I now have all the material needed. Let me compile the comprehensive exam answer.
Imaging in Bone Tumours - Detailed Notes for ND Radiology Theory Exam
Source: Grainger & Allison's Diagnostic Radiology, Chapters 40 & 41
PART 1: RADIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT - THE SYSTEMATIC APPROACH
When analysing any bone lesion, six key radiological parameters must be assessed before making a diagnosis.
1. Age of Patient
| Age Group | Most Likely Lesion |
|---|
| <5 years | Metastatic neuroblastoma, leukaemia |
| 5-15 years | Ewing sarcoma, osteosarcoma |
| 10-25 years | Osteosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma, osteoblastoma |
| 20-40 years | GCT, fibrosarcoma/UPS |
| >40 years | Metastases (commonest!), myeloma, chondrosarcoma, Paget sarcoma |
2. Location within Skeleton & Bone
Skeletal site:
- Axial > appendicular (metastases, myeloma prefer red marrow)
- Long bones: osteosarcoma (distal femur, proximal tibia, proximal humerus)
- Flat bones / diaphysis: Ewing sarcoma (pelvis, ribs)
Location within the bone:
| Position | Tumours |
|---|
| Epiphysis | GCT (mature skeleton), chondroblastoma (open physis), clear cell chondrosarcoma |
| Metaphysis | Osteosarcoma, chondrosarcoma, NOF, ABC, SBC |
| Diaphysis | Ewing sarcoma, fibrous dysplasia, adamantinoma (tibia), myeloma |
| Epiphysis + Metaphysis | GCT (crosses physis in adults) |
| Intramedullary | Most primary bone tumours |
| Intracortical | Osteoid osteoma, adamantinoma |
| Surface/juxtacortical | Parosteal osteosarcoma, periosteal chondroma |
3. Rate of Growth - Lodwick Classification (Zone of Transition)
| Type | Description | Significance |
|---|
| Type 1A | Sharp, geographic, sclerotic margin | Slow growth; benign |
| Type 1B | Well-defined lytic, no marginal sclerosis | Slow growth; benign/low-grade |
| Type 1C | Slightly less sharp, non-sclerotic | Transitional |
| Type 2 | Moth-eaten - multiple lucent areas 2-5 mm, separated by intact bone | More aggressive |
| Type 3 | Permeative - multiple coalescing tiny (<1 mm) ill-defined lesions, zone of transition >several cm | Most aggressive; Ewing, lymphoma, myeloma |
- Benign/low-grade tumours: remain in medullary cavity, endosteal scalloping + expansion without cortical destruction
- High-grade malignant: cortical destruction + extra-osseous soft-tissue mass by presentation
4. Periosteal Reaction Types
| Type | Description | Significance |
|---|
| Solid/thick | Well-formed, uniform | Slow growth; NOT necessarily benign (can see in grade 2 chondrosarcoma) |
| Laminated ("onion skin") | Multiple parallel layers | Subperiosteal tumour extension, infection, haematoma; CLASSIC in Ewing sarcoma |
| Codman triangle | Interrupted periosteal reaction at edge of tumour | Marks limit of subperiosteal tumour in longitudinal direction; indicates aggressive lesion |
| Sunburst/hair-on-end (spiculated) | Radiating perpendicular spicules | Most aggressive; CLASSIC in osteosarcoma; also Ewing |
| Multilaminated | Periodic growth pattern | Repeated episodes of tumour growth |
Exam Pearl: No periosteal reaction is pathognomonic for any tumour - it indicates aggressiveness, not histological type.
