---

Medical Negligence - Complete Notes

---

1. What is Professional Negligence?

---

2. Types of Civil Negligence

• When a patient or their relatives file a case in civil court asking for money (compensation) because the doctor's wrong treatment caused them suffering, harm, damage, or death.
• When a doctor sues a patient who refuses to pay fees and the patient claims the treatment was negligent.

• When the negligence is so serious (gross/extreme) that it becomes a criminal offense.
• The state (government) files the case, not just the patient.

---

3. Civil Negligence vs. Criminal Negligence (Key Differences)

---

4. Elements of Negligence (The "4 Ds")

1. Duty - The doctor had a duty of care towards the patient (doctor-patient relationship existed).
2. Dereliction (Breach of Duty) - The doctor failed to meet the expected standard of care.
3. Direct cause (Causation) - The breach directly caused harm to the patient.
4. Damage - The patient actually suffered an injury, loss, or death.

---

5. Important Doctrines in Medical Negligence

a) Res Ipsa Loquitur ("The thing speaks for itself")

• Used when the negligence is so obvious that no expert is needed to explain it.
• Example: A surgeon leaves a surgical sponge inside the patient's abdomen.
• The patient does NOT need to prove how it happened - the injury itself proves negligence.

b) Calculated Risk Doctrine

• Res ipsa loquitur should NOT be applied if the injury could happen even with the best possible care.
• A doctor must prove that the treatment used had known unavoidable risks.
• Example: A patient dies during coronary bypass surgery - there is an inherent 2-5% risk with this procedure, so death alone does not prove negligence.
• This is an important defense for doctors.

c) Doctrine of Common Knowledge

• When the negligence involves basic common knowledge, NOT specialized medical knowledge.
• It is a variant of res ipsa loquitur.
• Experts cannot give evidence regarding matters of common knowledge.
• Example: Operating on the wrong limb.
• The patient must prove the act of commission or omission, but does NOT need to prove the standard of care separately.

d) Contributory Negligence

• Definition: When the patient or their attendant also acted unreasonably, and this contributed to the harm.
• Example: Patient did not give proper history, did not follow the doctor's instructions about diet or medicines.
• This is a good defense for doctors in civil cases (but NOT in criminal cases).
• If proven, damages awarded by the court may be reduced.

1. Last Clear Chance Doctrine - Even if the patient was negligent, if the doctor had the last opportunity to avoid the harm and did not take it, the doctor is still liable.
   • Example: Patient gets visual disturbance (side effect of a drug) at a follow-up visit, but the doctor ignores it. The patient then goes blind. The plea of contributory negligence fails because the doctor had the last chance to prevent the blindness.
2. Doctrine of Avoidable Consequences - After being injured, the patient must take reasonable steps to reduce further harm. If a patient unreasonably refuses medical care after injury and the condition worsens, the doctor is not responsible for the extra damage that could have been avoided.

---

6. Doctor-Patient Relationship

• A legal duty of care arises as soon as a doctor-patient relationship is established.
• This relationship creates the "Duty" element in negligence.
• Negligence consists of two acts:
  • Act of omission - NOT doing something (e.g., failing to prescribe the right medicine)
  • Act of commission - Doing something wrong (e.g., operating on the wrong site)

---

7. Consent

Definition

Types of Consent

• When a patient walks into a doctor's clinic, it is automatically assumed they agree to be examined.
• This only covers basic examination (inspection, palpation, percussion, auscultation).
• For more complex procedures (rectal/vaginal examination, blood withdrawal), expressed consent must be taken.

• Oral/Verbal consent: For minor examinations or therapeutic procedures, preferably in front of a witness (nurse or attendant).
• Written consent: Must be obtained for:
  • All minor and major diagnostic procedures
  • General anesthesia
  • Operations

Doctrine of Informed Consent

1. Their condition or diagnosis
2. Why further tests or treatment are needed
3. Natural course of the disease and possible complications
4. Nature of the proposed procedure/treatment
5. Risks and benefits of the treatment
6. Risks and benefits of alternative treatments
7. What happens if nothing is done (prognosis without treatment)
8. Approximate cost and duration of treatment
9. Expected outcome and follow-up

Important: There is NO need to explain very remote/theoretical risks that may only frighten the patient unnecessarily. The standard is what a reasonable physician would tell a reasonable patient.

Rules of Consent

• Consent must be free, voluntary, clear, intelligent, informed, direct, and personal.
• No undue influence, fraud, or coercion.
• Written consent for any surgical/diagnostic procedure provides evidence if disputed in court.
• Should be witnessed by another person.
• Video recording of consent has been proposed for clinical trials.

To Examine/Treat Without Consent is:

Consenting Ages (India)

Exceptions to Informed Consent (When consent is not required)

1. Emergencies - When life is in immediate danger and the patient is unconscious with no guardian available. Law presumes consent (Implied consent, Sec. 30 BNS / 92 IPC).
2. Medical examination by police order - (Sec. 51(1) BNSS / 53(1) CrPC)
3. Therapeutic privilege - When telling the patient the full truth (e.g., terminal diagnosis) would cause them serious harm/distress. The doctor may withhold information but must inform a responsible relative.
4. Therapeutic waiver - A competent patient who knows they are entitled to informed consent can voluntarily waive this right.
5. Placebos - In self-limiting conditions or high psychological dependency cases.
6. Prisoners - Can be treated without consent in the interest of society.
7. Psychiatric examination by court order
8. Medico-legal postmortems
9. Notifiable diseases - For community interest.

Special Consent Rules

• Insane or intoxicated persons: Their consent is invalid (Sec. 28 BNS / 90 IPC).
• Spouse's consent: Not required for the other partner's treatment. However, it is desirable (but not legally required) for: abortion, sterilization, and operations affecting sexual life.
• Sexual assault victims: Cannot be examined without their written consent.
• Accused females: Must be examined only by or under supervision of a female medical practitioner (Sec. 51(2) BNSS / 53(2) CrPC).
• Consent for diagnostic procedure ≠ consent for treatment. A doctor cannot use consent for one procedure to justify an entirely different procedure.
• Emergency exception: Unauthorized additional surgery is only permissible if done to save life or preserve health.

---

8. Criminal Negligence and BNS Sections

• If no death: Doctor charged under Sec. 125 BNS (Sec. 336, 337, 338 IPC) - causing hurt or grievous hurt by rash or negligent act.
  • Imprisonment up to 6 months and/or fine ₹5,000 (for simple hurt)
  • Imprisonment up to 3 years and/or fine ₹10,000 (for grievous hurt)
• If death occurs: Doctor charged under Sec. 106(1) BNS (Sec. 304A IPC) - causing death by rash or negligent act. The word "rash or negligent" here is to be read as "grossly" negligent.
• Sec. 105 BNS (Sec. 304 IPC): Non-bailable. Used when the act is intentional.
• Sec. 106(1) BNS (Sec. 304A IPC): Bailable. The act is NOT intentional - death is accidental due to gross negligence.

---

Quick Memory Summary

---

Important Acts in Forensic Medicine

1. Transplantation of Human Organs Act, 1994 (THOTA)
2. Consumer Protection Act, 2019
3. POCSO Act, 2012
4. MTP (Amendment) Act, 2021
5. PCPNDT Act, 1994
6. Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Act, 2021
7. Mental Healthcare Act, 2017

---

1. Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act (THOTA), 1994

What is it?

Why was it made?

• To regulate removal, storage, and transplantation of organs
• To stop organ trafficking (buying and selling of organs)
• To promote donation from brain-dead donors
• To create an ethical, transparent system

Key Definitions

• Human organs: Heart, kidneys, liver, lungs, pancreas
• Tissues: Cornea, bone, skin, blood vessels
• Near relative: Spouse, parents, siblings, children, grandparents, grandchildren
• Brain stem death: Irreversible loss of brain function while the heart is still beating (allows organ donation)
• Authorization Committee: Body that approves organ donation from unrelated (non-relative) living donors

Who can donate?

Brain Death Certification (Section 5)

1. Medical officer in charge of the hospital
2. An independent specialist nominated by the hospital
3. A neurologist or neurosurgeon
4. The treating doctor

Punishments

• Buying/selling organs: Up to 10 years imprisonment + fine up to ₹1 crore
• Illegal dealings: 3-7 years imprisonment + fine
• Unauthorized removal: Up to 5 years imprisonment + fine

Salient Features

• First law in India to legally recognize brain death
• Prohibition on commercial dealings in organs
• Transparent allocation via NOTTO (National Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation) and SOTTO (State level)
• Hospitals must report all brain deaths
• "Required request" policy - hospitals must ask families about organ donation

---

2. Consumer Protection Act, 2019

What is it?

How does it apply to Doctors?

• A patient is a consumer of medical services.
• A doctor or hospital is a service provider.
• If a doctor provides deficient/negligent services, the patient can file a complaint in a Consumer Forum and claim compensation.
• Free services are excluded - if no fees are charged, the Consumer Act does not apply.

Key Points

• Patient does NOT need to go to a civil court - the Consumer Forum is faster and simpler.
• Three-tier system:
  • District Commission: Claims up to ₹1 crore
  • State Commission: Claims ₹1 crore to ₹10 crore
  • National Commission: Claims above ₹10 crore
• Time limit: Complaint must be filed within 2 years of the cause of action.
• 2019 Amendment introduced e-filing, mediation, product liability, and stricter penalties.

Important Point for Doctors

---

3. POCSO Act, 2012 (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences)

What is it?

Definitions

• Child: Any person below 18 years of age
• Sexual assault: Penetrative or non-penetrative sexual acts against a child
• Aggravated assault: Assault by a person of authority (teacher, doctor, relative, police officer)
• Child pornography: Any visual depiction of sexually explicit acts involving a child

Key Sections and Punishments

Important Provisions

• Mandatory Reporting (Sec. 19): Every person who knows about sexual abuse of a child MUST report it to the police. Failure to report is a criminal offense (Sec. 21). This includes doctors, teachers, and all citizens.
• Reverse Burden of Proof (Sec. 29 & 30): The accused is presumed guilty unless they prove innocence (opposite of normal law).
• In-camera trials: Court hearings held in private to protect the child's identity.
• Child-friendly investigation: Child's statement must be recorded in a non-threatening environment.
• Compensation (Sec. 35): Courts can order compensation for medical treatment and rehabilitation.

Salient Features

1. Gender-neutral - Protects both boys and girls
2. Special courts for speedy trials
3. Doctor's role: Must report abuse; must conduct medical examination in a child-friendly way
4. 2019 Amendment added death penalty for aggravated penetrative sexual assault

---

4. MTP (Amendment) Act, 2021 - Medical Termination of Pregnancy

What is it?

When is Abortion Legal?

2021 Amendment - Key Changes

• Upper limit extended from 20 to 24 weeks for certain categories of women
• Unmarried women now included (earlier only married women could cite contraceptive failure)
• A Medical Board is required for termination beyond 24 weeks
• Confidentiality strengthened - identity of the woman cannot be disclosed
• Special categories for 20-24 weeks include: rape/incest survivors, disabled women, minors, mentally ill women

Consent Rules

• Adult woman: Her own consent is sufficient
• Minor (< 18 years): Written consent of guardian required
• Mentally ill woman: Written consent of guardian required
• No consent of husband is required

Where can it be done?

