Here is a detailed, realistic case study of Multiple Sclerosis covering all the Unit 17 topics (etiology, pathophysiology, classification, clinical signs & symptoms, investigations, differential diagnosis, medical management, and complications) — structured in the format used in clinical neurology teaching.
CASE STUDY: Multiple Sclerosis
PATIENT PROFILE
| |
|---|
| Name | Mrs. Aisha Mir (fictional) |
| Age | 28 years |
| Sex | Female |
| Occupation | School teacher |
| Residence | Srinagar, Kashmir (high altitude, northern latitude) |
| Marital Status | Married, 1 child |
| Referred by | General Physician → Neurology OPD |
CHIEF COMPLAINTS
- Sudden painless blurring of vision in the right eye - 3 weeks ago (resolved spontaneously)
- Tingling and numbness in both legs - present for 2 weeks
- Weakness in both lower limbs - progressive over 10 days
- Electric shock sensation down the spine on bending the neck - 1 week
- Urinary urgency and occasional incontinence - 5 days
HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS
Mrs. Aisha Mir, a 28-year-old school teacher from Srinagar, presented to the Neurology OPD with a 3-week history of sudden, painless blurring of vision in her right eye associated with mild pain on eye movement. She noticed a "washed out" appearance of colors. This episode resolved completely over 2 weeks without any treatment, and she dismissed it.
Two weeks prior to the current visit, she developed tingling and numbness starting in the feet and ascending to the thighs bilaterally. Over the next week, she noticed progressive weakness in both legs, making it difficult to climb stairs and walk long distances. She describes her legs as feeling "stiff and heavy."
One week ago, she noticed that on bending her neck forward, she experienced a sudden electric shock-like sensation radiating down her spine into both legs - lasting a second but frightening her enough to seek medical care.
She also reports urinary urgency with difficulty holding urine and two episodes of incontinence in the last 5 days.
She denies fever, headache, seizures, vomiting, or recent vaccinations/infections.
PAST HISTORY
- 5 years ago: An episode of transient diplopia (double vision) lasting 3 weeks that resolved spontaneously - never investigated
- No history of diabetes, hypertension, tuberculosis, epilepsy
- No prior hospitalizations
Clinical Note: The history of transient diplopia 5 years ago represents a prior demyelinating episode - highly significant in retrospect.
FAMILY HISTORY
- No first-degree relative with MS or autoimmune disease
- Mother has Hashimoto's thyroiditis (autoimmune background in family)
PERSONAL HISTORY
- Non-smoker, non-alcoholic
- Diet: predominantly vegetarian, limited sun exposure (lives in high-latitude, frequently cloudy Kashmir)
- No recent travel
- Menstrual history: regular; symptoms worsened after a hot bath last week
DRUG HISTORY
- No current medications
- No history of drug allergy
GENERAL EXAMINATION
- Conscious, cooperative, well-oriented to time, place, and person
- Vitals: BP 118/76 mmHg, Pulse 78/min, Temp 37°C, SpO2 98%
- No pallor, icterus, cyanosis, clubbing, lymphadenopathy, or edema
- No skin rash, oral ulcers, or joint swelling
NEUROLOGICAL EXAMINATION
Higher Mental Functions
- Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE): 27/30 (mild inattention, slightly slow processing)
- Mood: mildly anxious, appropriate affect
Cranial Nerve Examination
| Nerve | Finding |
|---|
| CN I | Normal |
| CN II (Right eye) | Visual acuity 6/18 (reduced); Central scotoma on Amsler grid; Pale optic disc on fundoscopy (resolving optic neuritis) |
| CN II (Left eye) | Normal 6/6 |
| CN III/IV/VI | Internuclear ophthalmoplegia (INO) on left gaze: impaired adduction of right eye, nystagmus of left abducting eye (MLF lesion - right side) |
