I now have extensive textbook content on VNG. Let me compile a comprehensive, structured teaching lesson.
π Full VNG (Videonystagmography) Interpretation β Complete Guide
1. What is VNG?
Videonystagmography (VNG) is the modern gold-standard method for recording and interpreting eye movements to assess vestibular (balance) system function.
- ENG (Electronystagmography) β older method; uses electrodes at the lateral canthi and above/below one eye to measure the corneoretinal electrical potential (a dipole) indirectly.
- VNG β modern method; uses infrared video cameras to record eye movements directly in real-time and digitally.
VNG replaced ENG because it is more accurate, allows visualization of torsional nystagmus, and produces digital recordings.
2. Components of VNG
VNG has two major test categories:
A. Vestibular Subtests
| Subtest | What it tests |
|---|
| Spontaneous nystagmus | Nystagmus at rest, eyes open/closed |
| Gaze nystagmus | Nystagmus with sustained lateral/vertical gaze |
| Positional nystagmus | Nystagmus in static head positions |
| Positioning nystagmus | Nystagmus triggered by head movement (e.g., Dix-Hallpike) |
| Fistula test | Pressure-induced nystagmus (perilymphatic fistula) |
| Bithermal caloric tests | Lateral SCC function assessment (most important subtest) |
B. Oculomotor Subtests
| Subtest | What it tests |
|---|
| Pursuit (smooth pursuit) | Ability to track a slow-moving target |
| Saccadic system | Accuracy and speed of fast eye movements |
| Optokinetic (OKN) | Nystagmus response to a moving visual field |
| Fixation | Ability to suppress nystagmus with visual fixation |
3. Key Concept: Nystagmus
Nystagmus = rhythmic involuntary eye movement with a slow phase (vestibular drift) and a fast phase (corrective saccade).
- By convention, direction of nystagmus = direction of the FAST phase
- The slow phase velocity (SPV) is the actual measure of vestibular function
4. Spontaneous Nystagmus
- Tested with eyes open and eyes closed (fixation removed)
- Normal: No nystagmus (or very minimal, < 2Β°/s)
- Abnormal: Nystagmus > 2Β°/s
Key rule β Fixation suppression:
- In peripheral lesions β fixation suppresses nystagmus (normal fixation suppression)
- In central lesions β fixation does NOT suppress nystagmus (failure of fixation suppression)
5. Gaze Nystagmus
Patient looks to the right, left, up, and down.
| Finding | Significance |
|---|
| Direction-fixed nystagmus (always beats one way) | Peripheral pathology |
| Direction-changing nystagmus (changes with gaze direction) | Central pathology |
| Gaze-evoked nystagmus in direction of gaze | Central (cerebellar/brainstem) |
| Downbeat nystagmus | Central (cervicomedullary junction) |
| Upbeat nystagmus | Central (brainstem/cerebellum) |
6. Positional vs. Positioning Nystagmus
| Positional | Positioning |
|---|
| When tested | Static position held | During the head movement (e.g., Dix-Hallpike) |
| Example | Supine, head-right | Roll test, Dix-Hallpike |
| Peripheral feature | Fatigues, direction-fixed | Latency, fatigues, transient |
| Central feature | Persistent, direction-changing | No latency, no fatigue, persistent |
BPPV Note: Standard ENG/VNG cannot record torsional nystagmus (characteristic of BPPV). A 3D VNG or infrared Frenzel goggles are needed for proper BPPV visualization.
7. The Bithermal Caloric Test β The Core of VNG
Principle
The caloric test stimulates the lateral (horizontal) semicircular canal (SCC) using a thermal stimulus. It is the only test that can assess each ear independently.
Position: Patient lies supine with head elevated 30Β° (caloric test position β CTP) β this puts the lateral SCC in the vertical plane so convection currents can form.
Stimulus
| Stimulus | Water | Air |
|---|
| Warm | 44Β°C for 30 sec | 58Β°C for 60 sec |
| Cool | 30Β°C for 30 sec | 24Β°C for 60 sec |
Contraindications to water: Tympanic membrane perforation, tympanostomy tubes β use air instead.
COWS Mnemonic
Cold β Opposite, Warm β Same
- Cold irrigation β endolymph falls β ampullofugal flow β inhibition of that ear β eyes drift toward the stimulated ear β fast (corrective) nystagmus beats to the opposite side
- Warm irrigation β endolymph rises β ampullopetal flow β excitation of that ear β eyes drift away β fast nystagmus beats to the same side
How to Calculate
Step 1 β Record peak slow phase velocity (SPV) for all four irrigations:
- RW = Right ear Warm
- RC = Right ear Cool
- LW = Left ear Warm
- LC = Left ear Cool
Step 2 β Unilateral Weakness (UW) / Canal Paresis (CP):
$$UW = \frac{(RW + RC) - (LW + LC)}{RW + RC + LW + LC} \times 100%$$
- Abnormal if > 25β30% (lab-dependent, commonly 25%)
- A high UW% means the ear with the lower sum is the weak (hypoactive) ear
- Indicates peripheral vestibular hypofunction on that side
Step 3 β Directional Preponderance (DP):
$$DP = \frac{(RW + LC) - (LW + RC)}{RW + RC + LW + LC} \times 100%$$
- Abnormal if > 30%
- Reflects an asymmetry in nystagmus direction regardless of which ear is stimulated
- Weak clinical value on its own, but may point toward the side of a central lesion (preponderance) or away from a peripheral lesion
Step 4 β Bilateral Weakness:
- Abnormal if LW + LC < 12Β°/s AND RW + RC < 12Β°/s (lab-dependent)
- Suggests bilateral peripheral vestibular loss (e.g., ototoxicity, autoimmune)
8. Oculomotor Subtest Interpretation
Smooth Pursuit
- Patient tracks a sinusoidally moving target
- Normal: Smooth, continuous tracking
- Abnormal: Saccadic (jerky) pursuit = central pathology (cerebellum, brainstem, or age-related)
Saccades
- Patient makes rapid eye movements to jump between targets
- Metrics: Latency, velocity, accuracy
- Undershoot (hypometria): Normal minor variant, also in cerebellar disease
- Overshoot (hypermetria): Cerebellar lesion
- Slow saccades: Brainstem, neurodegenerative disease
Optokinetic Nystagmus (OKN)
- Moving stripes/pattern β induced nystagmus
- Asymmetric OKN: Central pathway lesion (brainstem, parietal lobe)
- Symmetric OKN gain reduction: Diffuse central dysfunction
Fixation Suppression
- If nystagmus is present during caloric, can the patient suppress it with visual fixation?
