Recurrent shoulder dislocation in details according to orthopaedics text books

Reading File
Finding Sources
Finding Sources
Searching Images

recurrent shoulder dislocation Bankart lesion Hill-Sachs

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), axial view.

**Anatomical Region:** Glenohumeral joint (shoulder).

**Observed Pathology:** The image demonstrates findings consistent with sequelae of anterior shoulder dislocation, specifically a bony Bankart lesion and an associated Hill-Sachs deformity.

**Characteristic Visual Features:**
*   **Bankart Lesion:** Evidence of a fracture and fragmentation at the anterior-inferior aspect of the glenoid rim. There is associated disruption of the anterior labrum.
*   **Hill-Sachs Deformity:** A cortical depression and wedge-shaped defect are visible on the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head.
*   **Signal Intensity:** High T2-weighted/STIR signal intensity is noted within the humeral head and adjacent glenoid, indicating subchondral bone marrow edema or bruising (bone marrow contusion) at the impact sites.

**Clinical Context:** These findings are pathognomonic for recurrent or acute anterior glenohumeral instability. The "kissing lesions" represent the forceful impact between the humeral head and the glenoid during the dislocation event.

**Key Diagnostic Features:** Posterolateral humeral head compression fracture (Hill-Sachs) and anterior-inferior glenoid rim osseous avulsion (Bony Bankart).

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), axial view. **Anatomical Region:** Glenohumeral joint (shoulder). **Observed Pathology:** The image demonstrates findings consistent with sequelae of anterior shoulder dislocation, specifically a bony Bankart lesion and an associated Hill-Sachs deformity. **Characteristic Visual Features:** * **Bankart Lesion:** Evidence of a fracture and fragmentation at the anterior-inferior aspect of the glenoid rim. There is associated disruption of the anterior labrum. * **Hill-Sachs Deformity:** A cortical depression and wedge-shaped defect are visible on the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head. * **Signal Intensity:** High T2-weighted/STIR signal intensity is noted within the humeral head and adjacent glenoid, indicating subchondral bone marrow edema or bruising (bone marrow contusion) at the impact sites. **Clinical Context:** These findings are pathognomonic for recurrent or acute anterior glenohumeral instability. The "kissing lesions" represent the forceful impact between the humeral head and the glenoid during the dislocation event. **Key Diagnostic Features:** Posterolateral humeral head compression fracture (Hill-Sachs) and anterior-inferior glenoid rim osseous avulsion (Bony Bankart).

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), coronal oblique view, fat-saturated T2-weighted or proton density sequence.

**Anatomical Region:** Right shoulder glenohumeral joint.

**Observed Pathology:** Post-traumatic changes consistent with a prior anterior glenohumeral dislocation. The image demonstrates a Hill-Sachs lesion, characterized by a cortical depression and marrow signal abnormality (bone bruise) on the posterolateral aspect of the superior humeral head. 

**Characteristic Visual Features:**
*   **Hill-Sachs Deformity:** A distinct contour defect and focal hyperintensity in the subchondral bone of the posterolateral humeral head, indicating an impaction fracture.
*   **Labral Assessment:** There is evidence of a Bankart lesion, visualized as a disruption of the anteroinferior glenoid labrum with associated high signal intensity, suggesting a tear.
*   **Joint Space:** Mild joint effusion is present. The acromioclavicular joint and subacromial space are visible superiorly.

**Clinical Significance:** These findings are pathognomonic for anterior instability of the shoulder. The combination of a Hill-Sachs impaction fracture and a Bankart labral tear is a common sequela of shoulder dislocation, increasing the risk of chronic recurrent instability and secondary osteoarthritis.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), coronal oblique view, fat-saturated T2-weighted or proton density sequence. **Anatomical Region:** Right shoulder glenohumeral joint. **Observed Pathology:** Post-traumatic changes consistent with a prior anterior glenohumeral dislocation. The image demonstrates a Hill-Sachs lesion, characterized by a cortical depression and marrow signal abnormality (bone bruise) on the posterolateral aspect of the superior humeral head. **Characteristic Visual Features:** * **Hill-Sachs Deformity:** A distinct contour defect and focal hyperintensity in the subchondral bone of the posterolateral humeral head, indicating an impaction fracture. * **Labral Assessment:** There is evidence of a Bankart lesion, visualized as a disruption of the anteroinferior glenoid labrum with associated high signal intensity, suggesting a tear. * **Joint Space:** Mild joint effusion is present. The acromioclavicular joint and subacromial space are visible superiorly. **Clinical Significance:** These findings are pathognomonic for anterior instability of the shoulder. The combination of a Hill-Sachs impaction fracture and a Bankart labral tear is a common sequela of shoulder dislocation, increasing the risk of chronic recurrent instability and secondary osteoarthritis.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), axial plane.

