I now have excellent primary source material from Boericke's Materia Medica. I have enough to compile a thorough, well-organized answer. Let me now write the complete response.
Therapeutics of Oedema (Dropsy) - Boericke's Materia Medica
Note: Boericke's Materia Medica is not in the medical library database, so this answer is compiled from Boericke's Pocket Manual of Homoeopathic Materia Medica (public domain text), cross-verified against the live materiamedica.info Boericke source.
REMEDIES COVERING ALL THREE CAUSES (Cardiac + Renal + Hepatic)
1. APOCYNUM CANNABINUM (Indian Hemp)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke states: "Increases secretions of mucous and serous membranes and acts on cellular tissue, producing oedema and dropsy, and on skin causing diaphoresis." It is "one of our most efficient remedies in dropsies, ascites, anasarca and hydrothorax, and urinary troubles." In Bright's disease (renal oedema) it addresses "the digestive complaints with nausea, vomiting, drowsiness, difficult breathing." Its active principle Cymarin lowers pulse rate and increases blood pressure - directly addressing the haemodynamic failure driving cardiac dropsy. The remedy covers hepatic and renal dropsy through its diuretic action on cellular tissue.
Keynote
"A diminished frequency of the pulse is a prime indication." Generalised anasarca, ascites, hydrothorax with scanty urine, thirst and nausea with vomiting of whatever is swallowed. General cyanosis and general dropsy. Great prostration.
Modalities
- Worse: cold weather, cold drinks, uncovering
- Complementary: Apis, Arsenicum, Digitalis, Helleborus
2. APIS MELLIFICA (Bee Venom)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke: "Erysipelatous inflammations, dropsical effusions and anasarca, acute inflammation of kidneys and other parenchymatous tissues are characteristic pathological states corresponding to Apis. Apis acts especially on outer parts, skin, coatings of inner organs, serous membranes. It produces serous inflammation with effusion - membranes of brain, heart, pleuritic effusion." The remedy acts on the serous membranes regardless of whether the cause is cardiac (pericardial effusion), renal (nephrotic syndrome anasarca), or hepatic (ascites/peritoneal effusion).
Keynote
"Swelling or puffing up of various parts, oedema, red rosy hue, stinging pains, soreness, intolerance of heat and slightest touch, and afternoon aggravation." Scanty, dark urine. Bag-like, watery swelling under eyes (especially lower lids). No thirst with anasarca.
Modalities
- Worse: heat in any form, touch, pressure, late afternoon, after sleeping, in closed heated rooms, right side
- Better: open air, uncovering, cold bathing
3. ARSENICUM ALBUM
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Arsenicum produces profound debility with oedema through its action on tissue metabolism and blood. It covers cardiac dropsy through its action on heart muscle weakness; renal dropsy through albuminuria and nephritis; and hepatic dropsy through liver congestion and ascites. Boericke notes: "Dropsical swelling after ague; oedema and dropsy from organic disease of heart, liver, kidneys." The characteristic burning with great restlessness and prostration unites all three forms.
Keynote
Oedema with great burning pains relieved by heat. Extreme restlessness and anxiety. Marked periodicity. Great thirst for small sips of cold water. Waxy, pale, oedematous skin. Ascites with wasting - abdomen large while limbs emaciate.
Modalities
- Worse: cold, wet weather; after midnight (1-2 a.m.); cold drinks; right side
- Better: heat, warm applications, sitting erect
CARDIAC OEDEMA - Principal Remedies
4. DIGITALIS PURPUREA (Foxglove)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke states: "Comes into play in all diseases where the heart is primarily involved, where the pulse is weak, irregular, intermittent, abnormally slow, and dropsy of external and internal parts. Weakness and dilatation of the myocardium. Its greatest indication is in failure of compensation and especially when auricular fibrillation has set in." The remedy addresses cardiac dropsy at its root - the failing myocardium - producing "cardiac dropsy" as a direct consequence of inability of the heart to maintain circulation. Boericke further notes: "Liver enlarged, dyspnoea, albuminuria."
Keynote
"The least movement causes violent palpitation and sensation as if it would cease beating if he moves." Very slow, weak, intermittent pulse. Sudden sensation as if the heart stood still. Cyanosis. Swelling of feet. Dyspnoea worse lying - must sit up. Cardiac failure following fevers.
Modalities
- Worse: sitting erect, after meals, music
- Better: stomach empty, open air
5. STROPHANTHUS HISPIDUS
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke: "Extreme cardiac depression with intense gastric disturbance; dropsy." Strophanthus acts like a milder Digitalis - it tones the heart muscle and increases cardiac output without affecting pulse rate significantly, thus relieving the venous back-pressure causing oedema. It is especially suited to cardiac dropsy when Digitalis has been over-used or when the patient cannot tolerate Digitalis. Boericke notes it for "oedema and dyspnoea of valvular disease."
