2022)
4. PALPATION
A. Bony Structures (Systematic sequence - examiner behind patient)
Step 1 - Sternoclavicular joints
- Both thumbs placed on sternal ends of both clavicles simultaneously.
- Abnormal anterior prominence = sternoclavicular dislocation.
Step 2 - Clavicle (entire length)
- Palpate medial to lateral; any break in line or local bony tenderness = fracture clavicle.
- Conoid and trapezoid ligaments almost always torn in AC dislocation.
Step 3 - AC Joint and Acromion
- Undue upward prominence of distal clavicle = AC joint dislocation.
- Undue tenderness over AC joint = AC joint pathology.
Step 4 - Greater Tuberosity of Humerus
- Slide fingers from acromion downward.
- Disappearance of greater tuberosity + loss of resistance = shoulder dislocation.
- Local bony tenderness + irregularity at surgical neck = fracture neck of humerus.
Step 5 - Upper End of Humerus (bimanual)
- One hand in axilla, one hand over deltoid.
- Head of humerus can be palpated bimanually; absence in socket = dislocation.
Step 6 - Coracoid Process
- Abnormal tenderness at coracoid = coracoid fracture, coracobrachialis/biceps short head pathology.
Step 7 - Scapula
- Palpate spine, inferior angle, medial border.
- Medial to glenoid cavity tenderness = fracture neck of scapula (no tenderness at upper end of humerus in this case).
(Das, Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th Ed)
B. Soft Tissue Palpation
| Structure | Location | Significance |
|---|
| Supraspinatus tendon | Just below anterior acromion edge | Tenderness = supraspinatus tendinopathy/tear |
| Bicipital groove (Long head of biceps tendon) | Anterior shoulder, between greater and lesser tuberosities (arm in ~10° IR) | Tenderness = bicipital tendinitis |
| Infraspinatus/teres minor | Posterior shoulder, infraspinatus fossa | Tenderness = posterior rotator cuff pathology |
| Subacromial bursa | Lateral shoulder, below acromion | Tenderness = bursitis |
| Trigger points (trapezius, levator scapulae) | Neck/shoulder girdle muscles | Myofascial pain syndrome, fibromyalgia |
| Scapulothoracic region | Medial scapular border | Scapulothoracic crepitus (usually benign) |
(Rheumatology 2-Volume Set, Elsevier 2022)
C. Bony Landmark Relationships (Palpation Measurements)
Hamilton's Ruler Test:
- A straight ruler resting on the lateral arm normally cannot touch both the lateral epicondyle and the acromion simultaneously (due to the greater tuberosity intervening).
- If the ruler CAN connect both points = dislocation of shoulder (greater tuberosity displaced medially).
(Das, Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th Ed)
Bryant's Test (Axillary Fold):
- Vertical circumference of axilla is increased in shoulder dislocation.
- Lowering of anterior axillary fold confirms anterior dislocation.
Arm Length Measurement:
- From angle of acromion to lateral epicondyle of humerus.
- Shortened arm = subcoracoid dislocation, fracture neck/shaft of humerus.
- Lengthened arm = subglenoid dislocation, fracture neck of scapula.
5. SPECIAL TESTS
A. Impingement Tests
| Test | Technique | Positive Sign | Sensitivity | Specificity |
|---|
| Neer Impingement Sign | Examiner raises affected arm in forced forward elevation while stabilizing scapula (passive FF >90°) | Pain (greater tuberosity impinges against acromion) | 68% | 68.7% |
| Neer Impingement Test | Same as above; then inject 10 mL 1% lidocaine subacrominally | Pain relief after injection | - | - |
| Hawkins-Kennedy Test | Passive forward flexion to 90°, then internal rotation | Pain = impingement | 71.5% | 66.3% |
| Painful Arc Sign | Active abduction; note pain between 60°-120° | Pain in arc = impingement/rotator cuff | 73.5% | 81.1% |
| Drop-Arm Test | Examiner places arm in FF in scapular plane, releases it | Inability to maintain = supraspinatus rupture | 26.9% | 88.4% |
B. Rotator Cuff Tests
| Test | Technique | Positive Sign | Muscle |
|---|
| Jobe (Empty Can) Test | Arm at 90° abduction, 30° forward flexion, IR (thumb down); resist abduction | Pain/weakness | Supraspinatus |
| Infraspinatus Test | Resist ER with arm at side, elbow 90° | Pain/weakness | Infraspinatus |
| Horn Blower's Sign | Resist maximal ER with arm in 90° abduction | Pain/inability | Infraspinatus, teres minor, posterior supraspinatus |
| Gerber's Lift-Off Test | Hand placed on lumbar spine; patient lifts hand off back | Inability to lift = subscapularis tear | Subscapularis |
| Belly-Press Test | Patient presses palm against abdomen; examiner tries to pull elbow forward | Inability to maintain = subscapularis | Subscapularis |
| Bear-Hug Test | Patient places hand on opposite shoulder; examiner tries to lift hand off | Inability to maintain contact = subscapularis | Subscapularis |
(Miller's Review of Orthopaedics, 9th Ed; Table 4.7)