**Anatomical Region:** Shoulder joint (glenohumeral joint).

**Observed Pathology:**
*   **Hill-Sachs Lesion:** A prominent impaction fracture is visible on the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head. This is characterized by a cortical depression and subchondral marrow edema, appearing as an area of increased signal intensity on this fluid-sensitive sequence.
*   **Bankart Lesion:** Evidence of injury to the anteroinferior glenoid labrum. There is disruption of the labral-ligamentous complex, consistent with an avulsion of the labrum from the glenoid rim.
*   **Joint Effusion:** Increased intra-articular signal intensity indicates presence of joint fluid/effusion.

**Characteristic Visual Features:** The "hatchet" deformity of the posterior humerus and the blunting/detachment of the anterior labrum are classic markers of shoulder instability.

**Clinical Context:** These findings are pathognomonic for sequelae of recurrent anterior glenohumeral dislocation.

**Diagnostic Differentiating Features:** The co-occurrence of a posterolateral humeral head defect (Hill-Sachs) and an anteroinferior labral tear (Bankart) confirms a mechanism of anterior instability, distinguishing it from posterior dislocation patterns.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), axial plane. **Anatomical Region:** Shoulder joint (glenohumeral joint). **Observed Pathology:** * **Hill-Sachs Lesion:** A prominent impaction fracture is visible on the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head. This is characterized by a cortical depression and subchondral marrow edema, appearing as an area of increased signal intensity on this fluid-sensitive sequence. * **Bankart Lesion:** Evidence of injury to the anteroinferior glenoid labrum. There is disruption of the labral-ligamentous complex, consistent with an avulsion of the labrum from the glenoid rim. * **Joint Effusion:** Increased intra-articular signal intensity indicates presence of joint fluid/effusion. **Characteristic Visual Features:** The "hatchet" deformity of the posterior humerus and the blunting/detachment of the anterior labrum are classic markers of shoulder instability. **Clinical Context:** These findings are pathognomonic for sequelae of recurrent anterior glenohumeral dislocation. **Diagnostic Differentiating Features:** The co-occurrence of a posterolateral humeral head defect (Hill-Sachs) and an anteroinferior labral tear (Bankart) confirms a mechanism of anterior instability, distinguishing it from posterior dislocation patterns.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
**Anatomical Region:** Right shoulder (glenohumeral joint)
**View:** Axial section

**Observed Pathology:**
The image demonstrates signs of chronic anterior shoulder instability. There is evidence of a **Bankart lesion**, characterized by a disruption or fracture of the anterior-inferior glenoid labrum/rim. This is accompanied by a **Hill-Sachs deformity**, visible as a cortical depression or flattening of the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head.

**Characteristic Visual Features:**
- **Bankart Lesion:** Loss of the normal triangular low-signal intensity of the anterior labrum, with associated irregularity of the glenoid margin.
- **Hill-Sachs Lesion:** A wedge-shaped defect in the humeral head, resulting from forceful impaction against the glenoid during an anterior dislocation event.
- **Joint Space:** The relationship between the humeral head and the glenoid fossa is visualized, showing post-traumatic structural changes.

**Clinical Context:**
These findings are pathognomonic for recurrent anterior glenohumeral dislocations. The combination of the bony/labral Bankart and the Hill-Sachs lesion represents the "bipolar" nature of many instability-related injuries.