| CN V | Normal sensation |
| CN VII | Normal |
| CN VIII | No hearing loss; mild positional nystagmus |
| CN IX, X | Normal gag reflex |
| CN XI, XII | Normal |
Key Finding: Unilateral optic neuritis + INO in a young woman = MS until proven otherwise
Motor Examination (Lower Limbs)
| Finding | Right | Left |
|---|
| Tone | Increased (spasticity) | Increased (spasticity) |
| Power (hip flexion) | 3/5 | 3/5 |
| Power (knee extension) | 4/5 | 4/5 |
| Power (ankle dorsiflexion) | 4/5 | 4/5 |
| Reflexes (knee jerk) | ++++ (brisk) | ++++ (brisk) |
| Reflexes (ankle jerk) | +++ (brisk) | +++ (brisk) |
| Plantar response | Extensor (Babinski +ve) | Extensor (Babinski +ve) |
| Clonus | Present at ankle | Present at ankle |
Upper limbs: essentially normal power, mildly brisk reflexes bilaterally
Sensory Examination
| Modality | Finding |
|---|
| Pain & Temperature | Mildly reduced below T6 level bilaterally |
| Vibration sense | Significantly reduced in both feet and knees |
| Joint position sense | Impaired at toes bilaterally |
| Light touch | Reduced below mid-thoracic level |
Sensory level at approximately T6 = cervicothoracic cord involvement
Cerebellar Examination
- Mild bilateral dysmetria on finger-nose test
- Heel-shin test mildly impaired bilaterally
- Tandem gait impossible (falls to sides)
- No dysarthria at this stage
Special Signs
- Lhermitte's sign: POSITIVE - electric shock sensation down the spine on neck flexion
- Uhthoff's phenomenon: POSITIVE - symptoms worsened after hot bath (history)
- Romberg's test: POSITIVE - sways markedly, near-fall
Bladder
- Palpable bladder on lower abdominal examination
- Post-void residual urine on bladder scan: 120 mL (neurogenic bladder)
PROVISIONAL DIAGNOSIS
Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS)
Based on:
- Young female, episodic CNS attacks with recovery
- Current attack: spinal cord + optic nerve + brainstem involvement
- Previous attacks: diplopia (5 yrs ago) + optic neuritis (3 wks ago)
- Dissemination in SPACE: optic nerve + brainstem (INO) + spinal cord
- Dissemination in TIME: prior episode (5 yrs) + current attack
INVESTIGATIONS
1. MRI Brain with Gadolinium (MOST IMPORTANT)
Report:
- Multiple T2/FLAIR hyperintense lesions in periventricular white matter, oriented perpendicular to ventricles (Dawson's fingers)
- Juxtacortical lesions in right frontal and parietal regions
- Infratentorial lesion in dorsal pons (explains INO)
- Gadolinium-enhancing lesion in right pericallosal region (active, current attack)
- Non-enhancing chronic lesions in left periventricular region (prior attack)
Conclusion: Lesions satisfy McDonald 2017 criteria for both DIS and DIT
2. MRI Cervical Spine
Report:
- T2 hyperintense intramedullary lesion at C3-C5 level (right lateral column)
- Lesion < 3 vertebral segments in length
- No cord expansion or swelling
3. Cerebrospinal Fluid (CSF) Analysis
| Parameter | Result | Reference |
|---|
| Appearance | Clear, colorless | Clear |
| Opening pressure | 140 mmH₂O | Normal |
| WBC | 12 cells/mm³ (lymphocytes) | <5 |
| Protein | 52 mg/dL | 15-45 mg/dL |
| Glucose | 58 mg/dL (blood glucose 100) | Normal ratio |
| Oligoclonal bands (OCBs) | POSITIVE (5 bands in CSF, absent in serum) | Abnormal |
| IgG Index | 0.72 (elevated) | <0.66 |
| Myelin Basic Protein (MBP) | Elevated | Normal |
OCBs in CSF absent in serum = intrathecal IgG synthesis = highly supportive of MS
4. Visual Evoked Potentials (VEP)
- Right eye: P100 latency = 128 ms (prolonged; normal <115 ms) - confirms subclinical right optic nerve demyelination
- Left eye: P100 latency = 109 ms (borderline) - suggests subclinical prior involvement
5. Blood Investigations (to exclude differentials)
| Test | Result | Significance |
|---|
