Here is a thorough, well-structured explanation of polycyclic landforms:
Polycyclic Landforms
1. Conceptual Foundation: The Cycle of Erosion
To understand polycyclic landforms, one must first grasp W.M. Davis's Cycle of Erosion (1899), also called the Geographical Cycle or Geomorphic Cycle.
Davis proposed that a newly uplifted landmass passes through an ordered sequence of erosional stages:
| Stage | Characteristics |
|---|
| Youth | Rapid incision, V-shaped valleys, waterfalls, steep gradients, little floodplain |
| Maturity | Maximum relief, interlocking spurs removed, broad valleys, lateral erosion begins |
| Old Age | Near-flat peneplain, wide meanders, low gradients, monadnocks (residual hills) |
The end product, if the cycle runs to completion undisturbed, is a peneplain - an almost featureless, gently undulating plain eroded close to base level (sea level). The three controlling variables are structure (rock type and arrangement), process (erosional agents), and stage/time.
2. What are Polycyclic Landforms?
Polycyclic landforms (also written as polycyclical or multicyclic landforms) are landscapes that bear the imprints of two or more incomplete cycles of erosion, each superimposed on the remnants of the previous one.
"Landscapes that show evidence of more than one cycle of erosion are termed polycyclical." - Wikipedia, Cycle of Erosion
The Trigger: Rejuvenation
A single, uninterrupted erosion cycle rarely completes itself because the landscape is periodically disturbed by:
- Tectonic uplift - The land surface is raised relative to base level, steepening river gradients
- Eustatic sea level fall - Global sea level drops (e.g., during glacial periods), effectively lowering the base level
- Isostatic rebound - Land rises after removal of ice sheet weight (post-glacial uplift)
- Climate change - Changes in precipitation and runoff alter erosional energy
- River capture - A more energetic river pirates a neighboring catchment, increasing discharge and erosive power
Any of these events rejuvenates the landscape - rivers re-acquire erosive energy and begin incising downward again, initiating a new, younger cycle while the features of the older cycle survive in the landscape as elevated remnants.
The result is a landscape where old features (peneplain remnants, wide valley floors, graded terraces) co-exist with young features (gorges, waterfalls, incised meanders, knickpoints) - this is the hallmark of polycyclicity.
3. Key Polycyclic Landforms and Processes
A. River Terraces
River terraces are the most characteristic and widespread polycyclic landform.
Formation:
- During an earlier cycle, a river erodes laterally and creates a broad, flat valley floor (floodplain or strath)
- Rejuvenation causes the river to incise vertically, cutting downward into the old valley floor
- The old valley floor is left stranded as a flat-topped bench above the new river level - a terrace
- If rejuvenation occurs again, a second (lower) terrace forms, leaving the first terrace even higher
- Repeated uplift events produce a staircase of terraces at successively lower elevations
Types:
- Paired terraces: Matching terraces at the same elevation on both sides of the valley - indicate rapid, symmetric incision. These are polycyclic terraces.
- Unpaired terraces: Terraces at different elevations on opposite banks - indicate slower, lateral migration during incision (non-cyclic terraces).
- Strath terraces: Terraces cut into bedrock, then covered by a thin alluvial veneer. Each strath represents one cycle of lateral erosion followed by renewed incision.
Examples:
- Thames Valley terraces, England: The River Thames exhibits a well-documented staircase of seven terraces (e.g., Boyn Hill Terrace, Lynch Hill Terrace, Taplow Terrace, Floodplain Terrace) formed during successive Pleistocene glacial-interglacial cycles. Each terrace records a phase of lateral widening followed by incision triggered by base level fall during glaciation.
- Rhine Valley terraces, Germany: Multiple terrace levels record repeated Quaternary uplift of the Rhenish Massif combined with Pleistocene sea level changes.
- Yellow River (Huang He) terraces, China: Multiple terrace levels record tectonic uplift of the Tibetan Plateau margin and Quaternary climate-driven incision episodes.
B. Peneplain Remnants and Erosion Surfaces
If an old peneplain is uplifted and a new cycle begins, rivers incise into it. The remnants of the original flat surface survive on interfluves and plateaux as summit surfaces or accordant summits.
Multiple erosion surfaces at different altitudes in the same region indicate multiple cycles:
| Surface Level | Interpretation |
|---|
| Highest (oldest) | First cycle peneplain, most uplifted |
| Intermediate | Second cycle erosion surface |
| Lowest (youngest) | Most recent, closest to current base level |
Examples:
- Appalachian Mountains, USA: W.M. Davis himself used the Appalachians as the classic example of polycyclicity. The broad, accordant summit surfaces at about 1,000 m are interpreted as remnants of an ancient Cretaceous peneplain (the "Schooley Peneplain"). Rivers subsequently re-incised this surface as the region was gently uplifted, creating the current ridge-and-valley topography. A lower erosion surface (the "Harrisburg Surface" at ~150-300 m) represents a second, incomplete cycle.
