I now have a comprehensive set of source material. Let me compile the full, detailed answer.
Case History and Clinical Examination in Peripheral Neuropathy
Sources: Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine 22E (2025); Adams & Victor's Principles of Neurology, 12th Ed; Goldman-Cecil Medicine
Diagnostic Approach Overview
The clinician facing a patient with suspected peripheral neuropathy must answer four sequential questions (Adams & Victor):
- Is this truly a peripheral nervous system disease, or a CNS/neuromuscular junction/muscle disorder?
- What is the topographic pattern (polyneuropathy, mononeuropathy, radiculopathy, plexopathy)?
- Is the process motor, sensory, autonomic, or mixed - and is it axonal or demyelinating?
- Is the neuropathy acquired or hereditary?
Harrison's frames this as three main goals: localize the lesion, identify the cause, determine treatment - approached through 7 Key Questions answered from history and examination.
Figure: Approach to the evaluation of peripheral neuropathies (Harrison's 22E)
PART I: CASE HISTORY
A. Chief Complaint and Onset
Begin by documenting what symptoms brought the patient in - sensory symptoms (numbness, tingling, burning, pain), motor symptoms (weakness, tripping, difficulty with fine tasks), or autonomic symptoms (dizziness on standing, sweating abnormalities, bladder/bowel/sexual dysfunction).
Ask specifically:
- Onset: sudden vs. gradual
- Duration and progression: acute (days-4 weeks), subacute (4-8 weeks), chronic (>8 weeks)
- Course: monophasic, progressive, relapsing-remitting
- Distribution: feet first? Both feet simultaneously? One limb? Multiple sites?
A chronic, slowly progressive symmetrical sensory-predominant course starting in the feet is the classic pattern of a length-dependent polyneuropathy (e.g., diabetic, toxic, idiopathic).
An acute onset (days to 4 weeks) of ascending weakness with areflexia strongly suggests Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS).
An asymmetric, multifocal or episodic onset suggests mononeuropathy multiplex (vasculitis, diabetes, sarcoid, leprosy).
B. The 7 Key Questions from History (Harrison's)
Question 1: What Systems Are Involved?
Ask about:
- Motor: weakness, foot drop, difficulty with grip, trips/falls
- Sensory: numbness, tingling, burning, "pins and needles," pain, loss of balance in the dark
- Autonomic: fainting, orthostatic dizziness, heat intolerance, anhidrosis, bowel/bladder/sexual dysfunction
How this rules out other diagnoses:
- Pure motor involvement without sensory symptoms → consider motor neuron disease (ALS), myopathy, or neuromuscular junction disorder (myasthenia gravis, Lambert-Eaton) rather than polyneuropathy
- Prominent autonomic dysfunction without diabetes → strongly suggests amyloid polyneuropathy or hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy (HSAN)
- Sensory-only with normal strength → small-fiber neuropathy (DM, glucose intolerance, amyloid) or sensory neuronopathy/ganglionopathy (paraneoplastic, Sjögren's)
Question 2: What Is the Distribution of Weakness?
- Distal-only weakness: typical axonal polyneuropathy (DM, toxic, idiopathic)
- Proximal AND distal symmetric weakness: hallmark of acquired immune demyelinating polyneuropathies - GBS (acute) and CIDP (chronic); this pattern cannot be overemphasized as it identifies a treatable disorder
- Asymmetric/multifocal weakness: radiculopathy, plexopathy, compressive mononeuropathy, or mononeuropathy multiplex (vasculitis, leprosy, diabetes)
- Unilateral extremity weakness without sensory symptoms: consider ALS (motor neuron disease) vs. multifocal motor neuropathy (MMN) - the latter is treatable with IVIg
Rules out:
- Proximal-predominant weakness without sensory loss → myopathy or NMJ disorder, not polyneuropathy
- Neck extensor/bulbar weakness → ALS, isolated bulbar GBS, Kennedy's syndrome
Question 3: What Is the Nature of Sensory Involvement?