**Key Diagnostic Features:**
- Anterior-inferior glenoid rim disruption.
- Posterolateral humeral head impaction fracture.
- Presence of these dual osseous/cartilaginous defects in a patient with a history of shoulder instability.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) **Anatomical Region:** Right shoulder (glenohumeral joint) **View:** Axial section **Observed Pathology:** The image demonstrates signs of chronic anterior shoulder instability. There is evidence of a **Bankart lesion**, characterized by a disruption or fracture of the anterior-inferior glenoid labrum/rim. This is accompanied by a **Hill-Sachs deformity**, visible as a cortical depression or flattening of the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head. **Characteristic Visual Features:** - **Bankart Lesion:** Loss of the normal triangular low-signal intensity of the anterior labrum, with associated irregularity of the glenoid margin. - **Hill-Sachs Lesion:** A wedge-shaped defect in the humeral head, resulting from forceful impaction against the glenoid during an anterior dislocation event. - **Joint Space:** The relationship between the humeral head and the glenoid fossa is visualized, showing post-traumatic structural changes. **Clinical Context:** These findings are pathognomonic for recurrent anterior glenohumeral dislocations. The combination of the bony/labral Bankart and the Hill-Sachs lesion represents the "bipolar" nature of many instability-related injuries. **Key Diagnostic Features:** - Anterior-inferior glenoid rim disruption. - Posterolateral humeral head impaction fracture. - Presence of these dual osseous/cartilaginous defects in a patient with a history of shoulder instability.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), coronal oblique view, likely T2-weighted with fat suppression or STIR sequence.

**Anatomical Region:** Right glenohumeral joint (shoulder).

**Observed Pathology:** Evidence of chronic glenohumeral instability and sequelae of recurrent anterior shoulder dislocations. There is a prominent defect in the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head, consistent with a Hill-Sachs lesion (compression fracture). The glenoid margin shows architectural changes suggestive of a Bankart lesion or chronic labral injury.

**Characteristic Visual Features:**
*   **Humeral Head:** Focal loss of bone volume and marrow signal alteration at the posterolateral humeral head superiorly.
*   **Glenoid:** Blunting or irregularity of the inferior glenoid labrum.
*   **Soft Tissues:** Increased signal intensity in the subacromial/subdeltoid space, possibly reflecting bursal fluid or reactive changes. The supraspinatus tendon is visible superior to the humeral head.

**Clinical Context:** Findings are highly characteristic of recurrent anterior instability commonly seen in contact sports (e.g., rugby).

**Key Diagnostic Features:** The "engaging" Hill-Sachs deformity and associated glenoid rim irregularity are the hallmark diagnostic indicators of previous anterior dislocation events.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), coronal oblique view, likely T2-weighted with fat suppression or STIR sequence. **Anatomical Region:** Right glenohumeral joint (shoulder). **Observed Pathology:** Evidence of chronic glenohumeral instability and sequelae of recurrent anterior shoulder dislocations. There is a prominent defect in the posterolateral aspect of the humeral head, consistent with a Hill-Sachs lesion (compression fracture). The glenoid margin shows architectural changes suggestive of a Bankart lesion or chronic labral injury. **Characteristic Visual Features:** * **Humeral Head:** Focal loss of bone volume and marrow signal alteration at the posterolateral humeral head superiorly. * **Glenoid:** Blunting or irregularity of the inferior glenoid labrum. * **Soft Tissues:** Increased signal intensity in the subacromial/subdeltoid space, possibly reflecting bursal fluid or reactive changes. The supraspinatus tendon is visible superior to the humeral head. **Clinical Context:** Findings are highly characteristic of recurrent anterior instability commonly seen in contact sports (e.g., rugby). **Key Diagnostic Features:** The "engaging" Hill-Sachs deformity and associated glenoid rim irregularity are the hallmark diagnostic indicators of previous anterior dislocation events.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
**Anatomical Region:** Right shoulder (glenohumeral joint)
**View:** Coronal oblique T1-weighted sequence

**Observed Pathology:**
The image demonstrates a classic **Hill-Sachs lesion**, characterized by a cortical depression and marrow signal abnormality on the posterolateral aspect of the superior humeral head. This impaction fracture is a hallmark sign of prior anterior glenohumeral dislocation.