C. Instability Tests
| Test | Technique | Positive Sign | Significance |
|---|
| Apprehension Test | Supine; shoulder abducted 90°, ER applied | Patient's facial apprehension (not just pain) | Anterior glenohumeral instability |
| Relocation Test | During apprehension test, apply posterior force to humeral head | Relief of apprehension | Confirms anterior instability |
| Load-and-Shift Test | Apply anterior/posterior force on humeral head | Degree of translation | Grades laxity/instability |
| Sulcus Sign | Apply inferior traction force to arm at side | Gap >1 cm inferior to acromion | Inferior laxity or multidirectional instability |
| Jerk Test | Posterior force applied with arm adduction and FF | Audible/palpable "clunk" | Posterior subluxation |
D. Labrum / Biceps Tests
| Test | Technique | Positive Sign | Significance |
|---|
| O'Brien (Active Compression) Test | Arm forward flexed 90°, 10° adduction, maximal pronation; resist FF | Pain with pronation, relieved with supination | SLAP lesion |
| Crank Test | Full abduction, axial humeral loading, rotation | Pain/click | SLAP lesion |
| Speed Test | Resist FF in scapular plane with elbow extended, forearm supinated | Pain over bicipital groove | Bicipital tendinitis / SLAP |
| Yergason's Test | Elbow at 90°, resist supination + ER | Pain in bicipital groove | Bicipital tendinitis |
| Anterior Slide Test | Hand on hip, axial load applied anteriorly | Pain/click | SLAP lesion |
Evidence note: O'Brien + Crank test in combination = most sensitive two-test combination for SLAP lesions. Yergason + Anterior Slide test combination = most specific. Sensitivity improves with parallel testing; specificity improves with serial (sequential) testing.
(Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th Ed 2026)
E. AC Joint Test
| Test | Technique | Positive Sign | Significance |
|---|
| Cross-Body Adduction Test | Passive horizontal adduction of the arm across the chest | Pain over AC joint | AC joint pathology |
F. Neurological Test - Axillary Nerve
- Do NOT test deltoid abduction alone (arm injury limits this anyway).
- Test cutaneous sensation over the "regimental badge" area (lower part of deltoid, lateral arm).
- Loss of sensation = axillary nerve injury (complication of shoulder dislocation, humeral neck fracture).
(Das, Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th Ed)
6. NEUROVASCULAR EXAMINATION
- Peripheral pulse (radial artery) - vascular injury in fracture-dislocations.
- Neurological screen of entire upper extremity (C5-T1):
- C5: Deltoid, biceps; sensation over lateral arm
- C6: Wrist extensors; thumb and index finger sensation
- C7: Triceps, wrist flexors; middle finger
- C8/T1: Intrinsics; ring/little fingers
- Check axillary nerve (see above).
- Brachial plexus screen if high-energy trauma.
(Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th Ed 2026)
7. MEASUREMENTS (Objective Documentation)
| Measurement | Method | Normal/Finding |
|---|
| Arm length | Angle of acromion to lateral epicondyle of humerus | Equal bilaterally |
| Vertical circumference of axilla | Tape measure around axilla | Increased in dislocation |
| Goniometric ROM | As above | See normal values table |
| Limb girth (muscle bulk) | Tape at fixed distance from bony landmark | Assess wasting |
8. SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS (to supplement assessment)
| Investigation | Indication |
|---|
| X-ray (AP + Lateral/Axial) | First-line for fractures/dislocations; mandatory even if clinical diagnosis seems certain |
| MRI | Rotator cuff tears, glenoid labrum (SLAP), articular cartilage, adhesive capsulitis |
| MR Arthrogram | Improved labral visualization |
| CT Scan | Bony abnormalities, glenoid bone loss, preoperative arthroplasty planning |
| Ultrasound | Dynamic rotator cuff assessment, guided injections |
(Miller's Review of Orthopaedics, 9th Ed; Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th Ed 2026)
REFERENCES
- Das S. - A Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th Edition. Chapter 13: Examination of Injuries About the Shoulder, pp. 182-185.
- Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th Edition 2026 (Azar, Beaty, Canale) - Chapter 51: Physical Examination of the Shoulder; Table 51.2.
- Miller's Review of Orthopaedics, 9th Edition - Table 4.7: Shoulder Key Examination Points.
- Firestein & Kelley's Textbook of Rheumatology, 2-Volume Set - Chapter 46: Physical Examination of the Shoulder, Fig 46.3.
- Rheumatology, 2-Volume Set (Elsevier 2022) - Movements and palpation of the shoulder.
- Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition - Clinical Examination of the Shoulder.
- Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice - Table 28.1: MRC Scale for Grading Muscle Strength.