I now have comprehensive information from multiple textbooks. Let me compile the complete hernia viva Q&A.
Hernia - Comprehensive Viva Q&A
1. DEFINITION & BASICS
Q: Define hernia.
A: A hernia is a protrusion of a viscus (or part of a viscus) through an abnormal opening in the wall of the cavity that normally contains it.
Q: What are the essential parts of a hernia?
A: Every hernia has three components:
- Sac - a peritoneal diverticulum composed of mouth, neck, body, and fundus
- Contents - what is inside the sac (omentum, small bowel, large bowel, bladder, ovary, etc.)
- Coverings - the layers of the abdominal wall that cover the sac
Q: What is the most common content of a hernia?
A: Omentum (epiplocele). Small bowel is the next most common.
2. ANATOMY
Q: What are the boundaries of Hesselbach's (Hesselbachs) triangle?
A:
- Medially - lateral border of rectus abdominis
- Inferiorly - inguinal ligament
- Laterally - inferior epigastric vessels
Direct inguinal hernias pass through this triangle.
Q: What are the boundaries of the femoral canal?
A (from S. Das):
- Superoanteriorly - inguinal ligament
- Inferoposteriorly - pubic ramus and pectineus muscle
- Medially - lacunar (Gimbernat's) ligament
- Laterally - femoral vein
Q: What is the difference between the deep and superficial inguinal rings?
A:
- Deep inguinal ring: opening in the transversalis fascia, lies lateral to the inferior epigastric vessels
- Superficial inguinal ring: opening in the external oblique aponeurosis, lies just above and medial to the pubic tubercle
Q: What is the inguinal canal?
A: A 4 cm oblique passage in the lower abdominal wall running from deep inguinal ring (laterally) to superficial inguinal ring (medially). It runs parallel to and just above the medial half of the inguinal ligament.
- Anterior wall: external oblique aponeurosis (and internal oblique laterally)
- Posterior wall: transversalis fascia (and conjoint tendon medially)
- Roof: arching fibers of internal oblique and transversus abdominis
- Floor: inguinal ligament and lacunar ligament medially
3. INDIRECT vs DIRECT INGUINAL HERNIA
Q: Differentiate indirect from direct inguinal hernia.
| Feature | Indirect | Direct |
|---|
| Path | Through deep inguinal ring, along canal, out superficial ring | Directly through posterior wall of inguinal canal (Hesselbach's triangle) |
| Relation to epigastric vessels | Lateral | Medial |
| Type | Congenital or acquired | Always acquired |
| Neck | Narrow - high risk of strangulation | Wide - low risk of strangulation |
| Descent into scrotum | Common | Rare |
| Age | Younger patients | Older patients |
| Sac relation to cord | Within spermatic cord | Medial to cord |
| Zieman's test finger | Index finger | Middle finger |
(Bailey & Love; General Anatomy - Thieme Atlas)
Q: Which is more common - direct or indirect inguinal hernia?
A: Indirect inguinal hernia is more common (accounts for ~60% of inguinal hernias). Overall, inguinal hernia is the most common hernia.
Q: Why is the right side more common for indirect inguinal hernia?
A: Because the right testis descends later than the left; the processus vaginalis closes later on the right, leaving a patent processus for longer and increasing risk.
4. CLINICAL TYPES / COMPLICATIONS
Q: What are the clinical types of hernia?
- Reducible hernia - Contents can be returned into the abdominal cavity
- Irreducible (Incarcerated) hernia - Contents cannot be returned; no blood supply interference yet
- Obstructed hernia - Irreducible + intestinal obstruction; no interference with blood supply (yet)
- Strangulated hernia - Irreducible + obstruction + arrest of blood supply to contents - a surgical emergency
- Inflamed hernia - Rare; contents become inflamed (appendix, Meckel's, salpinx); not tense, no intestinal obstruction
(S. Das, Manual on Clinical Surgery)
Q: What is strangulation? How is it diagnosed?
A: Strangulation = blood supply to hernial contents is cut off. Diagnosis: hernia is irreducible, extremely tense, tender, no impulse on coughing, followed by features of intestinal obstruction. Patient is toxic, dehydrated, febrile. - Mulholland & Greenfield's Surgery
Q: Is intestinal obstruction always present in strangulation?
A: No. Intestinal obstruction may NOT be present in:
- Omentocele (only fat content)
- Richter's hernia (only part of bowel wall strangulated)
- Littre's hernia (Meckel's diverticulum involved)
Q: Which hernia has the highest risk of strangulation?
A: Femoral hernia - because of its narrow, rigid neck bounded by the lacunar ligament. All femoral hernias should be repaired electively. - Bailey & Love
5. SPECIAL/EPONYMOUS HERNIAS
Q: What is Richter's hernia?
A: Only a portion of the circumference (antimesenteric wall) of the bowel is strangulated in the hernial sac. Intestinal obstruction is absent until >50% of circumference is involved. Most commonly complicates femoral hernia. Dangerous because it mimics gastroenteritis and diagnosis is delayed. - S. Das; Yamada's GI
Q: What is Littre's hernia?
A: A hernia containing a Meckel's diverticulum in the sac.
Q: What is Maydl's hernia (Hernia-en-W)?
A: Two loops of bowel lie in the sac with the connecting loop remaining inside the abdomen. The connecting loop undergoes retrograde strangulation first ("W" shape). The danger is that the abdominal loop is strangulated even though the loops in the sac appear viable - this is missed unless the abdomen is opened and the connecting loop inspected.