Keynote
Cardiac dropsy with gastric disturbance. Pulse rapid, irregular, alternating with slow. Oedema of lower limbs. Dyspnoea on least exertion. Anasarca. Useful in the aged with weak hearts.
Modalities
- Worse: exertion, motion
- Better: rest
6. CONVALLARIA MAJALIS (Lily of the Valley)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke: "Heart disease with vertigo and digestive disturbances." Convallaria increases the activity of the heart and acts on the nervous system. It is particularly indicated in cardiac dropsy where the whole venous system is engorged - the heart beats too rapidly and weakly. Produces scanty urine, palpitation, and oedema of a purely cardiac origin.
Keynote
Heart feels too large for the chest. Extremely rapid and irregular heart. Oedema with sensation of pulsation throughout the body. Dyspnoea; least exertion causes it. Tobacco heart with dropsy.
Modalities
- Worse: warm room, lying down, least exertion
- Better: fresh air
7. SQUILLA MARITIMA (Sea Onion)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke: "Squilla follows Digitalis if this fails to relieve water-logged cases." Squilla acts powerfully as a diuretic and cardiac stimulant. In cardiac dropsy with oedematous lungs and suppressed urine - especially when there is much urine which is watery and involuntary - Squilla restores urinary output. It targets the kidneys secondarily to cardiac failure.
Keynote
"Much watery urine - great urging; involuntary spurting of urine when coughing." Icy cold hands and feet with warmth of rest of the body. Cardiac dropsy not responding to Digitalis. Chest complaints with oedema.
Modalities
- Better: rest
- Worse: motion
- Compare: Digitalis, Strophanthus, Apocynum, Bryonia, Kali carbonicum
RENAL OEDEMA - Principal Remedies
8. HELLEBORUS NIGER (Christmas Rose)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke states Helleborus produces "dropsical effusion" and acts on the brain and kidneys. It specifically covers "general dropsical condition" arising from renal disease. The remedy depresses all vital functions, producing extreme sluggishness - urine is dark, scanty or suppressed with renal oedema. It is used in "post-scarlatinal dropsy" - a classic renal oedema following scarlet fever.
Keynote
Slow perception - everything is done slowly. Muscle weakness with oedema - body puffed, pale, waxy. Dark, scanty urine with coffee-ground sediment. Post-scarlatinal anasarca. Staring eyes with automatic motion of one hand to the mouth. Chewing motion of the jaw.
Modalities
- Worse: from evening until morning, uncovering, cold air
- Better: warmth
9. MERCURIUS DULCIS (Calomel)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke states: "Dropsies due to combined renal and cardiac diseases, especially with jaundice. Cirrhosis of the liver, especially in the hypertrophic form." Calomel promotes biliary and renal secretion, thus addressing dropsy arising from the combined derangement of these organs. The "pallor, flabby bloatedness, and turgid flaccidity" described by Boericke captures the renal-hepatic oedema picture. Dose: 1x (Jousset).
Keynote
Dropsy with jaundice - the combined renal-cardiac-hepatic picture. Pallor and flabby bloatedness. Eustachian catarrh and otitis media in scrofulous children. Remittent bilious attacks. Peritonitis and meningitis with plastic exudate.
Modalities
- Compare: Mercurius solubilis, Hepar sulph
10. TEREBINTHINA (Oil of Turpentine)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Terebinthina acts powerfully on the kidneys and mucous membranes producing haemorrhagic nephritis with oedema. Boericke describes "haematuria, burning, smoky urine" and anasarca from kidney affections. The remedy clears renal congestion that underlies dropsy.
Keynote
Urine smells of violets - a classic Boericke keynote. Haematuria with oedema. Anasarca with kidney involvement. Scanty, dark, smoky, bloody urine. Tympanitic abdomen with oedema.
Modalities
- Worse: at night, damp cold
- Better: motion, walking
11. ARSENICUM IODATUM
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Combines the renal action of Arsenicum (albuminuria, nephritis) with the glandular action of Iodine. Boericke indicates it for "cachectic states with albuminuria and nephrotic oedema" - the wasting, strumous patient with waxy oedema of renal disease.
Keynote
Profound debility, waxy pallor, oedema with nephritis. Ravenous appetite with emaciaton. Thin, watery, excoriating discharges. Oedema with great debility.
Modalities
- Worse: cold, damp
- Better: warmth, open air
HEPATIC OEDEMA - Principal Remedies
12. CHELIDONIUM MAJUS (Celandine)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke: "A prominent liver remedy, covering many of the direct reflexes from hepatic disturbances." Chelidonium acts on the liver to increase bile flow, reduce congestion, and relieve portal hypertension that drives hepatic ascites. It specifically targets "jaundice with liver enlargement" and the liver-driven oedema of cirrhotic and obstructive hepatic disease.
Keynote
"Constant pain under the inferior angle of the right scapula" - the most characteristic Boericke keynote. Jaundice with clay-coloured stool. Right-sided complaints. Liver enlarged and tender. Ascites with jaundice.
