| Category | Quantitative haemoglobinopathy (↓ globin synthesis) | Qualitative haemoglobinopathy (structurally abnormal Hb) |
| Mutation | Multiple mutations in β-globin gene (splicing, promoter, chain terminator) | Single missense point mutation: Glu→Val at codon 6 of β-globin gene |
| Abnormal protein | No structural abnormality in globin; simply ↓ β-chain production | HbS (α₂β²ˢ) - valine substitution gives hydrophobic patch on deoxyHbS |
| Pathogenic mechanism | Unpaired α-chains precipitate → membrane damage → ineffective erythropoiesis + haemolysis | HbS polymerises when deoxygenated → sickling → haemolysis + microvascular occlusion |
| Primary problem | Ineffective erythropoiesis (most precursors die in marrow) + haemolysis | Haemolysis + vascular occlusion |
| Type of haemolysis | Predominantly intravascular destruction of precursors + extravascular haemolysis | Primarily extravascular (spleen, liver); also intravascular due to fragile sickled cells |
| Blood smear | Hypochromic, microcytic cells; target cells, poikilocytes, anisocytes, nucleated RBCs, basophilic stippling | Sickle cells (irreversibly sickled cells), target cells, Howell-Jolly bodies, reticulocytosis |
| HbA | Absent (β⁰/β⁰) or markedly reduced | Absent (replaced entirely by HbS in homozygotes) |
| HbF | Markedly elevated (compensatory) | Normally low after 6 months; if elevated, disease is milder |
| HbA₂ | Elevated (β-thal minor/trait) | Normal |
| Anaemia severity | Severe (Hb 3-6 g/dL in untransfused β-thal major) | Moderate (haematocrit 18%-30%) |
| Spleen | Enlarged (extramedullary haematopoiesis) - splenomegaly throughout life | Enlarged in infancy (sickled cells trapped) → progressive infarction → autosplenectomy by adolescence (tiny fibrotic remnant) |
| Bone marrow | Massive erythroid hyperplasia, bony cortex erosion | Erythroid hyperplasia; "crew-cut" skull on X-ray |
| Skeletal changes | Prominent: frontal bossing, maxillary hypertrophy, "crew-cut" skull | Present but less pronounced |
| Iron overload | Major complication - from gut absorption (erythroferrone ↑ hepcidin suppression) + transfusions → secondary haemochromatosis, cardiac/hepatic injury | Less prominent unless heavily transfused |
| Vascular occlusion | NOT a feature | Cardinal feature - bone pain crises, stroke, acute chest syndrome, renal infarcts, leg ulcers, retinal infarcts |
| Painful crises | Absent | Present - the hallmark; triggered by hypoxia, dehydration, infection, cold |
| Infections | Increased (due to splenomegaly-related immune dysfunction; also transfusion risks) | Greatly increased due to autosplenectomy; especially encapsulated organisms (Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae) |
| Gallstones | Pigment gallstones (from chronic haemolysis) | Pigment gallstones (from chronic haemolysis) - both share this |
| Malaria protection | Heterozygous carriers (thalassaemia trait) have some protection | Heterozygous HbS carriers (sickle cell trait) protected against P. falciparum malaria |
| Treatment | Transfusions + iron chelation; hydroxyurea; stem cell transplant; gene therapy | Hydroxyurea (↑ HbF); transfusions for crises; stem cell transplant; analgesics |
| Prognosis | Untreated β-thal major: death in 1st or 2nd decade from iron overload | Untreated: median survival ~40-50 years; modern treatment improves this |