I'll now do a thorough, test-by-test clinical analysis of Lata's entire VNG dataset, integrating all numerical values with clinical interpretation.
Detailed VNG Analysis — Lata | CCDA00454 | 54F | 11-May-2026
PATIENT CONTEXT
Key history drivers for interpretation:
- First vertigo episode 20 years ago post two-wheeler fall (head trauma)
- Second major head trauma 7th April 2026 → vertigo 2 days later
- Positional triggers (rolling, looking up/down, lying↔sitting)
- Symptoms while watching moving objects (10–15 years) → OKN pathway involvement
- Ear fullness/pressure > right ear
- Thyroid medication + antidepressants (both can mildly suppress vestibular gain)
- Unterberger's: >30° deviation right → right vestibular asymmetry
1. SACCADE TESTING
Horizontal Saccades (0.3 Hz & 0.45 Hz)
All parameters returned as "–" (not reportable/below threshold). This occurs in VNG systems when the eye tracking signal is clean but the software does not compute individual metrics — the traces were present and visually normal on the tracing graphs.
Interpretation: No dysmetric (hypometric/hypermetric), slow, or delayed horizontal saccades. The horizontal saccade system (frontal eye fields → superior colliculus → PPRF → abducens) is intact bilaterally.
Vertical Saccades
| Frequency | Eye | Velocity | Precision | Latency |
|---|
| 0.3 Hz | Right Eye | 313.52°/s | 92.92 | 312.00 ms |
| 0.3 Hz | Left Eye | 307.32°/s | 97.37 | 312.00 ms |
| 0.45 Hz | Right Eye | 308.84°/s | 94.49 | 292.31 ms |
| 0.45 Hz | Left Eye | 301.93°/s | 94.01 | 293.85 ms |
Reference norms: Saccade velocity: 300–600°/s (vertical); Precision (accuracy): >80% = normal; Latency: 150–250 ms (slightly prolonged here but consistent with individual variation at 54 years).
Detailed interpretation:
- Velocity: Bilateral vertical saccade velocities are comfortably within normal range (300–315°/s). Symmetric between right and left eyes — no internuclear ophthalmoplegia (INO), no skew deviation pattern.
- Precision: Excellent — 92–97% bilaterally. No dysmetria.
- Latency: Mildly prolonged (~292–312 ms vs. the 150–250 ms ideal range). At age 54 with history of head trauma and medication use, this is within acceptable limits. Does not suggest frontal lobe or basal ganglia pathology at this level.
- Overall: Saccade system intact. No brainstem saccade generator pathology.
2. SMOOTH PURSUIT TRACKING
Horizontal Pursuit
| Frequency | Direction | Right Eye Gain | Left Eye Gain | Norm (Age 54) |
|---|
| 0.2 Hz | Rightward | 0.94 | 0.92 | ≥0.80 ✓ |
| 0.2 Hz | Leftward | 0.89 | 0.89 | ≥0.80 ✓ |
| 0.4 Hz | Rightward | 0.74 | 0.71 | ≥0.70 ✓ borderline |
| 0.4 Hz | Leftward | 0.62 | 0.62 | ≥0.65 ✗ mildly low |
Vertical Pursuit
| Frequency | Direction | Right Eye Gain | Left Eye Gain | Norm (Age 54) |
|---|
| 0.2 Hz | Upward | 1.00 | 0.97 | ≥0.80 ✓ |
| 0.2 Hz | Downward | 0.78 | 0.80 | ≥0.70 ✓ |
| 0.4 Hz | Upward | 0.75 | 0.74 | ≥0.65 ✓ |
| 0.4 Hz | Downward | 0.37 | 0.36 | ≥0.55 ✗ Significantly reduced |
Detailed interpretation:
Horizontal pursuit is symmetric (same gain both eyes, both directions) — this rules out unilateral cerebellar hemisphere pathology or ipsilateral pursuit deficit. At 0.4 Hz leftward (0.62) there is mild reduction — this can represent: (a) normal ageing effect (pursuit gain declines with age and frequency), (b) mild floccular/parafloccular cerebellar dysfunction, or (c) mild effect of medication (thyroid/antidepressants).
