I now have very comprehensive data from multiple authoritative forensic medicine textbooks. Let me compile these into thorough PG exam notes.
HANGING - Complete PG Exam Notes
Forensic Medicine & Toxicology
1. DEFINITION
Hanging is a form of violent (mechanical) asphyxial death resulting from the suspension of the body by a ligature encircling the neck, where the constricting force is the weight of the body itself (or the head alone in partial hanging).
Key distinction: In hanging the constricting force = body weight. In strangulation = external force applied by another person or ligature tightened externally.
2. TYPES / CLASSIFICATION
A. By Position of Feet (Degree of Suspension)
| Type | Description |
|---|
| Complete hanging | Body fully suspended in air; entire body weight acts as constricting force |
| Partial (Incomplete) hanging | Feet/toes/knees/buttocks touch the ground; only the weight of the head (~5-6 kg / 10-12 lb) acts as constricting force; this is SUFFICIENT to occlude carotid arteries and cause death |
Exam point: Partial hanging is extremely common - a person can hang themselves kneeling, sitting, or even lying in bed. The weight of the head alone is sufficient to occlude jugular veins (2 kg) and carotid arteries (3.5 kg).
B. By Position of Knot (Typical vs Atypical)
| Type | Knot Position | Frequency |
|---|
| Typical hanging | Back of neck (nape) | More common |
| Atypical hanging | Anywhere except the nape - side, front, under the chin | Less common |
C. By Manner of Death
| Manner | Details |
|---|
| Suicidal | Most common; virtually all hangings are suicidal; more common in males in India |
| Accidental | Rare; seen in autoerotic/sexual asphyxia (hanging used for erotic pleasure); children accidentally |
| Homicidal (Lynching) | Very rare; victim must be rendered unconscious/incapacitated by drugs, alcohol, or assault first |
| Judicial | Execution of convicted criminals - distinct mechanism (see below) |
3. PRESSURE REQUIRED TO OCCLUDE NECK STRUCTURES
| Structure | Pressure Required |
|---|
| Jugular veins | 2 kg (4.4 lb) |
| Carotid arteries | 3.5 kg (11 lb) |
| Trachea | 15 kg |
| Vertebral arteries | 16.6 kg |
PG High-Yield: The ease of occlusion of jugular veins and carotids (far less than the weight of the head) explains why partial/incomplete hangings are lethal and why NO full suspension is needed for death.
4. CAUSE OF DEATH
Death in hanging is primarily due to compression of cerebrovascular supply, NOT asphyxia alone. Causes include:
- Cerebral ischaemia and anoxia - obstruction of carotid arteries (most important)
- Cerebral congestion - compression of jugular veins causing venous back-pressure
- Airway obstruction - direct tracheal compression OR root of tongue forced upward/backward blocking pharynx; epiglottis folded over laryngeal inlet
- Vagal inhibition - pressure on vagus nerve or carotid sinus causing reflex cardiac arrest
- Spinal cord injury - especially in judicial hanging (fracture-dislocation at C2-C3 level)
- Combination of above
Key evidence that asphyxia is NOT the primary mechanism:
- Persons with tracheostomy (below the level of noose) have died by hanging
- Vomitus found in bronchi BELOW the ligature level (airway was patent)
- Blood vessel occlusion occurs at far lower pressures than tracheal occlusion
5. FATAL PERIOD
- Suicidal/non-judicial hanging: 5-8 minutes (common)
- With vagal inhibition: Nearly instantaneous
- Judicial hanging (with cervical fracture): Instantaneous unconsciousness; heart may beat for 8-20 minutes thereafter
- Filmed hanging study (Sauvageau et al.):
- Loss of consciousness: ~13 seconds
- Mild convulsions: ~15 seconds
- Decerebrate posturing: ~19 seconds
- Loss of muscle tone: ~1 minute
- Complete cessation of all movement: ~4 minutes
6. JUDICIAL HANGING
This is a distinct entity and a separate exam topic:
- Convicted criminal; face covered with a dark mask
- Stands on trapdoor; noose placed with knot on the left side of jaw (near chin)
- Trapdoor springs; person falls a calculated distance based on body weight (platform ~5 meters height)
- Sudden violent jerk to neck causes fracture-dislocation at C2-C3 (or atlanto-occipital / atlanto-axial joint)
- Transection of the spinal cord
- Immediate unconsciousness; heart beats 8-20 minutes afterward
- If fall is too short: strangulation (slow death)
- If fall is too long: decapitation
- X-ray shows bilateral fractures of pedicles/laminae of 2nd, 3rd or 4th cervical vertebra
- Associated findings: muscular contractions of facial muscles, twitching/convulsions of limbs, violent respiratory movements of chest
7. SEQUENCE OF EVENTS / SYMPTOMS (Suicidal Hanging)
- Flashes of light before eyes
- Ringing in ears
- Sudden loss of consciousness
- Convulsive movements
- Death
8. POSTMORTEM APPEARANCES
A. External Appearances
| Feature | Details |
|---|
| Neck | Elongated/stretched due to upward pull of ligature |