**Characteristic Visual Features:**
*   **Humeral Head:** Focal wedge-shaped defect in the subchondral bone of the superolateral humeral head.
*   **Glenohumeral Alignment:** The humeral head is currently reduced within the glenoid fossa.
*   **Surrounding Structures:** Visualization of the acromion, clavicle, and deltoid musculature. There is a suggestion of labral pathology (likely a Bankart lesion) at the inferior glenoid rim, typically associated with this injury pattern.

**Clinical Context & Significance:**
The presence of a Hill-Sachs lesion is a critical radiologic marker for shoulder instability. It represents the "engagement" of the humeral head against the anterior glenoid rim during a dislocation event. This finding is essential for preoperative planning to assess the risk of recurrent instability and to determine the need for specialized procedures like a Remplissage or bone grafting.

**Imaging Modality:** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) **Anatomical Region:** Right shoulder (glenohumeral joint) **View:** Coronal oblique T1-weighted sequence **Observed Pathology:** The image demonstrates a classic **Hill-Sachs lesion**, characterized by a cortical depression and marrow signal abnormality on the posterolateral aspect of the superior humeral head. This impaction fracture is a hallmark sign of prior anterior glenohumeral dislocation. **Characteristic Visual Features:** * **Humeral Head:** Focal wedge-shaped defect in the subchondral bone of the superolateral humeral head. * **Glenohumeral Alignment:** The humeral head is currently reduced within the glenoid fossa. * **Surrounding Structures:** Visualization of the acromion, clavicle, and deltoid musculature. There is a suggestion of labral pathology (likely a Bankart lesion) at the inferior glenoid rim, typically associated with this injury pattern. **Clinical Context & Significance:** The presence of a Hill-Sachs lesion is a critical radiologic marker for shoulder instability. It represents the "engagement" of the humeral head against the anterior glenoid rim during a dislocation event. This finding is essential for preoperative planning to assess the risk of recurrent instability and to determine the need for specialized procedures like a Remplissage or bone grafting.

Reading File
Finding Sources
Finding Sources
Reading File
Finding Sources
Reading File
Finding Sources
Reading File
Finding Sources
Finding Sources
Finding Sources
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Reading File
Loading Image
Loading Image
I now have everything I need to write a comprehensive, textbook-quality response. Let me compile it all.

Recurrent Dislocation of the Shoulder

Based on Rockwood and Green's Fractures in Adults (10th ed., 2025), Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics (15th ed., 2026), and Pye's Surgical Handicraft (22nd ed.)

1. Definition and Introduction

Recurrent shoulder dislocation refers to repeated episodes of glenohumeral joint displacement following an initial traumatic event. Glenohumeral instability is the most common form of joint instability in the body, with anterior instability being far more prevalent than posterior or multidirectional instability (MDI). The incidence of anterior glenohumeral instability in the general US population is 0.08 per 1,000 person-years, but rises dramatically to 1.69 per 1,000 person-years in military personnel, and young males in contact sports develop it at rates as high as 3% per year.
After a first dislocation, recurrence rates are especially high in the young. In a landmark study by Hovelius et al., nearly half of patients under 25 years old required eventual surgical stabilization, and approximately two-thirds had shoulder arthritis at 25-year follow-up. Robinson et al. demonstrated that 56% of patients under 35 years old developed recurrent instability after nonoperative management.

2. Pathoanatomy - "The Essential Lesion"

Bankart originally identified the avulsion of the anteroinferior glenohumeral ligament-labrum complex from the glenoid rim as the essential lesion creating shoulder instability. In practice, a spectrum of injuries occurs:

a. Soft Tissue Injuries

  • Classic Bankart lesion: Avulsion of the anteroinferior labrum and inferior glenohumeral ligament (IGHL) complex from the glenoid rim
  • HAGL (Humeral Avulsion of Glenohumeral Ligament): Less common; IGHL avulses from the humeral side
  • Capsular stretching/rupture: Especially the anterior band of the IGHL
  • ALPSA (Anterior Labroligamentous Periosteal Sleeve Avulsion): Labrum and periosteum peel medially

b. Bony Injuries ("Bipolar Lesions")