Modalities
- Worse: right side, motion, touch, change of weather, early morning
- Better: after dinner, from pressure, hot food and drink
13. CARDUS MARIANUS (St. Mary's Thistle)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke describes Cardus as acting specifically on the liver and portal system: "Liver, engorged and indurated. Cirrhosis with dropsy." It relieves portal congestion and the resultant ascites. The remedy stimulates bile secretion and restores hepatic parenchymal function - directly relieving the mechanism of hepatic oedema (reduced albumin synthesis + portal hypertension).
Keynote
Hepatic dropsy with yellow complexion. Ascites with enlarged liver. Hard, nodular liver. Varicose veins and haemorrhoids (portal hypertension picture). Nausea and vomiting of green, acid fluid.
Modalities
- Worse: lying on left side, motion, touch
- Better: rest
14. LYCOPODIUM CLAVATUM (Club Moss)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke: "Deep-acting remedy on the nutritional sphere." Lycopodium produces profound hepatic dysfunction with flatulence, constipation, and oedema driven by liver failure and portal hypertension. It particularly suits "liver affections with portal congestion" and hepatic ascites where the right lobe is predominantly affected.
Keynote
Bloating and fullness immediately after eating - even a small amount. 4-8 p.m. aggravation. Right-sided affections. Ascites with flatulence and liver enlargement. Urine: red sediment (lithiasis). Emaciation of upper body with oedema below.
Modalities
- Worse: 4-8 p.m., warmth, right side, lying on right side
- Better: warm food and drink, motion, after midnight
15. CHINA OFFICINALIS (Peruvian Bark / Cinchona)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke: "Debility from exhausting discharges, from loss of vital fluids." China produces dropsy through profound debility - particularly the hepatic cachexia of malaria, repeated fevers, and long-standing liver disease. Boericke specifically states it for "dropsical affections" where the cause is "periodical liver troubles" and depletion. The oedema is a consequence of hypo-albuminaemia from exhausted hepatic synthesis.
Keynote
"Periodicity is the keynote." Oedema after profuse haemorrhage, repeated fevers, or debilitating discharge. Tympanitic, bloated abdomen. Liver and spleen enlarged and sensitive. Every other day paroxysms. Great debility with tendency to oedema.
Modalities
- Worse: least touch, after loss of fluids, alternate days, periodically
- Better: hard pressure, warmth, bending double
16. ASCLEPIAS CORNUTI (Silk-weed)
How the Medicine Works (Pathophysiology)
Boericke states: "A remedy for dropsy, hepatic, renal or cardiac and post-scarlatinal; causes diaphoresis." The remedy acts on serous membranes and the skin - it promotes elimination through the skin via diaphoresis, relieving the burden on kidneys and reducing oedema. It has a special affinity for the liver, urinary organs, and nervous system.
Keynote
Dropsy of any cause (hepatic, renal, or cardiac) with suppressed perspiration. Acts as a depurant - eliminates through the skin when kidneys are failing. Restores diaphoresis where suppression has occurred.
Modalities
- Worse: smoking, sedentary habits
- Better: sweating, warm wraps
Quick Reference Summary Table
| Remedy | Cardiac | Renal | Hepatic | Hallmark Keynote |
|---|
| Apocynum | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Diminished pulse; nausea with vomiting |
| Apis | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Stinging pains; no thirst; afternoon agg. |
| Arsenicum | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Burning relieved by heat; restlessness; 1 a.m. |
| Asclepias cornuti | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Dropsy with suppressed perspiration |
| Digitalis | ✓ | - | - | Slow, intermittent pulse; heart ceases if moves |
| Strophanthus | ✓ | - | - | Cardiac depression + gastric disturbance |
| Convallaria | ✓ | - | - | Heart too large; extreme tachycardia |
| Squilla | ✓ | - | - | Follows Digitalis; urine spurts on coughing |
| Mercurius dulcis | - | ✓ | ✓ | Dropsy with jaundice; combined organ failure |
| Helleborus | - | ✓ | - | Post-scarlatinal; slow perception; dark urine |
| Terebinthina | - | ✓ | - | Urine smells of violets; haematuria |
| Chelidonium | - | - | ✓ | Pain under right scapula; jaundice |
| Cardus marianus | - | - | ✓ | Cirrhotic dropsy; portal congestion |
| Lycopodium | - | - | ✓ | 4-8 p.m.; bloating after eating; right side |
| China | - | - | ✓ | Periodicity; post-fever debility; tympanitis |
Clinical Note: When all three causes co-exist (cardiac-renal-hepatic combined failure), Apocynum cannabinum, Arsenicum album, and Apis mellifica are the first three remedies to consider in Boericke's schema. Mercurius dulcis specifically covers the combined renal + cardiac + hepatic picture with jaundice. The selection must always be individualised by the totality of symptoms - the modalities and keynotes above are the discriminating features.