I now have all the material needed for a thorough answer. Here is a comprehensive breakdown of the modes (types) of aphasia:
Modes of Aphasia
Aphasia is an acquired language disorder from damage to the brain's dominant (usually left) hemisphere language centers. The classic classification is based on three bedside features: fluency of spontaneous speech, auditory comprehension, and repetition. Naming is impaired in virtually all types.
Perisylvian Aphasias (Repetition Impaired)
These aphasias involve the perisylvian language zone; repetition is always impaired.
1. Broca Aphasia (Non-fluent / Expressive)
- Lesion: Posterior inferior frontal gyrus (Brodmann areas 44 & 45) + adjacent cortex and subcortical white matter; territory of upper division of left MCA
- Speech: Non-fluent, hesitant, telegraphic ("agrammatism") - e.g., "wife come hospital." Phonetic errors inconsistent utterance-to-utterance (literal paraphasias)
- Comprehension: Relatively preserved, though complex syntax is impaired
- Repetition: Impaired
- Naming: Impaired (often "tip of the tongue" phenomenon)
- Reading/Writing: Both impaired
- Associated signs: Right hemiparesis, right hemisensory loss, apraxia of left limbs
- Behavior: Patients are typically aware of deficits; depression is common
| Feature | Finding |
|---|
| Spontaneous speech | Nonfluent, telegraphic |
| Comprehension | Intact (mild difficulty with complex syntax) |
| Repetition | Impaired |
| Associated signs | Right hemiparesis, apraxia |
2. Wernicke Aphasia (Fluent / Receptive)
- Lesion: Posterior superior temporal gyrus (Wernicke area, Brodmann area 22); territory of lower division of left MCA
- Speech: Fluent, effortless, sometimes logorrhea (excessive) - but empty of meaning; filled with verbal paraphasias, neologisms, and jargon
- Comprehension: Impaired - even for simple commands
- Repetition: Impaired
- Naming: Severely impaired with bizarre paraphasic substitutions
- Reading: Impaired (similar to auditory comprehension)
- Associated signs: Often no hemiparesis; right hemianopia or superior quadrantanopia may be present
- Behavior: Patients are often unaware of their deficits (anosognosia); may become agitated or paranoid when not understood
| Feature | Finding |
|---|
| Spontaneous speech | Fluent, paraphasic, jargon |
| Comprehension | Impaired |
| Repetition | Impaired |
| Associated signs | No hemiparesis typically |
3. Global Aphasia
- Lesion: Large left hemisphere lesion involving both inferior frontal AND superior temporal regions + much of parietal lobe; most of left MCA territory
- The most severe form - essentially Broca + Wernicke combined
- Speech: Mute or non-fluent
- Comprehension: Impaired
- Repetition: Impaired
- Naming: Impaired
- Reading/Writing: Impaired
- Associated signs: Dense right hemiplegia, hemisensory loss, hemianopia
- Prognosis: Recovery may continue through the second 6 months post-stroke; patients often evolve toward Broca aphasia if the superior temporal gyrus is spared
| Feature | Finding |
|---|
| Spontaneous speech | Mute or nonfluent |
| Comprehension | Impaired |
| Repetition | Impaired |
| Associated signs | Right hemiplegia, hemianopia |
4. Conduction Aphasia
- Lesion: Arcuate fasciculus (disconnects Broca from Wernicke areas); involves the supramarginal gyrus and/or the insula
- The hallmark: Disproportionately impaired repetition - a patient who can hold a conversation cannot repeat even single words. Classic example: patient could not repeat "boy" but said "I like girls better."
