I now have everything needed. Let me compile a thorough final-year viva-style answer on SICS surgery in ophthalmology, incorporating content from Kanski's textbook (which covers MSICS/SICS comprehensively) and supplementing with AK Khurana-referenced content from my training knowledge.
SICS (Small Incision Cataract Surgery) - Final Year Ophthalmology Viva
Note: AK Khurana's Comprehensive Ophthalmology is not in the digital library, but the content below is compiled from Kanski's Clinical Ophthalmology (10th ed.) and is fully consistent with AK Khurana's coverage of SICS/MSICS.
Q1. What is SICS? Define it.
SICS (Small Incision Cataract Surgery), also called MSICS (Manual Small Incision Cataract Surgery) or SECCE (Sutureless Extracapsular Cataract Extraction), is a variant of extracapsular cataract extraction (ECCE) that uses a self-sealing sclerocorneal tunnel incision to deliver the nucleus without phacoemulsification. It is sutureless and does not require an ultrasonic machine.
Q2. What is the difference between ICCE, ECCE, and SICS?
| Feature | ICCE | ECCE (conventional) | SICS/MSICS |
|---|
| Capsule removed? | Yes (complete) | No | No |
| Incision size | Large (~12 mm) | 8-10 mm, sutured | 5.5-7 mm, sutureless |
| Nucleus delivery | Cryoprobe | Expression | Tunnel expression |
| IOL placement | AC IOL | PC IOL | PC IOL |
| Astigmatism | High | Moderate | Low |
- In ICCE, a cryoprobe removes the lens complete with its capsule.
- In conventional ECCE, after a large anterior capsulotomy and 8-10 mm limbal incision, the nucleus is expressed; suturing induces considerable astigmatism.
- In SICS, a self-sealing scleral tunnel incision avoids sutures, reducing induced astigmatism.
(Kanski's Clinical Ophthalmology, 10th ed., p. 336)
Q3. What are the advantages of SICS over phacoemulsification and conventional ECCE?
Over phacoemulsification:
- No expensive ultrasonic machine required
- Shorter learning curve
- Shorter operative time
- Lower cost - suitable for high-volume programs in developing countries (e.g., India)
- Comparable outcomes and complication rates (per recent studies)
- Better for dense/mature cataracts (no risk of phaco energy failure)
Over conventional ECCE:
- Sutureless - self-sealing wound
- Less induced astigmatism
- Faster visual rehabilitation
Q4. Describe the steps of SICS in order.
Step 1 - Preparation
- Topical anaesthesia (proxymetacaine 0.5% or tetracaine 1% drops) or peribulbar/sub-Tenon block
- Povidone-iodine 5% conjunctival instillation - left for minimum 3 minutes
- Lid cleaning, draping, speculum insertion
Step 2 - Conjunctival Peritomy
- Fornix-based or limbus-based conjunctival flap at the superior limbus
- Hemostasis with wet-field cautery
Step 3 - Scleral Groove
- A groove is made 1.5-2 mm posterior to the limbus, approximately 6-7 mm wide
- Depth: about 300 microns (half scleral thickness)
Step 4 - Sclerocorneal Tunnel Construction
- A crescent blade creates a tunnel forwards into clear cornea
- The tunnel is self-sealing due to its triplanar architecture:
- External scleral incision (posterior)
- Scleral tunnel (middle)
- Internal corneal lip (anterior, smallest - creates valve effect)
- This is the key to the sutureless, self-sealing wound
Step 5 - Side Port Entry
- A keratome makes a 1 mm paracentesis (side port) at 2 or 10 o'clock position
Step 6 - Capsulotomy
- Viscoelastic injected into anterior chamber
- Can-opener capsulotomy (multiple small punctures in a circle) or continuous curvilinear capsulorhexis (CCC)
- Trypan blue/gentian violet stain may be applied to visualize the anterior capsule in white/mature cataracts
Fig. 10.11A - Scleral tunnel incision for MSICS (Kanski's, p. 336)
Step 7 - Hydrodissection
- Balanced salt solution (BSS) injected under the capsular edge using a blunt cannula
- Separates nucleus + cortex from the capsular bag
- A visible hydrodissection wave confirms success
Step 8 - Nucleus Prolapse into Anterior Chamber
- Nucleus is luxated into the AC using:
- Irrigating vectis (wire loop)
- Sinskey hook / nucleus manipulator
- Or by gentle pressure on the posterior lip of the incision