Vertical pursuit downward at 0.4 Hz (0.37/0.36) is the most clinically significant finding here. Normal downward pursuit gain at 0.4 Hz should be ≥0.55 for this age group. Reduced downward smooth pursuit is a recognised indicator of dorsal vermis / posterior fossa dysfunction. Critically, downward pursuit is mediated by the flocculus and nodulus — structures that also mediate otolith-ocular reflexes and VOR. Damage to these structures (even from old head trauma) produces exactly this pattern.
Asymmetry analysis: Gains are bilaterally symmetric throughout — effectively excluding an acute unilateral cerebellar hemisphere lesion. This is a bilateral, frequency-dependent reduction consistent with diffuse floccular ageing, prior head trauma effect, or medication suppression.
3. OPTOKINETIC NYSTAGMUS (OKN)
OKN tests the subcortical reflex arc: retina → nucleus of the optic tract (NOT) → vestibular nuclei → ocular motor nuclei. It also assesses cortical pursuit pathway at higher velocities.
Horizontal OKN
| Direction | Gain RE | Gain LE | Fast Phase Dir. | Assessment |
|---|
| L→R 10° | 0.98 | 1.00 | — | Normal |
| R→L 10° | 0.75 | 0.78 | — | Mildly reduced |
| L→R 20° | 0.57 | 0.60 | — | Reduced |
| R→L 20° | 0.44 | 0.44 | — | Moderately reduced |
Vertical OKN
| Direction | Gain RE | Gain LE | Fast Phase Dir. | Assessment |
|---|
| T→B 10° | 0.73 | 0.74 | 63.05° | Reduced; oblique fast phase |
| B→T 10° | 0.63 | 0.65 | — | Reduced |
| T→B 20° | 0.15 | — | 65.46° | Markedly reduced; left-eye absent |
| B→T 20° | — | — | — | Absent bilaterally |
Detailed interpretation:
-
L→R 10° being normal (0.98–1.00) while R→L 10° is reduced (0.75–0.78): This horizontal OKN asymmetry (better leftward stimulus response vs. rightward stimulus) suggests relative dysfunction of the right NOT/accessory optic system. The NOT mediates the reflex OKN response to visual field motion ipsilateral to each hemisphere. Right NOT or right hemisphere parieto-occipital dysfunction would reduce gain for rightward stimulus.
-
Velocity-dependent reduction (10° better than 20°): At higher stimulus velocities, cortical pursuit pathways dominate. The progressive reduction at 20° reflects the same smooth pursuit limitation seen above — floccular/cortical pathway dysfunction.
-
Vertical OKN: Bottom-to-Top 20° being completely absent and Top-to-Bottom 20° nearly absent (RE 0.15) with left eye non-responsive is the most striking OKN finding. Vertical OKN is mediated primarily by the interstitial nucleus of Cajal (INC) and the posterior commissure — structures in the mesencephalon. Severe vertical OKN reduction disproportionate to horizontal can indicate:
- Posterior fossa / mesencephalic dysfunction (old head trauma)
- Nodulus/uvula dysfunction (controls vertical VOR and OKN)
- Bilateral otolith pathway dysfunction
-
Oblique fast phase direction (63°–65°) in T→B OKN: Fast phase at 63–65° is oblique (45° = pure diagonal; 90° = pure vertical). A vertical OKN stimulus producing an oblique fast phase indicates a torsional component to the nystagmus, suggesting otolith-ocular coupling dysfunction — the same pathway implicated in BPPV-related nystagmus.
-
Patient symptoms during OKN: Spinning sensation and head heaviness = confirms active vestibulo-ocular mismatch, particularly when large visual fields move. This is consistent with long-standing visual-vestibular conflict (symptoms of watching moving objects for 10–15 years).
4. SPONTANEOUS NYSTAGMUS
In Light: All parameters negative (SPV –, amplitude –, fast phase –, frequency –).