- Scottish Highlands, UK: Geomorphologists have identified up to three or four planation surfaces at different altitudes (e.g., the "High Plateau," "Main Plateau," and lower valley surfaces), each representing an ancient erosion surface that was uplifted and dissected.
- Western Ghats, India: The broad, flat-topped summit plateaux of the Deccan plateau surface, standing high above deeply incised river gorges cutting seaward, represent classic polycyclic relief - the plateau is a remnant of an older cycle; the gorges are the product of the new cycle triggered by rifting and uplift of the Western Ghats escarpment.
C. Incised (Entrenched) Meanders
In old age, rivers develop wide, sweeping meanders across a flat floodplain. When rejuvenation occurs, the river cannot escape its meander pattern - it is locked into the curves by the surrounding terrain - but begins to cut vertically downward. The result is a deep gorge in the shape of a meander.
These are called incised or entrenched meanders and are a spectacular polycyclic landform - old-age meander geometry carved into young-stage deep valleys.
Examples:
- Goosenecks of the San Juan River, Utah, USA: One of the finest examples. The San Juan River has incised over 300 m into the Colorado Plateau, yet retains its mature meander loops almost perfectly. This occurred because the Colorado Plateau was uplifted gently while the river maintained its meandering course.
- Moselle (Mosel) River meanders, Germany/Luxembourg: The deeply incised meanders of the Moselle are polycyclic - formed during the Tertiary on a near-flat surface, then deeply entrenched following tectonic uplift of the Rhenish Massif in the Quaternary.
- Dee and Wye valleys, Wales/England: Classic incised meanders carved during post-glacial rejuvenation.
D. Knickpoints and Waterfalls
A knickpoint is a sharp break in the longitudinal profile of a river - a sudden steepening, often marked by a waterfall or rapid. It represents the boundary between the old, graded profile and the new, actively incising reach triggered by rejuvenation.
Knickpoints migrate upstream over time as the river erodes headward. If rejuvenation has occurred multiple times, multiple knickpoints at different positions along the river profile record each event.
Examples:
- Afon Cynfal, Wales: Described as a good example of "polycyclic relief" (Howe and Thomas, 1963). The river responds to at least three distinct base levels, with two main platform levels at 400-500 m and 200 m, producing a series of gorges and waterfalls.
- Victoria Falls (Zambezi River, Zambia/Zimbabwe): The Zambezi's profile shows multiple knickpoints and gorge systems, with successive gorges (1st through 7th gorge downstream) each representing an earlier position of the waterfall, recording episodic downcutting related to tectonic and climatic rejuvenation.
- Niagara Falls, USA/Canada: The falls are a knickpoint migrating upstream (at ~1 m/year historically), with a gorge downstream representing the upstream migration of the knickpoint since postglacial times.
E. Raised Beaches and Coastal Terraces
In coastal settings, polycyclicity is expressed through raised beaches - former wave-cut platforms and beach deposits now elevated above present sea level due to:
- Isostatic uplift (land rising after ice unloading)
- Eustatic sea level fall (past interglacial high sea levels, now stranded)
Multiple raised beaches at different elevations indicate multiple high sea level stands or uplift events.
Examples:
- Scottish coastline, UK: Raised beaches at 8 m, 15 m, and 30 m above present sea level record successive postglacial isostatic uplift stages as Scotland "bounced back" after the retreat of the Pleistocene ice sheet. The "Main Postglacial Shoreline" (about 7-8 m) and the "Main Lateglacial Shoreline" (~15 m) are the best documented.
- Pacific coast of Chile and Peru: Multiple marine terraces step upward from the coast, each recording a past interglacial sea level high combined with ongoing tectonic uplift. Some sequences span the entire Quaternary.
- Mediterranean coastlines: Raised beaches record both Pleistocene interglacial sea level highs and ongoing tectonic activity.
F. Gorges and Canyon-within-Canyon
When rejuvenation is sudden and intense, a deep gorge may be cut rapidly within an older, broader valley. This produces a gorge-within-a-valley or canyon-within-a-canyon cross-section.