- Pain, burning, temperature loss, allodynia = small-fiber (C and A-delta fibers) involvement → DM, glucose intolerance, amyloid, HIV, Fabry's disease
- Vibration and proprioception loss (with normal pain/temperature) = large-fiber involvement → vitamin B12 deficiency, CIDP, hereditary neuropathy (CMT)
- Severe proprioceptive loss with imbalance, positive Romberg, pseudoathetosis = sensory neuronopathy/ganglionopathy → paraneoplastic (anti-Hu), Sjögren's syndrome, cisplatin toxicity, vitamin B6 toxicity, CANVAS syndrome
Rules out:
- Loss of vibration/proprioception with hyperreflexia and UMN signs → posterior column + corticospinal lesion (subacute combined degeneration from B12 deficiency, MS, cervical myelopathy) - NOT peripheral neuropathy alone
- Pain and temperature loss with preserved vibration/proprioception = dorsal horn or spinothalamic tract lesion (syringomyelia, Brown-Séquard) rather than peripheral neuropathy
Question 4: Is There Upper Motor Neuron Involvement?
Always ask about: spasticity, brisk reflexes, upgoing plantars (Babinski), clonus, sphincter disturbance
- Peripheral neuropathy produces lower motor neuron signs: weakness, wasting, hyporeflexia/areflexia, sensory loss
- If UMN + LMN signs coexist: suspect ALS (UMN + LMN), vitamin B12 deficiency (combined system degeneration), adrenomyeloneuropathy, or hereditary spastic paraplegia with neuropathy (HSP-plus)
- UMN signs alone with no sensory loss → motor neuron disease (ALS, PLS), NOT peripheral neuropathy
Question 5: What Is the Temporal Evolution?
| Course | Duration | Suggested Cause |
|---|
| Acute | Days-4 weeks | GBS, porphyria, diphtheria, toxic (arsenic, thallium) |
| Subacute | 4-8 weeks | CIDP, deficiency states (B1, B12), drug toxicity, vasculitic neuropathy, paraneoplastic |
| Chronic progressive | >8 weeks-years | Diabetic, hereditary (CMT), CIDP, paraproteinemic, amyloid |
| Relapsing-remitting | Episodic | CIDP, hereditary neuropathy with pressure palsies (HNPP), porphyria |
Rules out:
- Hyperacute onset (hours-1 day) of profound weakness → consider acute ischemic neuropathy, porphyria, or critical illness polyneuropathy
- Very slow insidious course over decades, often with pes cavus and no sensory symptoms → hereditary neuropathy (CMT) rather than acquired
Question 6: Is There Evidence of a Hereditary Neuropathy?
Ask specifically:
- Family history of neuropathy, gait difficulty, foot deformity, inability to run since childhood
- Pes cavus (high arched feet) and hammer toes (especially if present since childhood)
- Lack of sensory symptoms despite sensory signs on examination (highly characteristic of CMT - patients adapt to slow fiber loss)
- Scoliosis, kyphoscoliosis
Hereditary clues in history:
- CMT: onset in childhood/teens, slowly progressive, family members similarly affected, no sensory complaints despite objective loss
- Porphyria (acute intermittent): episodic attacks of neuropathy with abdominal pain, psychiatric symptoms, urine that turns red/dark on standing
- Fabry's disease: X-linked, burning/lancinating pain in hands and feet in males since childhood, angiokeratomas around umbilicus and scrotum, premature cardiovascular disease
- Familial amyloid polyneuropathy: autonomic + sensory neuropathy, family history, carpal tunnel syndrome, cardiomyopathy
Rules out acquired causes when hereditary pattern is clear, preventing unnecessary workup.
Question 7: Are There Associated Medical Conditions?