In Dark: All parameters negative.
Detailed interpretation: The complete absence of spontaneous nystagmus in both light and dark is highly informative:
- In an uncompensated acute peripheral lesion, spontaneous nystagmus in dark (removed fixation suppression) would be expected.
- Absence confirms that the vestibular system is centrally compensated — the brainstem/cerebellum has adapted to the right-sided asymmetry over time. This is consistent with a chronic or recurrent condition (20-year history) rather than an acute unilateral peripheral loss.
- This also argues against active Menière's disease or acute labyrinthitis at the time of testing.
- The fact that the right-sided asymmetry only emerges on provocative testing (head shake, positional) means the deficit is present but compensated at rest.
5. HIGH-FREQUENCY HEAD SHAKE NYSTAGMUS (HSN)
Finding: Slight left up-beating nystagmus post-head shake. SPV and amplitude returned as "–" (low but detectable visually on tracing). Patient reported slight discomfort.
Head Shake Video: The .mov file confirms the nystagmus was captured during/after the horizontal head shake manoeuvre. The left-beating + upward vector is clearly the clinically relevant observation.
Pathophysiology of Head Shake Nystagmus:
During vigorous horizontal head shaking, the semicircular canals are alternately stimulated and inhibited. In a normal system, inputs cancel out. In a vestibular asymmetry, the "velocity storage" mechanism in the brainstem generates nystagmus post-shake, with the fast phase directed toward the stronger (intact) ear — i.e., fast phase left = left ear is dominant = right ear is relatively hypofunction.
The upward component: Vertical (upward) HSN appearing after horizontal head shake is called cross-coupled HSN or indicates otolith pathway involvement. It suggests the right utricle/saccule are also dysfunctional, causing the velocity storage integrator to "overflow" into the vertical plane. This is a well-documented sign of right otolith hypofunction.
Clinical significance: This is one of the most reliable objective signs in this case — confirming right vestibular hypofunction even in the absence of spontaneous nystagmus.
6. GAZE TESTS
All 10 gaze positions (centre, left, right, up, down — with and without fixation) showed no gaze-evoked nystagmus and no fixation-failure nystagmus.
Detailed interpretation:
- No gaze-evoked nystagmus (GEN): Rules out cerebellar gaze-holding failure (flocculus, nucleus prepositus hypoglossi). Pure floccular lesions produce GEN; its absence confirms the smooth pursuit/OKN deficits noted above are not from a complete floccular lesion.
- No Alexander's law violation: In peripheral vestibular lesions, spontaneous nystagmus increases in the direction of the fast phase (Alexander's law). The absence of any gaze-evoked nystagmus even without fixation confirms complete central compensation.
- No rebound nystagmus: No cerebellar rebound nystagmus detected.
- No fixation-suppression failure: The fixation suppression index is effectively normal — the cerebellum is suppressing any residual vestibular drive when fixation is provided.
7. HEAD POSITION TESTS
Yaw Positions
| Position | H-SPV RE | H-SPV LE | Fast Phase | Finding |
|---|
| Yaw Right | — | — | — | No nystagmus |
| Yaw Left | 2.16°/s | 1.46°/s | — | Left-beating nystagmus |
Yaw Left findings: SPV 2.16°/s (RE) and 1.46°/s (LE) — these are low-velocity nystagmus values (threshold ~2°/s). Frequency 0.70 Hz (RE) and 0.57 Hz (LE). The asymmetry between yaw left (positive) and yaw right (negative) is consistent with geotropic or ageotropic horizontal canal nystagmus:
- Left-beating in left yaw = geotropic nystagmus in this position → consistent with right horizontal canal BPPV (cupulolithiasis pattern) or right HC hypofunction.
