I now have comprehensive material from authoritative surgical textbooks. Let me compile the exam-oriented answer.
HERNIA — Exam-Oriented Review
Definition
A hernia is the protrusion of any viscus from its normal cavity through an abnormal opening (congenital or acquired defect) in the containing wall.
- Roberts & Hedges' Clinical Procedures in Emergency Medicine
Parts of a Hernia (Must Know)
| Part | Description |
|---|
| Sac | Peritoneal pouch covering the hernial contents |
| Neck | Constriction at the opening; tight neck → strangulation |
| Body | Main portion of the sac |
| Contents | Omentum (most common), small bowel, large bowel, bladder |
| Coverings | Layers of abdominal wall over the sac |
Classification
A. By Reducibility (Most Important for Exams)
| Type | Definition |
|---|
| Reducible | Contents return to abdomen spontaneously or manually |
| Irreducible (Incarcerated) | Contents cannot be returned without surgery; swelling of sac contents present |
| Obstructed | Incarcerated hernia with lumen of bowel occluded; no blood supply compromise yet |
| Strangulated | Incarcerated hernia where blood supply to herniated structures is compromised → ischemia → necrosis; surgical emergency |
⚠️ Key exam point: Obstructed hernia ≠ Strangulated. In strangulation there is both obstruction + vascular compromise. Femoral hernias are most prone to strangulation (incarcerate in up to 45% of cases due to tight neck).
B. By Etiology
- Congenital — patent processus vaginalis (indirect inguinal, umbilical in children)
- Acquired — weakness from aging, raised intra-abdominal pressure, poor wound healing
C. Richter's Hernia
Only part of the bowel circumference is caught in the hernia ring — no bowel obstruction, but strangulation can occur silently.
D. Littre's Hernia
Hernia sac contains Meckel's diverticulum.
E. Sliding Hernia (en-glissade)
Retroperitoneal viscus (e.g., sigmoid colon, caecum, bladder) forms part of the wall of the hernia sac.
F. Maydl's Hernia (Hernia-in-W)
Two loops of intestine in the sac in a W-shape; the intermediate loop inside the abdomen becomes strangulated first — dangerous because signs are inside.
Types of Hernia by Location
1. Indirect Inguinal Hernia ⭐ (Most Common Overall)
- Passes through the deep (internal) inguinal ring → inguinal canal → may reach scrotum
- Located lateral to inferior epigastric vessels
- Occurs because of patent processus vaginalis
- Most common in males, children, and young adults
- ~5% of full-term infants, ~30% of preterm infants
- Congenital in children; can be acquired in adults
2. Direct Inguinal Hernia
- Protrudes through Hesselbach's triangle (bounded by inferior epigastric vessels laterally, rectus abdominis medially, inguinal ligament inferiorly)
- Located medial to inferior epigastric vessels
- Acquired; more common after age 40
- Appears on standing, disappears immediately on lying down
- Rarely strangulates (wide neck)
| Feature | Indirect | Direct |
|---|
| Position vs. epigastric vessels | Lateral | Medial |
| Pathway | Through deep ring, into canal | Directly through posterior wall |
| Age | Children, young adults | >40 years |
| Cause | Congenital (patent PV) | Acquired (weakness) |
| Strangulation risk | Higher | Lower |
| Reaches scrotum | Yes | Rarely |
| Control on deep ring pressure | Yes (controlled) | No (not controlled) |
3. Femoral Hernia
- Protrudes through the femoral canal (below inguinal ligament)
- Boundaries of femoral canal: femoral vein (lateral), inguinal ligament (anterior), iliopectineal/Astley Cooper's ligament (posterior), lacunar/Gimbernat's ligament (medial)
- More common in women (but inguinal hernia is still more common than femoral even in women overall)
- Appears as a medial thigh mass below the inguinal ligament
- High strangulation risk (45% incarceration) — tight neck is the reason
- No cough impulse when irreducible → commonly misdiagnosed as lymph node
4. Pantaloon Hernia
- Combination of direct + indirect hernia straddling the inferior epigastric vessels
- Difficult to diagnose and reduce manually; usually found at surgical exploration
5. Umbilical Hernia
- Traverses the fibromuscular umbilical ring
- In children: congenital, usually resolves by age 5; repair if >2 cm, persists >5 years, or incarcerates
- In adults: acquired; associated with obesity, ascites, pregnancy; higher risk of strangulation than in children
- Treatment: Mayo repair (fascial overlap "waistcoat over trousers") or mesh for defects >2 cm
6. Epigastric Hernia
- Through linea alba between umbilicus and xiphoid
- Usually contains extraperitoneal fat (rarely bowel)
- Often small and symptomatic; repair recommended
7. Incisional Hernia (Ventral)
- Occurs in up to 20% of patients after abdominal surgery
- Risk factors: wound infection, obesity, malnutrition, steroids
- Recurrence rate: 20–50% after repair
- Larger defects paradoxically have lower risk of strangulation (wider neck)
8. Spigelian Hernia
- Through the spigelian fascia (lateral edge of rectus abdominis at the semilunar line)
- Rare; lies between muscle layers → interparietal (difficult to detect clinically)
- Located just lateral to the rectus, usually below umbilicus
9. Hiatal Hernia
- Protrusion of stomach through the oesophageal hiatus of the diaphragm
| Type | Description | Clinical note |
|---|
| Type I — Sliding | GEJ and fundus slide into chest; most common (95%) | Predisposes to GORD |
| Type II — Rolling/Paraesophageal | Fundus herniates; GEJ stays below diaphragm | Obstructive symptoms |
| Type III — Mixed | Both GEJ and fundus herniate | |
| Type IV | Other viscera (colon, spleen) also herniate | |
Types II/III/IV can cause volvulus and strangulation → surgical emergency.
