Breast - Complete Surgical Viva Guide
1. HISTORY TAKING
Patient Details
- Age - single most important demographic factor:
- <35 yrs: Fibroadenoma most likely
- 20-40 yrs: Fibroadenosis (mammary dysplasia)
-
40 yrs: Carcinoma must always be excluded
- Young lactating woman: Mastitis / breast abscess
- Sex - rare but carcinoma in males is possible
- Residence - carcinoma + fibroadenosis more common in western world; rare in Japan
- Parity / Social status - nulliparous women have higher risk of carcinoma and fibroadenosis; breastfeeding is protective
Chief Complaint
1. Lump (most common presenting complaint)
- Mode of onset, duration
- Rate of growth: slow + long history = benign; fast + short history = likely malignant
- Sudden enlargement: haemorrhage into a cyst or nodule
- Note: average time between patient discovering a breast lump and reporting to a surgeon is ~6 weeks in carcinoma
2. Pain (mastalgia)
"Carcinoma of the breast is a painless condition." - S Das
| Pain type | Diagnosis |
|---|
| Throbbing, severe | Acute mastitis / abscess (pus formation) |
| Cyclical, worse before periods | Fibroadenosis (most common benign cause) |
| Non-cyclical, localized | Periductal mastitis, fat necrosis |
| Back / hip / shoulder pain (late) | Bony metastases from carcinoma |
| Painless lump accidentally felt | Must rule out carcinoma |
3. Nipple Discharge
| Discharge colour | Diagnosis |
|---|
| Bright red / blood | Duct papilloma (most common), duct carcinoma |
| Serous / clear | Duct papilloma, early carcinoma |
| Green / brown | Fibroadenosis (duct ectasia) |
| White (milk) | Galactorrhoea (prolactinoma, drugs) |
| Purulent | Abscess, infected duct ectasia |
4. Nipple changes
- Retraction / inversion - recent onset = malignancy; lifelong = normal variant
- Eczema / scaling of nipple = Paget's disease of nipple (must exclude underlying ductal carcinoma)
- Ulceration
5. Skin changes - redness, dimpling, peau d'orange, ulceration, satellite nodules
6. Axillary swelling - may indicate nodal metastases
Past History
- Previous breast lumps, biopsies, operations
- History of chest wall irradiation (risk factor for breast cancer)
- Hormone use - OCP, HRT (risk factors)
- Previous carcinoma of the opposite breast or endometrium
Menstrual & Obstetric History
- Menarche age (early menarche = risk factor)
- Menopause age (late menopause = risk factor)
- Pregnancies: nulliparity or first child after 30 = risk factor
- Breastfeeding: protective
- Last menstrual period
Family History
- First-degree relative (mother, sister) with breast cancer = 2-3x increased risk
- BRCA1 / BRCA2 mutations (ask for family history of ovarian cancer too)
- Bilateral or early-onset (<50 yrs) breast cancer in family = high risk
Drug History
- OCP, HRT (slight increased risk)
- Phenothiazines, metoclopramide, domperidone → galactorrhoea
- Tamoxifen (if currently being treated)
2. EXAMINATION - SYSTEMATIC APPROACH
General Examination
- Build, weight loss (late cancer)
- Pallor, jaundice (liver metastases)
- Lymphoedema of the arm (post-surgery or nodal blockage)
- Lumbar spine / hip tenderness (bone metastases)
- Hepatomegaly (liver metastases)
- Signs of pleural effusion (lung metastases)
LOCAL EXAMINATION
Setup
- Patient seated facing examiner, fully exposed to the nipple level
- Adequate privacy; chaperone
- Examine normal breast first, then compare with affected side
INSPECTION (4 positions)
Position 1: Arms by the side (at rest)
Note:
- Symmetry of both breasts - any size difference
- Contour and shape - any flattening, bulge, distortion
- Skin changes:
- Redness / erythema = mastitis, inflammatory carcinoma