Pitch Positions
| Position | H-SPV (RE/LE) | V-SPV (RE/LE) | Fast Phase Dir. | Frequency | Finding |
|---|
| Pitch Forward | 3.63°/s / 3.24°/s | 3.29°/s / 3.95°/s | 310.07° / 306.54° | 1.80 / 1.77 Hz | Left-torsional nystagmus |
| Pitch Backward | — | — | — | — | No nystagmus |
Pitch Forward analysis: Fast phase direction 310° (RE) and 307° (LE) — these angles place the fast phase in the upper-left quadrant (270° = straight left; 360°/0° = straight up; 315° = upper-left). This is a left-torsional nystagmus component. The velocity is moderate (H: 3.2–3.6°/s; V: 3.3–4.0°/s) and frequency ~1.8 Hz.
Pathophysiology: Left-torsional nystagmus in pitch-forward position reflects stimulation of the right anterior/posterior canal system or right otolith (saccule). The right saccule mediates pitch-plane otolith sensation; dysfunction produces compensatory left-torsional nystagmus. The patient reported dizziness and head heaviness specifically in pitch forward — this symptom-matched nystagmus response strengthens the right vestibular localisation.
Roll Positions
| Position | H-SPV (RE/LE) | V-SPV (RE/LE) | Fast Phase Dir. | Frequency | Finding |
|---|
| Roll Right | 3.29°/s / 4.19°/s | -3.83°/s / -0.65°/s | 59.35° / 359.61° | 1.76 / 2.33 Hz | Left up-beating nystagmus |
| Roll Left | — | — | — | — | Upward beats (low amplitude) |
Roll Right analysis: Fast phase 59.35° (RE) ≈ upper-right quadrant; 359.61° (LE) ≈ straight up. Combined: predominantly upward + slight rightward torsion. The vertical SPV is negative (-3.83°/s RE) — downward slow phase = upward fast phase. This is upbeat nystagmus with left-torsional component in roll right — the mirror pattern of what is expected in right posterior canal BPPV when the head rolls toward the right ear.
Roll Left: Upward beats noted (low amplitude, no quantified SPV). Upward beats in roll left with upward/torsional in roll right = consistent with otolith (utricle) asymmetry — the right utricle is hypoactive, generating compensatory upward nystagmus in both roll positions (BPPV-related otolith dysfunction pattern).
8. DIX-HALLPIKE TEST
This is the diagnostic cornerstone of this entire evaluation.
Right Dix-Hallpike
Position 1 — Supine Head Extension + Right:
| Parameter | Right Eye | Left Eye |
|---|
| V-SPV | 4.66°/s | 8.04°/s |
| V-Amplitude | 2.09° | 3.36° |
| Fast Phase Dir. | — | — |
| Frequency | 1.03 Hz | 1.08 Hz |
Vertical slow phase velocity present bilaterally (RE 4.66°/s, LE 8.04°/s). Upward fast phase = up-beating nystagmus. The LE showing higher SPV (8.04) than RE (4.66) is expected — the left eye displays greater torsional amplitude in right posterior canal stimulation (due to the oblique pulling of the superior rectus/inferior oblique in left eye for right posterior canal excitation). Frequency ~1 Hz is classic for canalith-mediated nystagmus (cupulolithiasis would be sustained; ~1 Hz indicates free-floating canalith tumbling through canal — canalolithiasis).
Position 2 — Return to Sit (Head Right):
| Parameter | Right Eye | Left Eye |
|---|
| H-SPV | 3.14°/s | — |
| H-Amplitude | 1.66° | — |
| V-SPV | 16.99°/s | -6.78°/s |
| V-Amplitude | 9.95° | -3.15° |
| Fast Phase Dir. | 279.47° | — |
| Frequency | 2.31 Hz | 0.99 Hz |
This is the most diagnostically significant measurement in the entire dataset. On return to sitting:
- V-SPV RE = 16.99°/s — this is the strongest nystagmus velocity recorded in the entire study
- Fast phase direction 279.47° ≈ straight left (270° = left; 279° = slightly upward-left)
- RE frequency 2.31 Hz — higher than the supine position, consistent with reversal nystagmus on return to sitting
- LE V-SPV = -6.78°/s (downward slow phase = upward fast phase in left eye) with 0.99 Hz
This pattern — up-beating/right-torsional nystagmus going down on the right DH, then reversing to right-beating/left-torsional on sitting back up — is the TEXTBOOK signature of right posterior canal BPPV (canalolithiasis). The canaliths are carried by gravity into the right posterior canal on the down-right position, generating utriculofugal cupula deflection; on return to sitting, the debris falls back, generating reversal nystagmus.
