I now have enough information to provide a thorough answer for all 3 cases. Let me compile the comprehensive response.
Clinical Case Discussion - Gynecology Cases (Sem. 6, Batch-53 C, Manipal University College Malaysia)
CCD FILE - Case 1: Ms. J.K., 28 years old
Case Summary
28-year-old woman | Menorrhagia x 6 months | Regular cycles (30-day cycle, 7-day bleed) | Clots | Pallor, tachycardia (HR 100), hypotension (BP 100/60) | 3 years primary infertility | Abdominal mass ~20 weeks size in hypogastrium + umbilical region | Irregular surface, firm consistency | Upper & lateral borders palpable, lower border not reachable
Differential Diagnosis
Most Likely: Uterine Fibroids (Leiomyoma)
The clinical picture strongly points to multiple uterine fibroids - the irregular, firm, uterine-origin mass with menorrhagia and primary infertility in a reproductive-age woman is classic. As noted in S Das Manual on Clinical Surgery: "Menorrhagia of some standing may be due to fibroid in women above 30 years of age but before menopause with irregular enlargement of the uterus (except in the submucous type in which the swelling will be smooth)."
| Diagnosis | Supporting Features | Against |
|---|
| Uterine fibroid (most likely) | Irregular firm mass, menorrhagia, infertility, firm, hypogastric location | - |
| Pregnancy (gravid uterus) | Uterine mass, amenorrhea possible | She has regular periods; no amenorrhoea mentioned |
| Adenomyosis | Menorrhagia, enlarged uterus | Usually smooth/uniformly enlarged, not irregular |
| Ovarian mass / fibroma | Pelvic mass | Ovarian mass tends to be separate from uterus, cystic |
| Chronic PID / tubo-ovarian mass | Young woman, infertility | No fever/tenderness mentioned |
| Endometrial carcinoma | Uterine mass, bleeding | Very rare at 28; usually postmenopausal |
Fibroid types to consider: Multiple intramural and subserosal fibroids account for the large, irregular mass; a submucosal component is likely causing heavy bleeding.
Management of Case 1
Immediate/Initial:
- Correct anaemia: Check FBC, serum iron/ferritin; start oral/IV iron; consider blood transfusion if Hb critical (tachycardia + hypotension suggests significant anaemia)
- Confirm uterine origin: Catheterize bladder first before palpation (S Das)
- Urine pregnancy test to rule out pregnancy
Investigations:
- Ultrasound pelvis (TVS/TAS) - first-line: maps number, size, location of fibroids; rules out ovarian pathology
- FBC, coagulation profile (rule out coagulopathy as AUB-C)
- Serum CA-125 (if ovarian mass not excluded)
- MRI pelvis - gold standard for pre-surgical fibroid mapping (Grainger & Allison)
- Hysteroscopy - assess submucosal component
- Thyroid function, prolactin (rule out AUB-O/hormonal causes)
Medical Management (if fertility desired):
- GnRH analogues (e.g., leuprolide): shrink fibroid volume by 30-50% pre-operatively; correct anaemia
- Tranexamic acid / NSAIDs - reduce heavy bleeding temporarily
- Combined OCP / LNG-IUS - heavy bleeding control (if submucosal excluded)
Surgical Management (given large fibroid + infertility):
- Myomectomy - treatment of choice when fertility preservation is required; can be open, laparoscopic or hysteroscopic depending on fibroid location
- Uterine artery embolisation (UAE) - alternative if surgery declined, though fertility outcomes less predictable
- Hysterectomy is NOT appropriate here (28 years old, desires fertility)
For infertility: After myomectomy, evaluate tubal patency (HSG), ovulation, semen analysis for complete infertility workup.
CCD FILE - Case 2: Mrs. E., 45 years old
Case Summary
45-year-old parous woman | Indigestion x 1 month | No weight loss or anorexia | Family history: mother died of ovarian cancer | Abdominal mass ~24 weeks size in hypogastrium | Irregular surface, partly cystic + partly solid | All borders palpable (can reach lower border - excludes uterine origin) | Fluid thrill present | Percussion: resonant centre, dull in flanks
Clinical Diagnosis
Ovarian Malignancy (Ovarian Cancer) - until proven otherwise
The critical distinguishing features here:
- All borders palpable (unlike fibroid uterus where lower border is not reachable)
- Partly cystic, partly solid - classic for ovarian malignancy
- Fluid thrill + flank dullness = ascites (not ovarian cyst, which causes central dullness and flank resonance - as S Das explains: ovarian tumour causes "dullness over the front of the abdomen with resonant areas in the flanks, whereas in ascites there is dullness on the flanks with resonance over the front of the abdomen")
- First-degree family history of ovarian cancer - major risk factor
- Indigestion/dyspepsia = common GI presentation of ovarian cancer
Note: The percussion finding here (resonant centre, dull flanks) is actually consistent with ascites - which is a sinister sign pointing to ovarian malignancy with peritoneal spread.
