I now have comprehensive material from both Campbell's and Rockwood & Green. Let me compile this into a detailed, well-structured answer.
Approaches to the Proximal Tibia - Complete Enumeration
The proximal tibia (tibial plateau and proximal metaphysis) can be approached from six major directions. The choice depends on fracture pattern, soft tissue condition, and what needs to be fixed. Below is a complete enumeration with skin incision planes, intermuscular intervals, and key anatomical notes.
1. Anterolateral Approach to the Lateral Tibial Plateau
(Kandemir and MacLean; most common approach)
Indications: Unicondylar or bicondylar fractures involving the lateral plateau; the workhorse for split-depression fractures.
Position: Supine on radiolucent table; hip bumped to neutral rotation.
Skin Incision:
- Begin 2-3 cm proximal to the joint line, in line with the lateral femoral epicondyle.
- Carry the incision obliquely distally, crossing the midpoint of Gerdy's tubercle.
- As the tibial crest is approached, keep the incision 1-2 cm lateral to stay over the anterior compartment musculature (not over the crest itself).
- Optional: S-shaped or hockey-stick modification proximally.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Incise the iliotibial band in line with the skin incision; detach it anterior and posterior from Gerdy's tubercle.
- Develop the interval between the ITB and the joint capsule.
- Reflect the origin of the anterior compartment musculature (tibialis anterior) from the anterolateral tibia posteriorly.
- For articular exposure: perform a submeniscal arthrotomy - incise the meniscotibial (coronary) ligament immediately off its tibial insertion. Carry it posteriorly as far as the fibula (avoiding the LCL), and anteriorly as far as the lateral tibial tubercle, leaving the anterior horn origin intact.
- Place 3-4 retraction sutures in the lateral meniscal periphery.
Key structures at risk: Lateral meniscus (iatrogenic injury during arthrotomy), peroneal nerve (if dissection extended posteriorly past fibula).
- Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics 15th Ed, Technique 1.32
- Rockwood and Green's 10th Ed, p. 3137
2. Medial Approach to the Medial Tibial Plateau
(Technique 1.33)
Indications: Isolated medial plateau fractures; medial half of bicondylar plateau fractures.
Position: Supine.
Skin Incision:
- Begin 1-2 cm proximal to the joint line, in line with the medial femoral epicondyle.
- Extend distally over the pes anserinus insertion (bisecting the posteromedial border of the tibia and tibial crest - Line A in the figure below).
- Avoid the saphenous vein and saphenous nerve, which run posteriorly to the incision.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Take down the pes anserinus tendons (sartorius, gracilis, semitendinosus) sharply from the tibia, or retract them.
- Expose the superficial medial collateral ligament.
- Apply plate directly over the medial collateral ligaments.
Key structures at risk: Saphenous vein and nerve (anterior/medial); pes anserinus tendons must be carefully handled.
3. Posteromedial Approach to the Medial Tibial Plateau - Supine
(Technique 1.34)
Indications: Shear fractures of the medial plateau (especially posteromedial split fragments, Moore type I).
Position: Supine, knee externally rotated and slightly flexed.
Skin Incision:
- Longitudinal incision along the posteromedial border of the tibia (Line B in figure above).
- Begin 3 cm above the joint line; extend as far distally as needed.
- Avoid the saphenous vein and nerve, which lie anterior to this incision.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Mobilize and retract or incise the pes anserinus tendons (proximally/anteriorly or distally/posteriorly).
- Retract the medial gastrocnemius and soleus posteriorly.
- Expose the junction of popliteal fascia, semimembranosus muscle, and posterior capsule.
- Incise the periosteum longitudinally and subperiosteally elevate the popliteus muscle insertion off the posterior tibia.
4. Posteromedial Approach - Prone (Banks and Laufman)
(Technique 1.35)
Indications: Fixation of posteromedial split fractures; access to superomedial region of tibia.
Position: Prone.
Skin Incision:
- Hockey-stick incision: Begin the transverse limb at the lateral end of the popliteal flexion crease, extend it transversely across the popliteal space, then turn the incision distally along the medial side of the calf for 7-10 cm.
- This creates an angular flap of skin and subcutaneous tissue.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Incise deep fascia in line with the skin incision; identify and protect cutaneous nerves and superficial vessels.
- Define the interval between the semitendinosus tendon (medially) and the medial head of gastrocnemius (laterally).
- Retract semitendinosus proximally and medially; retract gastrocsoleus distally and laterally.
- Popliteus and flexor digitorum longus lie in the floor of this interval.
- Subperiosteally elevate FDL distally/laterally and popliteus proximally/medially.
- Exposes the posterior surface of the proximal fourth of the tibia.
- Further popliteus elevation exposes the posterior cruciate ligament fossa.
Key structures at risk: Tibial nerve and posterior tibial artery (lie beneath the soleus); protect by staying superficial to soleus during distal extension.
5. Lobenhoffer Posteromedial Approach (Galla and Lobenhoffer)
(Technique 1.36)
Indications: Direct posteromedial approach for medial tibial plateau fractures, specifically posteromedial split. Avoids popliteal neurovascular dissection.
