I now have comprehensive information from multiple authoritative sources. Let me compile the detailed answer.
Submental Intubation
Definition and Historical Background
Submental intubation (SMI) is a specialized airway management technique in which an endotracheal tube (ETT) is passed through the floor of the mouth and externalized via a small skin incision in the submental (under-chin) region. This keeps the oral and nasal cavities completely clear of the tube, allowing surgeons unobstructed access to the facial skeleton.
The technique was first described by Francisco Hernandez Altemir in 1986 and was published in the Journal of Maxillofacial Surgery. Since then, over 2,200 cases have been reported in the literature (systematic review, 1986-2018). It was further refined by Hwang et al., who popularized modifications to minimize complications.
Why is it Needed? The Airway Problem in Facial Surgery
In craniomaxillofacial (CMF) surgery, there is a fundamental conflict between the anaesthetist and the surgeon - both need the same space:
- Oral intubation (orotracheal) obstructs the mouth, preventing occlusion checks and intraoral work.
- Nasal intubation (nasotracheal) is contraindicated when nasal bones are fractured, when basilar skull fracture is suspected, or when nasal/NOE (naso-orbito-ethmoid) fractures need to be repaired.
- Tracheostomy is definitive but carries significant morbidity - early complication rate 6-8%, late complication rate up to 60% - including tracheal stenosis, tracheoesophageal fistula, voice changes, bleeding, stoma complications.
SMI elegantly resolves this by routing the tube out of the submental region entirely, freeing both the oral and nasal cavities.
Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition notes: "A tracheostomy is often placed because of difficulty with nasal endotracheal intubation and the need to check occlusion during fracture repair, which means oral intubation is not desirable. Alternatively, a submental intubation technique may be one that allows for the occlusion to be checked during fracture repair."
Anatomy
The submental triangle lies between the symphysis of the mandible, the hyoid bone, and the anterior bellies of the two digastric muscles. Key anatomical structures in the submental region and floor of the mouth include:
- Mylohyoid muscle - forms the muscular diaphragm of the floor of the mouth; must be perforated during the procedure
- Geniohyoid muscle - lies superior to mylohyoid
- Genioglossus muscle - must be avoided
- Wharton's duct (submandibular duct) - opens near the lingual frenulum; injury causes salivary fistula or mucocele
- Lingual nerve - runs medially; injury causes paresthesia/numbness of the tongue
- Sublingual gland - can be inadvertently injured
- Submental vessels (submental artery and vein) - branches of the facial artery/vein; care must be taken to avoid them
- The preferred passage is medial to the mandible, through a midline or paramedian path, to avoid the submandibular gland and facial vessels laterally.
Indications
From the largest systematic review (Goh et al., 2020, n=2,229 patients):
| Indication | Proportion |
|---|
| Maxillofacial trauma | 81% |
| Orthognathic surgery | 15% |
| Pathological disease (tumor, abscess) | 2% |
| Cosmetic surgery (rhinoplasty, facelift) | 1% |
Specific indications include:
- Panfacial fractures - multiple fractures of the facial skeleton (mandible, maxilla, zygoma, orbit, frontal bone) requiring intraoperative maxillomandibular fixation (MMF) to check dental occlusion
- Le Fort I, II, III fractures - when both nasal and oral access are needed
- Naso-orbito-ethmoid (NOE) fractures - nasotracheal route is blocked
- Mandible fractures - especially bilateral, symphyseal, or condylar fractures requiring MMF
- Orthognathic surgery (Le Fort I osteotomy, BSSO) - access to occlusion needed intraoperatively
- Skull base surgery - when neither nasal nor oral approach is suitable
- Rhinoplasty / facelift in selected cases
- Oral cancer surgery (OCSCC) - a listed option alongside tracheostomy per Bailey and Love's
Contraindications
Absolute:
- Need for prolonged postoperative mechanical ventilation (>24-48 hours) - tube must be converted to orotracheal or tracheostomy before extubation
- Active submental infection or cellulitis (Ludwig's angina, abscess in the submental area)
- Suspected deep floor-of-mouth pathology
Relative:
- History of keloid or hypertrophic scarring (cosmetic concern)
- Severe neurological deficits requiring long-term airway management
- Previous submental surgery or scarring
- Very short or obese neck with limited submental anatomy
- Need for multiple sequential maxillofacial procedures
- Patients requiring extensive postoperative suctioning
Technique (Step-by-Step)
Equipment Required
- Reinforced (armored/spiral-wound wire) ETT - size 7.0 or 7.5 (preferred - resists kinking) or standard PVC tube with pilot balloon
- No. 15 scalpel blade
- Curved mosquito or Kelly hemostat
- Wound dilators (from a percutaneous tracheostomy set) or artery forceps
- Scissors, needle driver, absorbable sutures
- Lubricant
Steps
Step 1 - Standard oral intubation first
The patient is first intubated via the standard orotracheal route using a reinforced ETT. General anaesthesia is induced. The tube position is confirmed by ETCO₂ and auscultation.