Examples:
- Grand Canyon, Colorado Plateau, USA: Arguably the world's most famous polycyclic landscape. The broad upper canyon walls represent older cycles of erosion across the Plateau surface; the Inner Gorge (Vishnu schist) represents much more recent, rapid incision by the Colorado River following renewed Quaternary uplift. The Colorado Plateau's flat surface is a remnant of the older cycle; the canyon is the new cycle.
- Indus, Brahmaputra, and Sutlej gorges, Himalayas: These rivers were graded across a gentler landscape before the Himalayan uplift began. As the mountains rose, the rivers maintained their courses (antecedent drainage) and cut some of the world's deepest gorges - the Indus gorge at Nanga Parbat reaches over 5,000 m depth. The high, broad valley shoulders represent the pre-uplift surface; the gorges represent the new cycle.
4. Monadnocks - Polycyclic Survivors
A monadnock (from Mount Monadnock, New Hampshire) is a residual hill of resistant rock that rises above a peneplain because it resisted erosion. In a polycyclic landscape, monadnocks from an earlier cycle may survive as prominent hills after the second cycle has further eroded the surrounding surface.
Examples:
- Inselbergs of Africa (e.g., Uluru/Ayers Rock, Australia): Some inselbergs are considered polycyclic - they survived multiple erosion cycles because their rock is exceptionally resistant (quartzite, granite) while surrounding softer rock was planed away.
- Sugarloaf Mountain (Pão de Açúcar), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: A classic inselberg/monadnock rising abruptly from a near-flat coastal plain, interpreted as a survivor of ancient erosion cycles acting on the Brazilian Shield.
5. Schematic Illustration of a Polycyclic Valley
Elevation
|
| [OLD PENEPLAIN REMNANT] [OLD PENEPLAIN REMNANT]
|___________↓___________________________________↓__________
| Knickpoint Wide valley
| ↓ waterfall (1st cycle)
| [River Terrace] [River Terrace]
| _____________ ______________
| ↓ new incision ↓
| [Deep gorge - 2nd cycle]
| ~~~river~~~
|_______________________________________________ Base Level
The old wide valley floors become terraces; the flat uplands are remnants of the earlier peneplain; the gorge and knickpoint represent the active, younger cycle.
6. King's Pediplanation Cycle: An Alternative View
Lester King (1953) proposed an alternative to Davis's cycle, arguing that landscape evolution in arid/semi-arid regions proceeds through pediplanation - the parallel retreat of slopes leaving behind gently graded pediments that coalesce into a pediplain. Polycyclicity in King's model produces multiple pediment levels separated by scarps, rather than the river terraces and peneplains of the Davisian model.
King argued that remnants of multiple pediplain cycles could be identified globally, each representing an episode of landscape lowering separated by uplift.
7. Critical Evaluation
Strengths of the polycyclic concept:
- Provides a logical framework for interpreting complex landscapes with multiple generations of landforms
- Widely used in denudation chronology (dating the history of landscape development)
- Supported by evidence from terraces, knickpoints, and erosion surfaces worldwide
Limitations and criticisms:
- Davis assumed rapid uplift followed by complete stillstand - unrealistic, as uplift and erosion overlap continuously
- The idea of discrete, complete cycles is idealized; real landscapes show continuous, overlapping processes
- Climate change and lithological variation create similar effects to rejuvenation without needing tectonic uplift
- Modern process geomorphology (dynamic equilibrium theory, stream power models) challenges the cyclic framework but does not invalidate the observation that landscapes preserve multiple generations of landforms
Summary Table: Polycyclic Landforms at a Glance
| Landform | Polycyclic Signal | Classic Example |
|---|
| River terraces | Staircase of old valley floors | Thames Valley, Rhine Valley |
| Peneplain remnants | High, flat summit surfaces | Appalachian Schooley Peneplain |
| Incised meanders | Old-age meanders in deep gorge | Goosenecks (San Juan), Moselle |
| Knickpoints / Waterfalls | Break in river profile | Victoria Falls gorges, Afon Cynfal |
| Canyon-within-canyon | Gorge cut into broader valley | Grand Canyon Inner Gorge |
| Raised beaches | Old shorelines above sea level | Scottish coast, Chile terraces |
| Inselbergs / Monadnocks | Resistant hills above planed surface | Uluru, Sugarloaf Mountain |
| Antecedent gorges | Deep gorge through rising mountain | Indus, Brahmaputra gorges |
In essence, polycyclic landforms are geological "palimpsests" - landscapes written over multiple times, with earlier chapters still legible in the form of high terraces, hanging valleys, flat-topped hills, and gorges. Each interruption of the erosion cycle by uplift, sea level change, or climate shift adds a new chapter to the landscape's story, and the geomorphologist's task is to read them in sequence.