Possible viva questions for a short case of CTEV / clubfoot
1. What is your diagnosis?
Congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV), also called congenital clubfoot.
Describe side involved, whether unilateral/bilateral, severity, rigidity, and whether it is primary idiopathic or syndromic.
2. What are the components of deformity?
Use CAVE:
- Cavus: high medial arch due to plantar-flexed first ray
- Adductus: forefoot adduction
- Varus: hindfoot inversion/varus
- Equinus: ankle plantar-flexion
This is also the order in which deformities are corrected by the Ponseti method.
3. Why is the foot called “clubfoot”?
Because the foot is turned inward and downward, resembling the shape of a golf club.
4. Is CTEV a positional deformity?
No. True CTEV is a structural, fixed deformity involving soft tissues, joints, and bones. It must be distinguished from a flexible positional foot deformity, which can be passively corrected.
5. How will you examine the child?
- Observe from front, side, and back.
- Determine laterality and severity.
- Look for CAVE components.
- Assess rigidity and passive correctability.
- Check calf wasting and foot size. The affected foot and calf are often smaller.
- Examine skin creases, especially medial and posterior creases.
- Assess dorsiflexion at ankle and hindfoot position.
- Check neurovascular status.
- Examine the spine for occult spinal dysraphism.
- Perform a full neurological examination.
- Look for associated anomalies, especially DDH and arthrogryposis.
6. What is the typical appearance in an untreated case?
- Small foot, heel elevated
- Forefoot adducted and supinated
- Hindfoot in varus
- Equinus at ankle
- Deep medial and posterior creases
- Prominent lateral border of foot
- Smaller calf on affected side
7. What is the difference between CTEV and metatarsus adductus?
| CTEV | Metatarsus adductus |
|---|
| Forefoot adduction with hindfoot varus and equinus | Forefoot adduction only |
| Rigid structural deformity | Often flexible |
| Heel is in varus | Heel is usually neutral |
| Ankle dorsiflexion limited due to equinus | Ankle dorsiflexion normal |
| Needs Ponseti casting if idiopathic clubfoot | Often observation/stretching |
8. Differentiate CTEV from congenital vertical talus.
- CTEV: hindfoot equinus and varus, forefoot adducted.
- Vertical talus: rigid rocker-bottom foot, hindfoot equinus with valgus, forefoot dorsiflexed and abducted, and a prominent talar head on the plantar-medial aspect.
9. What scoring systems are used?
- Pirani score: evaluates six clinical signs, each scored 0, 0.5, or 1. Total score is 0 to 6.
- Dimeglio score: grades severity and reducibility.
Pirani scoring is useful for documenting severity and monitoring response to serial casting.
10. Are radiographs necessary initially?
Usually
not in a typical newborn with idiopathic CTEV, because diagnosis is clinical and tarsal bones are incompletely ossified. Radiographs may be needed in atypical, resistant, recurrent, neglected, or syndromic cases.
POSNA guidance notes that initial radiographs are not commonly used for a clearly isolated clubfoot.
11. What are the associated conditions?
CTEV may be:
- Idiopathic, most common
- Syndromic, for example arthrogryposis and Larsen syndrome
- Neuromuscular, for example spina bifida or cerebral palsy
- Associated with congenital constriction bands
Bilateral, atypical, or rigid deformity should prompt a careful neurological and syndromic evaluation.
12. What is the management?
The standard treatment is the Ponseti method, started as early as possible after birth:
- Gentle manipulation
- Weekly above-knee plaster casts
- Correction in CAVE order
- Percutaneous Achilles tenotomy for residual equinus in most feet
- Foot-abduction brace to maintain correction
13. Explain the Ponseti sequence.
- Correct cavus first by elevating the first metatarsal and supinating the forefoot.
- Correct adduction and varus together by abducting the foot around the talar head.
- Correct equinus last, often with percutaneous Achilles tenotomy.
Never pronate the forefoot during correction, as this can worsen cavus and impede correction.
14. Why is the cast above knee?
An above-knee cast prevents knee movement and rotation, helping maintain correction and preventing slippage.
15. When is Achilles tenotomy done?
After correction of cavus, adduction, and varus, if residual equinus remains and adequate foot abduction has been achieved. It is usually a percutaneous procedure followed by a final cast.
16. What brace is used after correction?
A foot-abduction brace, commonly the Denis Browne bar with shoes attached in external rotation.
Typical positioning:
- Affected foot: about 60-70 degrees external rotation
- Unaffected foot in unilateral CTEV: about 30-40 degrees external rotation
- Both feet: around 60-70 degrees external rotation in bilateral disease
17. What is the brace protocol?
Commonly:
- Full-time wear for about the first 3 months after final correction
- Then during sleep and naps until approximately 4-5 years of age
Exact protocol can vary by treating unit.
18. What is the commonest cause of relapse?
Poor compliance with the foot-abduction brace. Parents must be counselled that casting achieves correction, but bracing maintains it. POSNA reports high initial correction rates with Ponseti treatment, while recurrence remains common if bracing is discontinued.
POSNA clubfoot review
19. How does relapse present?
- Recurrent equinus
- Dynamic forefoot supination during walking
- Recurrent adduction or heel varus
- Difficulty wearing normal shoes
20. How do you manage relapse?
Depends on age and deformity:
- Repeat Ponseti manipulation and casting for early relapse
- Repeat Achilles tenotomy or lengthening if equinus persists
- Tibialis anterior tendon transfer for dynamic supination in an ambulatory child, after obtaining a supple plantigrade foot
- More extensive surgery only for resistant, rigid, or neglected cases
21. What is dynamic supination?
During gait, the forefoot supinates in swing phase and the child bears weight on the lateral border of the foot. It suggests overactivity of tibialis anterior and may require tibialis anterior tendon transfer after correction of fixed deformity.
22. What are the indications for surgery?
Surgery is reserved for:
- Failure of properly performed Ponseti management
- Rigid resistant deformity
- Recurrent deformity not responding to recasting
- Neglected clubfoot in older children
- Selected syndromic or neuromuscular clubfoot
Extensive posteromedial release is generally avoided where possible because it can lead to a stiff, painful foot later.
23. What is the aim of treatment?
A painless, plantigrade, flexible, functional foot that can fit into normal footwear. The goal is not merely a cosmetically straight foot.
24. What should you tell the parents?
- Treatment should start early.
- Serial casting is highly effective.
- Tenotomy is commonly required and is a small procedure.
- Brace adherence is essential for years.
- Relapse can occur, but early recognition and recasting often work well.
- The affected foot and calf may remain smaller despite successful treatment.
High-yield closing statement for viva
“This child has CTEV characterized by CAVE deformity: cavus, forefoot adduction, hindfoot varus, and equinus. I will assess rigidity, Pirani score, associated neuromuscular or syndromic causes, and then manage with early Ponseti serial above-knee casting, correcting CAVE sequentially, followed by Achilles tenotomy for residual equinus and prolonged foot-abduction bracing to prevent relapse.”
Recent-evidence note: a 2024 network meta-analysis supports contemporary nonoperative Ponseti-based management for idiopathic clubfoot (PMID: 38015923).