Asha worker vs auxillary nurse midwife from park 27th edition community medicine

Reading File

Finding Sources

Reading File

I now have all the content needed to provide a comprehensive comparison. Here is the detailed comparison from Park's Textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine (27th edition):

ASHA Worker vs Auxiliary Nurse Midwife (ANM) - Park's Community Medicine

1. Basic Profile

Feature	ASHA	ANM (Health Worker Female)
Full form	Accredited Social Health Activist	Auxiliary Nurse Midwife
Nature of role	Community health volunteer (not a regular govt employee)	Trained health worker; regular government employee
Posted at	Village level (community)	Sub-centre
Education required	Minimum 8th class pass	Formally trained in nursing and midwifery
Gender	Female (married/widow/divorced preferred)	Female
Age group	25-45 years preferred	-
Selection norm	1 ASHA per 1000 population (relaxed in tribal/hilly/desert areas to 1 per habitation)	1 ANM per sub-centre (covering ~5000 population)
Remuneration	Performance-based incentives (not a fixed salary)	Regular government salary

2. Roles and Responsibilities

ASHA - Key Responsibilities

Health promotion/awareness - Creates awareness on nutrition, sanitation, hygiene, healthy living, and available health services.
Counseling - Counsels women on birth preparedness, safe delivery, breastfeeding, complementary feeding, immunization, contraception, RTI/STI prevention, and young child care.
Community mobilization - Mobilizes community to access services at anganwadi/sub-centre/PHC (immunization, ANC, PNC, nutrition, sanitation).
Village health planning - Works with Village Health and Sanitation Committee to develop a comprehensive village health plan.
Escort/accompaniment - Escorts/accompanies pregnant women and children requiring treatment to PHC/CHC/First Referral Unit.
Primary medical care - Provides primary care for minor ailments (diarrhoea, fevers) and first aid for minor injuries; provides DOTS under RNTCP.
Depot holder - Holds essential drugs/supplies: ORS, IFA tablets, chloroquine, disposable delivery kits, oral pills, condoms.
Vital events reporting - Reports births, deaths, and disease outbreaks to sub-centre/PHC.
Sanitation promotion - Promotes construction of household toilets.
Drug kit - Provided a drug kit with both AYUSH and allopathic formulations.

ASHA may have her role expanded (graded training for newborn care, management of common childhood illnesses).

ANM (Health Worker Female) - Key Responsibilities

1. Maternal and Child Health (MCH):

Registers and provides care to pregnant women throughout pregnancy
Ensures minimum 4 ANC visits per pregnancy
Tests urine for albumin and sugar; estimates haemoglobin
Refers for RPR test (syphilis) at PHC
Conducts deliveries when called; supervises Dai-conducted deliveries
Post-natal home visits on 0, 3, 7, and 42nd day (home/sub-centre delivery); 3, 7, and 42nd day (institutional delivery)
For low-birth-weight baby: 6 PNC visits (0, 3, 7, 14, 21, 28th day)
Initiates early breastfeeding within 1 hour of birth
Assesses growth/development of infants and under-5 children
Treats diarrhoea, ARI, minor ailments; refers severe cases per IMNCI guidelines
Implements JSY (Janani Suraksha Yojana) - identifies beneficiaries, obtains approvals, disburses funds
Tracks all pregnancies by name for ANC/PNC services

2. Family Planning:

Maintains eligible couple and child register (up to date at all times)
Distributes conventional contraceptives and oral contraceptives
Follow-up of female family planning acceptors; manages minor side effects; refers to PHC if needed
Establishes female depot holders for contraceptive supply
Builds rapport with ASHA, Dais, village leaders
Identifies women leaders; helps train them

3. Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP):

Identifies women needing MTP; refers to nearest approved institution
Educates community on septic abortion and MTP services

4. Nutrition:

Identifies malnutrition among children (0-5 years); treats and refers
Distributes IFA tablets to pregnant women, nursing mothers, young children
Administers Vitamin A solution to children per guidelines

5. Universal Programme on Immunization (UIP):

Immunizes pregnant women with TT
Administers pentavalent, DPT, OPV, IPV, measles, Hepatitis B, BCG vaccines per schedule
Ensures injection safety, manages AEFI
Submits weekly/monthly reports

6. Disease Control:

Passive surveillance for malaria; collects blood slides
Disease control activities for filariasis, TB, blindness, NCDs
IEC for NCD prevention and detection

7. Record Keeping:

Registers pregnant women, infants (0-1 year), under-5 children, women (15-44 years)
Maintains prenatal, maternity, child care, family planning records
Submits weekly/monthly reports to Health Assistant (Female)

8. Team Activities:

Attends staff meetings at PHC/CD Block
Coordinates with Health Worker Male (HWM), ASHA, and Dais
Coordinates with PRI and Village Health and Sanitation Committee
Meets Health Assistant (Female) weekly
Disposes medical waste per guidelines

3. Key Differences at a Glance

Parameter	ASHA	ANM
Level in health system	Peripheral community volunteer	Sub-centre level (formal health worker)
Training	Short-term induction + on-job	Formal 18-month ANM training course
Salary/Pay	Performance-based incentives only	Fixed government salary
Clinical skills	Basic first aid, minor ailments, DOTS	Conducts deliveries, ANC, immunizations, clinical procedures
Supervises	Nobody	Supervises ASHAs and Dais
Supervised by	ANM/AWW	Health Assistant Female (LHV)
ANC role	Motivates, escorts women for ANC	Directly provides ANC care
Delivery care	Not trained to conduct deliveries	Conducts deliveries, supervises Dais
Drug dispensing	Limited drug kit (ORS, IFA, chloroquine, etc.)	Full range as per government norms
Record maintenance	Minimal (reports births/deaths)	Extensive (eligible couple register, ANC/PNC records, family planning data)
JSY role	Link worker - escorts and motivates	Identifies beneficiaries, obtains approvals, disburses money
Immunization	Does not administer vaccines	Administers full UIP vaccines
Integration	Works WITH ANM and AWW	Coordinates with ASHA, HWM, LHV

4. Hierarchy

Medical Officer (PHC)
        ↓
Health Assistant Female (LHV)
        ↓
ANM (Health Worker Female) - Sub-centre
        ↓
ASHA - Village level
        ↓ (guidance from)
Anganwadi Worker (AWW)

Source: Park's Textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine, 27th Edition - Chapter on Health Care Infrastructure/National Health Programmes, pp. 989-1012

This is a shared conversation. Sign in to Orris to start your own chat.