| CBC | Normal | Excludes anemia, infection |
| ESR | 18 mm/hr | Normal (against SLE/vasculitis) |
| ANA | Weakly positive 1:40 | Low titer, non-specific |
| Anti-dsDNA | Negative | Excludes lupus |
| Anti-AQP4 (NMO-IgG) | Negative | Excludes NMOSD |
| Anti-MOG antibody | Negative | Excludes MOG-AD |
| Serum B12 | 320 pg/mL (normal) | Excludes B12 deficiency |
| Thyroid function | TSH mildly elevated (3.8 mIU/L) | Autoimmune thyroid disease (incidental) |
| HIV ELISA | Negative | Excludes HIV myelopathy |
| VDRL | Negative | Excludes neurosyphilis |
| ACE level | Normal | Excludes neurosarcoidosis |
| Chest X-ray | Normal | Excludes sarcoidosis, TB |
DIAGNOSIS CONFIRMED
Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS)
McDonald 2017 Criteria Fulfilled:
| Criterion | Evidence |
|---|
| DIS | Periventricular + Juxtacortical + Infratentorial + Spinal cord lesions on MRI |
| DIT | Simultaneous enhancing + non-enhancing lesions on MRI + CSF OCBs |
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSES (Considered and Excluded)
| Diagnosis | Arguments For | Arguments Against / How Excluded |
|---|
| NMOSD (Devic's) | Female, optic neuritis, myelopathy | Anti-AQP4 negative; cord lesion < 3 segments; no area postrema syndrome |
| MOG antibody disease | Female, optic neuritis, relapsing | Anti-MOG negative; no cortical encephalitis |
| SLE/Lupus sclerosis | Young female, ANA weakly positive | Anti-dsDNA negative; no systemic features; no renal/skin/joint involvement |
| Neurosarcoidosis | Can mimic MS on MRI | ACE normal; no systemic sarcoid features; no granulomas |
| ADEM | Demyelination | No recent infection/vaccination; polyphasic course (prior attacks); OCBs present |
| Spinal cord tumor | Myelopathy with sensory level | MRI shows no mass/cord expansion; no extramedullary compression |
| Vitamin B12 deficiency (SCD) | Posterior column + pyramidal signs | B12 normal; no macrocytosis; episodic relapsing course inconsistent |
| Cervical spondylotic myelopathy | Cervical cord lesion | Age 28, female; MRI no spondylotic changes; episodic history inconsistent |
MANAGEMENT
Phase 1: Acute Relapse Treatment
IV Methylprednisolone 1 g/day IV in 250 mL normal saline over 3-4 hours × 5 days
- Shortens duration and severity of current relapse
- Does NOT improve long-term disability
- Followed by oral prednisolone taper (optional)
Monitoring during steroids: Blood glucose, BP, electrolytes, sleep disturbance, mood changes
Phase 2: Disease-Modifying Therapy (DMT)
Decision: Start moderate-efficacy DMT given first confirmed MS diagnosis at young age
Choice: Interferon beta-1a (Avonex) 30 mcg IM once weekly
- Reduces relapse rate by ~30%
- Slows MRI lesion accumulation
- Counsel about: flu-like side effects (pre-treat with paracetamol), injection site reactions, liver function monitoring every 6 months, thyroid function (important here given autoimmune thyroid disease)
Alternative if intolerant: Glatiramer acetate or Dimethyl fumarate (oral)
Escalation plan: If ≥2 relapses/year or new MRI lesions on first-line therapy → escalate to Natalizumab (after JC antibody testing) or Ocrelizumab
Phase 3: Symptomatic Management
| Symptom | Drug / Intervention | Dose |
|---|
| Spasticity | Tab. Baclofen | Start 5 mg TDS, titrate to 25 mg TDS |
| Urinary urgency/incontinence | Tab. Oxybutynin | 5 mg BD; clean intermittent catheterization |
| Neuropathic tingling/pain | Tab. Gabapentin | 300 mg TDS (titrated) |
| Fatigue | Tab. Amantadine | 100 mg BD (morning + afternoon) |
| Depression (if develops) | Tab. Sertraline | 50 mg OD |
| Vitamin D deficiency | Cholecalciferol | 2000 IU/day (given northern latitude) |
Phase 4: Rehabilitation (Physiotherapy - Key for BPT students)
Goals:
- Improve functional mobility and independence
