Here is the complete 15-mark MD exam answer on Systemic Sclerosis - ILD, compiled directly from Fishman's Pulmonary Diseases & Disorders and Murray & Nadel's Textbook of Respiratory Medicine, with ATS/ERS management framework integrated throughout.
Systemic Sclerosis - Interstitial Lung Disease (SSc-ILD)
MD Examination Answer - 15 Marks
Sources: Fishman's Pulmonary Diseases & Disorders | Murray & Nadel's Textbook of Respiratory Medicine | ATS/ERS guidelines
1. Introduction & Epidemiology
Systemic sclerosis is an inflammatory-fibrotic disease causing excessive extracellular matrix deposition in the skin, lungs, heart, kidneys, and GI tract. Two subtypes:
- Diffuse cutaneous SSc (dcSSc): Extensive skin + marked progressive visceral involvement
- Limited cutaneous SSc (lcSSc): CREST syndrome - more protracted course; ILD can occur but PAH is the dominant vascular complication
The lung is involved in the vast majority: postmortem series show 70-100% incidence. HRCT abnormalities are found in >90%, yet up to two-thirds have normal chest radiographs. ILD is more likely in dcSSc but also complicates lcSSc. (Fishman, p.1028-29)
2. Pathogenesis
A triad of immune dysregulation, vasculopathy, and fibrosis:
- Immune cells drive inflammation
- Endothelial injury - electron microscopy shows early endothelial and epithelial cell injury even before light microscopy abnormalities
- Fibroblast activation - excessive ECM deposition in interstitium
In the lung, this causes:
- Interstitial fibrosis
- Intimal thickening of pulmonary arteries - luminal obliteration - WHO Group 1 PAH
The inflammatory phase (cellular NSIP) predates fibrosis and is usually clinically silent. Ground-glass on HRCT, inflammatory BAL cells, and cellular biopsy all reflect this active phase. (Fishman, p.1029)
3. Histopathology
| Pattern | Frequency |
|---|
| NSIP (cellular + fibrotic subtypes) | Most common - the hallmark of SSc-ILD |
| UIP with honeycombing | Less common |
| Unclassifiable fibrosing ILD | Occasional |
| Organizing Pneumonia (OP) | Rare; may be first presentation; steroid-responsive |
| LIP | In Sjögren overlap |
| DAD | Acute exacerbations |
| Diffuse Alveolar Hemorrhage | Rare |
| Granulomatous disease (sarcoid-like) | Rare |
Critical exam point: Unlike idiopathic disease where UIP = worse prognosis than NSIP, in SSc outcomes do NOT differ materially between histologic patterns - the largest series confirms this. Biopsy does not provide sufficient prognostic information to justify the procedure routinely. (Murray & Nadel, p.2088)
4. Clinical Features
Symptoms: Dyspnea on exertion (progresses to rest), chronic cough
Signs:
- Bibasilar fine crackles (Velcro)
- Clubbing is unusual - capillary destruction in nail beds distinguishes SSc from IPF
- Nail-fold capillaroscopy: abnormal loops with capillary dropout - pathognomonic
- Signs of cor pulmonale in advanced disease
SSc sine scleroderma: ILD and PAH can precede skin manifestations; course similar, but greater tendency toward PAH. (Fishman, p.1029)
5. Radiological Features
Chest X-Ray
- Normal in up to two-thirds of patients with HRCT-proven disease
- Reticular basal pattern in early disease; volume loss, diffuse reticulation, honeycombing in advanced disease
HRCT - the key diagnostic modality (Murray & Nadel, p.2087)
| Feature | Detail |
|---|
| Distribution | Peripheral, posterior, basal; progresses superiorly and centrally |
| Ground-glass opacity (GGO) | Reflects cellular histopathology or fine fibrosis; active/treatment-responsive disease |
| Reticulation | Intralobular interstitial thickening from fibrosis |
| Traction bronchiectasis | Accompanies reticular pattern in advanced disease |
| Honeycombing | Up to one-third of cases; usually limited |
| Esophageal dilation | Common on CT - diagnostic clue specific to SSc |
HRCT extent correlates moderately with DLCO. SSc patients are less hypoxemic than IPF patients for equivalent HRCT disease extent - due to relative absence of abnormal new vessel formation.