Step 2 - Marking the incision
A 1.5-2 cm skin incision is marked in the submental region, either:
- Paramedian (52% preferred per systematic review) - 1-2 cm lateral to the midline, in a skin crease for better cosmesis
- Median/midline (33%) - directly in the midline
The incision is placed about 2 cm behind the chin, between the symphysis menti and the hyoid bone.
Step 3 - Creating the skin incision
A 1.5-2 cm incision is made through skin and subcutaneous tissue down to the mylohyoid muscle.
Step 4 - Perforating the floor of mouth
A curved hemostat is introduced through the skin incision and advanced bluntly through:
- The subcutaneous tissue
- The mylohyoid muscle (the key layer)
- Into the floor of the mouth, immediately lingual to the mandibular alveolus
The tip of the hemostat becomes visible intraorally, medial to the mandible. The passage must remain medial to avoid the submandibular gland and facial vessels.
Step 5 - Passage of the tube
- The pilot balloon/cuff inflation line of the ETT is detached from the connector
- The proximal connector of the ETT is disconnected
- The circuit tubing is temporarily disconnected (brief apnea of approximately 30-60 seconds)
- The tube tip is grasped by the hemostat intraorally and pulled through the submental passage
- Alternatively (two-tube technique): a new tube is threaded through the submental tunnel and connected to the first tube intraorally, then pulled through
Step 6 - Reconnection and confirmation
- The tube is reconnected to the circuit via the submental route
- The pilot balloon is reconnected to allow cuff inflation
- Tube position is reconfirmed with ETCO₂ and chest auscultation
- The tube is secured to the skin at the exit wound with a suture or tape
Step 7 - Wound management at skin exit
The skin exit site is left loose or lightly sutured around the tube (not tightly, to allow respiration and to prevent pressure necrosis).
Mean time to complete: approximately 10 minutes (range 2-37 minutes).
One-Tube vs. Two-Tube Technique
- One-tube technique (84% preferred): the same oral ETT is manipulated through the submental tunnel - quicker, less risk of disconnection
- Two-tube technique (6%): a new armored tube is passed through the tunnel and connected to the oral ETT inside the mouth before exiting - allows use of a fresh, purpose-selected tube
Intraoperative Management
- The tube exit from the submental skin is draped into the surgical field
- The tube is passed over the chest and connected to the anaesthetic circuit
- Surgeons can now freely place MMF (intermaxillary fixation with arch bars or wires) and check occlusion without any airway obstruction
- The anesthesiologist monitors the tube carefully - the submental route creates a curve that must not kink; the reinforced ETT prevents this
- Suction via the tube may be slightly more difficult due to the curve
Extubation and Tube Reversal
At the end of surgery, reversal is straightforward:
- The tube is pulled back through the submental tunnel into the oral cavity
- The standard connector is replaced
- The tube is secured in the orotracheal position
- Standard extubation follows when the patient is awake and protective reflexes have returned
- The submental wound is irrigated and closed in layers (mylohyoid and subcutaneous tissue with absorbable sutures, skin with non-absorbable or absorbable sutures)
A 2024 study (
Mahajan et al., Craniomaxillofac Trauma Reconstr) described a novel safe extubation method for which the authors obtained copyright from the Government of India.