Patient symptoms provoked: Spinning sensation and head heaviness — symptom-matched nystagmus = highly confirmatory of the diagnostic location.
Left Dix-Hallpike
Sit Head Left: All parameters negative. No nystagmus.
Supine Head Extension + Left:
| Parameter | Right Eye | Left Eye |
|---|
| H-SPV | 4.43°/s | — |
| H-Amplitude | 2.87° | — |
| V-SPV | 6.63°/s | — |
| V-Amplitude | 4.63° | — |
| Fast Phase Dir. | 301.80° | — |
| Frequency | 1.68 Hz | — |
Right eye only generates nystagmus here, left eye silent. FPD 301.80° ≈ upper-left direction. This small unilateral response may represent:
- Residual right-sided posterior canal debris stimulated even in left DH position (as the right posterior canal is still partially gravity-dependent in this position)
- Possible right anterior canal minor component (anterior canal BPPV produces down-beating nystagmus in the ipsilateral DH position)
- No symptoms reported for left DH — further distinguishing this from left-canal pathology
No left posterior canal BPPV confirmed. The left DH sitting position was completely clean.
9. McCLURE-PAGNINI (ROLL TEST)
Right Lateral
| Parameter | Right Eye | Left Eye |
|---|
| H-SPV | 4.72°/s | 3.67°/s |
| H-Amplitude | 2.06° | 1.28° |
| Frequency | 1.00 Hz | 1.23 Hz |
Left-beating nystagmus at ~1 Hz with moderate SPV in right lateral position. Patient reported spinning sensation and head heaviness.
Pathophysiology: In right lateral position, the right ear is dependent. Left-beating nystagmus (fast phase away from the ground = ageotropic pattern) in right lateral position is seen in:
- Right horizontal canal BPPV — cupulolithiasis (debris attached to cupula → tonic deflection → ageotropic nystagmus, typically sustained)
- Right horizontal canal hypofunction — the dependent (right) ear stimulation should produce rightward nystagmus; left-beating in right lateral = right side weaker
The ~1 Hz frequency with SPV ~3.7–4.7°/s favours a positional nystagmus component rather than purely static hypofunction. This may represent mild horizontal canal involvement secondary to the posterior canal BPPV (mixed canal BPPV is recognised) or a residual horizontal canal positional nystagmus from the head trauma.
Left Lateral: No nystagmus, No symptoms.
The left-positive, right-negative asymmetry again localises pathology to the right side.
Supine Neutral (post both): No nystagmus — confirming position-dependence.
10. SUBJECTIVE VISUAL VERTICAL (SVV)
| Condition | Deviation | Perceived Direction | Time |
|---|
| Clockwise | +3° (Right) | Clockwise | 20s |
| Anti-clockwise | -1° (Left) | Clockwise | 18s |
| Blank Background | +1° (Right) | Clockwise | 20s |
Normal SVV range: ±2° from true vertical.
Detailed interpretation:
- Clockwise trial +3°: Exceeds the ±2° normal limit. The rod is tilted 3° to the right of true vertical but the patient perceives it as vertical — this means her perceived vertical is shifted clockwise (rightward tilt), consistent with right otolithic hypofunction.
- Anti-clockwise trial -1°: Within normal range, but the perceived direction is "Clockwise" — i.e., even when approaching from the other side, the patient's perception drifts rightward.
- Blank Background +1°: Without visual context cues, the deviation persists at +1° rightward.
The SVV tilt in BPPV context: In posterior canal BPPV, SVV may be normal or near-normal interictally. The consistent rightward tilt seen here suggests additional right utricular dysfunction beyond just posterior canal canalolithiasis — this could be:
- Concurrent right utricular otoconia displacement (utricular BPPV contributing)
- Chronic right utricular deafferentation from repeated head trauma
- Saccular asymmetry
This finding elevates the diagnosis beyond simple posterior canal BPPV to include a right otolith organ (utricle) dysfunction component.