Complications
- Irreducibility → Incarceration
- Obstruction → Bowel obstruction (no vascular compromise)
- Strangulation → Vascular compromise → gangrene → perforation → peritonitis
- Inflammation / Maydl's (internal strangulation without external signs)
- Rupture (rare; umbilical in cirrhosis with ascites)
Clinical Features
- Reducible: Intermittent swelling; increases on standing/coughing; reduces on lying flat
- Cough impulse: Expansile impulse on coughing (hallmark); absent in tight-necked hernias
- Strangulated: Tense, tender, non-reducible; no cough impulse; overlying skin erythema; signs of bowel obstruction; systemic toxicity
- Examination: supine → standing → Valsalva/cough; examine contralateral side (occult hernia in 20%)
Investigations
| Investigation | Use |
|---|
| Clinical exam | Diagnosis in most cases |
| Ultrasound | Irreducible hernia, uncertain diagnosis; distinguish from lymph node/saphena varix |
| CT abdomen | Complex ventral hernias; preoperative planning; content assessment |
| MRI | Sportsman's groin; musculoligamentous injury |
Treatment
Conservative
- Truss/binder: reserved for patients unfit for surgery (temporary measure, not curative)
- Watch-and-wait: asymptomatic male inguinal hernia (watchful waiting is safe; risk of strangulation ~0.3%/year)
Surgical — Principles
All symptomatic, incarcerated, or strangulated hernias require surgery. Strangulated hernia = emergency operation.
Inguinal Hernia Repair
| Technique | Key Points |
|---|
| Bassini | Posterior wall repair; conjoined tendon to inguinal ligament; non-mesh; historically important |
| Shouldice | 4-layer posterior wall repair; best non-mesh result; ~1% recurrence |
| Lichtenstein (Tension-free mesh) | Gold standard open repair; polypropylene mesh; simple, low recurrence |
| TEP (Totally Extraperitoneal) | Laparoscopic; best for bilateral/recurrent hernias; preperitoneal mesh; avoids peritoneum |
| TAPP (Transabdominal Preperitoneal) | Laparoscopic; enters peritoneum; mesh in preperitoneal space |
Lichtenstein described tension-free flat polypropylene mesh repair in the 1980s — it remains the most widely performed technique.
Laparoscopic repair (TEP/TAPP) is preferred for bilateral or recurrent inguinal hernias after prior open repair.
Femoral Hernia Repair
| Approach | Route |
|---|
| Low (Lockwood) | Below inguinal ligament; best for elective |
| High (McEvedy) | Above inguinal ligament; best for strangulated (better bowel access) |
| Transinguinal (Lotheissen) | Through inguinal canal |
Umbilical Hernia Repair
- Mayo repair: "Waistcoat-over-trousers" fascial overlap (defects ≤2 cm)
- Mesh repair: preferred for defects >2 cm (lower recurrence)
Incisional Hernia Repair
- Mesh repair mandatory (suture repair has very high recurrence)
- Laparoscopic or open; retromuscular (sublay) mesh placement preferred
Key Exam One-Liners
- Most common hernia overall: Indirect inguinal
- Most common hernia in females: Indirect inguinal (but femoral is proportionally more common in women vs. men)
- Most likely to strangulate: Femoral hernia
- Hernia that resolves spontaneously: Umbilical (in children <5 years)
- Emergency indication for hernia surgery: Strangulation
- Obstructed ≠ Strangulated: Obstructed has lumen blockage only; strangulated has blood supply compromise
- Richter's hernia: No bowel obstruction; silent strangulation of bowel wall
- Littre's hernia: Contains Meckel's diverticulum
- Maydl's hernia: W-shaped; intra-abdominal loop strangulates first
- Sliding hernia: Viscus forms part of sac wall (sigmoid/caecum/bladder)
- Lichtenstein repair: Tension-free, open mesh; gold standard
- TEP/TAPP: Preferred laparoscopic approaches; indicated for bilateral/recurrent hernias
- Mayo repair: Umbilical hernia; overlapping fascial repair
Sources: Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery 28th Ed.; Roberts & Hedges' Clinical Procedures in Emergency Medicine; S Das Manual on Clinical Surgery 13th Ed.; Sleisenger & Fordtran's GI & Liver Disease; Current Surgical Therapy 14e