I now have comprehensive content from both textbooks. Let me compile the full answer.
Hip Dislocation - Answers from Tintinalli's and Rosen's Emergency Medicine
Question 1(a): Classification and Clinical Features of Hip Dislocation (5 Marks)
Classification
Based on the relationship of the femoral head to the acetabulum, hip dislocations are classified into the following types:
1. Posterior Dislocation
- Most common type, accounting for 80-90% of all hip dislocations (Rosen's) / >90% (Tintinalli's)
- Results from high-energy trauma - classically a "dashboard injury" where a seated occupant's knee strikes the dashboard, transmitting force through the femoral shaft posteriorly
- The femoral head is forced out through a posterior capsular tear
- May be associated with acetabular rim fractures (fracture-dislocation)
2. Anterior Dislocation
- Accounts for 10-15% of dislocations
- Results from forceful extension, abduction, and external rotation, levering the femoral head out anteriorly
- Further subdivided into:
- Superior (Pubic/Iliac) type - hip is in extension and mild abduction at time of injury; femoral head lies near the pubis or iliac crest
- Inferior (Obturator) type - hip is in flexion and abduction; femoral head lies near the obturator foramen
- Associated with femoral artery or femoral nerve injury (less common than sciatic nerve injury in posterior dislocations)
3. Central Dislocation
- Accounts for 2-4% of cases
- Not a true dislocation - the entire femoral head is forced centrally through a comminuted fracture of the acetabulum
- High-energy axial load injury
4. Inferior Dislocation (Luxatio Erecta Femoris)
- Very rare
- Occurs with or without associated trochanteric fracture
- Involves inversion of the femoral shaft
Rosen's Emergency Medicine, p.699-700
A fracture-dislocation involves an associated fracture of the acetabulum or femoral head, and is seen in up to 70% of hip dislocations per Rosen's.
Clinical Features
Posterior Dislocation:
- Extremity is shortened, adducted, and internally rotated - this is the classic triad
- The knee of the affected limb rests on the opposite thigh
- The greater trochanter and buttock may be unusually prominent
- Differentiating feature from femoral neck fracture: femoral neck fractures present with external rotation, whereas posterior dislocation presents with internal rotation
- Sciatic nerve injury is present in approximately 10% of cases - must carefully assess motor and sensory function in the sciatic distribution (dorsiflexion, eversion, plantar sensation)
- Palpable femoral head posteriorly on the buttock
Anterior Dislocation:
- Extremity is in abduction and external rotation (opposite of posterior dislocation)
- Superior type: hip extended, extremity in external rotation
- Inferior type: hip and knee flexed, thigh held in extreme abduction - appears as if the extremity is pointing toward the ceiling
- Femoral artery and femoral nerve at risk - check femoral pulse and sensation of anterior thigh/medial leg
General Features (All Types):
- Severe hip pain with inability to bear weight
- Limb deformity and shortening (except in some anterior types)
- History of high-energy trauma (MVC is most common mechanism)
- Up to 95% of patients with native hip dislocations have other associated injuries (Tintinalli's)
- Up to 30% have associated knee ligamentous injuries or fractures (Rosen's)
- Up to 50% of children have fractures elsewhere (Rosen's)
Radiological Features:
- AP and lateral pelvis X-ray: posterior dislocation shows loss of the lesser trochanter on AP view; the femoral head appears smaller (farther from detector) and above/posterior to the acetabulum
- Disruption of Shenton's line (smooth curved line along the superior border of obturator foramen and medial femoral metaphysis) suggests dislocation or femoral neck fracture
- CT scan is mandatory after identification to evaluate acetabulum and femoral head for associated fractures
Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine, p.1887-1890; Rosen's Emergency Medicine, p.699-701
Question 1(b): Reduction Techniques in Posterior Hip Dislocation (5 Marks)
Both Tintinalli's and Rosen's emphasize that posterior hip dislocation is an orthopedic emergency. Reduction should occur within 6 hours of injury. Risk of avascular necrosis (AVN) increases from <10% to nearly 25% when delay extends from 10 to 15 hours (Tintinalli's). AVN is reported in up to 15% of all dislocations (Rosen's).
Prerequisites before reduction:
- Rule out ipsilateral femoral neck fracture on X-ray (traction maneuvers in femoral neck fracture can cause displacement)
- IV procedural sedation and analgesia
- Pelvic stabilization with an assistant
- Multiple attempts should be avoided if unsuccessful - early orthopaedic consultation required
Important principle: Nearly all techniques involve in-line traction with hip flexed to 90 degrees and hip adducted. Be gentle, not forceful with rotation - the posteriorly dislocated hip is locked in internal rotation, and aggressive rotation can cause a spiral femoral shaft fracture, especially in osteoporotic bone.