A disproportionate DLCO reduction vs lung volumes = think PAH (especially in lcSSc). (Fishman, p.1027)
6. Pulmonary Function Tests
- Restrictive pattern: Reduced TLC, VC, compliance; reduced RV
- Reduced DLCO: May be the only abnormality in early disease - most sensitive marker
- ABG: Normal or slightly reduced PaO2; hypoxemia mild until late disease (absent PAH)
- Exercise testing: V/Q mismatch + diffusion abnormality; increased RR rather than Vt; elevated Vd/Vt
- Rate of decline: ~100 mL/yr VC loss in SSc (normal = 20-30 mL/yr)
- Lower FVC within 3 years of onset predicts progressive decline and increased mortality
- Rates of decline are highest in first few years of SSc - early detection and treatment is essential
(Murray & Nadel, p.2088)
7. BAL
- Can identify alveolitis before pulmonary symptoms
- Up to 60% have abnormal inflammatory cell distribution (Fishman)
- Neutrophil alveolitis: Marker of disease extent (more reticular pattern on CT), not an independent predictor of progression
- Lymphocytic/eosinophilic predominance: Suggests treatment-responsive cellular disease
- Not recommended routinely for diagnosis or monitoring - patients with normal BAL may still progress (Murray & Nadel / ATS-ERS aligned)
8. Serologic Investigations
| Antibody | SSc Subtype | ILD Risk |
|---|
| Anti-Scl-70 (anti-topoisomerase I) | dcSSc | High ILD risk - more severe fibrosis |
| Anti-centromere (ACA) | lcSSc/CREST | Low ILD; high isolated PAH risk |
| Anti-RNA polymerase III | dcSSc | Renal crisis; less ILD |
| Anti-Th/To | lcSSc | ILD + PAH |
| Anti-PM/Scl | Myositis overlap | ILD |
| Anti-U1 RNP | MCTD | Variable |
ANAs present in majority. Raynaud + ANA + nailfold capillaroscopy abnormality = high suspicion for SSc-ILD even before skin changes. (Murray & Nadel, p.2086)
9. Biopsy - When to Consider
- Surgical lung biopsy: virtually never required in established SSc-ILD
- Indicated only if clinical and CT findings are atypical and an alternative diagnosis is suspected
- Transbronchial biopsy and cryobiopsy: no useful diagnostic information in SSc-ILD
- (Murray & Nadel, p.2088)
10. Treatment
Who to Treat
- Progressive decline in FVC or DLCO over time
- Significant GGO on HRCT
- Symptomatic or functionally significant ILD
- Inflammatory/cellular BAL
Landmark Trials
| Trial | Intervention | Key Finding |
|---|
| SLS I (NHLBI) | Oral cyclophosphamide vs placebo | Improved FVC; benefit waned 12 months after stopping |
| SLS II | MMF 24 months vs oral CYC | Both improved FVC %, fibrosis score, PROs; MMF = CYC in efficacy; MMF superior in tolerability |
| INBUILD | Nintedanib vs placebo (progressive fibrosing ILDs) | Nintedanib reduced annual FVC decline in progressive ILD including SSc (Fishman, p.1030) |
| SENSCIS | Nintedanib vs placebo (SSc-ILD specifically) | Nintedanib significantly slowed FVC decline in SSc-ILD |
Drug Dosing (Murray & Nadel treatment table)
| Drug | Dose | Notes |
|---|
| Mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) | 1-3 g/day continuous | Currently favored first-line; usually with low-dose prednisolone |
| Cyclophosphamide oral | 2 mg/kg/day | Can substitute MMF at 3 months |
| Cyclophosphamide IV pulse | 15 mg/kg/month | Induction; better adverse effect profile than oral |
| Azathioprine | 2.5 mg/kg/day (max 200 mg/day) | Maintenance; effect seen at 6-9 months |
| Prednisolone | Low dose (≤10 mg/day) + immunosuppressant | High-dose steroids risk renal crisis in SSc |
| Methylprednisolone IV | 500-1000 mg x 3-5 days | Acute exacerbations, pneumonitis, vasculitis |
| Rituximab (anti-CD20) | 1g IV induction + maintenance | Rapidly progressive/resistant disease; small RCT showed benefit (Fishman) |
| Nintedanib | 150 mg BD | Progressive fibrosing phenotype; antifibrotic |
| Cyclosporin A | 5 mg/kg/day | Blood level + renal monitoring; used with prednisolone |
| Methotrexate | 7.5-25 mg/week | Limited evidence; pulmonary toxicity limits use |
Important Caveats
- High-dose steroids must be avoided in SSc due to risk of precipitating scleroderma renal crisis
- OP in SSc: responds well to corticosteroids
- Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT): ASTIS and SCOT trials demonstrated survival benefit in severe progressive dcSSc-ILD vs pulse CYC in selected patients
11. Other Pulmonary Complications
- Pleural disease: Fibrosis/adhesions in 40% at autopsy; clinically apparent effusions uncommon; usually secondary to cor pulmonale or cardiomyopathy
- Aspiration pneumonia: Classical aspiration uncommon despite near-universal esophageal dysmotility; microaspiration as cofactor in ILD progression - uncertain
- Chest wall restriction: Skin tightness rarely causes extrinsic ventilatory limitation
- Scar carcinoma: SSc was the first ILD in which scar carcinoma (adenocarcinoma/alveolar cell carcinoma) was reported; increased incidence of lung cancer in SSc (Fishman, p.1030)
12. Prognosis
- ILD + PAH = two leading causes of death in SSc
- SSc-ILD generally better prognosis than IPF for equivalent histologic pattern
- Histologic pattern (NSIP vs UIP) does NOT predict prognosis in SSc (unlike idiopathic disease)
- Progressive FVC decline = strongest predictor of mortality
- Annual echocardiography screening for PAH is recommended in all SSc patients
Quick Revision Table
| Feature | SSc-ILD |
|---|
| Most common histology | NSIP |
| HRCT hallmark | Peripheral basal GGO + reticulation + traction bronchiectasis |
| CT clue specific to SSc | Dilated esophagus |
| PFT pattern | Restrictive + reduced DLCO |
| Earliest PFT abnormality | Reduced DLCO |
| Clubbing | Unusual (capillary destruction) |
| Antibody linked to ILD | Anti-Scl-70 |
| Best-tolerated first-line drug | MMF (SLS II) |
| Antifibrotic approved | Nintedanib (SENSCIS + INBUILD) |
| BAL role | Not routinely recommended |
| Biopsy role | Virtually never required |
| Steroid to avoid | High-dose (renal crisis risk) |
| Unique oncologic feature | First ILD with scar carcinoma |