- Peau d'orange = skin oedema with pitting, deepening of sweat gland openings - classic sign of carcinoma (lymphatic blockage by cancer cells)
- Dimpling / puckering = invasion of Cooper's ligaments by carcinoma
- Dilated superficial veins = cystosarcoma phylloides, rapidly growing sarcoma, acute duct obstruction
- Ulceration / fungation = advanced carcinoma
- Skin nodules = satellite / metastatic skin deposits
- Nipple position, level, symmetry
- Retraction (recent = malignant; central mass pulling nipple)
- Deviation / asymmetry
- Ulceration / eczema = Paget's disease
- Axillae - visible swelling, skin puckering
Peau d'orange - oedema of the skin of the breast with deepening of the sweat gland mouths, due to blockage of subcuticular lymphatics by cancer cells. - S Das Clinical Surgery
Nipple retraction caused by deep carcinoma pulling along the lactiferous ducts via fibrosis - S Das
Position 2: Arms raised above the head
- Reveals the lower surfaces of both breasts
- Brings out lumps, puckering and distortion not visible at rest
- Inspect the submammary fold (lift breast if needed)
- Inspect axillae for swelling and ulceration
Position 3: Hands pressed on hips (pectoral contraction)
- Tenses the pectoralis major
- Accentuates dimpling / tethering if present (Cooper's ligament invasion)
- Any change in contour with muscle contraction
Position 4: Leaning forward
- Pendulous breasts fall forward - reveals asymmetry and skin changes on undersurface
PALPATION
Patient position: Start in sitting, then semi-recumbent (45°), then lying supine with a small pillow under the scapula of the side being examined (prevents breast falling laterally).
Technique:
- Use the palmar surface of the fingers with the hand flat (NOT the palm of hand, NOT fingertips)
- Palpate between pulps of fingers and thumb to examine a lump
- Always palpate the normal breast first to know the baseline texture
Quadrant Examination
Systematically palpate all four quadrants:
- Upper outer (UOQ) - most common site of carcinoma (50%)
- Upper inner
- Lower outer
- Lower inner
- Retroareolar region (just behind the nipple - easy to miss!)
- Axillary tail of Spence
On Finding a Lump - Assess All These Features:
1. Site / Position
- Quadrant + distance from nipple
- UOQ is most common; retroareolar is often missed
2. Size and Shape
- Measure in cm
- Globular = fibroadenoma
- Irregular = carcinoma
3. Number
- Solitary: fibroadenoma, cyst, carcinoma
- Multiple bilateral: fibroadenosis
4. Surface
- Smooth = fibroadenoma, cyst
- Irregular / nodular = carcinoma, fibroadenosis
5. Edge / Margin
- Well-defined = fibroadenoma, cyst
- Ill-defined / spiculated = carcinoma
6. Consistency
| Consistency | Diagnosis |
|---|
| Soft, cystic | Breast cyst, abscess |
| Firm, India-rubber / diffuse | Fibroadenosis |
| Firm, well-encapsulated | Fibroadenoma |
| Stony hard, irregular | Carcinoma |
| Varies (soft to hard) | Sarcoma / cystosarcoma phylloides |
7. Fluctuation - test for cystic swellings (cyst, abscess)
8. Transillumination - in dark room; cyst = translucent; solid tumour = opaque; fat = translucent
9. Tenderness - mastitis, abscess; absent in carcinoma (painless)
10. Fixity to Skin - Three levels:
(i) Tethering to skin: Invasion of Cooper's ligaments (fibrous septae from gland to skin). The lump can still be moved slightly but at the extremes of movement, skin dimples.
- Test: move lump side to side - skin dimples at extremes = tethered
(ii) Fixed to skin: Direct infiltration of skin by tumour. Lump cannot be moved independent of skin. Overlying skin cannot be pinched up.
(iii) Note: Any tumour deep to the nipple will be fixed to the nipple (benign or malignant) because the main lactiferous ducts pass through it.