- Normal: Nystagmus suppressed β₯ 60% (fixation suppression index, FSI > 0.6)
- Abnormal FSI (failure of fixation suppression): Central lesion (cerebellar/brainstem)
9. Pattern Recognition β Central vs. Peripheral
| Feature | Peripheral (labyrinth / CN VIII) | Central (brainstem / cerebellum) |
|---|
| Spontaneous nystagmus | Unidirectional, horizontal-torsional | Any direction, may be vertical |
| Direction of nystagmus | Fixed | Changing with gaze |
| Fixation suppression | Present (suppresses nystagmus) | Absent (fails to suppress) |
| Caloric response | Unilateral weakness | Bilaterally absent or normal with central signs |
| Saccades / pursuit | Normal | Abnormal |
| OKN | Symmetric | Asymmetric |
| Onset | Acute, severe vertigo | Gradual or insidious |
Red Flags for Central Pathology in VNG:
- Spontaneous/positional nystagmus with normal caloric responses
- Direction-changing nystagmus
- Failure of fixation suppression
- Bilateral absent caloric responses without history of ear disease or ototoxicity
- Abnormal saccades or saccadic pursuit with normal calorics
- Hyperactive caloric responses (loss of cerebellar inhibition) without TM defect or mastoid cavity
Signs of Peripheral Pathology:
- Unilateral caloric weakness (UW > 25β30%)
- Bilateral caloric weakness with history of labyrinthine disease or ototoxicity
- Fatiguing positional nystagmus
- Intact fixation suppression
- Direction-fixed nystagmus
10. Step-by-Step VNG Interpretation Approach
STEP 1: Oculomotor subtests
β Are saccades, pursuit, OKN normal?
β If abnormal β suspect CENTRAL
STEP 2: Spontaneous nystagmus
β Present? Direction? Suppressed by fixation?
β Failure of fixation suppression β CENTRAL
STEP 3: Gaze testing
β Direction-changing? β CENTRAL
β Direction-fixed β peripheral
STEP 4: Positional/positioning tests
β Fatiguing, latency, direction-fixed β peripheral (BPPV)
β Persistent, no fatigue, direction-changing β CENTRAL
STEP 5: Caloric test (the KEY step)
β Calculate UW and DP
β Unilateral weakness β peripheral hypofunction on that side
β Bilateral weakness β bilateral peripheral loss
β Normal calorics but abnormal oculomotor β CENTRAL
STEP 6: Synthesize
β Match all findings β peripheral vs. central pattern
β Correlate with clinical history
11. Common Clinical Correlations
| Diagnosis | Expected VNG Findings |
|---|
| Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo (BPPV) | Positive Dix-Hallpike (torsional-upbeat nystagmus), normal calorics |
| Vestibular Neuritis / Labyrinthitis | Unilateral caloric weakness, direction-fixed nystagmus, intact fixation suppression |
| Ménière's Disease | Unilateral caloric weakness (during or after attacks), direction-fixed nystagmus |
| Acoustic Neuroma (Vestibular Schwannoma) | Unilateral caloric weakness on affected side (ipsilateral) |
| Cerebellar Stroke / Lesion | Abnormal pursuit, saccadic dysmetria, failure of fixation suppression, hyperactive calorics |
| Bilateral Vestibular Loss (ototoxicity, e.g., aminoglycosides) | Bilateral caloric weakness |
| Central positional nystagmus | Non-fatiguing, no latency, direction-changing positional nystagmus |
12. Quick Memory Anchors
| Mnemonic | Meaning |
|---|
| COWS | Cold-Opposite, Warm-Same (caloric nystagmus direction) |
| BPPV = fatigues | Positioning nystagmus with latency and fatigue = peripheral |
| Central = can't suppress | Fixation suppression failure = always think central |
| UW > 25% | Unilateral Canal Paresis = peripheral hypofunction |
| Saccades abnormal + normal calorics | Classic central pattern |
Sources: K.J. Lee's Essential Otolaryngology (pp. 350β352); Cummings Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery; Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine 22E
This covers the full VNG interpretation framework β from recording principles through every subtest, caloric formulas, central vs. peripheral pattern recognition, and clinical correlation. Ask if you want deeper focus on any particular subtest, a worked caloric calculation example, or BPPV positioning tests in detail.