  • Hill-Sachs lesion: An impaction fracture of the posterolateral humeral head against the harder glenoid rim during anterior dislocation. Visible as a "hatchet" or wedge-shaped defect
  • Bony Bankart lesion: Fracture and fragmentation of the anteroinferior glenoid rim
  • Less commonly: coracoid fractures, greater tuberosity fractures, lesser tuberosity fractures
These are the "kissing lesions" visible on MRI:
MRI axial showing Hill-Sachs posterolateral humeral head impaction and Bankart anteroinferior glenoid avulsion - pathognomonic of recurrent anterior glenohumeral instability

c. Other Associated Injuries

  • Rotator cuff tears (especially in patients >40 years)
  • Axillary nerve injury
  • Brachial plexus injury
  • Vascular injury (rare)

3. Static and Dynamic Stabilizers

Understanding why the shoulder re-dislocates requires understanding its stabilizing system:

Static Stabilizers

StructureRole
Glenoid labrumDeepens the glenoid socket by ~50%; increases concavity
IGHL (anterior band)Primary restraint to anterior translation in ABER position
MGHLLimits anterior translation at 45° abduction; absent in up to 30% of people
SGHL + coracohumeral lig.Limits inferior translation in adduction
Glenohumeral articular geometryCartilage arc, version, shape
Negative intra-articular pressureActs as a suction cup mechanism

Dynamic Stabilizers

StructureRole
Rotator cuffJoint compression, force couple, dynamizes ligaments
Biceps tendonSecondary stabilizer via superior labral attachment
DeltoidCompressive and directional force
ProprioceptionMechanoreceptors (Pacinian corpuscles, Ruffini endings, Golgi tendon organs) in capsule/ligaments mediate reflex muscle activation
Both Warner et al. and Lephart et al. showed that proprioception is disrupted in patients with recurrent instability, and can be restored after surgical repair.

4. Classification

Matsen and Thomas Classification (TUBS / AMBRII)

TUBSAMBRII
Traumatic onsetAtraumatic onset
Unidirectional instabilityMultidirectional instability
Bankart lesion presentBilateral laxity
Surgery requiredRehabilitation first-line
Inferior capsule shift if surgery needed
Interval (rotator) closure

Direction-Based Classification

  • Anterior (most common, ~95%)
  • Posterior
  • Inferior (luxatio erecta - rare)
  • Multidirectional

5. Risk Factors for Recurrence

Key patient- and injury-specific factors that predict recurrence after a primary dislocation:
  • Age <25 years - single strongest predictor
  • Male sex
  • Contact/collision sport participation (football, rugby)
  • Military service
  • First dislocation requiring ER visit with sedation for reduction
  • Number and direction of prior dislocations
  • Bony lesions (large Hill-Sachs or glenoid bone loss)
  • Capsular laxity or collagen disorder (Ehlers-Danlos, Marfan syndrome)
  • Prior failed surgical repair

6. Clinical Features

History

  • Mechanism: arm abducted and externally rotated (ABER) - classic mechanism for anterior dislocation
  • Subsequent episodes occur with less force - eventually spontaneous or with minimal provocation
  • Patient may sometimes self-reduce the shoulder
  • Painful apprehension with the arm in the "at-risk" position
  • Documented prior dislocations, prior reductions (with or without sedation)

Physical Examination

Inspection: Shoulder asymmetry, wasting of deltoid, scars from prior surgery
Key Provocative Tests for Anterior Instability:
  1. Apprehension Test: Arm in 90° abduction and maximal external rotation - positive if patient feels apprehension (not just pain)
  2. Relocation Test: Posterior pressure on the proximal humerus in the apprehension position relieves symptoms
  3. Anterior Release (Surprise) Test: Sudden removal of the posterior force - the most accurate single test (sensitivity 63.9%, specificity 98.9%)
  4. Bony Apprehension Test: Apprehension at ≤45° abduction and ≤45° ER - sensitivity 100%, specificity 86% for significant bony lesions
  5. Load and Shift Test: Humeral head translation assessed anteriorly and posteriorly
  6. Sulcus Sign: For inferior/multidirectional instability
For posterior instability:
  • Jerk Test: Axial load with arm at 90° abduction and maximal internal rotation, then horizontally adducted - positive if a clunk is felt
  • Posterior Drawer Test
For MDI: Beighton Hypermobility Score (≥5 = hypermobile)