Technique 1: Allis Maneuver (Most Common)
(Described in both Tintinalli's and Rosen's as the most commonly used method)
Steps (Rosen's/Tintinalli's):
- Place the patient supine on a backboard on the floor (preferred over standing on a stretcher - reduces clinician back injury risk per Rosen's)
- Secure the pelvis to the stretcher with a sheet or strap over the ischial wings and pubic symphysis - an assistant stabilizes the pelvis by applying downward pressure on the anterior superior iliac spines (ASIS)
- Stand astride the patient or beside the bed (if patient is on stretcher)
- Flex the patient's hip and knee to 90 degrees
- Apply steady in-line traction upward toward the ceiling (in the direction of the deformity), then slightly toward the contralateral side - this achieves the required flexion and adduction
- Apply gentle internal rotation if needed while under traction
- The assistant may push the greater trochanter forward toward the acetabulum
- Once reduction is achieved (felt as a "clunk"), bring the hip to the extended position while maintaining traction
Caution: Aggressive rotation risks spiral femoral fracture.
Tintinalli's, p.1888; Rosen's, p.700, Fig. 47.25
Technique 2: Stimson (Gravity) Technique
(Described in both Rosen's and Tintinalli's - relatively atraumatic; uses gravity as the reduction force)
Steps:
- Place the patient prone (face down) on the stretcher
- The affected leg hangs over the edge of the bed, with hip and knee flexed at 90 degrees
- An assistant stabilizes the pelvis against the stretcher
- The physician applies gentle downward pressure on the popliteal fossa (behind the knee) - this leverages the femoral head anteriorly back into the acetabulum
- Gentle rotation of the leg may assist reduction
Advantage: Atraumatic, uses gravity; minimal force needed.
Disadvantage: Requires prone positioning, which may be difficult in multi-trauma patients with spinal precautions.
Rosen's Emergency Medicine, p.701, Fig. 47.26
Technique 3: Bigelow Maneuver
(Described in Tintinalli's)
Steps:
- Patient is supine, hip and knee flexed to 90 degrees
- The physician secures the patient's knee with the flexed elbow, and grasps the patient's foot with the opposite hand
- An assistant applies downward pressure on the ASIS to stabilize the pelvis
- Using the flexed elbow under the knee, lift upward (apply traction to the femur at the knee)
- While applying traction, gently externally rotate and extend the hip
- Reduction is confirmed by a palpable/audible clunk
Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine, p.1888, Fig. 273-9
Technique 4: Captain Morgan Technique
(Described in both Tintinalli's and Rosen's)
Steps:
- Patient is supine on the stretcher in its lowest position
- Secure the pelvis to the stretcher with a sheet or strap
- The physician places their knee under the patient's popliteal fossa (physician's knee acts as a fulcrum)
- Flex both the patient's hip and knee to 90 degrees by resting the leg on the physician's thigh
- The physician then plantar-flexes their own foot, raising the heel - this elevates the patient's leg, applying upward traction through the femur
- Simultaneous gentle internal and external rotation of the limb assists reduction
Advantage: Reduces lower back strain on the physician; does not require the physician to stand on the stretcher.
Tintinalli's, p.1888, Fig. 273-11; Rosen's, p.701, Fig. 47.27
Technique 5: Whistler Technique
(Described in Rosen's)
Steps (Rosen's, Fig. 47.28):
- Patient is supine
- The physician flexes the patient's knee and slides their arm under the popliteal fossa
- The physician's hand grasps the patient's wrist of the same side
- Upward traction is then applied by lifting through the arm - the physician's forearm acts as a lever under the knee
- Gentle rotation aids reduction
Advantage: Single-operator technique possible; ergonomically less stressful.
Rosen's Emergency Medicine, p.701, Fig. 47.28
Post-Reduction Care
- Immediately reassess neurovascular status (sciatic nerve function)
- Gently range the hip
- Confirm reduction with post-reduction imaging (X-ray and CT)
- Immobilization: Abduction pillow (extension + abduction position prevents re-dislocation since flexion + adduction cause it) OR knee immobilizer
- Most patients require hospital admission due to associated injuries from high-energy trauma
- Orthopedic consultation required if:
- Reduction unsuccessful after several attempts
- Irreducible fracture
- Complex fracture-dislocation
Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine, p.1889; Rosen's Emergency Medicine, p.701
Summary Table: Reduction Techniques
| Technique | Patient Position | Key Action | Special Feature |
|---|
| Allis | Supine / floor | In-line traction at 90° flex + adduction | Most commonly used |
| Stimson | Prone, leg hanging | Gravity + gentle knee pressure | Atraumatic; needs prone position |
| Bigelow | Supine | Elbow under knee, lift + ext. rotate | Circumduction arc of motion |
| Captain Morgan | Supine | Physician's knee as fulcrum | Ergonomic; reduces physician strain |
| Whistler | Supine | Forearm lever under knee | Single-operator possible |