5. Matrix Mineralisation
| Matrix Type | Appearance | Tumour |
|---|
| Osteoid/tumour bone | Dense, fluffy, cloud-like, "ivory" | Osteosarcoma |
| Chondroid | Rings, arcs, C-shapes, "pop-corn" calcification | Chondrosarcoma, enchondroma, osteochondroma |
| No matrix | Purely lytic | GCT, myeloma, metastases (renal, thyroid), fibrosarcoma |
| Ground glass | Hazy, "smoke-filled" | Fibrous dysplasia |
6. CT and MRI Role
CT:
- Best for: cortical detail, matrix mineralisation characterisation, periosteal reaction details
- Identifies subtle endosteal scalloping, cortical destruction
- CT-guided biopsy
MRI (Gold Standard for Local Staging):
- T1W: anatomy, medullary extent (normal marrow = bright; tumour = dark, intermediate)
- T2W/STIR: tumour extent, oedema, soft-tissue component (tumour = bright); identifies skip lesions
- Contrast (Gd): tumour enhancement pattern; solid vs cystic components; vascular supply
- Key MRI roles:
- Defines intramedullary extent - always underestimated on X-ray
- Cortical saucerisation by Ewing sarcoma visible
- Soft-tissue extension and neurovascular bundle proximity (surgical planning)
- Skip lesions (transarticular/intramedullary discontinuous foci)
- Response to chemotherapy assessment
PART 2: CLASSIFICATION OF BONE TUMOURS
WHO Classification - Key Benign Tumours (Table 40.1, Grainger & Allison)
| Origin | Benign | Intermediate/Locally Aggressive |
|---|
| Chondrogenic | Osteochondroma, enchondroma | ACT/grade 1 chondrosarcoma, chondroblastoma |
| Osteogenic | Osteoma, osteoid osteoma | Osteoblastoma |
| Giant cell-rich | GCL small bones | Giant cell tumour |
| Fibrogenic | NOF, benign fibrous histiocytoma | Desmoplastic fibroma |
| Undefined | Simple bone cyst, FD, ABC | - |
WHO Classification - Malignant Bone Tumours
| Origin | Malignant Tumour |
|---|
| Chondrogenic | Chondrosarcoma (grade 1-3), dedifferentiated |
| Osteogenic | Osteosarcoma (7 subtypes) |
| Fibrogenic | Fibrosarcoma, UPS (undifferentiated pleomorphic sarcoma) |
| Marrow | Ewing sarcoma, myeloma, lymphoma |
| Notochordal | Chordoma |
| Metastatic | (Most common overall >40 yrs) |
PART 3: INDIVIDUAL TUMOURS IN DETAIL
A. OSTEOSARCOMA
Epidemiology: Commonest non-haematological primary bone malignancy; 4/million/year; bimodal - peak at 10-14 years (adolescent growth spurt), second peak in elderly (Paget-related). Male:female = 1.35:1.
Associations: Li-Fraumeni syndrome, Rothmund-Thomson syndrome, familial retinoblastoma, Paget disease, prior radiotherapy, bone infarction, fibrous dysplasia.
WHO Subtypes (7):
- Conventional (75%) - high-grade intramedullary
- Telangiectatic
- Low-grade central
- Small cell
- Parosteal - surface, low grade
- Periosteal - surface, intermediate grade
- High-grade surface
Conventional Osteosarcoma:
Conventional osteosarcoma - X-ray appearances: (A) early normal appearing; (B) lytic permeative metaphyseal; (C) sclerotic with sunburst periosteal reaction - distal femur/proximal tibia (most common site = around knee)
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Metaphysis of long bones; distal femur (40%), proximal tibia (20%), proximal humerus (10%) - around the knee in 60% |
| X-ray | Mixed sclerotic-lytic lesion; permeative/moth-eaten destruction; sunburst periosteal reaction (most aggressive); Codman triangle; soft-tissue mass with tumour bone formation (fluffy/cloud-like density) |
| Matrix | Osteoid matrix - dense, fluffy, amorphous sclerosis (differentiate from reactive host bone!) |
| MRI T1 | Low-intermediate SI tumour; dark on T1; medullary extent clearly shown |
| MRI T2/STIR | Heterogeneous high SI; soft-tissue extension; skip lesions |
| Key MRI features | Defines extent for limb salvage surgery; neurovascular bundle proximity; skip lesions (intramedullary discontinuous foci within same bone or transarticular) |
| CT | Matrix mineralisation detail; periosteal reaction characterisation |
Telangiectatic Osteosarcoma:
- Purely lytic, large, expansile; no matrix mineralisation
- Multiple fluid-fluid levels (FFLs) on MRI - mimics ABC!