Position: Supine or prone (supine preferred).
Skin Incision:
- Straight 6-8 cm longitudinal incision along the medial border of the medial head of the gastrocnemius muscle, beginning at the level of the joint line.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Incise subcutaneous tissue and popliteal fascia sharply.
- Free the medial border of the medial gastrocnemius head (without detaching it); retract it laterally.
- Bluntly dissect and retract the semimembranosus complex medially.
- The interval is between semimembranosus (medial) and medial gastrocnemius (lateral) - neurovascular bundle lies deep in the midline and is not entered.
- Find the upper edge of the popliteus muscle and detach it subperiosteally.
- Exposes the posteromedial tibial plateau.
- If more exposure needed: incise the tibial insertion of semimembranosus subperiosteally.
Key advantage: No dissection of popliteal neurovascular structures required.
6. Posterolateral Approach to the Tibial Plateau - With Fibular Osteotomy
(Solomon et al., Technique 1.37)
Indications: Lateral and posterolateral plateau fractures where fibular head osteotomy provides superior access.
Position: Supine, knee extended, then flexed to 60 degrees.
Skin Incision:
- 6-cm longitudinal incision anterior to the biceps femoris tendon contour on the fibular head.
- Can be extended distally as needed.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Incise subcutaneous fat and deep fascia over biceps tendon; incise fascia lata over biceps tendon and common peroneal nerve.
- Identify the common peroneal nerve in the adipose tissue of the popliteal fossa - this is the key protection step.
- Release CPN from the posterior intermuscular septum, posterior to peroneus longus, as it enters the lateral compartment.
- Expose the deep peroneal nerve by detaching peroneus longus and tibialis anterior from both aspects of the anterior intermuscular septum.
- Release the deep peroneal nerve as it enters the anterior compartment.
- Predrill the fibular head and neck just lateral to biceps femoris insertion; osteotomize the fibular neck with osteotome just above the peroneal nerve.
- Release capsule from proximal tibiofibular joint; reflect the fibular head proximally with attached biceps femoris tendon and LCL complex.
- Mobilize the lateral meniscus by detaching the coronary ligament from PCL to ITB.
- At closure: repair osteotomy with a longitudinal lag screw (or a one-third or full fibular head excision if needed, leaving biceps/LCL intact).
7. Posterolateral Approach - Without Fibular Osteotomy
(Frosch et al., Technique 1.38)
Indications: Lateral and posterolateral plateau fractures; avoids fibular osteotomy and its complications.
Position: Lateral decubitus, operative side up; thick rolled pillow under the knee.
Skin Incision:
- 15-cm posterolateral incision, starting 3 cm above the joint line, then following the fibula distally.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Incise the posterior part of the iliotibial band from Gerdy's tubercle and perform a lateral arthrotomy.
- Bluntly dissect into the popliteal fossa between the lateral origin of the gastrocnemius and the soleus muscle, exposing the popliteus.
- Ligate the inferior geniculate vessels if necessary.
- Develop the interval between biceps femoris (anterolaterally) and popliteus (posteromedially) - this is the key internervous plane.
- Detach the soleus muscle from the posterior aspect of the fibula.
- Exposes the posterolateral plateau directly.
8. Tscherne-Johnson Extensile Approach to the Lateral Tibial Plateau
(Technique 1.39 - Johnson et al.)
Indications: Depressed lateral plateau fractures requiring maximum articular exposure.
Position: Supine, bump under ipsilateral hip; knee flexed over large bump so leg rests off the table edge.
Skin Incision:
- Lateral parapatellar incision from the supracondylar area of the distal femur to below and lateral to the tibial tubercle.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Develop a lateral full-thickness myocutaneous flap; reflect the ITB from Gerdy's tubercle.
- Flex the knee to 40 degrees; incise the middle part of the ITB distally from 4 cm above the joint line to the joint line, then continue anteriorly dividing the anterior half of the band to the patellar tendon.
- Incise the meniscal coronary ligament from posterior to anterior, ending at the patellar tendon; elevate the lateral meniscus with 3 absorbable sutures.
- Incise the origin of tibialis anterior along the lateral tibial metaphyseal flare, elevate it distally.
- Perform two osteotomies (anterior and distal to Gerdy's tubercle with a narrow osteotome at 90 degrees to each other).
- Rotate the Gerdy's tubercle fragment posteriorly on its posterior soft-tissue hinge to expose the undersurface of the lateral plateau.
- At closure: repair osteotomy with an overlying plate and screws.
9. Anterolateral Approach to the Tibial Shaft (Proximal Portion)
(Technique 1.29)
Indications: Anterior or anterolateral access to the proximal tibial shaft; preferred over direct anterior approach because it provides better soft-tissue coverage over implants.
Skin Incision:
- Longitudinal incision 1-2 cm lateral to the anterior border of the tibia (tibial crest). This ensures adequate soft-tissue bridge over the bone.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Sharply incise the fascia the entire length of the wound, approximately 1 cm lateral to the tibial crest.
- Elevate the anterior compartment musculature from the lateral face of the tibia.
- Incise and elevate periosteum over desired area (strip as little as possible - periosteal circulation is a nutritional source for bone).