7. Imaging

Plain Radiographs

  • AP view: Assess glenohumeral alignment, glenoid wear, Hill-Sachs deformity
  • True AP (Grashey view): Tangential view of the joint space
  • Axillary lateral: Assesses anterior-posterior position of humeral head (essential - cannot assess direction without it)
  • Modified axillary view: Patient tolerates this better in acute injury
  • Stryker notch view: Best for detecting Hill-Sachs lesion (arm raised vertically, beam 10° cephalad)
  • West Point view: Best for detecting bony Bankart lesion (beam 25° downward and 25° medial)
  • Bernageau profile view: Measures anterior glenoid bone loss; comparable accuracy to CT

CT and CT Arthrography

  • Best for quantifying glenoid bone loss and assessing Hill-Sachs size
  • 3D reconstruction helps calculate glenoid surface area deficit
  • Critical for surgical planning (Latarjet vs. Bankart vs. bone grafting)

MRI and MR Arthrography

  • Gold standard for soft tissue pathology: labral tears, capsular injury, HAGL, rotator cuff
  • MR arthrogram with ABER view improves detection of anteroinferior labral tears
  • Shows bone marrow edema in Hill-Sachs and Bankart lesions

8. Management

A. Nonoperative Treatment

Indications: First-time dislocation in older patients (>40 years), low-demand patients, atraumatic instability, MDI
Protocol:
  1. Reduction of acute dislocation (with analgesia/sedation)
  2. Brief immobilization in a sling (2-4 weeks)
  3. Supervised physiotherapy - rotator cuff strengthening (especially infraspinatus, teres minor, subscapularis), periscapular muscle strengthening, proprioception training
  4. Activity modification
Outcomes: Variable and strongly age-dependent. Recurrence rates approaching 90% in patients under 20 years old with nonoperative management alone.

B. Operative Treatment

Absolute Indications:
  • More than one shoulder subluxation or dislocation with anterior labral detachment (Bankart lesion)
  • Recurrent anterior instability despite adequate conservative treatment
  • Locked dislocation with failed closed reduction under anesthesia
Relative Indications:
  • High-risk athletes (contact/overhead sports) with first-time dislocation and documented labral pathology on MRI
Relative Contraindications:
  • Primary collagen disorders (Ehlers-Danlos, Marfan)
  • Voluntary dislocators or atraumatic MDI (without prior rehabilitation)
  • Active infection or severe post-traumatic arthritis
  • Neurologic paralysis (axillary/suprascapular nerve)
  • Capsular deficiency or prior thermal capsulorrhaphy

Surgical Procedures

The key determinant of surgical choice today is glenoid bone loss and the "engagement" of the Hill-Sachs lesion:
Treatment algorithm for recurrent anterior shoulder instability based on glenoid bone loss percentage and Hill-Sachs engagement - from Rockwood and Green's (2025)

1. Arthroscopic Bankart Repair (ABR)

Mechanism: Reattaches the avulsed anteroinferior labrum and IGHL complex to the glenoid rim using suture anchors, with capsular plication if needed.
Indications: Glenoid bone loss <13.5-17.3% with a non-engaging (on-track) Hill-Sachs lesion.
Key Points:
  • ABR now accounts for 90.5% of all shoulder stabilization surgeries
  • Success rates comparable to open repair when patient selection is appropriate
  • Advantages: minimizes subscapularis morbidity, reduces arthrofibrosis risk
  • Recurrence rates increase with: glenoid bone loss >20%, engaging Hill-Sachs, contact sports, age <20 years

2. Open Bankart Repair

Approach: Deltopectoral approach - subscapularis is split or tenotomized 1 cm from the bicipital groove, joint opened, labrum and capsule reattached with anchors.
Indication: When arthroscopic repair is insufficient, in revision cases, or in the presence of capsular deficiency.
Note: Inevitably produces some restriction of external rotation (which is its mechanism of action for stability).