- Reduce spasticity and prevent contractures
- Improve balance and reduce fall risk
- Manage fatigue
Physiotherapy Program:
| Component | Details |
|---|
| Stretching | Daily passive and active stretching of hamstrings, hip flexors, gastrocnemius to manage spasticity |
| Strengthening | Graduated resistance training for hip flexors, quadriceps (avoid overexertion/heat) |
| Gait training | Parallel bars → walking frame → cane progression |
| Balance training | Frenkel's exercises, proprioceptive training on wobble board |
| Aquatic therapy | Hydrotherapy in cool water (avoid warm water - Uhthoff's phenomenon) |
| Fatigue management | Energy conservation techniques, rest periods, pacing |
| Breathing exercises | Prevent chest infections in later stages |
| Bladder retraining | Timed voiding schedule |
Occupational Therapy:
- Adaptive devices (grab rails, raised toilet seat, non-slip mats)
- Home modification advice
- Return-to-work planning
COUNSELLING
The neurologist and team explained to Mrs. Aisha:
- MS is not curable, but is manageable - majority of RRMS patients remain ambulatory for decades
- DMT reduces relapse rate and slows disability progression - must be taken regularly
- Avoid heat - no hot baths, manage fever promptly (Uhthoff's phenomenon)
- Pregnancy - MS relapses decrease during pregnancy (especially 3rd trimester) but increase post-partum; interferon beta must be stopped before conception
- Importance of vitamin D supplementation and maintaining active lifestyle
- Regular follow-up: MRI every 6-12 months, neurologist review every 3-6 months
- MS Society support group referral
- Psychological support offered
FOLLOW-UP at 4 Weeks
- Patient reports significant improvement in leg strength (power improved to 4+/5 bilaterally)
- Urinary urgency reduced with oxybutynin
- Tingling partially resolved
- Lhermitte's sign still present but less intense
- Started walking with minimal support
- Commenced physiotherapy 5 days/week
Repeat MRI at 3 months:
- Gadolinium-enhancing lesion resolved (inactive)
- No new lesions (treatment response)
COMPLICATIONS NOTED / ANTICIPATED
| Complication | Status in this Patient |
|---|
| Neurogenic bladder / UTI risk | Active - managed with oxybutynin + hygiene |
| Depression | Counselled; watchful monitoring |
| Fatigue | Active - amantadine + physiotherapy |
| Falls | Risk present - home safety review done |
| Cognitive decline | Mildly present - monitored |
| Contractures | Prevented by physiotherapy stretching program |
| Secondary progression (SPMS) | Risk in future; DMT initiated to delay |
| Pregnancy planning | Discussed - DMT adjustment needed |
| Vitamin D deficiency | Corrected with supplementation |
LEARNING POINTS FROM THIS CASE
- Optic neuritis in a young woman is MS until proven otherwise - 50% develop MS within 15 years
- Bilateral INO in a young adult = pathognomonic of MS (virtually no other cause)
- Lhermitte's sign + Uhthoff's phenomenon are hallmark clinical features
- Dissemination in space AND time is the diagnostic cornerstone (McDonald criteria)
- A prior undiagnosed episode (diplopia 5 years ago) is frequently identified retrospectively - thorough history is essential
- CSF oligoclonal bands support diagnosis and allow earlier treatment initiation
- Anti-AQP4 and anti-MOG must always be checked to exclude NMOSD/MOGAD before labeling MS
- Physiotherapy is a core pillar of MS management - not supplementary
- Avoid heat during physiotherapy sessions - use cool environments
- MS is a lifelong condition requiring multidisciplinary care: Neurologist + Physiotherapist + Occupational Therapist + Urologist + Psychologist + Ophthalmologist
This case study is designed for 4th Year BPT students, Dept. of Neurology, GMC Srinagar, as per Unit 17 syllabus (Dr. Sheikh Hilal Ahmad).