10. Posteromedial Approach to the Tibial Shaft (Phemister Medial Approach)
(Technique 1.30)
Indications: Delayed unions and nonunions requiring posterior tibial bone grafting (Phemister technique). Continuation of the posteromedial approach to the proximal tibia distally.
Skin Incision:
- Longitudinal incision along the posteromedial border of the tibia.
Deep Dissection Plane:
- Protect the saphenous nerve and vein.
- This is a continuation distally of the posteromedial plateau approach.
11. Intramedullary Nailing Approaches (for Proximal Tibia IM Nailing)
(Rockwood and Green's 10th Ed)
For IM nail insertion, the starting point is in the proximal tibia. Three infrapatellar and one suprapatellar approach are used:
a. Medial Parapatellar (Infrapatellar)
- Incision: Centered at the midpoint of the patella, running distally approximately the length of the patella, placed 1 cm medial to center.
- Plane: Through skin down to identify the medial border of the patella; longitudinal incision along its medial border into the fat pad (extra-articular). Stay out of the knee joint.
- Issue: Patella and patellar tendon tend to push the starting wire too medially - overly medial start causes valgus deformity in proximal fractures.
b. Lateral Parapatellar (Infrapatellar)
- Incision: Same as above but centered 1 cm lateral to midline.
- Plane: Same principle, lateral border of patella; used when anatomy makes ideal start point more accessible laterally, or for proximal fractures.
c. Patellar Tendon Split (Infrapatellar)
- Incision: Midline, at midpoint of patella, running distally.
- Plane: Longitudinal split directly in the patellar tendon. Allows more central and lateral starting point than medial parapatellar.
- Issue: The tendon cannot be translated away from the wire, so the wire may angle posteriorly.
d. Suprapatellar Approach
- Position: Knee in semiextended position (preferred for proximal tibia fractures as it reduces extension deformity of the proximal fragment).
- Incision: Superior to the patella, through the quadriceps tendon or just above the superior pole of the patella.
- Plane: Enters the suprapatellar pouch/patellofemoral joint; allows near-straight access to the tibial canal without flexing the knee.
- Advantage: Decreased malalignment rates compared to hyperflexed infrapatellar approaches; reduced fluoroscopic time.
- Concern: Potential patellofemoral cartilage damage (long-term data still emerging).
Summary Table
| Approach | Incision | Interval / Plane | Key Indication |
|---|
| Anterolateral (lateral plateau) | Oblique, proximal to Gerdy's tubercle distally to 1-2 cm lateral to tibial crest | ITB/joint capsule; anterior compartment off tibia; submeniscal arthrotomy | Lateral plateau fractures (most common) |
| Medial (medial plateau) | Longitudinal, medial epicondyle to pes anserinus | Pes anserinus tendons retracted; over sMCL | Medial plateau fractures |
| Posteromedial - supine | Longitudinal along posteromedial border, 3 cm above joint line | Pes anserinus retracted; popliteus subperiosteal elevation | Posteromedial shear fractures |
| Posteromedial - prone (Banks & Laufman) | Hockey-stick: transverse across popliteal fossa + distal along medial calf | Between semitendinosus and medial gastrocnemius | Superomedial tibial access |
| Lobenhoffer posteromedial | 6-8 cm longitudinal along medial gastrocnemius border, at joint line | Between semimembranosus (med) and medial gastrocnemius (lat) | Posteromedial split fragments; no NV dissection |
| Posterolateral with fibular osteotomy (Solomon) | 6 cm, anterior to biceps femoris on fibular head | ITB/biceps; CPN protection; fibular head osteotomy | Posterolateral plateau with fibular head osteotomy |
| Posterolateral without fibular osteotomy (Frosch) | 15 cm posterolateral, 3 cm above joint line, following fibula | Between lateral gastrocnemius/soleus and biceps/popliteus | Posterolateral plateau; avoids fibular osteotomy |
| Tscherne-Johnson extensile | Lateral parapatellar, supracondylar to below tibial tubercle | ITB/Gerdy's osteotomy; submeniscal; tibialis anterior elevated | Depressed lateral plateau (maximum exposure) |
| Anterolateral shaft | Longitudinal, 1-2 cm lateral to tibial crest | Anterior compartment off lateral tibial face | Tibial shaft plating |
| Posteromedial shaft (Phemister) | Longitudinal, posteromedial border | Saphenous NV protected; posterior tibial surface | Nonunion bone grafting |
| IM nail - infrapatellar (3 variants) | Midline or 1 cm medial/lateral at patella midpoint | Medial/lateral parapatellar or tendon split into fat pad | IM nailing of tibia |
| IM nail - suprapatellar | Above patella, through quadriceps tendon | Enters patellofemoral joint/suprapatellar pouch | Proximal tibia fractures; semiextended position |
Sources:
- Campbell's Operative Orthopaedics 15th Ed 2026, Techniques 1.29, 1.30, 1.32-1.39 (pp. 43-50)
- Rockwood and Green's Fractures in Adults 10th Ed 2025, Chapter 62-63 (pp. 3137, 3191)