Complications
From the systematic review by Goh et al. (2020, n=2,229 patients), overall complication rate was 7%, with 93% of patients complication-free.
Intraoperative
| Complication | Notes |
|---|
| Right mainstem bronchus intubation | Tube advancement during passage; tube depth must be checked |
| Accidental extubation | Especially in children; tube must be secured |
| Excessive flexion of the tube | Prevented by reinforced tube |
| Venous bleeding | From submental vessels; usually minor |
| Difficult passage | Trismus, anatomical variation, obesity |
Postoperative
| Complication | Frequency |
|---|
| Superficial skin infection | Most common: 2.4% (n=54/2229) |
| Hypertrophic scarring | 0.8% (n=18) |
| Damage to tube apparatus | 0.7% (n=15) |
| Orocutaneous/salivary fistula | 1.1% (30-year review) |
| Lingual nerve paresthesia | Transient, rare |
| Mucocele formation | Rare; from Wharton's duct injury |
| Keloid scar | Rare |
| Submental swelling/hematoma | Rare |
- No deaths or life-threatening complications directly attributable to SMI have been reported in the literature.
- The 100% success rate was noted in the 2012 literature review (Jundt et al.) of 842 cases across 41 articles.
Comparison with Alternatives
| Parameter | Submental Intubation | Tracheostomy | Nasotracheal Intubation |
|---|
| Invasiveness | Minimal | High (formal surgery) | Moderate |
| Oral cavity access | Fully clear | Fully clear | Partially obstructed |
| Nasal access | Fully clear | Fully clear | Obstructed |
| Occlusion check | Yes, possible | Yes, possible | No (tube in mouth) |
| Duration | Temporary (same operation) | Days to weeks | Hours only |
| Postoperative ventilation | Not suitable | Suitable | Not suitable long-term |
| Complication rate | Low (~7%) | Early 6-8%, late up to 60% | Sinusitis, epistaxis, nasal injury |
| Stoma care needed | No | Yes | No |
| ICU stay impact | Shorter than tracheostomy | Longer | N/A |
Bailey and Love notes that in oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma (OCSCC) surgery, the available airway options are: immediate postoperative extubation, overnight intubation/delayed extubation, submental intubation, and tracheostomy - with the choice being a joint anaesthetist-surgeon decision based on ability to re-establish the airway rapidly if needed.
Special Considerations
Pediatric patients: SMI has been performed in children but carries a higher risk of accidental extubation (smaller tube, shorter neck). Extra securing and vigilance required.
Obese patients: Short or fatty necks may make the tunnel passage technically difficult; a longer passage may be needed and tube kinking is more likely.
Surgeons' tip (Luce & Alvarez, 2018): The access should be via a midline approach rather than lateral through the mylohyoid, an armored ETT must be used, and passage should be facilitated by wound dilators from a percutaneous tracheostomy set to safely widen the tunnel.
Advantages Summary
- Preserves both the oral and nasal airway for surgical access
- Allows intraoperative maxillomandibular fixation (MMF) and occlusion verification
- Avoids tracheostomy and all its associated complications
- Reversible within the same operation
- No stoma, no prolonged wound care
- Short procedure time (~10 min)
- High success rate (~98-100%)
- Shorter ICU stay compared to tracheostomy patients
- Cosmetically acceptable scar in the submental region (hidden under the chin)
Key References
- Goh EZ et al. Systematic review of submental intubation 1986-2018. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2020. [PMID 31718913] - 2,229 patients
- Jundt JS et al. Submental intubation: a literature review. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2012. [PMID 21930363] - 842 patients, 100% success
- Lim D et al. Thirty years of submental intubation. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2018. [PMID 29731193] - 1,021 patients
- Mahajan AD et al. Unlocking the Potential of Submental Intubation. Craniomaxillofac Trauma Reconstr 2024. [PMID 39553800]
- Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th Edition (panfacial fractures and head/neck airway management sections)