- Key distinction: solid nodular tissue in walls + Gd enhancement = malignant
- DDx: ABC has no solid enhancing component
Parosteal Osteosarcoma:
- Surface lesion; posterior distal femur most common
- Dense ossified surface mass; may encircle bone; normal medullary cavity (until late)
- X-ray: densely ossified lobulated surface lesion
- MRI: low SI ossified centre; cleavage plane between lesion and cortex useful prognostically
Periosteal Osteosarcoma:
- Surface, intermediate grade (chondroblastic)
- X-ray: spiculated periosteal reaction + ossified soft-tissue component
- MRI: confirms extensive surface lesion + intramedullary signal change
B. EWING SARCOMA
Epidemiology: 2nd most common bone sarcoma in children; 6-8% primary malignant bone tumours; 75% under age 20 (peak 5-15 yrs); male:female = 1.4:1; rare in non-Caucasians. Translocation t(11;22).
Family includes: Ewing sarcoma, PNET, adult neuroblastoma, Askin tumour (chest wall).
Ewing sarcoma - humerus: permeative lytic diaphyseal lesion with wide zone of transition and classic lamellated periosteal reaction
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Diaphysis (35%) or metadiaphysis (60%) - classic diaphyseal unlike osteosarcoma (metaphyseal); femur + humerus (31%), pelvis (21%, ilium), ribs (<8%) |
| X-ray | Permeative/moth-eaten destruction; wide zone of transition; "onion-skin" (multilamellar) periosteal reaction; soft-tissue mass in 80% |
| Codman triangle | Present |
| Sunburst | Can occur but less typical than in osteosarcoma |
| MRI | Large soft-tissue mass (often disproportionate to bone destruction); may show "cortical saucerisation"; T2 bright; intermediate T1 |
| Mimics infection | Systemic features (fever, raised ESR) + diaphyseal lytic lesion - DDx osteomyelitis |
| Pelvic Ewing | Large soft-tissue mass; can be very large with iliac bone destruction |
C. CHONDROSARCOMA
Epidemiology: 2nd most common primary bone malignancy; 4th-5th decade (unlike osteosarcoma); male predominance.
Types:
- Central (conventional) - most common; arises in medullary cavity
- Secondary - from osteochondroma or enchondroma
- Dedifferentiated - high-grade component within low-grade; worst prognosis
- Clear cell - epiphyseal; low grade
- Mesenchymal - young patients; highly malignant
Imaging:
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Pelvis, proximal femur, proximal humerus, ribs (unlike osteosarcoma = distal femur) |
| X-ray | Lytic lesion with chondroid matrix (rings and arcs calcification, "popcorn"); endosteal scalloping; slow-growing; no aggressive periosteal reaction in low-grade |
| Size | Mean 8 cm (vs enchondroma 5 cm) |
| Endosteal scalloping >2/3 cortical thickness | Seen in 67% chondrosarcomas vs 11% enchondromas - key imaging sign |
| Bone scintigraphy | >80% chondrosarcomas show increased uptake; normal activity favours enchondroma |
| MRI | Lobulated; T2 very bright (high water content cartilage); septal enhancement post-contrast; dynamic CE-MRI for dedifferentiation foci |
| CT | Best for calcification pattern and cortical erosion |
| Cartilage cap (secondary from osteochondroma) | Cap >2 cm on US/CT/MRI = malignant transformation likely; <2 cm = unlikely |
| FDG-PET | Low SUVmax = benign; elevated SUVmax = higher-grade; not yet routine |
D. GIANT CELL TUMOUR (GCT) OF BONE