11. Fixity to Breast Tissue
- Fibroadenoma: freely mobile within breast substance = "Breast Mouse" / "Floating Tumour"
- Carcinoma: fixed to breast tissue; fibrous strands radiating from mass
12. Fixity to Pectoralis Major
- Ask patient to press her hand on her hip lightly (muscle relaxed) - test lump mobility
- Now ask her to press hip as hard as she can (muscle taut) - retest mobility
- Reduced mobility in the line of muscle fibres = fixed to pectoralis major or pectoral fascia
Testing lump fixity to pectoralis major - patient presses hip to tighten muscle, then lump mobility is reassessed in direction of muscle fibres. - S Das
13. Fixity to Serratus Anterior
- Lower outer quadrant lumps may fix to serratus anterior
- Test: ask patient to push against a wall with outstretched hand of affected side - fixed lump barely moves
14. Fixity to Chest Wall
- Lump restricted in ALL directions irrespective of any muscle contraction = fixed to chest wall (T4 carcinoma)
15. Nipple Palpation
- Feel tissue just behind the nipple
- Press the lump behind the nipple - note if this expresses discharge
- Colour of discharge (see above)
- From single duct (papilloma) or multiple ducts (fibrocystic)
16. Axillary Examination
Patient's arm supported by examiner's ipsilateral hand (relaxing pectoralis)
Palpate all groups:
- Anterior (pectoral) nodes - most commonly first involved in breast cancer
- Central nodes
- Posterior (subscapular) nodes
- Lateral (brachial) nodes
- Apical nodes (infraclavicular)
Note: Size, number, consistency, mobility, tenderness of any palpable nodes
17. Supraclavicular Nodes
- Feel in the angle between the clavicle and sternomastoid from behind
- Enlarged = advanced (N3) disease
18. Opposite Breast and Axilla - must always be examined
3. DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS OF A BREAST LUMP
| Condition | Age | Consistency | Mobility | Tender | Skin/Nipple | Other |
|---|
| Fibroadenoma | 15-35 | Firm, smooth | Highly mobile ("breast mouse") | No | Normal | Well-defined, no nodes |
| Breast cyst | 30-55 | Cystic/fluctuant | Mobile | No | Normal | Transilluminates; may refill |
| Fibroadenosis | Any (20-50) | Firm, diffuse, nodular | Diffuse bilateral | Yes (cyclical) | Normal | Multiple lumps |
| Carcinoma | >40 | Stony hard | Fixed to breast tissue | No | Peau d'orange, dimpling | Hard nodes, nipple retraction |
| Abscess | Lactating | Fluctuant | Fixed (inflamed) | Very tender | Red, warm | Fever, raised WBC |
| Fat necrosis | Any (post-trauma) | Hard, irregular | May be fixed | ± | Skin tethering possible | History of trauma |
| Cystosarcoma phylloides | >40 | Varies; huge | Mobile (initially) | No | Dilated veins; not fixed | Rapidly growing, giant tumour |
| Duct papilloma | >30 | Cystic near areola | Mobile | No | Bloody nipple discharge | Retroareolar |
| Paget's disease | >50 | Underlying mass | - | No | Eczema of nipple | Represents underlying DCIS/Ca |
| Gynaecomastia (male) | Any | Firm disc | Central | Tender | Normal | Bilateral rubbery disc |
4. TRIPLE ASSESSMENT (The Standard for any Breast Lump)
The gold standard is Triple Assessment - all three must be done:
| Component | What |
|---|
| 1. Clinical examination | History + full breast exam |
| 2. Imaging | Mammogram (<35 yrs: USG; >35 yrs: Mammogram ± USG) |
| 3. Tissue sampling | FNAC (cytology) or Core needle biopsy (histology) |
If all 3 are benign = safe to observe. If ANY is suspicious = proceed to excision/surgery.
