I now have all the information needed from authoritative Forensic Medicine textbooks. Here is the complete answer:
In road traffic accidents, the moving head decelerates suddenly on impact, producing contrecoup lesions that are typically larger than the coup lesions. The contrecoup injury is located in relatively inaccessible portions. - Parikh's Textbook of Medical Jurisprudence, Forensic Medicine and Toxicology
-
Distinguishing fall from assault:
The pattern of coup vs. contrecoup injury helps determine whether the injury resulted from a fall (contrecoup > coup) or from a direct blow/assault (coup > contrecoup). In falls, contrecoup injuries are dominant; in blows, coup injuries are dominant. This is critical in road traffic accidents to determine mechanism.
-
Establishing manner and cause of death:
When a victim dies after a head injury, the presence of coup-contrecoup pattern at autopsy helps the forensic pathologist establish that death was due to mechanical trauma (blunt force), and not a spontaneous intracranial bleed or natural disease. This distinguishes homicide, accident, or self-inflicted injury.
-
Identifying the site and direction of impact:
Contrecoup lesions are almost always located in the frontal poles, temporal poles, and orbital surfaces of frontal lobes. Knowing this allows reconstruction of the direction of impact force - vital in court proceedings and accident reconstruction.
-
Legal implications - establishing assault:
A single blow to one side may produce devastating internal brain injury on the opposite side. An accused may claim "I only struck him once lightly," yet autopsy reveals severe contrecoup injury. This allows the forensic expert to corroborate or refute witness statements in court (as in Parikh's classic pub example above).
-
Assessment of negligence and liability:
In road traffic accident cases, the mechanism of coup-contrecoup injury can determine speed of impact, nature of collision, and degree of force involved, which is important for fixing criminal negligence or civil liability of the driver.