Epidemiology: Locally aggressive (intermediate); 20-40 years; rare in skeletally immature; female preponderance. ~1-2% metastasise to lung.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Epiphysis (closed physis required); distal femur, proximal tibia, distal radius; extends to subchondral bone |
| X-ray | Purely lytic ("soap bubble" appearance); eccentric, epiphyseal/subchondral; no matrix; no periosteal reaction in uncomplicated cases; type 1B/1C zone of transition; cortical expansion; may break cortex |
| MRI T1 | Low-intermediate SI |
| MRI T2 | Heterogeneous; areas of low SI (haemosiderin); fluid-fluid levels (25%) |
| MRI Gd | Solid enhancement (distinguishes from ABC) |
| CT | No internal calcification (distinguishes from chondroid lesions); cortical thinning; soft-tissue extension |
| Recurrence | High local recurrence rate after curettage |
E. OSTEOID OSTEOMA
Epidemiology: Young adults (10-35 years); male:female = 3:1; night pain relieved by aspirin/NSAIDs (classic clinical feature from prostaglandin production).
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Cortex of long bone diaphysis/metaphysis (femur, tibia); posterior elements of spine (scoliosis) |
| X-ray | Small (<1.5 cm) radiolucent nidus surrounded by dense reactive sclerosis; nidus may be hard to see |
| CT | Modality of choice - shows nidus precisely; central calcification in 50% of nidus; surrounding sclerosis; localises lesion for radiofrequency ablation guidance |
| MRI | Marked surrounding reactive marrow oedema (can be confusing - overestimates lesion); nidus T1 iso, T2 high; Gd enhancement |
| Bone scan | Intense "double density" hot spot |
F. OSTEOBLASTOMA
- Similar to osteoid osteoma but >2 cm in diameter
- Posterior spinal elements (common site)
- Less reactive sclerosis; more expansile
- No aspirin-relief (typically)
- May be locally aggressive
G. ENCHONDROMA
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Short tubular bones of hands/feet (>50%); metaphysis |
| X-ray | Lytic lesion with chondroid calcification (rings/arcs/stippled); expansion in small bones; minimal or no endosteal scalloping |
| DDx Chondrosarcoma | Size >5 cm; deep endosteal scalloping (>2/3 cortical thickness); pain; soft-tissue mass |
| Syndromes | Ollier disease (multiple enchondromatosis - non-hereditary; increased risk of malignancy); Maffucci syndrome (enchondromas + soft-tissue haemangiomas; high malignancy risk) |
H. OSTEOCHONDROMA (MOST COMMON BENIGN BONE TUMOUR)
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Metaphysis of long bones (distal femur, proximal tibia, proximal humerus); may be pedunculated or sessile |
| X-ray | Bony excrescence with cortex and medullary cavity continuous with parent bone (pathognomonic); grows away from physis; cartilage cap not visible on X-ray |
| MRI | Cartilage cap: T2 bright; measure cap thickness perpendicular to bony component: cap >2 cm = suspicious for secondary chondrosarcoma |
| US | Can measure cap thickness |
| Malignant change | Pain after skeletal maturity; continued growth; cap >2 cm; dispersal of calcifications in soft-tissue mass |
| Multiple hereditary | Multiple hereditary exostoses (MHE) - autosomal dominant; higher risk of malignancy |
I. BONE METASTASES
Most common bone malignancy in >40 years. Bone is 3rd commonest site of metastatic spread (after lung and liver).
"BLT Kidney Thyroid" (Breast, Lung, Thyroid, Kidney, Prostate) = 80% of all bone metastases.
Prevalence at death: Breast + Prostate = 80-85%; Lung = 40-80%; Thyroid = 50-60%; Renal = 20-35%.