Differential Diagnosis
| Diagnosis | Supporting Features | Against |
|---|
| Ovarian carcinoma (most likely) | Partly solid+cystic, ascites, family Hx, all borders palpable, age 45 | - |
| Ovarian borderline tumour | Similar presentation, younger age | Less aggressive |
| Benign ovarian cyst (dermoid, endometrioma) | Cystic pelvic mass | No solid component in benign; no ascites |
| Tubo-ovarian abscess | Adnexal mass | No fever, no pain, no PID history |
| Uterine fibroid | Firm pelvic mass | Lower border reachable, partly cystic; ascites unlikely with fibroid |
| Pseudomyxoma peritonei | Ascites + mass | Rare; usually mucinous ovarian primary |
| Colorectal/GI malignancy with metastasis | GI symptoms | No weight loss; primarily ovarian features |
Management of Case 2
Investigations:
- Transvaginal/transabdominal ultrasound - first line; characterize mass (solid vs. cystic, septations, papillary projections, vascularity)
- Serum CA-125 - elevated in ~80% of epithelial ovarian cancers; also check HE4 (more specific)
- CT abdomen + pelvis with contrast - staging; assess peritoneal implants, LN involvement, omental deposits
- MRI pelvis - better soft tissue characterization
- CXR - pleural effusion (Meigs' syndrome or malignancy)
- FBC, LFTs, renal function (pre-operative workup)
- Ascitic fluid tap - cytology; LDH, protein
- BRCA1/BRCA2 genetic testing given family history
- CEA, CA19-9, AFP, LDH (germ cell / sex-cord stromal tumours)
Definitive Management:
- Refer urgently to Gynae-Oncology MDT
- Surgical staging and debulking (cytoreductive surgery): total abdominal hysterectomy + bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy + omentectomy + pelvic/para-aortic lymph node dissection
- Platinum-based chemotherapy (carboplatin + paclitaxel) - adjuvant or neoadjuvant
- If BRCA mutation confirmed - PARP inhibitor (e.g., olaparib) as maintenance therapy
- Counselling regarding prognosis, genetic counselling for first-degree relatives
PBL FILE - Case 1 (Mrs. M, 45 years old): Abnormal Uterine Bleeding
Case Summary
45-year-old woman | Menorrhagia x 6 months | Irregular periods (35-45 day cycle), 10-day bleed | 2 soaked pads/day + clots | No dysmenorrhoea | G3P3 (all NVD) | Pallor, HR 88, BP 120/80 | Soft abdomen, no palpable mass | Bulky uterus on PV exam | Fornices free, no tenderness
Clinical Diagnosis
Abnormal Uterine Bleeding (AUB) - likely AUB-O (Anovulatory) ± AUB-L (Leiomyoma/Adenomyosis)
At 45 years (perimenopausal), anovulatory cycles are the most common cause of AUB (Berek & Novak). The PALM-COEIN classification applies: the bulky uterus suggests possible adenomyosis (AUB-A) or leiomyoma (AUB-L).
PALM-COEIN Classification Applied:
- P - Polyp (endometrial/cervical)
- A - Adenomyosis (bulky uterus, no discrete mass - very likely here)
- L - Leiomyoma (no palpable mass but could be small intramural)
- M - Malignancy/hyperplasia (must exclude at age 45)
- C - Coagulopathy (rule out)
- O - Ovulatory dysfunction (perimenopause - most likely)
- E - Endometrial (endometritis)
- I - Iatrogenic
- N - Not yet classified
Management
Investigations:
- Urine/serum pregnancy test (exclude pregnancy first)
- FBC - assess degree of anaemia
- Thyroid function tests (TFTs) - hypothyroidism causes menorrhagia
- Coagulation screen (PT, aPTT, platelets) - rule out AUB-C
- Pelvic ultrasound (TVS) - assess endometrial thickness, adenomyosis features, fibroids
- Endometrial biopsy / sampling (MANDATORY at age 45 to exclude endometrial hyperplasia/carcinoma - AUB-M)
- Hysteroscopy - if sampling inconclusive; visualize polyps/submucosal fibroids
Medical Treatment:
- LNG-IUS (Mirena) - first-line for heavy menstrual bleeding with bulky uterus; also treats adenomyosis
- Combined OCP or progestogens - regulate cycles; treat anovulatory AUB
- Tranexamic acid - antifibrinolytic; reduces blood loss by ~40%
- NSAIDs (mefenamic acid) - reduce prostaglandin-mediated heavy bleeding
- Iron supplementation for anaemia
Surgical Treatment (if medical fails):
- Endometrial ablation - if no desire for future fertility; treats heavy bleeding
- Hysterectomy - definitive treatment when other measures fail; consider at perimenopausal age with completed family
PBL FILE - Case 2 (Mrs. AH, 29 years old): Acute Pain Abdomen - Ectopic Pregnancy