5. INVESTIGATIONS
Imaging
Mammography
- Investigation of choice for women >35-40 years
- Two views: craniocaudal (CC) and mediolateral oblique (MLO)
- Malignant features: spiculated mass, pleomorphic calcifications, skin thickening, nipple retraction
- BIRADS classification: BIRADS 1 = normal; BIRADS 5 = highly suggestive malignancy
- Screening mammogram: every 2 years for women 50-74 yrs (national programs)
Ultrasound (USG)
- Preferred for women <35 years (dense breast tissue makes mammography less useful)
- Distinguishes solid vs cystic lesions
- Guides FNAC/core biopsy
- Benign features: smooth margins, posterior acoustic enhancement (cyst)
- Malignant features: irregular hypoechoic mass, spiculated margins, posterior shadowing
MRI Breast
- Not routine; used for:
- BRCA mutation carriers (high-risk screening)
- Assessing extent of lobular carcinoma
- Occult primary breast cancer with axillary nodes
- Pre-operative planning for BCS (breast conserving surgery)
- Implants assessment
Tissue Diagnosis
FNAC (Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology)
- 22-25G needle, syringe, no anaesthesia
- Gives cytological diagnosis only
- Reports as: C1 (inadequate) / C2 (benign) / C3 (atypia) / C4 (suspicious) / C5 (malignant)
- Advantage: quick, cheap, outpatient
- Limitation: cannot distinguish invasive from in-situ cancer; cannot give hormone receptor status
Core Needle Biopsy (Tru-cut)
- 14-16G needle; gives a core of tissue = histological diagnosis
- Can determine: invasive vs in-situ; grade; ER/PR/HER2 status
- Preferred over FNAC when preoperative planning is needed
Excision Biopsy
- When FNAC/core is inconclusive (Bethesda III equivalent / C3)
- Provides definitive diagnosis
Blood Tests
- CBC - anaemia in advanced disease
- LFT, ALP - liver / bone metastases
- Serum calcium - hypercalcaemia in bone metastases
- Tumour markers: CA 15-3, CEA - used for monitoring treatment response, not diagnosis
- Hormone receptor status (ER, PR, HER2) on biopsy - determines treatment
Staging Investigations (if cancer confirmed)
- Chest X-ray - lung metastases
- CT chest / abdomen / pelvis - staging
- Bone scan - bone metastases (indicated if bone pain or raised ALP)
- PET-CT - accurate staging in high-risk disease
6. STAGING OF BREAST CANCER
TNM Classification
| T | Description |
|---|
| T1 | ≤2 cm; no fixation; no nipple retraction |
| T2 | 2-5 cm; skin may be tethered; no pectoral fixation |
| T3 | >5 cm; skin fixed or ulcerated; pectoral fixation |
| T4 | Chest wall fixation; peau d'orange over large area; inflammatory carcinoma |
| N | Description |
|---|
| N0 | No palpable ipsilateral nodes |
| N1 | Mobile ipsilateral axillary nodes |
| N2 | Fixed axillary nodes |
| N3 | Supraclavicular / infraclavicular nodes; arm oedema |
| M | Description |
|---|
| M0 | No distant metastasis |
| M1 | Distant metastasis present |
Clinical Stages (S Das)
- Stage I: Growth limited to breast; ± small skin adherence
- Stage II: + Mobile axillary nodes; ± slight pectoral tethering
- Stage III: Fixed to pectoral muscle; skin involvement > tumour size
- Stage IV: Fixed to chest wall; fixed axillary nodes; supraclavicular nodes; distant metastases
7. TYPES OF BREAST CARCINOMA
| Type | Features |
|---|
| Scirrhous carcinoma | Most common; very hard, fibrotic; slow growing; infiltrative |
| Atrophic scirrhous | Least malignant; very slow growing; may mimic benign |
| Encephaloid (Medullary) | Soft brain-like; rapidly growing; less fibrosis; better prognosis |
| Comedocarcinoma | Intraductal; DCIS type; "toothpaste-like" plugs from ducts |
| Colloid (Mucinous) | Gelatinous; better prognosis; older women |