Distribution: Axial skeleton (red marrow sites): spine (thoracic > lumbar > cervical), pelvis, proximal femur/humerus, ribs, sternum, skull.
Batson venous plexus = valveless vertebral venous plexus explains spinal predilection.
| Type | Primary Tumour | X-ray Appearance |
|---|
| Lytic | Kidney, thyroid, lung, breast, GI | Destructive, permeative; no matrix |
| Sclerotic | Prostate (most common), breast (some), carcinoid, medulloblastoma | Dense, "ivory" vertebrae; diffuse sclerosis |
| Mixed | Breast (most common), lung | Both lytic and sclerotic |
Ivory vertebra: Prostate >> lymphoma, Paget disease (common causes); dense sclerotic vertebral body.
Imaging Modalities for Metastases:
| Modality | Role |
|---|
| X-ray | First-line; insensitive (requires 30-50% bone loss) |
| Bone scintigraphy (Tc-99m MDP) | Sensitive screening tool; detects osteoblastic activity; false-negative in lytic mets (renal, thyroid, myeloma) |
| CT | Cortical detail; pathological fracture risk; biopsy guidance |
| MRI | Most sensitive for marrow involvement; STIR/T1 for diffuse marrow disease; whole-body MRI replacing bone scan |
| FDG-PET-CT | Functional + anatomical; excellent for lytic mets; less sensitive for purely sclerotic |
| Specific tracers | NaF-PET (bone); PSMA-PET (prostate); I-131 (thyroid) |
Superscan: Diffuse, uniformly increased uptake on bone scan with absent renal activity and absent soft-tissue background - seen with widespread diffuse sclerotic metastases (prostate, breast).
J. MULTIPLE MYELOMA
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Age | >40 years (97% present after 40) |
| X-ray | "Punched out" lytic lesions (no reactive sclerosis); skull ("pepper-pot" skull); diffuse osteoporosis; vertebral compression fractures |
| Bone scan | Often FALSE NEGATIVE (no osteoblastic reaction) - bone scan not useful! |
| MRI | Modality of choice; focal or diffuse marrow involvement; T1 low SI, T2/STIR high SI |
| Whole-body MRI | Now recommended for staging in guidelines |
| FDG-PET-CT | Detects active disease; used for treatment response |
| X-ray skeletal survey | Traditional staging method |
K. SIMPLE BONE CYST (SBC) / UNICAMERAL BONE CYST
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Age | Children/adolescents |
| Site | Proximal humerus (most common), proximal femur; metaphyseal; central |
| X-ray | Central lytic lesion, slightly expansile, well-defined margins; thin cortex; may have "fallen fragment" sign (fallen cortical fragment inside cyst after pathological fracture) |
| MRI | Homogeneous fluid signal; T1 low, T2 high; no solid component |
L. ANEURYSMAL BONE CYST (ABC)
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Age | <20 years |
| Site | Metaphysis long bones; posterior spinal elements |
| X-ray | Eccentric, expansile, "blown out" lytic lesion; thin cortical shell; "soap bubble" |
| MRI | Multiple fluid-fluid levels (FFLs) - blood products of different ages; thin septa; T1 and T2 components from haemorrhage |
| DDx | Telangiectatic osteosarcoma (has solid enhancing nodules); GCT (older age, epiphysis) |
| Primary vs Secondary | Secondary ABC arises in GCT, chondroblastoma, fibrous dysplasia, osteoblastoma |
M. NON-OSSIFYING FIBROMA (NOF)
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Metaphysis/metadiaphysis; cortically based; distal femur, tibia |
| X-ray | Eccentric, cortically based lytic lesion with sclerotic margin (type 1A); no matrix; multilobulated; "bubbly" |
| MRI | T1/T2 low-intermediate SI (fibrous tissue); no oedema |