3. Putti-Platt Procedure

  • Overlapping subscapularis and anterior capsule repair, shortening both
  • Tightens anterior structures
  • Produces significant restriction of external rotation
  • Now largely of historical interest; replaced by anatomic Bankart-type repairs

4. Remplissage Procedure

  • Arthroscopic infraspinatus tenodesis into the Hill-Sachs defect (fills the lesion)
  • Performed in combination with Bankart repair when an "engaging" (off-track) Hill-Sachs lesion is present with glenoid bone loss 17.4-30%
  • Prevents the Hill-Sachs defect from engaging the glenoid rim

5. Latarjet Procedure (Coracoid Transfer)

Mechanism: The coracoid process (with its attached conjoined tendon) is transferred to the anteroinferior glenoid to:
  1. Extend the glenoid arc (bone effect)
  2. Create a sling effect via the conjoined tendon against the subscapularis (dynamic sling)
  3. Repair of CA ligament to capsule
Indications: Glenoid bone loss 17.4-30% with an engaging (off-track) Hill-Sachs lesion
Surgical Technique: Deltopectoral approach; subscapularis split horizontally; coracoid is osteotomized, decorticated, and fixed to the anteroinferior glenoid neck with 2 partially-threaded cortical screws, flush with the glenoid articular surface.
Outcomes: Low recurrence rates even in contact athletes.

6. Glenoid Bone Grafting (Autograft or Allograft)

Indication: Massive glenoid bone loss >30%
Grafts used: Iliac crest autograft, distal tibial allograft, distal clavicle

9. Posterior Glenohumeral Instability

Less common. Common causes include seizures, electrocution, falls onto forward-flexed and internally rotated arm.
  • Subscapularis, anterior deltoid, and pectoralis major overpower the posterior cuff during tonic-clonic seizures, creating a locked posterior dislocation
  • Treatment: reverse Bankart repair (posterior labral reattachment), posterior capsular plication, or posterior glenoid bone grafting

10. Multidirectional Instability (MDI)

  • Characterized by instability in more than one direction, usually with generalized ligamentous laxity
  • AMBRII pattern
  • First-line: Intense physiotherapy (rotator cuff, deltoid, periscapular muscles) for 6-12 months
  • If surgery needed: Inferior capsular shift (open or arthroscopic capsulorrhaphy) with closure of the rotator interval

11. Complications

ComplicationNotes
Recurrent instabilityMost common; related to bony deficiency, patient factors
Glenohumeral arthritisOccurs in ~2/3 of patients at 25-year follow-up
Axillary nerve injuryWith dislocation or during surgery
Rotator cuff tearEspecially in >40 years age group
Loss of external rotationAfter Putti-Platt or over-tightened capsulorrhaphy
Hardware failure (Latarjet)Screw breakage, coracoid nonunion
Subscapularis ruptureOpen anterior surgery complication
InfectionRare

12. Summary Table

FeatureDetail
Most common directionAnterior (~95%)
Essential lesionBankart (anteroinferior labral avulsion)
Impaction fractureHill-Sachs (posterolateral humeral head)
Key classificationTUBS vs. AMBRII (Matsen)
Strongest recurrence predictorAge <25 years
Best imaging for bone lossCT with 3D reconstruction
Best imaging for soft tissueMR arthrogram
Most common surgery (2025)Arthroscopic Bankart repair (90.5%)
Bone graft procedureLatarjet (for >17-30% glenoid loss)
MDI initial treatmentPhysiotherapy (not surgery)

Sources:
  • Rockwood and Green's Fractures in Adults, 10th ed. (2025), Chapter 35: Glenohumeral Instability, pp. 1248-1325
  • Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics, 15th ed. (2026), Shoulder Chapter
  • Pye's Surgical Handicraft, 22nd ed. - Recurrent dislocation of the shoulder
This is a shared conversation. Sign in to Orris to start your own chat.