- Speech: Relatively fluent, but with literal paraphasic errors and frequent self-correction attempts (conduite d'approche)
- Comprehension: Preserved
- Repetition: Severely impaired (out of proportion to spontaneous speech)
- Naming: Moderately impaired
- Associated signs: Right hemisensory loss, mild hemiparesis; limb apraxia
| Feature | Finding |
|---|
| Spontaneous speech | Fluent with literal paraphasias |
| Comprehension | Intact |
| Repetition | Severely impaired (hallmark) |
| Associated signs | Apraxia, mild right-sided deficits |
Transcortical Aphasias (Repetition Preserved / Spared)
These involve areas outside the core perisylvian zone. Repetition is relatively preserved because the arcuate fasciculus is intact.
5. Transcortical Motor Aphasia
- Lesion: Anterior or superior to Broca area (supplementary motor area / anterior watershed zone)
- Speech: Non-fluent, reduced, but can become fluent when prompted or completing a phrase
- Comprehension: Intact
- Repetition: Preserved (often echolalia)
- Naming: Impaired
6. Transcortical Sensory Aphasia
- Lesion: Posterior watershed zone, posterior to Wernicke area (temporo-parieto-occipital junction)
- Speech: Fluent with paraphasias - similar to Wernicke, but repetition is intact
- Comprehension: Impaired
- Repetition: Preserved
- Naming: Impaired
7. Mixed Transcortical Aphasia (Isolation Aphasia)
- All modalities impaired except repetition
- Patient can only repeat (echo) what is said
- Lesion: Watershed zone infarcts isolating the perisylvian language zone
Non-Perisylvian Aphasias
8. Anomic Aphasia
- Lesion: Variable - can be the angular gyrus, temporal-parietal junction, or any part of the language network; also seen in recovery from other aphasias
- The mildest and most common aphasia type
- Speech: Fluent, but marked word-finding difficulty (anomia). Patients circumlocute ("the thing you use to... cut bread")
- Comprehension: Intact
- Repetition: Intact
- Naming: Impaired (defining feature)
- Often a residual of other aphasias after recovery
Quick Reference Summary Table
| Aphasia Type | Fluency | Comprehension | Repetition | Key Feature |
|---|
| Broca | Non-fluent | Intact | Impaired | Telegraphic speech, right hemiparesis |
| Wernicke | Fluent | Impaired | Impaired | Jargon/paraphasic, unaware of deficits |
| Global | Non-fluent | Impaired | Impaired | All modalities affected; dense hemiplegia |
| Conduction | Fluent | Intact | Impaired | Disproportionate repetition deficit |
| Transcortical Motor | Non-fluent | Intact | Preserved | Like Broca but repetition spared |
| Transcortical Sensory | Fluent | Impaired | Preserved | Like Wernicke but repetition spared |
| Mixed Transcortical | Non-fluent | Impaired | Preserved | Echolalia only |
| Anomic | Fluent | Intact | Intact | Word-finding only; mildest |
Anatomy at a Glance
- Broca area: Posterior inferior frontal gyrus (BA 44, 45) - production
- Wernicke area: Posterior superior temporal gyrus (BA 22) - comprehension
- Arcuate fasciculus: White matter tract connecting the two - when cut, causes conduction aphasia
- Angular gyrus: Parietal lobe - reading, writing, and naming
- Watershed zones: Medial/superior frontoparietal and posterior parieto-occipital - transcortical aphasias
MRI: Broca Aphasia Infarct
MRI from a patient with Broca aphasia - the infarct involves the cortical Broca area, subcortical white matter, and insula. The patient made a good recovery. (Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice)
Special Notes
- Aphemia: A rare transient muteness from isolated left frontal/Broca area lesions; classified separately if writing is normal (may not be a true language disorder)
- Primary Progressive Aphasia (PPA): Unlike the above acquired aphasias (typically from stroke), PPA is a neurodegenerative syndrome that worsens over time
- Pure Word Deafness: Severe auditory comprehension deficit with preserved reading/writing; lesion isolates Wernicke area from auditory input
- All aphasias impair naming to some degree; naming is the most sensitive indicator of dominant hemisphere language dysfunction
Sources: Bradley and Daroff's Neurology in Clinical Practice, Ch. 13; Kaplan & Sadock's Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry, Ch. 55