Q: What is a sliding hernia (hernia-en-glissade)?
A: A portion of extraperitoneal bowel (usually caecum on right, pelvic colon on left, or bladder on either side) slides down to form the wall of the hernial sac. The sac is not completely lined by peritoneum - the bowel forms part of the posterior wall. Important surgically: do not excise the sac without identifying this.
Q: What is a pantaloon hernia?
A: Both a direct and indirect hernia are present simultaneously on the same side, straddling the inferior epigastric vessels.
Q: What is Spigelian hernia?
A: A hernia through the linea semilunaris (lateral border of rectus), usually below the level of the umbilicus at the arcuate line. It is an interparietal hernia - between layers of the abdominal wall - and can be difficult to diagnose clinically.
Q: What is an obturator hernia?
A: Protrusion through the obturator canal. More common in elderly, thin women. Classic sign is Howship-Romberg sign - pain on the inner aspect of the thigh radiating to the knee due to compression of the obturator nerve.
6. FEMORAL HERNIA
Q: Why do femoral hernias have a higher risk of strangulation?
A: Because the femoral ring has rigid, unyielding boundaries - especially the sharp medial boundary formed by the lacunar (Gimbernat's) ligament.
Q: Where does a femoral hernia emerge superficially?
A: Through the saphenous opening (fossa ovalis), situated 1.5 inches below and lateral to the pubic tubercle. It then expands into the loose subcutaneous tissue and takes a retort shape.
Q: How do you distinguish a femoral hernia from an inguinal hernia clinically?
A:
- Femoral hernia lies below and lateral to the pubic tubercle
- Inguinal hernia lies above and medial to the pubic tubercle
Q: Why is femoral hernia more common in women?
A: Women have a broader pelvis, giving a larger femoral ring. - Thieme Atlas
7. EXAMINATION
Q: How do you examine for an inguinal hernia?
A:
- Inspect in standing position - visible swelling with cough impulse
- Reduce hernia if possible
- Invaginate scrotum to reach superficial inguinal ring; ask patient to cough - a hernia impulse is felt
- Press finger at deep inguinal ring (just above midpoint of inguinal ligament) - if hernia is controlled, it is indirect; if not, it is direct
- Assess tone of abdominal muscles (Malgaigne's bulgings test)
- Percussion: resonant = enterocele; dull = epiplocele
Q: What is Zieman's test?
A: The three fingers of the right hand are placed on the right inguinal region with:
- Index finger on the superficial inguinal ring
- Middle finger on the femoral canal
- Ring finger on the obturator foramen
Ask the patient to cough - impulse felt against index finger = inguinal hernia; middle finger = femoral hernia; ring finger = obturator hernia.
8. SURGICAL REPAIR
Q: What are the principles of hernia repair?
A:
- Reduce contents
- Excise sac (herniotomy)
- Repair/reinforce the defect (herniorrhaphy / hernioplasty)
Q: What is the Lichtenstein repair?
A: Tension-free flat polypropylene mesh repair of inguinal hernia, described by Lichtenstein in the 1980s. The mesh is sutured to the inguinal ligament inferiorly and to the conjoint tendon/internal oblique above, creating a tension-free reinforcement of the posterior wall. Currently the most widely performed open inguinal hernia repair globally. - Bailey & Love; Sabiston
Q: Why is tension-free repair preferred?
A: Tension at the repair site is a primary contributor to recurrence. Mesh bridges the defect without bringing tissues together under tension.
Q: What are the laparoscopic approaches for inguinal hernia?
A:
- TAPP - Transabdominal Preperitoneal Repair (enters peritoneal cavity, dissects preperitoneal space)
- TEP - Totally Extraperitoneal Repair (works entirely in preperitoneal space, does not enter peritoneum)
Q: When is surgery MANDATORY for hernia?
A: All femoral hernias, obstructed hernias, and strangulated hernias require surgery. Symptomatic or irreducible inguinal hernias should also be repaired.
Q: What is watchful waiting in inguinal hernia?
A: In asymptomatic inguinal hernias, watchful waiting is safe - approximately 10% per year cross over to surgery due to developing symptoms. - Bailey & Love
9. UMBILICAL & INCISIONAL HERNIA
Q: Define umbilical, paraumbilical and incisional hernia.
- True umbilical hernia: congenital, through the umbilical ring, common in infants - most close spontaneously by age 2-3 years
- Paraumbilical hernia: in adults, occurs just above or below the umbilicus through a weakness in the linea alba; more common in obese, multiparous women
- Incisional hernia: hernia through a previous surgical incision; caused by wound infection, poor closure, obesity, malnutrition, steroids
Q: What is the most common cause of incisional hernia?
A: Wound infection. Other causes: poor suture technique, malnutrition, obesity, chronic cough, steroids.
10. HIGH-YIELD MNEMONICS
Sac contents - common to rare: Omentum > Small bowel > Large bowel (caecum/sigmoid) > Bladder > Ovary/Fallopian tube
Femoral canal mnemonic (NAVY - lateral to medial): Nerve, Artery, Vein, Y-fronts (empty space = femoral canal)
Strangulation triad: Irreducible + No cough impulse + Tense & Tender
Sources: S. Das - Manual on Clinical Surgery 13th ed.; Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery 28th ed.; Thieme General Anatomy & Musculoskeletal Atlas; Mulholland & Greenfield's Surgery 7e; Sabiston Textbook of Surgery; Yamada's Textbook of Gastroenterology