I have everything needed for a thorough, well-structured explanation. Let me compile the answer now.
Diplopia (Double Vision) - A Complete Explanation
What is Diplopia?
Diplopia is the perception of two images of a single object simultaneously - in simple terms, seeing double. It occurs when the visual axes of the two eyes are misaligned so that the same object projects its image onto non-corresponding points on the two retinas, causing the brain to perceive two separate images.
As Adams and Victor's Neurology states: "The term binocular diplopia refers to the symptom of double vision caused by a misalignment of the visual axes of the two eyes. It is only present when both eyes are open and can see. Covering one eye obliterates double vision that stems from misalignment of the eyes."
The Two Fundamental Types
The most important first step in any patient with diplopia is to ask: "Does the double vision go away when you close either eye?"
1. Monocular Diplopia
- Definition: Double vision that persists even when one eye is closed - the affected eye alone sees two images
- Cause: A problem intrinsic to the eye itself, not an alignment problem
- Common causes:
- Corneal irregularities (keratoconus, pterygium, astigmatism)
- Cataract (lens opacities split the image)
- Uncorrected refractive error
- Foveal traction or retinal disease
- Occasionally: malingering or psychiatric/functional disorder
- Key point: Monocular diplopia is almost never a neurological emergency. It is a local ocular problem.
2. Binocular Diplopia
- Definition: Double vision that is present only with both eyes open and disappears immediately when either eye is covered
- Cause: Misalignment of the visual axes (ocular motor problem)
- Key point: Binocular diplopia always demands investigation - it can signal serious neurological, vascular, or systemic disease
Heteronymous (crossed) diplopia in right exotropia - Kanski's Clinical Ophthalmology, 10th ed.
Classification of Binocular Diplopia
A. By Direction of Image Separation
| Type | Description | Seen In |
|---|
| Horizontal diplopia | Two images side by side | Esotropia, exotropia (CN VI or medial rectus palsy) |
| Vertical diplopia | One image above the other | Hypertropia, CN IV palsy, skew deviation |
| Torsional (oblique) diplopia | Images tilted relative to each other | CN IV palsy (trochlear nerve), oblique muscle problems |
| Mixed | Combination of horizontal + vertical | CN III palsy, orbital disease |
B. By Position of the False Image
| Type | Squint Present | Image Position |
|---|
| Homonymous (uncrossed) diplopia | Esotropia (eye turns in) | False image is on the same side as the squinting eye |
| Heteronymous (crossed) diplopia | Exotropia (eye turns out) | False image is on the opposite side to the squinting eye |
Memory trick: In esotropia (inward turn), the deviating eye's image is projected outward - so it appears on the same side. In exotropia (outward turn), the image is projected inward - appearing on the opposite side.
C. By Cause (Most Clinically Important Classification)
1. Neurogenic Diplopia (Cranial Nerve Palsies)
The most common cause of binocular diplopia requiring urgent workup.
| Nerve | Muscle Affected | Pattern of Diplopia | Other Signs |
|---|
| CN III (Oculomotor) | All except LR and SO | Diplopia in all directions except lateral gaze to same side; eye is "down and out" | Ptosis, dilated pupil (if compressive) |
| CN IV (Trochlear) | Superior oblique | Vertical + torsional diplopia; worse on looking down and inward | Head tilt away from affected side (compensatory) |
| CN VI (Abducens) | Lateral rectus | Horizontal diplopia; worse on looking to the affected side; esotropia | Most common isolated cranial nerve palsy |
2. Neuromuscular Junction Diplopia
- Myasthenia Gravis - the classic cause of painless, variable, fatigable diplopia. Not confined to a single nerve distribution. Pupils always normal. Worsens with sustained activity, improves with rest.
- Botulism - can mimic ocular myasthenia
3. Restrictive (Mechanical) Diplopia
Caused by physical restriction of globe movement, not nerve weakness:
- Thyroid eye disease (Graves') - fibrosis of inferior and medial recti; commonest cause is restriction of elevation (inferior rectus fibrosis)
- Orbital blowout fracture - inferior rectus or inferior oblique entrapment; vertical diplopia with upward gaze limitation
- Orbital pseudotumor / myositis - painful diplopia with proptosis
- Orbital tumors / abscesses
4. Supranuclear / Central Diplopia
Problems in the brainstem pathways:
- Internuclear ophthalmoplegia (INO) - lesion of the medial longitudinal fasciculus (MLF); impaired adduction of one eye with nystagmus in the abducting eye; classic in multiple sclerosis
- Skew deviation - vertical misalignment from brainstem or cerebellar lesions
- Alcohol or anticonvulsant toxicity - can cause transient diplopia by disrupting conjugate gaze
Key Clinical Assessment
Step 1 - Cover Test
Cover one eye: if diplopia disappears = binocular. If persists = monocular.
Step 2 - Direction of maximum diplopia
Ask: "In which direction of gaze is the double vision worst?" The weak muscle acts in the direction where the gap between images is greatest.
Step 3 - Identifying the false image
The image furthest from the midline (most peripheral) always belongs to the abnormal eye. As Neuroanatomy through Clinical Cases explains: "When an extraocular muscle is not working properly, the image further from the midline toward the direction of attempted gaze is always the one seen by the abnormal eye."
Step 4 - Red Glass Test
A red glass is placed over one eye (usually right). The patient looks at a white light and reports the position of the red vs. white images in 9 positions of gaze. This helps identify which muscle is weak.
Step 5 - Head posture
Patients often adopt a compensatory head posture to minimize diplopia (e.g., head tilt in CN IV palsy, face turn in CN VI palsy).
Quick Summary Diagram
DIPLOPIA (Double Vision)
│
├── MONOCULAR (one eye closed = still double)
│ └── Cause: cornea, lens, retina, refractive error
│ → NOT a neurological emergency
│
└── BINOCULAR (one eye closed = resolves)
└── Cause: ocular misalignment
│
├── By direction: Horizontal / Vertical / Torsional / Mixed
│
├── By image position: Homonymous / Heteronymous
│
└── By cause:
├── Neurogenic (CN III, IV, VI palsy)
├── Neuromuscular (Myasthenia gravis, Botulism)
├── Restrictive (Thyroid, Fracture, Tumor)
└── Central (INO, skew deviation, toxins)
Clinical pearl from Harrison's: "The first point to clarify is whether diplopia persists in either eye after the opposite eye is covered. If it does, the diagnosis is monocular diplopia... Diplopia alleviated by covering one eye is binocular diplopia and is caused by disruption of ocular alignment."
Sources: Adams and Victor's Principles of Neurology, 12th ed.; Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine, 22nd ed.; Kanski's Clinical Ophthalmology, 10th ed.; Rosen's Emergency Medicine; Neuroanatomy through Clinical Cases, 3rd ed.