This is the cornerstone of etiologic diagnosis. Systematically ask about:
Metabolic/endocrine:
- Diabetes mellitus (most common cause, ~50% of polyneuropathies)
- Prediabetes/metabolic syndrome (accounts for many "idiopathic" neuropathies)
- Hypothyroidism, uraemia, liver disease, vitamin deficiencies (B1, B6, B12, folate, vitamin E)
Malignancy:
- Known cancer (especially lung, breast, lymphoma) → paraneoplastic neuropathy (anti-Hu antibodies); may precede tumour diagnosis
- Multiple myeloma, POEMS syndrome → paraproteinemic neuropathy
Autoimmune/connective tissue:
- Rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, Sjögren's, vasculitis, sarcoidosis
- Sjögren's → sensory neuronopathy (ganglionopathy) or painful sensory neuropathy
Infections:
- HIV (distal painful sensory neuropathy, most common neurological complication)
- Leprosy (most common treatable neuropathy worldwide; thickened cutaneous nerves)
- Lyme disease (mononeuropathy multiplex, cranial nerve palsies)
- Hepatitis B/C (cryoglobulinemia → vasculitic mononeuropathy multiplex)
- CMV, EBV (GBS trigger, polyradiculopathy in immunocompromised)
Toxic/drug history (critical - ask about every medication and exposure):
- Drugs: chemotherapy (vincristine, cisplatin, paclitaxel), isoniazid, metronidazole, nitrofurantoin, phenytoin, thalidomide, amiodarone, colchicine
- Alcohol (direct toxic + nutritional B1 deficiency)
- Heavy metals: lead (motor-predominant), arsenic (painful sensory), thallium (alopecia + neuropathy)
- Industrial solvents: n-hexane, methyl n-butyl ketone
Rules out:
- If a clear toxic/drug cause identified → acquired toxic neuropathy (remove agent, observe for recovery)
- If DM present and neuropathy is distal, symmetrical, sensory-predominant → likely diabetic polyneuropathy, but UMN signs or rapid course mandate exclusion of other causes
C. Additional History Points
Social history: alcohol use (amount and duration), occupation (solvent/heavy metal exposure), dietary habits (veganism → B12 deficiency)
Preceding illness: URI or diarrhoea 2-4 weeks before weakness onset → GBS (Campylobacter jejuni most common trigger)
Review of systems: carpal tunnel (common in amyloid, hypothyroidism, acromegaly, diabetes), hearing loss (CMT-X, Refsum's disease), optic atrophy (CMT2 variants), skin changes (leprosy, Fabry's angiokeratomas), orthostatic symptoms
PART II: CLINICAL EXAMINATION
A. General Inspection
Before touching the patient:
- Pes cavus (high arched foot) + hammer toes → hereditary neuropathy (CMT)
- Foot drop gait (steppage gait) → distal motor neuropathy
- Wide-based ataxic gait → severe proprioceptive loss (sensory ataxia) - do the patient's symptoms worsen in the dark? This distinguishes sensory from cerebellar ataxia
- Fasciculations in muscle → suggests motor neuron disease rather than pure peripheral neuropathy
- Skin: leprosy patches (hypopigmented, anaesthetic), angiokeratomas (Fabry's), xanthomas (hyperlipidaemia)
- Thickened nerves: leprosy, CMT, amyloid, Refsum's disease - palpate greater auricular, ulnar at elbow, common peroneal at fibular head
B. Motor Examination
Inspection:
- Wasting: distal > proximal distribution in polyneuropathy; "inverted champagne bottle" legs (below-knee atrophy) in CMT
- Fasciculations: ALS > peripheral neuropathy
Power testing (MRC grading 0-5):
- Test distal muscles first: ankle dorsiflexors (tibialis anterior), intrinsic foot/hand muscles, extensor hallucis longus
- Then proximal: hip flexors, shoulder abductors
- Predominantly distal weakness = axonal polyneuropathy