INTEGRATED ANALYSIS & TOPOGRAPHIC LOCALISATION
Site of Lesion Map
| Anatomical Structure | Status | Evidence |
|---|
| Right Posterior Semicircular Canal | Pathological — BPPV (canalolithiasis) | Positive right DH; up-beating + reversal nystagmus; symptom-matched |
| Right Horizontal Semicircular Canal | Mildly involved | Left-beating in right lateral (MP test); geotropic yaw-left nystagmus |
| Right Utricle | Hypofunction | SVV rightward tilt; cross-coupled vertical HSN; right-beating SVV |
| Right Vestibular Nerve (overall) | Relative hypofunction | Unterberger's rightward; left HSN fast phase; left-beating in yaw-left |
| Flocculus/Nodulus (bilateral) | Mildly affected | Reduced vertical smooth pursuit (0.37); reduced vertical OKN; no GEN (partial) |
| Posterior Fossa / Mesencephalon | Possible old trauma effect | Markedly reduced vertical OKN at 20°; absent B→T 20° OKN; oblique OKN fast phase |
| Left Vestibular System | Intact / Compensating | Negative left DH; normal left lateral MP; stronger left ear on HSN |
Diagnosis Hierarchy
- Primary (Definitive): Right Posterior Canal BPPV — Canalolithiasis type
- Classic provocation pattern; symptom-matched; reversal nystagmus; 1 Hz frequency; unilateral DH
- Secondary (Probable): Right Utricular Hypofunction / Otolith Dysfunction
- SVV deviation; cross-coupled HSN; pitch-forward left-torsional nystagmus; roll-position nystagmus
- Tertiary (Possible): Right Horizontal Canal Positional Component
- Mild horizontal canal nystagmus in McClure-Pagnini and yaw-left position
- Background (Likely chronic/old): Bilateral posterior fossa/floccular dysfunction from prior head trauma
- Symmetric reduction in vertical OKN and higher-frequency smooth pursuit; not acute
Why OKN is Globally Reduced (not just one direction)
The bilateral, direction-independent OKN reduction — especially vertical — is disproportionate to a pure unilateral peripheral lesion. This pattern, combined with the history of two head trauma events (20 years ago + April 2026), strongly suggests bilateral subclinical posterior fossa microtrauma affecting the flocculus, nodulus, and mesencephalic vertical OKN centres. This is a distinct and separate finding from the BPPV.
CLINICAL RED FLAGS TO MONITOR
| Flag | Why It Matters |
|---|
| Bilateral absent vertical OKN at 20° | Warrants MRI posterior fossa to exclude central pathology |
| Fainting episodes post-vertigo | Could indicate vasovagal component or rarely cardiac arrhythmia during Valsalva-like episodes |
| Reduced vertical smooth pursuit (downward) | Dorsal vermis/flocculus involvement — not explained by BPPV alone |
| Repeated head trauma + vertigo | Cumulative posterior fossa injury risk |
| Thyroid medication | Hypothyroidism itself causes endolymphatic hydrops-like symptoms; medication can affect vestibular gain |
TREATMENT PRIORITY SEQUENCE
- Immediate: Epley manoeuvre (right posterior canal) — highest level evidence (Cochrane Class A)
- Short-term: Brandt-Daroff habituation exercises for residual otolith dysfunction
- Concurrent: Gaze stabilisation VRT for floccular/OKN pathway deficit
- Investigate: MRI brain (posterior fossa, internal auditory canals) to exclude central pathology contributing to vertical OKN failure and downward smooth pursuit reduction
- Thyroid review: Ensure thyroid function is optimally controlled (hypothyroidism → endolymphatic pressure → can mimic/worsen BPPV)
- Follow-up VNG at 6 weeks: Expect resolution of DH nystagmus post-Epley; monitor OKN recovery and SVV normalisation