| Natural history | Usually involutes spontaneously (fills in with bone) |
| Jaffe-Campanacci | Multiple NOFs + café-au-lait spots |
N. FIBROUS DYSPLASIA
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Site | Rib (most common overall), proximal femur, skull/facial bones; mono or polyostotic |
| X-ray | "Ground-glass" matrix (hazy, "smoke-filled"); geographic lytic lesion with "rind" of sclerosis (thick sclerotic margin); bone expansion; NO periosteal reaction (unless fractured); "shepherd's crook" deformity (varus proximal femur - late) |
| CT | Best demonstrates ground-glass matrix |
| MRI T1 | Iso-intermediate SI; areas of hyperintensity from haemorrhage |
| MRI T2 | Variable (intermediate-low if fibrous; high if cystic change); FFLs possible |
| Bone scan/Whole body MRI | Polyostotic disease mapping |
| McCune-Albright | Polyostotic FD + café-au-lait spots + precocious puberty (GnRH-independent) |
PART 4: STAGING & BIOPSY IMAGING
Enneking Staging System (Musculoskeletal Tumour Society)
| Stage | Grade | Site | Metastasis |
|---|
| IA | Low grade (G1) | Intracompartmental (T1) | None (M0) |
| IB | Low grade (G1) | Extracompartmental (T2) | None |
| IIA | High grade (G2) | Intracompartmental (T1) | None |
| IIB | High grade (G2) | Extracompartmental (T2) | None |
| III | Any grade | Any | Regional/distant mets |
MRI is essential for Enneking staging - defines compartmental involvement.
Biopsy Planning
- MRI guides biopsy site (viable, non-necrotic, non-haemorrhagic tissue)
- Biopsy tract must lie in the planned surgical resection field
- CT-guided for axial/deep lesions
- US-guided for soft-tissue component
PART 5: RESPONSE TO TREATMENT
Post-chemotherapy MRI assessment:
- Decrease in T2 SI = good response
- Decrease in soft-tissue mass size
- Peripheral ossification around soft-tissue component
- Dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI: reduced enhancement = tumour necrosis
- Histological necrosis >90% = good response (Huvos grading)
EXAM SUMMARY: HIGH-YIELD IMAGING PEARLS
| Feature | Tumour |
|---|
| Sunburst periosteal reaction | Osteosarcoma (most classic) |
| Onion-skin periosteal reaction | Ewing sarcoma |
| Codman triangle | Any aggressive tumour (non-specific) |
| Fluid-fluid levels on MRI | ABC (primary), telangiectatic osteosarcoma, GCT |
| "Popcorn" calcification | Enchondroma, chondrosarcoma (chondroid matrix) |
| Ground-glass matrix | Fibrous dysplasia |
| "Sunray" spiculation + metaphyseal mixed lesion around knee | Conventional osteosarcoma |
| Purely lytic + epiphyseal + subchondral + no sclerosis | GCT |
| Punched-out lytic + no reactive sclerosis + false -ve bone scan | Myeloma |
| Diaphyseal lytic + fever + elevated ESR + periosteal reaction | Ewing sarcoma (DDx osteomyelitis) |
| Posterior distal femur surface mass + ossified + middle-aged | Parosteal osteosarcoma |
| Cortical based + small nidus + dense sclerosis + night pain | Osteoid osteoma |
| Endosteal scalloping >2/3 cortical thickness | Chondrosarcoma (not enchondroma) |
| Cartilage cap >2 cm on MRI | Secondary chondrosarcoma from osteochondroma |
| "Fallen fragment" sign | Simple bone cyst |
| Shepherd's crook deformity | Fibrous dysplasia (proximal femur) |
| Ivory vertebra | Prostate metastasis, Paget, lymphoma |
| Superscan on bone scan | Diffuse sclerotic metastases |
| False-negative bone scan | Myeloma, lytic metastases (renal, thyroid) |
Source: Grainger & Allison's Diagnostic Radiology, Chapters 40 (Benign Bone Tumours) & 41 (Malignant Bone Tumours), 6th/current edition