I now have sufficient information from authoritative neurology textbooks. Here is the full structured answer:
Differential Diagnosis: Acute Onset Left Lower + Upper Limb Weakness (Left Hemiparesis/Hemiplegia)
Weakness affecting the left arm AND left leg simultaneously = left-sided hemiparesis/hemiplegia. This pattern nearly always reflects a right-sided upper motor neuron (UMN) lesion above the midcervical spinal cord (most lesions are above the foramen magnum). Rare exception: a high left cervical cord lesion before the decussation can mimic this if combined with ipsilateral signs.
Localization First
The pattern of associated deficits helps localize the lesion before listing causes:
| Location | Left Hemi + What Else? |
|---|
| Right cerebral cortex | Aphasia (dominant) or neglect (non-dominant), focal arm > leg or vice versa |
| Right internal capsule / cerebral peduncle / upper pons | "Pure motor" hemiplegia - equal arm + leg + face involvement, no cortical signs |
| Brainstem (right side) | "Crossed" signs: right cranial nerve palsy (e.g. diplopia, facial droop) + LEFT hemiplegia |
| High cervical cord (C1-C4) | Bilateral deficits often, no cranial nerve signs, pain/temperature loss on opposite side (Brown-Sequard), usually PAINFUL |
- Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine 22E, Distribution of Weakness
- Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice, Focal Weakness of Central Origin
Differential Diagnosis by Priority
1. Vascular (Most Common - Acute Onset)
| Condition | Key Features |
|---|
| Ischemic stroke (MCA, lacunar) | Abrupt onset (seconds-minutes), no headache typically, maximally severe at onset or stuttering, DWI bright on MRI within 30 min |
| Intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) | Abrupt onset, often with headache, vomiting, elevated BP, may progress rapidly |
| Subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) | "Thunderclap" worst headache of life, may have focal deficits if hematoma or vasospasm occurs |
| TIA | Full recovery within 24 h (classically minutes to 1 h); DWI may be normal; high early stroke risk |
| Cerebral venous sinus thrombosis (CVST) | Headache + seizures + focal deficits; risk factors: OCP, pregnancy, dehydration, thrombophilia |
| Arterial dissection (carotid/vertebral) | Neck pain or Horner's syndrome; young patient; post-trauma or spontaneous |
- Adams and Victor's Principles of Neurology 12E, Differentiation of Stroke from Other Neurologic Illnesses
2. Epileptic (Acute, Often Transient)
| Condition | Key Features |
|---|
| Todd's (postictal) paralysis | Contralateral weakness after a focal/generalized seizure; lasts minutes to up to 36 h (median ~15 h); history of a seizure is key; EEG may show slow waves |
| Ictal paralysis | Weakness during the seizure discharge itself; rare, mainly children; EEG during episode is diagnostic |
- Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice, Todd Paralysis
3. Structural (Subacute to Acute)
| Condition | Key Features |
|---|
| Brain tumor (primary or metastatic) | Rapidly growing GBM, lymphoma, or metastasis can cause hemiplegia at "stroke-like pace"; may have preceding TIA-like episodes; contrast MRI shows ring-enhancing/mass lesion |
| Brain abscess | Fever + headache + focal deficit; risk factors: immunosuppression, infective endocarditis, dental procedures; ring-enhancing lesion with restricted diffusion |
| Subdural hematoma (SDH) | Can be acute (post-trauma) or chronic (elderly, anticoagulated); fluctuating consciousness, headache, lucid interval (epidural) |
| Epidural hematoma (EDH) | Post-trauma, lucid interval then rapid deterioration, uncal herniation |
| Herpes encephalitis / toxoplasmosis | Fever, temporal lobe involvement, immunocompromised (toxo); rapid progression |
- Adams and Victor's Principles of Neurology 12E
4. Demyelinating
| Condition | Key Features |
|---|
| Multiple sclerosis (MS) | Age 20-40, relapsing-remitting, MRI white matter lesions (periventricular, juxtacortical), CSF oligoclonal bands, optic neuritis history |
| Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) | Post-infectious or post-vaccination; children > adults; multifocal; encephalopathy |
| Neuromyelitis optica (NMOSD) | Optic neuritis + spinal cord or brain involvement; anti-AQP4 antibodies |
5. Metabolic / Toxic (Stroke Mimics)
| Condition | Key Features |
|---|
| Hypoglycemia | Any focal deficit can occur; correct glucose immediately and recheck |
| Hyperglycemic hyperosmolar state | Focal deficits, seizures; BS often >600 mg/dL |
| Hyponatremia / Wernicke's encephalopathy | Altered sensorium + focal deficits |
| Hepatic encephalopathy | Asterixis, confusion, focal deficits |
6. Migraine (Hemiplegic Migraine)
- Weakness "marches" progressively from one region to another (spreading cortical depression pattern - e.g., hand → arm → face)
- Usually precedes or accompanies headache
- Seldom complete hemiplegia
- Family history in familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM)
- Diagnosis of exclusion - must rule out stroke
- Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice, Table 26.6
7. High Cervical Cord Lesion (Rare for Pure Hemiplegia)
- Typically bilateral (quadriparesis/paraparesis)
- Pure unilateral left hemi pattern uncommon from cord alone
- Brown-Sequard syndrome: ipsilateral weakness + position/vibration loss + CONTRALATERAL pain/temperature loss
- Causes: trauma, MS transverse myelitis, cervical cord compression, epidural abscess/hematoma
Clinical Decision-Making Summary
ACUTE LEFT HEMI → THINK STROKE FIRST
├── Headache at onset → ICH / SAH / CVST / dissection
├── Post-seizure state → Todd's paralysis
├── Fever + immunocompromised → Abscess / toxoplasmosis / encephalitis
├── Trauma → SDH / EDH
├── Young woman, OCP → CVST
├── Neck pain + Horner → Carotid dissection
├── Progressive march of deficit → Migraine (but exclude stroke)
└── "Marching" + white matter on MRI → MS / ADEM
Immediate Investigation Priorities
- Blood glucose - exclude hypoglycemia immediately
- Non-contrast CT brain - exclude hemorrhage, mass, herniation
- MRI brain with DWI - most sensitive for ischemic stroke within minutes, demyelination, abscess
- MRI/MRA - vascular assessment (carotid dissection, stenosis, venous thrombosis)
- ECG + cardiac monitoring - cardioembolic source
- CBC, coagulation, metabolic panel - electrolytes, glucose, renal, liver function
- EEG - if Todd's paralysis or seizure disorder suspected
- LP - if SAH suspected and CT is negative
Bottom line: In any adult with acute left hemi, ischemic stroke must be ruled out first with urgent CT/MRI - the 4.5-hour thrombolysis window is time-critical. Do not delay imaging for an elaborate history. - Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine 22E; Adams and Victor's Neurology 12E; Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice