PATHOLOGY EXAMINATION ANSWERS
Q1 (20 Marks)
Aetiology of Acquired Valvular Lesions of the Heart
Acquired valvular lesions arise from damage to previously normal valves. They may produce stenosis (impaired opening), regurgitation/incompetence (impaired closure), or both (mixed lesion).
Aetiological Classification
1. Rheumatic Heart Disease (Most Common Worldwide)
- Follows Rheumatic Fever (Group A beta-hemolytic Streptococcus pharyngitis)
- Mitral valve most commonly affected, followed by aortic > tricuspid > pulmonary
- Pathology: fibrous thickening, commissural fusion, chordal shortening, calcification
- Results in: mitral stenosis (most characteristic), combined mitral stenosis + regurgitation
2. Degenerative / Calcific Disease
- Senile calcific aortic stenosis: Most common cause of AS in elderly (>70 yrs); calcium deposits in cusps, no commissural fusion
- Mitral annular calcification: Mainly causes regurgitation; common in elderly women
- Myxomatous degeneration (Mitral Valve Prolapse): Excess proteoglycans in spongiosa, billowing leaflets causing mitral regurgitation; Marfan syndrome is a classic predisposing condition
3. Infective Endocarditis
- Bacterial/fungal destruction of cusps, perforations, vegetations
- Causes acute severe regurgitation (aortic or mitral most commonly)
- May heal with fibrosis and stenosis
4. Ischaemic Heart Disease
- Papillary muscle dysfunction or rupture following MI causes acute mitral regurgitation
- Ischaemic annular dilatation causes functional MR without structural leaflet damage
5. Carcinoid Heart Disease
- Right-sided valves affected (pulmonary and tricuspid)
- Serotonin (5-HT) causes fibrous plaques - "carcinoid plaques" - on endocardial surface
- Results in tricuspid regurgitation and pulmonary stenosis
6. Drug-Induced Valvulopathy
- Ergot alkaloids (methysergide, ergotamine), fenfluramine-phentermine, pergolide, cabergoline
- Fibrous endocardial plaques similar to carcinoid
7. Connective Tissue / Autoimmune Diseases
- SLE: Libman-Sacks endocarditis - non-bacterial thrombotic vegetations on both surfaces of mitral/aortic valves (antiphospholipid syndrome)
- Rheumatoid arthritis: granulomatous nodules on valves
- Ankylosing spondylitis: aortic regurgitation
8. Iatrogenic / Procedural
- Radiation-induced valvular fibrosis (especially after mantle field radiotherapy)
- Prosthetic valve dysfunction (structural, thrombosis, paravalvular leak)
9. Rare Causes
- Syphilitic aortitis: aortic regurgitation due to root dilatation
- Hypereosinophilic syndrome / Loeffler endocarditis
- Whipple disease: right-sided valves
Infective Endocarditis (IE)
Definition
IE is infection of the endocardial surface of the heart, most often involving cardiac valves, caused by bacteria, fungi, or other microorganisms.
Etiopathogenesis
Step 1: Endothelial Damage / Non-Bacterial Thrombotic Endocarditis (NBTE)
- Normal endocardium is resistant to bacterial adhesion
- Turbulent blood flow (due to valvular disease, congenital defects, prosthetic valves, IDU-related right-sided jets) causes mechanical endothelial damage
- Damaged endothelium exposes subendothelial collagen and tissue factor
- This triggers platelet aggregation and fibrin deposition, forming a sterile thrombus (NBTE / marantic endocarditis) - the critical precursor lesion
Step 2: Bacteraemia
- Transient bacteraemia is common: dental procedures, GI/GU instrumentation, IV drug use, intravascular catheters, skin infections
- High-density bacteraemia with virulent or adherent organisms is required for IE to develop
Step 3: Bacterial Adherence and Colonisation
- Bacteria must adhere to the NBTE lesion
- Virulence factors promoting adhesion:
- S. aureus: fibronectin-binding proteins (FnBP), clumping factor A (ClfA), MSCRAMM family adhesins
- Viridans streptococci: dextran production, FimA, glucan-binding proteins
- Enterococcus, S. bovis, HACEK group: various adhesins
- Fibronectin acts as a bridge between bacteria and platelet-fibrin thrombus
Step 4: Vegetation Formation and Propagation
- Bacteria proliferate within the vegetation, protected from host immunity
- Further platelet deposition and fibrin layering buries bacteria (metabolically inactive inner core - explains why prolonged antibiotics needed)
- Vegetation size increases
- Tissue destruction: collagenases, hyaluronidases, proteases destroy valve leaflet
- Periannular abscess formation: direct extension of infection to adjacent structures
Step 5: Systemic Complications
- Embolic: Fragments break off and cause:
- Systemic emboli (aortic/mitral IE): stroke, splenic infarcts, renal infarcts, septic emboli
- Pulmonary emboli (tricuspid IE in IDU)
- Roth spots (retinal), Janeway lesions (non-tender embolic infarcts), Osler nodes (immune complex deposition)
- Immune complex deposition: Glomerulonephritis, arthritis, vasculitis
- Metastatic infection: Mycotic aneurysms (weakened vessel walls from infected emboli or immune complex deposition)
Risk Factors for IE
Cardiac Risk Factors (Predisposing Structural Lesions)
| High Risk | Moderate Risk |
|---|
| Prosthetic heart valves | Bicuspid aortic valve |
| Previous IE | Mitral valve prolapse with regurgitation |
| Cyanotic congenital heart disease (unrepaired) | Acquired valvular disease (RHD, AS) |
| Surgically corrected CHD with residual defects | Hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy |
| Cardiac transplant recipients with valvulopathy | VSD, ASD (AV canal type) |
Non-Cardiac Risk Factors
- IV drug use: Major risk factor for right-sided (tricuspid) IE; S. aureus predominant
- Intravascular devices: Central venous catheters, pacemaker/ICD leads (device-related IE)
- Haemodialysis: Arteriovenous fistula, tunneled catheters
- Poor dental hygiene / dental procedures: Source of viridans streptococcal bacteraemia
- Immunosuppression: HIV, chemotherapy, immunosuppressants
- Skin infections / breaks: S. aureus entry
- Gastrointestinal procedures / malignancy: S. bovis (S. gallolyticus) bacteraemia - associated with colonic neoplasia
Microbial Risk Factors
- S. aureus: Most virulent; can infect normal valves; #1 cause in developed countries
- Viridans group streptococci: Subacute IE on damaged valves
- Enterococcus faecalis: Associated with GI/GU procedures
- Coagulase-negative Staphylococci: Prosthetic valve IE
- HACEK group (Haemophilus, Aggregatibacter, Cardiobacterium, Eikenella, Kingella): Slow-growing, culture-negative
- Fungi (Candida, Aspergillus): IDU, immunocompromised, prosthetic valves
Pathology
Macroscopic Features
- Vegetations: The hallmark lesion; irregular, friable, tan-grey masses adherent to valve leaflets
- Location: typically on the atrial surface of AV valves and ventricular surface of semilunar valves (low-pressure side)
- Size: variable, 0.5 cm to several centimetres
- Right-sided vegetations (tricuspid) in IDU tend to be large and bulky
- Valve destruction: Perforations, erosions, aneurysm of cusp/leaflet
- Periannular abscess (ring abscess): Direct extension, especially in aortic valve IE; may fistulise
- Chordal rupture: Especially in mitral valve IE
- Myocardial abscess: Extension to myocardium
- Pericarditis: In S. aureus IE or periannular abscess perforation
Microscopic Features
Acute IE (S. aureus):
- Vegetation: fibrin, platelets, bacteria, numerous neutrophils
- Underlying valve leaflet: coagulative necrosis, destruction of collagen
- Heavy bacterial colonies visible within vegetation
- Abscess formation with neutrophils
Subacute IE (Viridans streptococci):
- Vegetation: fibrin, platelets, granulation tissue, sparse organisms
- Underlying valve: chronic inflammatory cells, fibroblast proliferation
- Healed vegetations: organized fibrous tissue, calcification, new vessel formation
Complications (Pathological Basis)
| Complication | Mechanism |
|---|
| Acute valvular regurgitation | Perforation / chordal rupture |
| Periannular abscess | Direct spread to valve ring and adjacent structures |
| Heart block | Abscess extending to AV node |
| Stroke | Embolism of vegetation fragments |
| Renal failure | Embolic infarcts + immune complex GN |
| Mycotic aneurysm | Emboli to vasa vasorum, weakening arterial wall |
| Splenic abscess | Septic embolism |
| Osler nodes / Janeway lesions | Immune complex vasculitis / septic emboli |
Modified Duke Criteria (Diagnostic Framework)
Major Criteria
- Positive blood cultures (at least 2 of typical IE organisms, or persistently positive, or single positive for Coxiella burnetii)
- Positive echocardiographic findings: vegetation, abscess, prosthetic valve dehiscence, or new valvular regurgitation
Minor Criteria
- Predisposing heart condition or IV drug use
- Fever >38°C
- Vascular phenomena (emboli, mycotic aneurysms, Janeway lesions, conjunctival haemorrhages)
- Immunological phenomena (glomerulonephritis, Osler nodes, Roth spots, rheumatoid factor)
- Microbiological evidence not meeting major criteria
Definite IE: 2 major, or 1 major + 3 minor, or 5 minor criteria
Possible IE: 1 major + 1 minor, or 3 minor criteria
Diagnostic Investigations
Blood Cultures (Most Important Investigation)
- Method: 3 sets from separate venipuncture sites, 30 min apart, before antibiotics
- Volume: 10 mL per bottle (adult) - increases yield
- Timing: Before any antibiotic administration
- Yield: 90-95% positive in native valve IE if done correctly
- Organisms: S. aureus and streptococci identified within 24-72 hours
- HACEK organisms: Culture-negative - require prolonged incubation (up to 2 weeks) or molecular methods
- Culture-negative IE: Due to prior antibiotics, fastidious organisms (Bartonella, Coxiella, Tropheryma whipplei, Brucella)
Echocardiography
- Transthoracic Echo (TTE): First-line; sensitivity 40-63% for vegetations (S. aureus IE, prosthetic valves - lower sensitivity)
- Transesophageal Echo (TEE): Sensitivity 87-100%; mandatory when:
- TTE non-diagnostic but IE suspected
- Prosthetic valve IE
- S. aureus bacteraemia
- Suspected periannular complications
- Assessment before/after surgery
- Findings on echo: Oscillating masses (vegetations), abscesses, fistulae, new regurgitation, dehiscence
Laboratory Investigations
- CBC: Leucocytosis (acute IE), anaemia of chronic disease (subacute IE), thrombocytopenia (sepsis)
- ESR and CRP: Markedly elevated; useful for monitoring treatment response
- Rheumatoid factor: Elevated in ~50% of subacute IE (non-specific)
- Serum procalcitonin: Elevated; aids in differentiating bacteraemia from IE
- Urinalysis: Microscopic haematuria, proteinuria, red cell casts (immune complex GN)
- Renal and hepatic function: Baseline; for aminoglycoside monitoring
Imaging Investigations
- Chest X-ray: Cardiomegaly, pulmonary oedema (heart failure), multiple peripheral infarcts (right-sided IE)
- ECG: PR prolongation/heart block (periannular abscess); new LBBB
- CT scan:
- Cardiac CT: Periannular abscess, pseudoaneurysms, fistulae
- CT chest/abdomen/pelvis: Embolic complications (pulmonary emboli, splenic/renal infarcts)
- CT brain: Ischaemic strokes, mycotic aneurysms
- MRI brain: More sensitive than CT for embolic cerebral lesions
- 18F-FDG PET/CT: Especially useful for prosthetic valve IE (increased metabolic activity around prosthesis)
- Radiolabelled leucocyte scintigraphy: For device-related IE diagnosis
Microbiological Investigations for Culture-Negative IE
- Serology: Coxiella burnetii (Q fever), Bartonella, Brucella, Chlamydia
- PCR: From blood or excised valve tissue - HACEK, Bartonella, Tropheryma whipplei
- 16S ribosomal RNA gene sequencing: Excised valve material
- Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionisation (MALDI-TOF): Organism identification
Histopathological Examination (Surgical Specimens)
- Excised valve: Gram stain, culture, histology
- Histology: Vegetation with bacteria, inflammatory cells, valve destruction confirms diagnosis definitively
- Methenamine silver and PAS for fungi; Warthin-Starry for Bartonella; Ziehl-Neelsen for mycobacteria
Q2 (20 Marks)
Classification of Bone Tumours
WHO Classification of Bone Tumours (2020)
I. Cartilage (Chondrogenic) Tumours
Benign:
- Osteochondroma (solitary / hereditary multiple exostoses)
- Enchondroma (solitary / Ollier disease / Maffucci syndrome)
- Periosteal chondroma
- Chondroblastoma
- Chondromyxoid fibroma
Intermediate (locally aggressive):
- Atypical cartilaginous tumour / Chondrosarcoma Grade 1 (central, periosteal)
Malignant:
- Chondrosarcoma Grade 2 and 3
- Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma
- Mesenchymal chondrosarcoma
- Clear cell chondrosarcoma
II. Osteogenic (Bone-Forming) Tumours
Benign:
- Osteoma
- Osteoid osteoma
- Osteoblastoma
Malignant:
- Osteosarcoma (conventional, parosteal, periosteal, telangiectatic, small cell, secondary)
III. Fibrogenic Tumours
- Desmoplastic fibroma (intermediate)
- Fibrosarcoma (malignant)
IV. Vascular Tumours
- Haemangioma (benign)
- Epithelioid haemangioendothelioma (intermediate)
- Angiosarcoma (malignant)
V. Osteoclastic Giant Cell-Rich Tumours
- Non-ossifying fibroma
- Giant cell tumour of bone (intermediate)
- Malignant giant cell tumour
VI. Notochordal Tumours
- Benign notochordal cell tumour
- Chordoma
VII. Marrow (Round Cell) Tumours
- Ewing sarcoma / PNET
- Plasmacytoma / Multiple myeloma
- Primary bone lymphoma
VIII. Smooth Muscle Tumours
- Leiomyoma (benign)
- Leiomyosarcoma (malignant)
IX. Nerve Sheath Tumours
X. Miscellaneous
- Adamantinoma
- Simple (unicameral) bone cyst
- Aneurysmal bone cyst
- Fibrous dysplasia
- Osteofibrous dysplasia
- Langerhans cell histiocytosis
Chondrogenic Tumours - Detailed Discussion
Chondrogenic tumours are characterised by the formation of cartilage matrix (hyaline or myxoid) by the tumour cells. They are the most common primary bone tumours.
1. Osteochondroma (Osteocartilaginous Exostosis)
Incidence and Epidemiology
- Most common benign bone tumour (35-40% of all benign bone tumours)
- Age: 10-30 years; Male > Female (2:1)
- Hereditary Multiple Exostoses (HME): Autosomal dominant, mutations in EXT1 (8q24) and EXT2 (11p13) - tumour suppressors
Sites
- Metaphysis of long bones (distal femur, proximal tibia, proximal humerus)
- Any bone formed by endochondral ossification
Pathogenesis
- Arises from displacement of small cartilage fragments from the growth plate epiphysis
- EXT1/EXT2 mutations disrupt heparan sulphate proteoglycan synthesis, affecting Hedgehog signalling and chondrocyte differentiation
Macroscopy
- Pedunculated (stalked) or sessile (broad base) bony outgrowth
- Covered by a fibrous perichondrium and a cartilaginous cap (blue-white, glistening)
- Cap thickness <1 cm in adults (>2 cm suggests malignant transformation)
- Bony cortex is continuous with underlying bone (key diagnostic feature)
Microscopy
- Cartilaginous cap: hyaline cartilage with benign chondrocytes in lacunae, organised in rows (like normal growth plate)
- Endochondral ossification at base of cap (zone of ossification)
- Perichondrium: fibrous connective tissue
- Core: normal cancellous bone with fatty/haematopoietic marrow
Malignant Transformation
- Solitary: <1%; Multiple (HME): 5-25%
- Risk factors: increasing cap thickness, growth after skeletal maturity, pain
- Transforms to: secondary chondrosarcoma (most often, Grade 1)
2. Enchondroma (Central Chondroma)
Epidemiology
- Second most common benign cartilage tumour
- Peak age: 10-40 years; No sex predilection
- Ollier disease: Multiple enchondromatosis (non-hereditary); 25-30% risk of malignant transformation
- Maffucci syndrome: Multiple enchondromas + soft tissue haemangiomas; >100 times malignant risk; IDH1/IDH2 mutations
Sites
- Short tubular bones of hands and feet (50-65%) - classic location
- Long bones (femur, tibia, humerus) in Ollier/Maffucci
Pathogenesis
- Residual islands of growth plate cartilage that fail to undergo endochondral ossification, arrested in medullary cavity
- IDH1 (R132) and IDH2 (R172) mutations in most enchondromas - produce 2-hydroxyglutarate (oncometabolite)
Macroscopy
- Well-circumscribed lobules of blue-white hyaline cartilage in medullary cavity
- Calcification: "popcorn" or "rings and arcs" pattern
- No cortical destruction
Microscopy
- Lobules of hyaline cartilage matrix
- Sparsely cellular; chondrocytes small and uniform in lacunae
- Minimal nuclear atypia, rare mitoses
- Calcification and endochondral ossification at periphery of lobules
3. Chondroblastoma
Epidemiology
- Rare; peak age 10-20 years (skeletally immature); M:F = 2:1
- Essentially the only primary bone tumour confined to epiphysis in children
Sites
- Epiphysis of long bones: distal femur, proximal tibia, proximal humerus (around knee and shoulder)
- May extend into metaphysis or subarticular region
Pathogenesis
- H3.3 histone mutations: H3F3B K36M (>95% of cases) - characteristic; affects epigenetic regulation
- Considered neoplastic
Macroscopy
- Lobulated, pink-red to grey, haemorrhagic mass
- "Chicken-wire" calcification on imaging (classic radiological feature)
Microscopy
- Sheets of round to polygonal chondroblasts with distinct cell borders and "coffee bean" (bilobed) nuclei with a longitudinal groove
- Scattered multinucleated osteoclast-type giant cells (reactive)
- Characteristic "chicken-wire" or "pericellular" calcification: fine lace-like calcification around individual chondroblasts
- Variable chondroid matrix (usually scant)
Behaviour
- Locally aggressive; requires curettage + bone grafting
- Rarely metastasises (<2%) - even then called "metastasising chondroblastoma"
4. Chondromyxoid Fibroma
Epidemiology
- Rarest of common benign cartilage tumours
- Age 10-30 years; M > F
Sites
- Metaphysis of long bones; tibial metaphysis most common (proximal tibia)
- Flat bones (ilium)
Pathogenesis
- GRM1 gene rearrangements (metabotropic glutamate receptor 1)
Macroscopy
- Lobulated, grey-white, firm mass; well-circumscribed, eccentric, often causes cortical expansion
Microscopy
- Stellate to spindled cells in a myxoid/chondroid matrix arranged in lobules
- Hypocellular centres with hypercellular periphery (lobule rim with spindle/round cells)
- Multinucleated giant cells at periphery of lobules
- Minimal nuclear atypia; rare mitoses
5. Chondrosarcoma (Malignant Chondrogenic Tumour)
Chondrosarcoma is the second most common primary malignant bone tumour after osteosarcoma.
Classification
| Type | Characteristics |
|---|
| Central (intramedullary) conventional | Most common; arises de novo or from enchondroma |
| Peripheral | Arises from surface/exostosis; from osteochondroma |
| Periosteal | From periosteum |
| Dedifferentiated | High-grade sarcoma component + low-grade cartilage component |
| Mesenchymal | Small round cells + islands of hyaline cartilage; HEY1-NCOA2 fusion |
| Clear cell | Rare; epiphyseal location; R108 IDH2 mutation |
Epidemiology
- Peak age: 30-60 years (adults - key difference from osteosarcoma which peaks in teenagers)
- Male > Female
- Second most common primary malignant bone tumour
Sites
- Central chondrosarcoma: Pelvis > proximal femur > proximal humerus > ribs
- (Contrast with enchondroma which occurs in hands/feet)
Pathogenesis
- De novo (primary): IDH1/IDH2 mutations (75-80%); also CDKN2A deletion, TP53 mutation, loss of RB1
- Secondary (from osteochondroma): Loss of EXT1/EXT2
- Progression: Enchondroma → Grade 1 chondrosarcoma → Grade 2 → Grade 3 via progressive genetic alterations
Grading (Histological)
Grade 1 (Low-grade / Atypical Cartilaginous Tumour):
- Hypercellular cartilage compared to enchondroma
- Mild nuclear atypia; enlarged, hyperchromatic nuclei
- Binucleate cells occasional
- No necrosis; rare mitoses
- Invades Haversian canals (permeation) - key distinguishing feature from enchondroma
- Excellent prognosis (>90% survival)
Grade 2 (Intermediate):
- Moderate cellularity; myxoid change in matrix
- Moderate nuclear atypia; mitoses present
- Areas of necrosis
- ~60-70% survival
Grade 3 (High-grade):
- Highly cellular; marked nuclear pleomorphism
- Numerous mitoses; extensive necrosis
- Spindle cell areas
- ~30% survival
Macroscopy (Conventional)
- Large, lobulated, blue-white-grey glistening mass with gelatinous areas (myxoid change)
- "Rings and arcs" calcification within lobules (key radiological sign)
- Cortical destruction and soft tissue extension in higher grades
Microscopy
- Lobules of cartilage matrix with chondrocytes in lacunae
- Grade-dependent atypia (as above)
- Permeation of host bone trabeculae and Haversian canals (most reliable feature distinguishing chondrosarcoma from enchondroma)
- Myxoid change: loosening of matrix, stellate cells "floating"
- Dedifferentiated: juxtaposition of low-grade cartilage and high-grade spindle cell sarcoma (abrupt interface)
Immunohistochemistry
- S100 protein: positive (marker of chondrogenic differentiation)
- SOX9: positive (transcription factor for chondrogenesis)
- IDH1 R132H mutant-specific antibody: positive in IDH-mutant cases
Molecular Features
- IDH1/IDH2 mutations: Present in enchondroma and Grades 1-3; useful diagnostic marker; therapeutic target (ivosidenib for IDH1)
- CDKN2A deletion: Progression marker
- HEY1-NCOA2 fusion: Diagnostic of mesenchymal chondrosarcoma
- COL2A1 mutations: In ~20%
Treatment and Prognosis
- Surgery is primary treatment (resistant to radiation and conventional chemotherapy)
- Grade 1: Wide local excision (intralesional curettage for accessible lesions)
- Grade 2/3: Wide resection; 5-year survival 60-70% (Grade 2), 30% (Grade 3)
- Dedifferentiated: Very poor prognosis; <10% at 5 years
- Mesenchymal chondrosarcoma: Chemotherapy may help; ~50% at 10 years
Q3 (20 Marks)
Classification of Adenomas of the Intestine
A. Classification by Morphology (Macroscopic / Endoscopic)
Paris Endoscopic Classification
- Pedunculated (Ip): Long stalk
- Sub-pedunculated (Isp): Short stalk
- Sessile (Is): Broad base, not elevated >2.5 mm
- Superficial elevated (IIa): Elevated ≤2.5 mm
- Flat (IIb): No elevation
- Slightly depressed (IIc): Slightly depressed
- Excavated (III): Deep ulceration
B. Classification by Histological Architecture
| Type | Features |
|---|
| Tubular adenoma (70-80%) | Branching crypts/tubules in fibrovascular stalk; dysplastic glandular epithelium |
| Villous adenoma (5-10%) | Finger-like villi projecting from muscularis mucosae; highest malignant potential |
| Tubulovillous adenoma (10-20%) | Mixed tubular and villous patterns |
| Serrated adenoma (traditional / sessile) | Saw-tooth architecture; BRAF or KRAS mutations; separate pathway to cancer |
C. Classification by Degree of Dysplasia
- Low-grade dysplasia (LGD): Nuclear stratification confined to lower half; mild atypia
- High-grade dysplasia (HGD): Nuclear stratification reaches luminal surface; marked atypia, complex glandular architecture, cribriform pattern, no invasion through basement membrane
- Intramucosal carcinoma: Invasion into lamina propria (no lymphatic access)
D. Special Syndromes / Polyposis
Familial Adenomatous Polyposis (FAP)
-
100 tubular adenomas throughout colon; APC gene (5q21) mutation
- Autosomal dominant
- 100% cancer risk if untreated; prophylactic colectomy required
- Gardner syndrome: FAP + osteomas + desmoid tumours + epidermoid cysts
- Turcot syndrome: FAP/HNPCC + CNS tumours
Hereditary Non-Polyposis Colorectal Cancer (HNPCC / Lynch Syndrome)
- Mismatch repair gene mutations (MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, PMS2)
- <100 adenomas; right-sided predominance
- Microsatellite instability (MSI-H)
MUTYH-Associated Polyposis (MAP)
- Autosomal recessive; base excision repair defect
- 10-100 adenomas
Serrated Polyposis Syndrome
-
5 serrated polyps proximal to sigmoid, OR >20 anywhere
Peutz-Jeghers Syndrome
- Hamartomatous polyps + mucocutaneous pigmentation; STK11 mutation
- Elevated risk of GI and extra-GI carcinomas
Juvenile Polyposis Syndrome
- Multiple juvenile (retention) polyps; SMAD4 or BMPR1A mutations; elevated cancer risk
Etiopathogenesis of Colon Carcinoma
Epidemiology
- 3rd most common cancer worldwide; 2nd leading cause of cancer death
- Male > Female (slight); Higher in Western countries (dietary habits)
- Risk increases after age 50
Molecular Pathways to Colon Cancer
Pathway 1: Chromosomal Instability (CIN) Pathway - 85% of sporadic cases
Also called the "Classic" Adenoma-Carcinoma Sequence (Fearon-Vogelstein Model, 1990).
Sequence: Normal epithelium → Aberrant crypt foci → Small tubular adenoma → Large tubular/villous adenoma → High-grade dysplasia → Invasive carcinoma
Key Genetic Events (in order):
| Step | Gene | Alteration | Effect |
|---|
| Initiation | APC (5q21) | Loss/mutation | Activates Wnt/β-catenin; β-catenin accumulates in nucleus |
| Promotion | KRAS (12p12) | Activating point mutation | Sustained proliferation via RAS-MAPK pathway |
| Progression | SMAD2/SMAD4 (18q21) | Deletion | Loss of TGF-β growth inhibition |
| Malignant transformation | TP53 (17p13) | Loss of function | Loss of G1/S checkpoint; DNA damage unchecked |
| Additional | DCC (deleted in colorectal carcinoma) | Loss | Loss of cell adhesion |
APC mutation details:
- APC normally promotes degradation of β-catenin
- Mutant APC → β-catenin accumulates → enters nucleus → activates TCF/LEF transcription factors → target genes: MYC (proliferation), cyclin D1 (cell cycle), MMP-7 (invasion)
- APC also regulates microtubule spindle function - explains chromosomal instability (aneuploidy)
Pathway 2: Microsatellite Instability (MSI) Pathway - 15% of sporadic cases; Lynch syndrome
Also called the "Mutator Pathway."
Mechanism:
- Loss of DNA mismatch repair (MMR) genes: MLH1 (promoter methylation - sporadic), MSH2, MSH6, PMS2 (germline mutation - Lynch)
- MMR failure → accumulation of mutations in microsatellite repeat regions (unstable repetitive DNA sequences)
- Microsatellites within key tumour suppressor genes (TGFBR2, BAX, IGF2R) undergo frameshift mutations → inactivation
- Results in hypermutation (hypermutator phenotype)
Features:
- Right-sided (proximal) tumours predominance
- Medullary / mucinous histology
- Heavy lymphocytic infiltrate ("Crohn's-like" reaction)
- Better prognosis despite higher grade
- Responds to immune checkpoint inhibitors (pembrolizumab)
Testing: IHC for MMR proteins (MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, PMS2); PCR for MSI; BRAF V600E mutation (present in sporadic MLH1-methylated but NOT in Lynch syndrome - used in Lynch triage)
Pathway 3: CpG Island Methylator Phenotype (CIMP) / Serrated Pathway
- Promoter hypermethylation of tumour suppressor genes (MLH1, CDKN2A)
- BRAF V600E mutation is the initiating event (vs KRAS in CIN)
- Serrated polyp → Sessile serrated lesion (SSL) → Carcinoma
- MLH1 methylation → MSI-H in BRAF-mutated serrated carcinomas (BRAF-mutated MSI carcinomas)
- Also KRAS-mutated pathway → MSS serrated carcinomas
- ~20-30% of colon cancers arise via serrated pathway
Risk Factors for Colon Carcinoma
Modifiable
- Diet: High red/processed meat, high fat, low fibre, low calcium, low vitamin D
- Obesity and physical inactivity: Elevate insulin/IGF-1; hyperinsulinaemia promotes colonocyte proliferation
- Alcohol and tobacco smoking
- Inflammatory bowel disease: Chronic UC (pancolitis >10 years); surveillance colonoscopy essential
Non-Modifiable
- Age: Risk doubles every decade after 40
- Hereditary syndromes: FAP (100% risk), Lynch syndrome (60-80% lifetime risk), MAP
- Previous colorectal adenomas: Personal history increases risk 3-5 fold
- Family history: First-degree relative doubles risk
- Type 2 diabetes / metabolic syndrome
- Acromegaly (elevated IGF-1)
Molecular Features Relevant to Treatment
- KRAS/NRAS mutation: Predicts resistance to anti-EGFR therapy (cetuximab, panitumumab)
- BRAF V600E: Poor prognosis; combination BRAF+MEK inhibitor (encorafenib+binimetinib+cetuximab)
- MSI-H: Excellent response to pembrolizumab (checkpoint inhibitor); FDA approved first-line
- HER2 amplification: ~3% of cases; targetable with trastuzumab/lapatinib
- NTRK fusion: Larotrectinib/entrectinib
Q4 Short Notes
Q4a: Interpretation of Liver Biopsy with Reference to Infective Lesions
Liver biopsy is evaluated systematically: tissue adequacy (>10-15 portal tracts), portal tracts, lobular architecture, hepatocytes, sinusoids, vasculature, and any focal lesions. For infective lesions:
Approach to Infective Liver Biopsy
Step 1 - Identify pattern of injury:
- Portal inflammation pattern (hepatitis)
- Granulomatous pattern
- Microabscess / suppurative pattern
- Diffuse sinusoidal / reticuloendothelial pattern
- Necrotising / fibrinous pattern
Specific Infective Lesions
1. Viral Hepatitis
- Acute hepatitis (HAV, HBV, HEV): Lobular disarray; hepatocyte swelling/ballooning degeneration; acidophil (Councilman) bodies (apoptotic hepatocytes); lobular inflammation; portal inflammation with lymphocytes; bridging necrosis in severe cases
- Chronic hepatitis B: Interface hepatitis (piecemeal necrosis); portal fibrosis; "ground-glass" hepatocytes (HBsAg in ER - orcein/Victoria blue positive); HBcAg: nuclear "sanded" nuclei (Shikata orcein); correlate with HBV serology
- Chronic hepatitis C: Portal lymphoid aggregates/follicles; mild steatosis (especially genotype 3); mild bile duct damage; mild interface hepatitis; lobular inflammation; progressive fibrosis
- CMV hepatitis: Large intranuclear inclusions with halo ("owl-eye" cells); microabscesses; useful in immunocompromised
- EBV (infectious mononucleosis): Sinusoidal infiltration by atypical lymphocytes ("beads on a string"); hepatitis pattern
- Herpes simplex: Geographic coagulative necrosis without inflammatory response; Cowdry type A intranuclear inclusions; haemorrhagic necrosis in neonates/immunocompromised
- Yellow fever: Mid-zonal necrosis (zone 2); Councilman bodies; Torres bodies (eosinophilic intranuclear inclusions); fat change
- COVID-19: Mild portal inflammation, macrovesicular steatosis, fibrin thrombi in sinusoids
2. Bacterial Infections
- Pyogenic liver abscess (E. coli, Klebsiella, Streptococcus, Staphylococcus, anaerobes): Zones of coagulative necrosis surrounded by neutrophilic inflammation, granulation tissue, and fibrous capsule; Gram stain for organisms
- Tuberculosis: Epithelioid granulomas with or without central caseous necrosis; Langhans giant cells; ZN stain / auramine-rhodamine for AFB; culture; GeneXpert; typically hepatic involvement in miliary TB (portal/lobular non-caseating granulomas also seen)
- Brucellosis: Small, non-caseating granulomas in portal tracts; fibrin ring granulomas (rare)
- Typhoid (Salmonella typhi): Typhoid nodules - small collections of macrophages (Kupffer cell hyperplasia); no true granuloma formation; relative lymphopenia
3. Granulomatous Hepatitis - Differential Diagnosis
| Cause | Granuloma Features |
|---|
| TB | Caseating; AFB positive; portal/lobular |
| Sarcoidosis | Non-caseating; fibrous rim; often portal; ACE elevated |
| PBC | Florid duct lesion; granuloma around damaged bile duct; portal |
| Q fever (Coxiella) | Fibrin ring granuloma (lipid vacuole surrounded by ring of fibrin and macrophages) - pathognomonic |
| Brucellosis | Small, non-caseating |
| Fungal (Histoplasma) | PAS-D + organisms within macrophages; GMS stain |
| Schistosomiasis | Granuloma around egg; pipestem fibrosis around portal veins |
| Drug reaction | Non-caseating; eosinophils; portal/lobular |
4. Parasitic Infections
- Schistosomiasis: Schistosome eggs in portal tracts surrounded by granulomas; progressive periportal fibrosis ("pipestem fibrosis" / Symmers fibrosis); PAS stain highlights egg wall
- Hydatid disease (Echinococcus): Cyst wall composed of outer laminated eosinophilic acellular membrane (chitinous) + inner germinal layer (nucleated cells); scolices with hooklets in cyst fluid; compressed liver parenchyma; fibrous host reaction
- Visceral leishmaniasis (Kala-azar): Kupffer cell hyperplasia with engulfed amastigotes (Leishman-Donovan bodies); Giemsa stain
- Malaria: Kupffer cell hyperplasia; haemozoin (malaria pigment) - brown-black granular deposits in Kupffer cells; minimal hepatocyte damage
- Amoebiasis: Amoebic liver abscess: "anchovy paste" (lytic necrosis, no neutrophils); trophozoites with engulfed erythrocytes visible at edge of abscess (PAS positive); fibrous capsule
5. Fungal Infections
- Candida: Microabscesses; pseudohyphae + budding yeasts on PAS/GMS
- Histoplasma: Intracellular organisms in macrophages; granulomas; GMS/PAS stain
- Aspergillus: Hyphae with acute angle branching, septate; angioinvasion
Special Stains Used in Infective Liver Biopsy:
- ZN / Auramine-rhodamine: AFB (mycobacteria)
- PAS-D (diastase): Fungi, glycogen
- GMS (Grocott): Fungi
- Giemsa: Leishmania, malaria
- Warthin-Starry: Bartonella, spirochaetes
- Shikata orcein / Victoria blue: HBsAg
- Immunohistochemistry: HBcAg, CMV, HSV, EBV (EBER in situ hybridisation)
Q4b: Role of Electron Microscopy and Immunofluorescence in Diagnosis of Glomerular Lesions
Renal biopsy for glomerular disease requires three modalities: light microscopy (LM), immunofluorescence (IF), and electron microscopy (EM). IF and EM provide information LM cannot.
Immunofluorescence (IF)
Technique: Fresh tissue snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen; 4 µm cryostat sections; labelled antibodies against IgG, IgA, IgM, C3, C1q, C4d, fibrinogen, albumin, kappa and lambda light chains.
Pattern Recognition:
| IF Pattern | Significance |
|---|
| Granular (immune complex) | Immune complex deposition (IgA nephropathy, lupus, membranous, MPGN) |
| Linear | Anti-GBM antibody (Goodpasture disease) |
| Mesangial | IgA nephropathy, lupus class II |
| Negative ("pauci-immune") | ANCA-associated vasculitis (GPA, MPA, EGPA) |
| Full house (IgG, IgA, IgM, C3, C1q) | Lupus nephritis (highly specific) |
| Dominant IgA mesangial | IgA nephropathy / Henoch-Schönlein purpura |
| Subepithelial granular IgG + C3 | Membranous nephropathy |
| Mesangial + capillary IgG/IgM/C3 | MPGN |
| C3 dominant (scant Ig) | C3 glomerulopathy (C3GN, dense deposit disease) |
| Kappa or lambda restricted (monoclonal) | AL amyloidosis, monoclonal Ig deposition disease |
Key Diagnoses Established by IF:
- Membranous nephropathy: Granular IgG (and IgG4 subclass) + C3, subepithelial, peripheral capillary loop pattern
- IgA nephropathy: Dominant/co-dominant mesangial IgA; IgG and C3 variable
- Anti-GBM disease (Goodpasture): Linear IgG (and C3) along entire GBM
- Lupus nephritis (Class IV): Full-house; IgG, IgA, IgM, C3, C1q all positive (C1q is characteristically strong)
- ANCA vasculitis: Pauci-immune (no Ig deposits despite severe injury)
- C3 glomerulopathy: C3 dominant without Ig (distinguishes from MPGN type I)
- Amyloidosis: Congo red fluorescence under polarised light (apple-green birefringence); IF with anti-amyloid A or anti-kappa/lambda for typing
PLA2R and THSD7A on IF: In primary membranous nephropathy, IgG4-dominant staining and PLA2R positivity confirm primary (idiopathic) membranous nephropathy.
Electron Microscopy (EM)
Technique: Glutaraldehyde-fixed tissue; osmium tetroxide post-fixation; epoxy resin embedding; 90 nm ultrathin sections; transmission EM (TEM). EM provides nanometre-scale resolution.
Key EM Findings and Diagnoses:
1. Electron-Dense Deposits (Immune Complexes) - Location Determines Diagnosis:
| Location | Disease |
|---|
| Subepithelial (between podocytes and GBM outer surface) | Membranous nephropathy; post-infectious GN (hump-shaped) |
| Subendothelial (between endothelium and GBM inner surface) | Lupus nephritis class III/IV; MPGN type I; proliferative GN |
| Mesangial | IgA nephropathy; lupus class II; MPGN |
| Intramembranous (within GBM) | Dense deposit disease (MPGN type II): highly electron-dense "sausage-like" deposits transforming GBM |
| Combined (subendothelial + subepithelial + mesangial) | Lupus nephritis class IV |
2. Podocyte Foot Process Effacement (Fusion):
- Minimal change disease (MCD): Complete (global, >90%) foot process effacement with no deposits; normal GBM; EM is essential for diagnosis since LM is near-normal
- Focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS): Diffuse (not focal) foot process effacement; microvillous transformation; no deposits
- Membranous nephropathy: Also shows foot process effacement + subepithelial deposits
3. GBM Abnormalities:
- Thin basement membrane disease: GBM uniformly thin (<200 nm; normal >300 nm) - benign familial haematuria
- Alport syndrome: GBM irregular thickening with lamellation ("basket-weave" appearance) and thinning; collagen IV α3α4α5 network disruption
4. Fibrillary Deposits:
- Amyloidosis: Randomly arranged, non-branching fibrils, 8-12 nm diameter; in mesangium and GBM
- Fibrillary GN: Randomly arranged fibrils, 16-24 nm diameter; IgG and C3 deposits
- Immunotactoid GN: Organised microtubular structures, 30-50 nm diameter, often parallel arrangement
5. Viral Inclusions:
- HIV-associated nephropathy (HIVAN): Tubuloreticular inclusions (TRI) in endothelial cells (induced by interferon); also seen in lupus nephritis
- Polyomavirus (BK) nephropathy: Intranuclear viral particles in tubular cells; EM diagnostic
6. Organised Deposits:
- Cryoglobulinaemic GN: Subendothelial "fingerprint" deposits (curved parallel fibrils with periodicity)
- Lupus: Fingerprint/tubuloreticular deposits (pathognomonic for lupus vs other MPGN patterns) + TRI
Summary Table - Combined IF + EM Approach:
| Disease | IF | EM |
|---|
| Minimal change | Negative | Diffuse podocyte foot process effacement only |
| FSGS | Negative or IgM/C3 (non-specific) | Diffuse FPE; no deposits |
| Membranous | IgG + C3 granular, subepithelial | Subepithelial electron-dense deposits; "spike and dome" |
| IgA nephropathy | IgA dominant mesangial | Mesangial dense deposits |
| Lupus class IV | Full house | Subendothelial + mesangial + subepithelial; TRI |
| Anti-GBM | Linear IgG | No deposits; GBM disruption |
| ANCA vasculitis | Negative (pauci-immune) | No deposits; fibrinoid necrosis |
| Amyloidosis | Congo red+; may show specific component | 8-12 nm random fibrils |
| DDD/C3GN | C3 dominant | Intramembranous (DDD) or mesangial/subendothelial (C3GN) |
Q4c: Paris System for Reporting Urinary Cytology
The Paris System for Reporting Urinary Cytology (TPS) was developed in 2013 (published 2016) to standardise the reporting of urine cytology specimens, focused on the primary goal: detection of high-grade urothelial carcinoma (HGUC).
Rationale
- Urine cytology is excellent at detecting HGUC (sensitivity ~80%) but poor for low-grade lesions (sensitivity ~30%)
- Previous inconsistent terminology led to management ambiguity
- TPS creates a standardised, reproducible reporting system analogous to Bethesda (thyroid/cervical)
Specimen Adequacy
- Adequate: >10 well-preserved urothelial cells per 10 HPF (for voided urine)
- Instrumented specimens (catheter, barbotage, wash): Generally considered adequate regardless of cellularity
- Unsatisfactory: <10 cells or heavy obscuring blood/inflammation
Paris System Diagnostic Categories
| Category | HGUC Risk | Management |
|---|
| Nondiagnostic (ND) / Unsatisfactory | Low | Repeat specimen |
| Negative for High-Grade Urothelial Carcinoma (NHGUC) | Low (<10%) | Routine surveillance |
| Atypical Urothelial Cells (AUC) | Intermediate (~20%) | Repeat cytology / cystoscopy |
| Suspicious for High-Grade Urothelial Carcinoma (SHGUC) | High (~70%) | Cystoscopy + biopsy |
| High-Grade Urothelial Carcinoma (HGUC) | Very high (>90%) | Cystoscopy + biopsy + treatment |
| Low-Grade Urothelial Neoplasm (LGUN) | (Low-grade lesion) | Cystoscopy (optional for monitoring) |
| Other Malignancy (primary or secondary) | - | As appropriate |
Cytomorphological Criteria
Normal / Benign Urothelial Cells (NHGUC):
- Superficial (umbrella) cells: large, multinucleated, abundant cytoplasm
- Intermediate urothelial cells: moderate N:C ratio
- No nuclear hyperchromasia or irregular nuclear contour
High-Grade Urothelial Carcinoma (HGUC) - Criteria (all 4 should be present for definitive diagnosis):
- High nuclear-to-cytoplasmic (N:C) ratio: N:C ≥0.7
- Hyperchromasia: Dark, irregular nuclear chromatin
- Irregular nuclear contours: Thickened, irregular nuclear membrane
- Any degree of nuclear abnormality: Mitoses, prominent nucleoli (secondary criteria)
Atypical Urothelial Cells (AUC):
- Cells with some features of HGUC but insufficient for definitive diagnosis
- N:C ratio 0.5-0.7, mild hyperchromasia
- Often reactive, instrumentation-related, or suspicious
Low-Grade Urothelial Neoplasm (LGUN):
- Papillary clusters (papillary urothelial neoplasm of low malignant potential / low-grade papillary urothelial carcinoma)
- Increased cellularity, papillary architecture
- Mild nuclear enlargement and crowding
- Reported as LGUN rather than HGUC - indicates presence of a low-grade papillary lesion
Ancillary Testing
- FISH (UroVysion): Detects gains of chromosomes 3, 7, 17 and loss of 9p21 (CDKN2A); improves sensitivity for HGUC detection; especially useful in AUC category
- Immunocytochemistry: p53, CK20 overexpression, CD44 loss in HGUC
- NMP22 (Nuclear Matrix Protein 22): Quantitative marker; elevated in bladder cancer
Clinical Applications
- Surveillance of known urothelial carcinoma (post-resection)
- Haematuria workup
- Monitoring patients with risk factors (smoking, occupational exposure, cyclophosphamide)
- Diagnosis of carcinoma in situ (CIS): flat HGUC not visible endoscopically
Q4d: Molecular Profiling of Breast Cancers and Prognosis
Molecular profiling has transformed breast cancer from a histological diagnosis into a molecularly-defined set of distinct diseases with different prognoses and treatment strategies.
Intrinsic Molecular Subtypes (Perou et al., 2000; Sorlie et al., 2003)
Gene expression profiling (microarray) identified four main intrinsic subtypes:
| Subtype | Markers | Frequency | Grade | Prognosis | Treatment |
|---|
| Luminal A | ER+, PR+, HER2-, Ki67 low (<20%) | 40-50% | Low | Best | Endocrine therapy alone |
| Luminal B | ER+, PR+/-, HER2+ or HER2- with Ki67 high (≥20%) | 20-30% | Intermediate-high | Intermediate | Endocrine ± chemotherapy ± HER2-targeted |
| HER2-enriched | ER-, PR-, HER2+ | 10-15% | High | Poor (pre-targeted therapy) | Anti-HER2 + chemotherapy |
| Triple-negative (TNBC) / Basal-like | ER-, PR-, HER2- | 15-20% | High | Poor overall; subset responds to chemo | Chemotherapy ± immunotherapy ± PARP inhibitor |
Surrogate IHC Classification (Clinical Approximation)
- Since gene expression profiling is not universally available, IHC surrogates are used:
- ER (Allred score or H-score; ≥1% nuclear staining = positive)
- PR (≥1% nuclear staining)
- HER2 (FISH/ISH for amplification; IHC 3+ = positive; 2+ requires FISH)
- Ki67 (proliferation index; cutoff varies by guideline: 14-20%)
Multigene Assays for Prognostication
1. Oncotype DX (Genomic Health)
- 21-gene recurrence score (RS) assay
- Validated in ER+, HER2-, node-negative (and node-positive) breast cancer
- RS 0-17: Low risk; endocrine therapy alone (TAILORx trial)
- RS 18-30: Intermediate risk; endocrine ± chemo (age/menopausal status guides)
- RS ≥31: High risk; chemo + endocrine therapy
- Genes measured: proliferation (Ki67, STK15, Survivin, CCNB1, MYBL2), invasion (MMP11, CTSL2), HER2 (GRB7, HER2), oestrogen (ER, PR, BCL2, SCUBE2), CD68
2. MammaPrint (Agendia)
- 70-gene expression signature (Amsterdam signature)
- MINDACT trial: 46% of patients classified as high clinical / low genomic risk could safely forgo chemotherapy
- Result: Low genomic risk vs High genomic risk
- FDA-cleared; requires fresh/frozen tissue (now FFPE version available)
3. Prosigna (PAM50)
- 50-gene assay classifying tumours into Luminal A, Luminal B, HER2-enriched, Basal-like subtypes
- Also provides Risk of Recurrence (ROR) score
- Validated in postmenopausal ER+ patients for distant recurrence
4. EndoPredict (EPclin)
- 12-gene assay + tumour size + nodal status = EPclin score
- Predicts late distant recurrence (>5 years)
5. Breast Cancer Index (BCI)
- Predicts benefit from extended endocrine therapy (>5 years)
- HOXB13:IL17BR ratio + proliferation genes
Key Molecular Alterations and Their Prognostic/Predictive Significance
| Alteration | Prevalence | Significance |
|---|
| ESR1 mutation | Acquired in 20-40% of metastatic ER+ tumours | Endocrine resistance; targetable with elacestrant (oral SERD) |
| PIK3CA mutation | 40% of HR+ cancers | PI3K pathway; targetable with alpelisib (+ fulvestrant) |
| PTEN loss | ~25% of TNBC | PI3K pathway activation |
| BRCA1/2 mutation | ~5% germline; somatic in TNBC | Olaparib/talazoparib (PARP inhibitors); platinum sensitivity |
| HER2 amplification | 15-20% | Trastuzumab, pertuzumab, T-DM1, tucatinib, trastuzumab deruxtecan |
| HER2-low (IHC 1+ or 2+/FISH-) | ~55% of HER2- | Trastuzumab deruxtecan (T-DXd) - new category; ADC therapy |
| CCND1 amplification | 20% of Luminal | CDK4/6 inhibitor sensitivity (palbociclib, ribociclib, abemaciclib) |
| RB1 loss | ~20% of TNBC | CDK4/6 inhibitor resistance |
| TP53 mutation | >80% of TNBC; ~30% of HER2+ | Poor prognosis |
| MYC amplification | ~15% | Poor prognosis |
| FGFR1/2 amplification | ~10% of Luminal B | Targetable (erdafitinib, futibatinib) |
TNBC Subtyping (Lehmann Classification)
TNBC is heterogeneous; Lehmann identified 6 subtypes (2011, revised 4 subtypes 2016):
- BL1 (Basal-like 1): Cell cycle/DNA damage response genes; responds to platinum/PARP inhibitors
- BL2 (Basal-like 2): EGFR signalling; growth factor receptor pathways
- M (Mesenchymal): EMT, stemness; PI3K/mTOR pathway
- LAR (Luminal androgen receptor): AR expression; responds to androgen receptor antagonists (enzalutamide)
- Immunotherapy (pembrolizumab) is approved for PD-L1+ TNBC (CPS ≥10) and high-risk early TNBC
Tumour Mutational Burden (TMB) and MSI
- High TMB (≥10 mut/Mb): Predicts response to pembrolizumab (tumour-agnostic FDA approval)
- MSI-H: Rare in breast cancer (~1-2%); immunotherapy responsive
- NTRK fusions: Rare (~0.5%); respond to larotrectinib/entrectinib
Prognostic Summary
- Best prognosis: Luminal A (ER+, PR high, HER2-, low Ki67) - 10-year survival >90%
- Intermediate: Luminal B
- HER2-enriched: Dramatically improved with targeted therapy; pCR to neoadjuvant anti-HER2 + chemo = excellent long-term outcome
- TNBC/Basal: Most aggressive; 5-year survival ~70-75% for early disease but drops sharply in metastatic; subset of BRCA-mutated and PD-L1+ patients benefit from targeted/immunotherapy
- Late recurrence is characteristic of ER+ tumours (can recur >10-20 years later); TNBC and HER2+ recurrences occur early (within 5 years)
Sources consulted: Braunwald's Heart Disease (textbook library); Robbins and Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease; WHO Classification of Tumours: Soft Tissue and Bone (5th ed.); WHO Classification of Tumours: Digestive System; Paris System for Reporting Urinary Cytology (2nd ed., 2022); ASCO/CAP guidelines; Perou CM et al. Nature 2000; Sorlie T et al. PNAS 2003; Fearon ER & Vogelstein B, Cell 1990.