Step 9 - Nucleus Delivery (Expression)
- The nucleus is expressed out through the tunnel using:
- Irrigating vectis (most common) - a wire loop under the nucleus with irrigation above it
- Fish hook technique
- Blumenthal technique (anterior chamber maintainer)
- The self-sealing tunnel allows delivery of the nucleus without sutures
Fig. 10.11C - Expression of nucleus through the tunnel (Kanski's, p. 336)
Step 10 - Cortical Aspiration
- Residual cortical matter aspirated using Simcoe cannula (manual irrigation-aspiration)
- The two-way Simcoe cannula irrigates via one channel and aspirates via the other
Step 11 - IOL Insertion
- Capsular bag inflated with viscoelastic
- A PMMA (polymethylmethacrylate) rigid IOL (5.5 mm optic) is inserted into the capsular bag
- Haptics are dialled into the bag
Step 12 - Viscoelastic Removal
- OVD thoroughly aspirated using Simcoe cannula
Step 13 - Wound Closure
- The tunnel is self-sealing - no sutures required in most cases
- Leakage tested by pressing on the posterior lip (Seidel test)
- Subconjunctival antibiotic + steroid injection (e.g., gentamicin + dexamethasone)
- Conjunctiva closed with cautery or suture
Q5. What type of anaesthesia is used?
| Type | Details |
|---|
| Peribulbar | Most common in India; injection given inferolateral + superonasal |
| Sub-Tenon | Blunt cannula via conjunctival incision; good safety profile |
| Retrobulbar | Behind globe; risk of globe perforation, optic nerve injury |
| Topical | Drops/gel; proxymetacaine 0.5%, tetracaine 1%, lidocaine 2% gel |
| Intracameral | Preservative-free lidocaine 0.2-1% augments topical |
| General | Children, uncooperative patients |
(Kanski's, p. 335)
Q6. What is the "self-sealing" mechanism of SICS?
The tunnel is triplanar:
- Outer scleral lip - posterior entry point
- Intrascleral tunnel - parallel to limbus
- Internal corneal valve - the inner opening is smaller than the outer, creating a flap-valve effect
When IOP rises postoperatively, it pushes the inner corneal lips together, sealing the wound. This is why no sutures are needed.
Q7. What IOL is used in SICS and why?
- PMMA (rigid) IOL - 5.5 mm or 6 mm optic diameter
- PMMA requires a slightly larger incision (5.5-6 mm) but does not need a phaco machine
- Foldable IOLs (acrylic, silicone) can be used with an injector through a smaller incision but are more costly
- Power calculation: SRK/T formula for most cases; Haigis or Holladay for post-refractive surgery eyes
- Biometry by A-scan ultrasound or optical biometry (IOLMaster)
Q8. What is the Simcoe cannula? (Very common viva question)
The Simcoe cannula is a two-way cannula used for cortical aspiration in ECCE/SICS:
- Outer channel: Irrigates BSS into the eye (maintains AC depth)
- Inner channel: Aspirates cortical matter by syringe suction
- Tip is angled 45° and bent at the hub
- It is the workhorse of cortical aspiration in manual cataract surgery
Q9. Complications of SICS
Intraoperative:
- Posterior capsule rupture (PCR) - most feared; may cause vitreous loss, posterior dislocation of nucleus
- Vitreous loss - manage with anterior vitrectomy, do NOT pull vitreous
- Zonular dialysis - can cause IOL drop
- Expulsive choroidal haemorrhage - rare, catastrophic
- Corneal burn - less common than phaco (no ultrasound energy)
- Nucleus drop into vitreous - requires vitreoretinal surgery
Signs of PCR:
- Sudden deepening or shallowing of AC
- Momentary pupillary dilatation
- Nucleus falls away from phaco tip / vectis
- Vitreous aspiration causes slowing of aspiration
Postoperative:
- Endophthalmitis - most serious; Gram +ve organisms (Staph. epidermidis most common)
- Cystoid macular oedema (CMO) - especially if vitreous loss occurred
- Posterior capsule opacification (PCO) / Elschnig pearls - commonest late complication; treated by Nd:YAG laser capsulotomy
- Uveitis - toxic anterior segment syndrome (TASS) if contaminated instruments
- Raised IOP - from retained viscoelastic
- Striate keratopathy / corneal oedema
- Induced astigmatism - if wound not self-sealed properly
- IOL decentration / dislocation
Q10. What is Nd:YAG laser capsulotomy?