- Proximal + distal weakness = demyelinating polyneuropathy (GBS, CIDP) - this is a key differential finding
- Asymmetric or multifocal weakness = mononeuropathy multiplex (vasculitis), radiculopathy, plexopathy
Rules out:
- Proximal-predominant weakness without sensory loss → myopathy (check CK, EMG)
- Global weakness with fatigability (worse with repetition, worse in afternoon) → NMJ disorder (myasthenia gravis)
- UMN signs (spasticity, clonus, extensor plantar) with weakness → central/combined lesion, not pure PNS
C. Sensory Examination
Test each modality separately, as selective loss distinguishes fiber types:
Large-fiber modalities (A-beta fibres):
- Vibration (128 Hz tuning fork): start at great toe; if absent, move to medial malleolus, tibial tuberosity, anterior iliac spine (to define the level)
- Joint position sense (proprioception): small passive movements of great toe; if impaired, confirm pseudoathetosis with eyes closed
- Light touch (cotton wool or 10g monofilament)
- Two-point discrimination
Small-fiber modalities (C and A-delta fibres):
- Pin-prick (sterile pin or neurological pin): compare left vs right, proximal vs distal
- Temperature (warm/cold test tubes or Tip-Therm)
Interpretation:
| Sensory loss pattern | Likely lesion |
|---|
| Loss of pain + temperature, preserved vibration/proprioception | Small-fiber neuropathy (DM, amyloid, HIV, idiopathic) |
| Loss of vibration + proprioception, preserved pain/temperature | Large-fiber neuropathy (B12 deficiency, CIDP, CMT) |
| All modalities lost distally ("glove and stocking") | Length-dependent polyneuropathy (most common pattern) |
| Severe proprioceptive loss with preserved strength | Sensory neuronopathy/ganglionopathy (paraneoplastic, Sjögren's, cisplatin) |
| Loss in dermatomal (band-like) distribution | Radiculopathy, NOT polyneuropathy |
| Loss along peripheral nerve territory | Mononeuropathy (e.g., carpal tunnel, ulnar nerve compression) |
| Dissociated sensory loss at a specific spinal level | Spinal cord lesion (syringomyelia, transverse myelitis) - rules out peripheral neuropathy |
Romberg test: patient stands with feet together, eyes open then closed
- Falls/sway only with eyes closed = sensory ataxia (posterior column or large-fiber neuropathy)
- Falls with eyes open also = cerebellar ataxia or vestibular disorder
D. Reflexes
Deep tendon reflexes are perhaps the single most important sign:
- Absent or reduced ankle jerks = peripheral neuropathy (almost universal finding); absent throughout = more widespread neuropathy
- Loss in an asymmetric or patchy pattern = mononeuropathy multiplex, radiculopathy
- Preserved or brisk reflexes in the presence of weakness or sensory loss = question whether lesion is truly peripheral; if UMN signs coexist → combined system disease (B12), ALS, or structural cord lesion
Rules out:
- Hyperreflexia/clonus/Babinski = UMN lesion (cord or brain), NOT peripheral neuropathy
- Selective loss of knee jerks with preserved ankle jerks = L3/L4 radiculopathy rather than peripheral neuropathy
Plantar responses: should be flexor (downgoing) in peripheral neuropathy; extensor response (Babinski) = UMN sign, pointing to spinal cord or brain
E. Autonomic Examination
- Blood pressure lying and standing: orthostatic hypotension (fall ≥20 mmHg systolic) without reflex tachycardia = autonomic neuropathy (DM, amyloid, GBS, HSAN)
- Skin: anhidrosis, trophic changes in feet, vasomotor changes (cold/cyanotic feet)
- Pupils: Argyll Robertson pupils or Horner's syndrome in autonomic neuropathy
- Bladder and bowel: palpate for distended bladder; rectal tone