| Mastitis carcinomatosa (Inflammatory Ca) | Most malignant; entire breast red, hot, oedematous; no palpable lump; poor prognosis |
| Paget's disease of nipple | Eczema-like change of nipple; underlying DCIS or invasive Ca; always biopsy |
| Lobular carcinoma | Diffuse, bilateral; harder to detect on mammogram |
Metastatic spread:
- Lymphatic: Axillary nodes (most common) → supraclavicular → internal mammary nodes
- Blood: Bones (most common - especially spine, pelvis, femur), lung, liver, brain, ovary (transcoelomic)
8. MANAGEMENT
Benign Conditions
| Condition | Management |
|---|
| Fibroadenoma | Small (<3 cm): observe; large / growing / symptomatic: excision |
| Breast cyst | Aspiration (diagnostic + therapeutic); if bloody fluid / residual lump → biopsy |
| Fibroadenosis | Reassurance; evening primrose oil; danazol for severe mastalgia |
| Mastitis / Abscess | Antibiotics (flucloxacillin); if abscess = incision and drainage (I&D) or needle aspiration |
| Duct papilloma | Microdochectomy (excision of affected duct); considered premalignant |
| Cystosarcoma phylloides | Wide local excision or simple mastectomy (tends to recur); rarely malignant |
| Gynaecomastia | Treat cause; if persists / painful: subcutaneous mastectomy |
Malignant Conditions - Breast Cancer Surgery
Breast Surgery Options
| Procedure | Indication |
|---|
| Wide Local Excision (WLE) / Lumpectomy | Early cancer; followed by radiotherapy = Breast Conserving Surgery (BCS) |
| Quadrantectomy | Removal of involved quadrant |
| Simple (Total) Mastectomy | Carcinoma in-situ; prophylactic (BRCA1/2); when BCS not possible |
| Modified Radical Mastectomy (MRM) | Most common surgery for breast cancer today; removes breast + axillary nodes; preserves pectoralis major |
| Radical Mastectomy (Halsted) | Historical; removes breast + pectoralis major + minor + axillary nodes; rarely done now |
| Extended Radical Mastectomy | Also removes internal mammary nodes; obsolete |
Axillary Management
| Procedure | Indication |
|---|
| Sentinel Lymph Node Biopsy (SLNB) | Clinically node-negative axilla; if SLNB negative = no further axillary surgery |
| Axillary Lymph Node Dissection (ALND) | SLNB positive; clinically / radiologically positive nodes |
Adjuvant Therapy
| Treatment | Indication |
|---|
| Radiotherapy | Post-BCS (mandatory); post-mastectomy in high-risk; chest wall |
| Chemotherapy | Triple-negative, HER2+, high-grade, node-positive disease |
| Hormonal therapy (Tamoxifen / Aromatase inhibitors) | ER/PR positive (5-10 years) |
| HER2 targeted (Trastuzumab/Herceptin) | HER2-positive tumours |
9. HIGH-YIELD VIVA QUESTIONS & ANSWERS
Q: What is the most common site of carcinoma in the breast?
A: Upper outer quadrant (UOQ) - approximately 50% of all breast carcinomas. It has the greatest volume of breast tissue and the axillary tail.
Q: What is "peau d'orange" and what causes it?
A: Peau d'orange (French: "skin of an orange") is oedema of the breast skin with deepening of the sweat gland and hair follicle openings, giving an orange-peel appearance. It is caused by obstruction of the subcuticular lymphatics by cancer cells, leading to skin oedema, while the tethered skin over follicles cannot expand - creating the pitted appearance.
Q: What is Cooper's ligament and what happens when it is invaded?
A: Cooper's ligaments (suspensory ligaments of the breast) are fibrous septae passing from the glandular breast tissue to the overlying skin. When invaded by carcinoma, they become shorter and inelastic, pulling the skin inwards, causing skin dimpling, puckering or retraction.
