Here is a comprehensive breakdown of internal vs external hemorrhoids:
Hemorrhoids: Internal vs External
What Are Hemorrhoids?
Hemorrhoids are submucosal vascular beds (dilated vascular channels / collateral vessels) located in the anal and rectal canal. They are a normal part of anatomy - they assist with defecation and the sensation of anorectal fullness. Pathology arises when they engorge, prolapse, thrombose, or bleed.
Prevalence: ~4.4% of the US population (~10 million people) complain of hemorrhoidal disease; up to 25% of the adult population are affected. ~1.9 to 3.5 million physician visits annually in the US.
Typical locations: Right anterior, right posterior, and left lateral positions. Hemorrhoids at other locations should raise concern for carcinoma, lymphoma, or condyloma.
The Key Anatomical Dividing Line: The Dentate (Pectinate) Line
| Internal Hemorrhoids | External Hemorrhoids |
|---|
| Location relative to dentate line | Above the dentate line | Below the dentate line |
| Venous plexus | Superior hemorrhoidal plexus (within distal rectum) | Inferior hemorrhoidal plexus (perianal) |
| Epithelium | Columnar or transitional mucosa | Squamous epithelium |
| Innervation | Autonomic only - NOT painful | Somatic innervation - painful |
| Portal vs caval | Portal system | Caval (systemic) system |
INTERNAL HEMORRHOIDS
Pathophysiology
Internal hemorrhoid symptoms occur due to loss of connective tissue support and resulting protrusion/prolapse of vascular tissue, rendering it susceptible to trauma from straining or hard stool passage. Associated with elevated circulating matrix metalloproteinases. More likely in patients with constipation, loose stools, or prolonged toilet sitting.
Risk Factors
- Constipation and straining (elevated intraabdominal/venous pressure)
- Low-fiber diet
- Prolonged sitting on toilet
- Pregnancy (mechanical compression of superior rectal vein + increased progesterone)
- Portal hypertension
- Obesity, aging, genetic factors
Symptoms
- Painless, bright-red rectal bleeding - hallmark; blood coats outside of stool, drips into toilet, or is seen on toilet paper; can be dark blood or clots if blood pools in rectum
- Prolapse - tissue protruding from anus
- Mucus or blood on underwear (from prolapse)
- Perianal itching (from moisture caused by prolapse)
- Pain is NOT typical - pain only occurs with thrombosis or strangulation
Grading (Classification)
| Grade | Description | Typical Treatment |
|---|
| Grade I | Bleed; may be enlarged; do not prolapse | Medical (fiber, fluids) |
| Grade II | Prolapse with defecation; reduce spontaneously | Medical ± rubber band ligation |
| Grade III | Prolapse and require manual reduction | Rubber band ligation or surgery |
| Grade IV | Remain prolapsed (irreducible) | Surgical excision |
Diagnosis
- Clinical history + physical examination
- Anoscopy (beveled or slotted anoscope) - gold standard for visualization and grading
- Flexible sigmoidoscopy/colonoscopy if bleeding source unclear, symptoms persist, or patient >40 years (to rule out colorectal cancer)
Treatment
Conservative / Medical (Grade I-II first line):
- Dietary fiber 20-30 g/day + 6-8 glasses of fluid daily (fiber supplements reduce symptoms by 53%)
- Stool softeners (docusate sodium), avoid straining
- Polyethylene glycol 3350 for constipation
- Topical agents: phenylephrine/mineral oil/petrolatum or glucocorticoid creams (short-term; caution - risk of candidiasis)
- Phlebotonics (flavonoids, plant extracts e.g., diosmin) - improve venous tone, reduce capillary permeability, superior to placebo for acute symptoms; excellent safety profile
Office Procedures (Grade I-III, failed medical therapy):
- Rubber band ligation (RBL) - most common office procedure; bands placed just proximal to dentate line (distal placement on squamous mucosa = pain, band must be removed immediately); tissue becomes necrotic and sloughs; contraindicated in anticoagulated patients
- Infrared photocoagulation (especially Grade I with persistent bleeding)
- Injection sclerotherapy
- Cryotherapy
- Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation
Surgery (Grade IV, or failed office procedures):
- Formal hemorrhoidectomy
- Stapled hemorrhoidopexy (procedure for prolapsing hemorrhoids, PPH)
EXTERNAL HEMORRHOIDS
Pathophysiology
External hemorrhoids = dilated vessels of the inferior hemorrhoidal plexus below the dentate line, covered by squamous epithelium with somatic innervation. What is visible at the anal verge as "external hemorrhoids" is often redundant skin (anal tags) from previous episodes of external hemorrhoid inflammation, edema, and thrombosis.
Symptoms
- Usually asymptomatic when not thrombosed
- Skin tags: no bleeding, difficult hygiene, itching and irritation
- Thrombosed external hemorrhoid = the painful acute presentation
Thrombosed External Hemorrhoid - Special Entity
- Acute onset of severe perianal pain
- Visible purplish/bluish nodule at the anal verge with taut overlying skin
- Bluish discoloration from underlying clot
- Overlying skin may ulcerate and bleed (usually 1-2 days, may coincide with pain relief)
Clinical photo of thrombosed external hemorrhoid and excision:
Office excision of thrombosed external hemorrhoid - Sleisenger & Fordtran's GI and Liver Disease
Treatment of thrombosed external hemorrhoid:
- If painless - reassurance; swelling subsides over several weeks
- If painful AND symptoms <72 hours - surgical excision under local anesthesia (1% lidocaine with epinephrine) is beneficial; enucleation preferred over simple incision (due to high recurrence with simple incision)
- If symptoms >72 hours - pain is already subsiding; observation preferred (pain resolves in 4-7 days regardless; outcome at 2 months is the same whether or not excision is performed)
- Conservative: warm sitz baths, stool softeners, topical analgesics (benzocaine, dibucaine, pramoxine)
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Internal | External |
|---|
| Location | Above dentate line | Below dentate line |
| Plexus | Superior hemorrhoidal | Inferior hemorrhoidal |
| Covering | Columnar/transitional mucosa | Squamous epithelium |
| Pain | Painless (unless thrombosed/strangulated) | Painful (somatic innervation) |
| Bleeding | Painless bright-red rectal bleeding | Minimal or none (unless ulcerated) |
| Key presentation | Prolapse, bleeding | Thrombosis (acute pain + blue nodule) |
| Grading system | Grade I-IV (by degree of prolapse) | Not formally graded |
| First-line treatment | Fiber + fluids + RBL | Observation or excision (if thrombosed <72 h) |
| Portal HTN link | Yes (portal venous drainage) | No (systemic venous drainage) |
Important Notes
- Patients often attribute unrelated anal symptoms (fissures, pruritus ani, warts) to hemorrhoids - careful exam is essential
- Hemorrhoids coexist with other anal pathology - do not assume hemorrhoids are the sole cause
- When hemorrhoids develop in the setting of portal hypertension, the implications are more serious
- In patients >40 years with hemorrhoidal bleeding, colonoscopy should be considered to exclude colorectal malignancy
Sources: Sleisenger & Fordtran's Gastrointestinal and Liver Disease; Textbook of Family Medicine 9e; Robbins & Kumar Basic Pathology; Clinical Gastrointestinal Endoscopy 3e; Yamada's Textbook of Gastroenterology; Creasy & Resnik's Maternal-Fetal Medicine