Rules out:
- Orthostatic hypotension with appropriate tachycardia = hypovolaemia or autonomic failure from a non-neurological cause
- Absent sweating over trunk with preserved limb sweating = central autonomic lesion, not peripheral
F. Cranial Nerve Examination
Cranial nerve involvement helps narrow the diagnosis:
- Facial diplegia (bilateral VII) = GBS (occurs in >50% of cases), Lyme disease, sarcoidosis
- Ophthalmoplegia (III, IV, VI) + ataxia + areflexia = Miller Fisher syndrome (GBS variant, anti-GQ1b antibodies)
- Bilateral lower cranial nerve palsies (IX, X, XII: dysphagia, dysarthria) = GBS, ALS, myasthenia gravis
- Trigeminal sensory neuropathy = Sjögren's syndrome, paraneoplastic
- Hearing loss with neuropathy = Refsum's disease (also has retinitis pigmentosa + ataxia), CMT-X
G. Special Tests on Examination
- Tinel's sign (wrist, elbow): focal entrapment neuropathies (carpal tunnel, cubital tunnel)
- Phalen's test: carpal tunnel syndrome
- Straight leg raise: lumbosacral radiculopathy (rules out polyneuropathy at that level)
- Nerve palpation: thickened, palpable nerves at ulnar at elbow, common peroneal at fibular head = CMT, leprosy, amyloid
- Tandem gait, heel-toe walking: discloses subtle proximal weakness or ataxia
- Pseudoathetosis: slow writhing movements of outstretched fingers with eyes closed = severe proprioceptive loss
Summary: Key Differentiating Features at a Glance
| Feature | Peripheral Neuropathy | UMN/Cord Lesion | Myopathy | NMJ Disorder |
|---|
| Reflexes | Reduced/absent | Increased (Babinski+) | Normal/reduced | Normal |
| Plantar response | Flexor | Extensor | Flexor | Flexor |
| Weakness distribution | Distal > proximal (or diffuse) | Pyramidal pattern | Proximal > distal | Bulbar, ocular, proximal |
| Sensation | Impaired (glove/stocking) | Dermatomal level | Normal | Normal |
| Wasting | Present (late) | Absent early | Present | Absent |
| Fatigability | No | No | Rare | Yes (myasthenia) |
| Autonomic signs | Possible | Possible (cord) | No | No |
| Gait | Steppage or ataxic | Spastic-scissor | Trendelenburg/waddling | Variable |
Topographic Patterns and Their Differential Diagnosis (Adams & Victor + Harrison's)
| Pattern | Key Clinical Features | Causes to Consider |
|---|
| Symmetric distal polyneuropathy | Stocking-glove sensory loss, distal areflexia, minimal weakness | DM, idiopathic (CSPN), toxic, alcohol, B12 deficiency, CMT, amyloid |
| Acute symmetric ascending motor + sensory | Rapid ascent, areflexia, facial diplegia, autonomic instability | GBS |
| Chronic symmetric proximal + distal | Proximal AND distal weakness, sensory loss | CIDP, paraproteinaemia, lymphoma |
| Asymmetric multifocal (mononeuropathy multiplex) | Multiple individual nerve territories, stepwise progression | Vasculitis, diabetes, leprosy, sarcoid, cryoglobulinaemia, Lyme |
| Sensory ataxia, severe proprioceptive loss | Romberg+, pseudoathetosis, intact strength | Paraneoplastic (anti-Hu), Sjögren's, cisplatin, CANVAS, B6 toxicity |
| Pure motor neuropathy | No sensory symptoms/signs | MMN (with conduction block), GBS, porphyria |
| Small-fiber neuropathy | Burning pain, allodynia, normal NCVs, preserved reflexes | DM/prediabetes, amyloid, idiopathic, HIV |
References
- Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine 22E (2025), Chapter 457: "Peripheral Neuropathy," pp. 3638-3645
- Adams and Victor's Principles of Neurology, 12th Ed., Chapter 43: "Approach to the Patient with Peripheral Neuropathy," pp. 1295-1298
- Goldman-Cecil Medicine, Chapter: "Peripheral Neuropathy," pp. 4073+