Case Summary
29-year-old | Infertility x 3 years | 6 weeks amenorrhoea | Cramping right iliac fossa pain (7/10) | Vaginal spotting | HR 90 (low volume) + BP 100/60 = haemodynamic instability | Syncopal episode on standing | Previous surgical evacuation for missed miscarriage 2 years ago
Diagnosis with Justification: Ruptured/Leaking Right Tubal Ectopic Pregnancy
Justification:
| Feature | Clinical Significance |
|---|
| 6 weeks amenorrhoea | Confirms pregnancy |
| Right iliac fossa pain (crampy, 7/10) | Tubal distension / rupture on right side |
| Vaginal spotting | Decidual shedding as ectopic fails |
| HR 90, low volume + BP 100/60 | Haemodynamic compromise from internal bleeding |
| Fainting on standing (orthostatic syncope) | Significant haemoperitoneum - surgical emergency |
| Prior surgical uterine evacuation | Instrumentation risk factor (endometrial scarring/adhesions) |
| 3 years infertility | Suggests possible tubal pathology pre-existing |
As stated in Berek & Novak's Gynecology: "The classic symptom triad of ectopic pregnancy is pain, amenorrhea, and vaginal bleeding. This symptom group is present in about 50% of patients and is more typical in patients with a ruptured ectopic pregnancy." The haemodynamic instability here (low-volume pulse, hypotension, syncope) indicates likely rupture with haemoperitoneum.
Differential Diagnosis
| Diagnosis | Supporting | Against |
|---|
| Ruptured ectopic pregnancy (most likely) | Amenorrhoea, RIF pain, spotting, haemodynamic instability, syncope | - |
| Ruptured corpus luteum cyst | RIF pain, haemoperitoneum possible | No amenorrhoea pattern; urine βhCG negative |
| Acute appendicitis | RIF pain | No amenorrhoea; no fever/anorexia; spotting not explained |
| Miscarriage (incomplete/threatened) | Amenorrhoea, cramping, spotting | Intrauterine; no haemodynamic shock usually |
| PID / Tubo-ovarian abscess | RIF pain | Fever expected; no amenorrhoea |
| Ovarian torsion | Severe pelvic pain | Sudden onset; less associated with amenorrhoea & spotting |
How to Confirm Diagnosis
- Serum βhCG - will be positive; serial levels help if stable (in ruptured, this is confirmatory not diagnostic as surgery is urgent)
- Transvaginal ultrasound (TVS) - most important non-invasive test: look for empty uterus + adnexal mass + free fluid in pouch of Douglas; "no intrauterine pregnancy with free fluid + positive βhCG = ectopic until proven otherwise"
- FBC - falling Hb/Hct confirms haemorrhage
- Blood group + crossmatch - preparation for surgery
- Diagnostic laparoscopy - both confirmatory AND therapeutic (gold standard)
- Culdocentesis (if ultrasound unavailable) - aspiration of non-clotting blood from pouch of Douglas confirms haemoperitoneum
Note: With haemodynamic instability + syncope, this patient likely needs EMERGENCY LAPAROSCOPY without delay for confirmation + treatment.
Treatment
This is a SURGICAL EMERGENCY:
Resuscitation (simultaneous):
- 2 large-bore IV cannulae, IV fluids (crystalloids)
- Blood crossmatch, transfusion if needed
- Oxygen supplementation
- Foley catheter + urine output monitoring
- Urgent surgical consent
Surgical Treatment (definitive):
- Emergency laparoscopy (preferred) or laparotomy if haemodynamically unstable
- Salpingectomy (tube removal) - if tube severely damaged or for haemostasis; appropriate here given haemodynamic instability
- Salpingotomy (linear salpingostomy) - conservative; considered if contralateral tube is absent/damaged and future fertility is paramount - but high risk of persistent trophoblast
Medical treatment (Methotrexate) is CONTRAINDICATED here because:
- Haemodynamic instability
- Evidence of rupture (syncope, low-volume pulse)
- βhCG likely high
Post-operative:
- Monitor βhCG to zero (ensure no persistent trophoblast)
- Anti-D immunoglobulin if Rh-negative
- Counsel on recurrence risk: 10-15% after first ectopic (Berek & Novak's Gynecology)
- HSG after recovery to assess tubal patency of remaining tube
- Early USS in any future pregnancy to confirm intrauterine location
Sources: Berek & Novak's Gynecology | S Das Manual on Clinical Surgery (13th Ed.) | Grainger & Allison's Diagnostic Radiology | ROSEN's Emergency Medicine | Sabiston Textbook of Surgery