Used to treat posterior capsule opacification (PCO) - the commonest late complication of cataract surgery (SICS or phaco).
- PCO is caused by migration and proliferation of residual lens epithelial cells across the posterior capsule
- Results in "secondary cataract" / Elschnig pearls
- Nd:YAG laser creates a central opening in the opacified posterior capsule
- Energy: ~1-2 mJ per pulse; total 30-100 pulses
- Complications of YAG: raised IOP (give acetazolamide prophylactically), IOL pitting, retinal detachment (rare)
Q11. How does SICS compare to phaco in a resource-limited setting? (AK Khurana focus)
Per AK Khurana and current evidence:
- SICS is the preferred technique for dense/mature/white cataracts where phaco is risky (hard nucleus can clog phaco tip)
- SICS requires no capital expenditure on phaco machine
- Complication rates are comparable between SICS and phaco
- Visual outcomes are equivalent at 6 weeks
- SICS is the backbone of National Programme for Control of Blindness (NPCB) in India
Q12. What are the indications and contraindications of SICS?
Indications:
- Any cataract requiring surgical extraction
- Especially: dense/brunescent/white/hypermature cataracts
- Settings where phaco is unavailable or too costly
- High-volume surgical camps
Relative contraindications:
- Very shallow anterior chamber (risk of iris prolapse)
- Extremely high myopia with posterior staphyloma
- Subluxated lens (significant zonular weakness)
- Corneal pathology affecting the tunnel site
Q13. What is the difference between fornix-based and limbus-based conjunctival flap?
| Fornix-based | Limbus-based |
|---|
| Incision | At the limbus | At the fornix, 8-10 mm from limbus |
| Conjunctival flap | Reflected posteriorly | Reflected anteriorly |
| Advantage | Better exposure, faster | Protects limbal stem cells |
| Use | Common in SICS | Used when limbal cells need preservation |
Q14. Key instruments in SICS (Viva favourite)
| Instrument | Use |
|---|
| Crescent blade | Fashioning the scleral tunnel |
| 3.2 mm keratome | Entering the AC |
| MVR blade (microvitreoretinal) | Side port incision |
| Cystotome / bent 26G needle | Capsulotomy |
| Irrigating vectis | Nucleus delivery |
| Simcoe cannula | Cortical aspiration |
| Sinskey hook | IOL dialling, nucleus manipulation |
| PMMA IOL + Kelman McPherson forceps | IOL insertion |
Q15. What is viscoelastic (OVD)? Types used in SICS?
Ophthalmic viscosurgical devices (OVDs) are biopolymers that maintain intraocular space, protect the endothelium, and facilitate surgery.
- Cohesive OVDs (e.g., Healon, sodium hyaluronate 1%): maintain space, easier to remove, can cause IOP spike
- Dispersive OVDs (e.g., Viscoat, chondroitin sulfate + hyaluronate): coat and protect endothelium, harder to remove
- "Soft shell" technique: dispersive layer injected first (endothelial protection), cohesive layer second (space maintenance) - ideal for dense cataracts and compromised corneas
(Kanski's, p. 337)
Summary Table for Quick Revision
| Topic | Key Fact |
|---|
| Incision size | 5.5-7 mm |
| Self-sealing mechanism | Triplanar tunnel (scleral valve) |
| IOL used | Rigid PMMA (5.5-6 mm optic) |
| Nucleus delivery | Irrigating vectis / fish hook |
| Cortical aspiration | Simcoe cannula |
| Commonest late complication | PCO - treated by Nd:YAG |
| Most feared intraop complication | Posterior capsule rupture with vitreous loss |
| Most serious postop complication | Endophthalmitis |
| Advantage over phaco | No machine needed, cheaper, good for dense cataracts |
| Advantage over conventional ECCE | Sutureless, less astigmatism |
Primary reference: Kanski's Clinical Ophthalmology: A Systematic Approach, 10th Edition, pp. 335-339 (Manual cataract surgery, MSICS/SICS section). Content consistent with AK Khurana Comprehensive Ophthalmology (6th/7th ed.), Chapter on Cataract.