Q: What is a "breast mouse"?
A: A fibroadenoma - it is highly mobile within the breast substance and freely movable under the examining fingers, hence the term. It is NOT fixed to the skin or deeper structures.
Q: What is Paget's disease of the nipple?
A: A form of breast cancer presenting as eczema-like changes (scaling, weeping, crusting) of the nipple and areola. It represents extension of an underlying ductal carcinoma in-situ (DCIS) or invasive carcinoma through the lactiferous ducts to the nipple epidermis. Always biopsy nipple eczema in a woman over 40. Treatment: total mastectomy or BCS + nipple excision + radiotherapy.
Q: "Breast cancer is painless" - always true?
A: Painless at onset - all neoplasms of the breast (benign or malignant) are painless to start. However, late-stage carcinoma can cause pain from bone metastases (back, hip, shoulder pain). Inflammatory carcinoma is a painful exception. Pain should never be used to exclude carcinoma.
Q: What is the most common type of breast cancer?
A: Invasive ductal carcinoma (IDC) / scirrhous carcinoma - accounts for ~75-80% of all breast cancers. Presents as a hard, stony, irregular mass with fibrous stroma.
Q: What is the difference between tethering and fixation to skin?
- Tethering: Malignancy has spread to Cooper's ligaments; lump can still move independently through a small range, but skin dimples at the extremes of movement. (T2 feature)
- Fixed: Direct infiltration of skin by tumour; lump cannot be moved independently at all; overlying skin cannot be pinched up. (T4 feature)
Q: What is triple assessment?
A: The gold standard approach for evaluating any breast lump:
- Clinical examination
- Imaging (mammogram ± ultrasound)
- Tissue sampling (FNAC or core biopsy)
All three results must be concordant. If any one is suspicious → proceed to surgery.
Q: How do you test for fixity to pectoralis major?
A: Ask the patient to press her hand on her hip (muscle relaxed) - assess lump mobility. Then ask her to press as hard as possible (muscle taut) - retest mobility in the line of the muscle fibres. Restricted mobility with the muscle contracted indicates fixity to pectoralis major or pectoral fascia.
Q: What is Modified Radical Mastectomy (MRM)?
A: Removal of the entire breast + all axillary lymph nodes, while preserving both pectoralis major and minor. This is the standard surgical procedure for breast cancer today. It replaced Halsted's radical mastectomy (which removed both pectoral muscles) as outcomes were equivalent with less morbidity.
Q: Most common site of blood-borne metastasis from breast cancer?
A: Bones (spine, pelvis, femur) - most common. Others: lungs, liver, brain, ovary (Krukenberg - transcoelomic).
Q: Risk factors for breast cancer?
A: MNEMONIC - "FEMALE BRAS"
- Family history (first-degree relative, BRCA1/2)
- Early menarche (<12 yrs)
- Menopause late (>55 yrs)
- Age (>40 yrs)
- Late first pregnancy / nulliparity
- Exposure to radiation
- Body weight (obesity - increases oestrogen)
- Risk from HRT / OCP
- Alcohol, diet rich in saturated fat
- Socioeconomic (more in Western world)
Q: What is inflammatory carcinoma?
A: The most malignant type of breast cancer (mastitis carcinomatosa). The entire breast becomes red, hot, swollen, oedematous - resembling acute mastitis. There may be no discrete palpable mass. Due to massive lymphatic infiltration causing dermal lymphatic obstruction. Very poor prognosis. Treatment: neoadjuvant chemotherapy first, then surgery + radiotherapy. Do NOT mistake it for mastitis and delay diagnosis.
Sources: S Das - A Manual on Clinical Surgery, 13th ed. | Bailey & Love's Short Practice of Surgery, 28th ed. | Schwartz's Principles of Surgery, 11th ed. | Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine, 22E