I now have enough high-quality data to write a comprehensive, strongly evidence-based answer. Let me compile it.
-
Men: 5% topical solution or foam, applied twice daily
-
Women: 2% topical solution (or 5% foam once daily)
-
Mechanism: Prolongs the anagen (growth) phase, increases dermal papilla cell proliferation, increases hair caliber, and decreases follicular apoptosis. The active metabolite is minoxidil sulfate, produced by follicular sulfotransferase - individuals with low sulfotransferase activity may respond poorly.
-
Evidence: Randomized controlled trials show increased hair density and thickness. Effects begin at 3-6 months and require continuous use; stopping causes acute telogen efflux 3-4 months later.
-
Caution: Avoid in pregnancy and breastfeeding. Propylene glycol in older liquid formulations causes dermatitis in some users (foam formulation avoids this).
-
Goldman-Cecil Medicine, p. 4334 | Dermatology 2-Volume Set 5e
-
Mechanism: Selectively inhibits Type II 5α-reductase, blocking conversion of testosterone to dihydrotestosterone (DHT) in hair follicles. DHT is the key androgen that miniaturizes genetically susceptible follicles.
-
Evidence: In a pivotal RCT of 1,553 men, finasteride significantly increased vertex hair counts vs. placebo at 1 year. 5-year data showed hair counts remained well above baseline in 90% of patients. Stabilized hair loss in 51% and produced regrowth in 48%. Hair growth peaks at 1-2 years.
-
Works best in men with high DHT levels (e.g., mid-twenties). Also benefits frontal scalp, not just vertex.
-
Side effects: Decreased libido (1.9%), erectile dysfunction (1.4%), decreased ejaculate (1.0%) - all resolve on drug cessation in most men. Rare: post-finasteride syndrome (persistent symptoms after stopping) - controversial but recognized.
-
Key interactions: Lowers PSA by ~50% (inform urologist). Teratogenic to male fetuses - women must not handle crushed tablets.
-
Topical finasteride spray is now available and as effective as oral, with less systemic DHT suppression.
-
Cummings Otolaryngology, p. 2141 | Dermatology 2-Volume Set 5e |
Rosenthal et al., 2024 (Systematic Review)
-
Inhibits both Type I and II 5α-reductase (finasteride only inhibits Type II), so it is a stronger DHT suppressor.
-
More effective than finasteride with a comparable safety profile.
-
FDA-approved for benign prostatic hyperplasia; approved for AGA in South Korea and Japan; used off-label in many countries.
-
A systematic review (141 studies) confirmed its superiority over finasteride for hair counts.
-
Goldman-Cecil Medicine, p. 4334 |
Rosenthal et al., 2024
-
A major trend supported by robust data. Doses far lower than the antihypertensive dose (10-40 mg) are effective.
-
Works systemically to stimulate hair growth; multiple studies confirm safety and efficacy in both men and women.
-
Men: 2.5 mg/day; Women: 0.625-1.25 mg/day (lower doses to reduce hypertrichosis risk)
-
Side effects: unwanted facial hair (most common), ankle edema, headache, rare cardiovascular effects.
-
Convenient (once-daily pill vs. twice-daily topical) - improving adherence.
-
Dermatology 2-Volume Set 5e | Goldman-Cecil Medicine, p. 4334
-
Gold standard surgical option for androgenetic alopecia with adequate donor hair.
-
Follicular Unit Extraction (FUE) and strip harvesting (FUT) both produce natural-appearing results.
-
Based on the principle of donor dominance - transplanted hairs retain their donor-site genetic characteristics and resist DHT.
-
Combining finasteride 1 mg/day with transplantation produces significantly greater hair counts at 48 weeks post-surgery vs. transplantation alone.
-
Best for men with stabilized, moderate-to-severe AGA; more complex in women due to diffuse thinning pattern.
-
Cummings Otolaryngology, p. 1963-1975
-
Autologous blood is centrifuged to concentrate platelets, then injected into the scalp.
-
Growth factors released (PDGF, TGF-β, VEGF, EGF, IGF) are thought to stimulate follicular regeneration.
-
Systematic review evidence (2024) shows hair growth benefit, but results are mixed and protocols vary widely (concentration, frequency, activation method).
-
Generally used as an adjunct - particularly alongside hair transplantation to improve graft survival and density.
-
No large standardized RCTs yet; evidence quality is moderate. Best considered a supplement to first-line treatments.
-
Cummings Otolaryngology, p. 2153 | Dermatology 2-Volume Set 5e