• Only in government hospitals OR private hospitals registered under the MTP Act

Punishment for Illegal Abortion

• Imprisonment up to 7 years for performing illegal abortion
• Up to 10 years if it results in the woman's death

---

5. PCPNDT Act, 1994 (Pre-Conception and Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques Act)

What is it?

Why was it made?

Objectives

1. Ban sex determination before and after conception
2. Prevent female feticide and improve the child sex ratio
3. Regulate diagnostic techniques (ultrasound, amniocentesis) for ethical use only
4. Punish medical professionals involved in illegal sex determination

Key Sections

Key Points

• Form F: A mandatory form filled for every patient undergoing sonography; must mention the indication but sex is NEVER to be written.
• Punishes both the doctor AND the person who sought sex determination.
• "Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao" campaign is linked to enforcement of this Act.
• Authorities: State-level Appropriate Authority + Advisory Committee

---

6. Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Act, 2021

What is it?

Why was it made?

Key Provisions

• All ART clinics and banks must be registered with the National Registry of ART Clinics and Banks.
• An ART bank stores gametes (sperm and eggs) for use.
• A donor can donate gametes to a maximum of one woman only (to prevent consanguinity).
• An oocyte (egg) donor must be a married woman between 23-35 years who already has her own child.
• A sperm donor must be between 21-55 years.
• Sex selection using ART is prohibited.
• Pre-implantation genetic testing is allowed only for detecting diseases, not for sex selection.
• The child born through ART is considered the legitimate child of the couple.
• ART services cannot be used for single males or same-sex couples (currently).

Punishments

• Abandoning a child born through ART: Up to 8 years + ₹10 lakh fine
• Exploiting or trafficking gametes/embryos: Up to 10 years + ₹25 lakh fine
• Using sex selection techniques: Up to 5 years + ₹10 lakh fine

Regulatory Body

• National ART and Surrogacy Board at central level
• State ART and Surrogacy Board at state level

---

7. Mental Healthcare Act, 2017

What is it?

Key Definitions

• Mental illness: A substantial disorder of thinking, mood, perception, orientation, or memory that grossly impairs judgment, behavior, and capacity to meet ordinary demands of life.
• Mental Health Establishment (MHE): Any facility providing mental healthcare.
• Mental Health Professional (MHP): Psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, psychiatric social workers, psychiatric nurses.
• Advance Directive: A legal document by which a person states HOW they wish to be treated during a future mental health crisis.
• Nominated Representative (NR): A person appointed to take decisions on behalf of the mentally ill person when they are incapacitated.

Salient Features

1. Rights-based approach - Mental healthcare is a right, not a privilege.
2. Right to access - Everyone has the right to affordable, good-quality mental health services.
3. Right to community living - Patients cannot be segregated from society.
4. Decriminalization of suicide (Sec. 115) - Suicide attempt is now presumed to be due to severe mental stress, NOT a crime. IPC Section 309 (attempt to suicide) effectively abolished for mental illness.
5. Informed consent and autonomy - Patients must be treated in the least restrictive manner.
6. Advance directives - Empowers patients to decide their own treatment plan in advance.
7. Ban on inhuman practices:
   • No seclusion rooms
   • No chaining of patients
   • No unmodified ECT (ECT without anesthesia)
   • No sterilization of mentally ill individuals
8. Insurance parity - Mental illness must be covered by insurers equal to physical illness.
9. Mental Health Review Boards (MHRBs) - Quasi-judicial bodies that protect patient rights and review admissions/discharges.

Decriminalization of Suicide (Section 115)

• Any person who attempts suicide is presumed to be under severe stress.
• Government has a duty to provide care and rehabilitation.
• No legal proceedings under IPC Section 309 (which carried imprisonment up to 1 year).

Offences and Penalties

• Running unlicensed Mental Health Establishment: Fine up to ₹5 lakhs
• Ill-treatment of patients: Punishable under law
• Violation of confidentiality: Legal and disciplinary action

---

Quick Summary Table