| Head position | Inclined to the side OPPOSITE the knot (due to gravity) |
| Face | Usually pale (complete hanging - carotids occluded); congested in partial hanging (vertebral arteries continue to supply) |
| Petechiae | Rare in complete hanging; common in partial hanging (vertebral arteries still supply blood while jugulars are occluded) |
| Eyes | Prominent/congested eyeballs |
| Tongue | Turgid, may protrude; dark brown/black due to drying (exposed part); pressed between teeth |
| Saliva | Dribbles from corner of mouth opposite to the knot side (pressure on salivary glands) |
| Postmortem lividity (PM hypostasis) | Found circumferentially on lower arms, hands and legs; also on face/neck ABOVE the ligature |
| Tardieu spots | Punctate haemorrhages due to hydrostatic rupture of vessels (seen in dependent areas) |
| Hands/nail beds | Cyanosed |
B. Ligature Mark (THE most important finding)
| Feature | Hanging | Strangulation |
|---|
| Direction | Oblique, runs upward toward the knot (inverted-V / U-shaped) | Horizontal, encircles entire neck |
| Continuity | Incomplete - fades out/absent at knot (point of suspension) | Complete - encircles entire neck |
| Level | Above thyroid cartilage (80%); at level (15%); below (5%; partial hanging) | Usually at/below thyroid cartilage |
| Shape | Inverted-V with apex at knot; groove/furrow | Horizontal groove |
| Colour | Pale, yellow/yellow-brown, parchment-like (dried abrasion) | May be more haemorrhagic |
| Width | Slightly less than or equal to width of ligature material | Similar |
| Knot impression | May show imprint of knot at apex | - |
Additional ligature mark details:
- Thin hard ligature: narrow, deep, distinct groove
- Rope: mirror-image impression of the twist of rope on skin
- Folded sheet: broad, indistinct furrow
- Rolled cloth: broad, pale furrow
- Along edges: thin line of congestion/haemorrhage at deepest point
- Ligature marks resist decomposition (compressed blood vessels restrict access by putrefying bacteria)
- Ecchymosis with abrasion = strongly suggests antemortem suspension
- The noose typically slips above the larynx, catching under the chin
C. Internal Appearances
- Neck fractures are rare in non-judicial hangings (only ~9-12% of cases)
- When present: superior horns of thyroid cartilage (most common), hyoid bone
- Cervical spine fracture: only in obese/elderly with degenerative disease + complete suspension + sudden drop
- Strap muscle haemorrhage: ~20% of cases
- Intimal tear of carotid artery (diagnostic of antemortem hanging)
- Ecchymosis of larynx and epiglottis
- Congestion and oedema of brain, lungs
- Petechial haemorrhages on brain surface, visceral pleura
- Heart: right side distended with dark fluid blood
9. DIAGNOSIS OF ANTEMORTEM HANGING
(These findings confirm hanging occurred while alive - important medicolegally)
- Antemortem ligature mark with vital reaction (redness, haemorrhage, inflammation)
- Saliva dribbling mark from angle of mouth
- Ecchymosis of larynx or epiglottis
- Intimal rupture of carotid vessels
- Fracture of thyroid cartilage / hyoid bone (with vital reaction)
10. MEDICOLEGAL ASPECTS
Suicidal Hanging
- Most common manner
- Room usually bolted from inside
- Suicide note may be present
- No marks of struggle usually
- Lone location chosen
- Common ligature materials: ceiling fan, roof, tree, window
Homicidal Hanging (Lynching)
- Very rare
- Victim must be incapacitated - by:
- Prior physical assault (look for other injuries)
- Alcohol or drug intoxication (toxicology screen mandatory)
- Significant size disparity (adult vs child; strong man vs small woman)
- If victim strangled first and then strung up: ligature mark will be horizontal (not inverted-V) - key differentiating point
- Contusions on arms from forcible restraint may be seen
- Complete toxicological screen and full autopsy mandatory in all alleged suicidal hangings
Accidental Hanging
- Autoerotic asphyxia (sexual asphyxia): deliberately reduces blood/oxygen to brain for erotic pleasure; may accidentally hang themselves; usually males; found in private place; often pornographic material nearby
Key Differentiating Features: Hanging vs Strangulation
| Feature | Hanging | Ligature Strangulation |
|---|
| Ligature mark direction | Oblique, upward toward knot | Horizontal |
| Marks encircle neck? | Incomplete (gap at knot) | Complete |
| Position of mark | Above thyroid cartilage | At/below thyroid cartilage |
| Hyoid/thyroid fracture | Rare (9-12%) | More common |
| Petechiae | Less common (complete hanging) | More common |
| Face colour | Usually pale | Usually congested |
| Manner | Usually suicidal | Usually homicidal |
| Carotid intimal tear | May be present | Less common |
11. SCENE EXAMINATION - KEY POINTS
- Note height of suspension and platform height
- Note pattern of knot (can the person make this knot themselves?)
- Diagrams, photographs, videography
- Never undo/cut the knot except for lifesaving measures - preserve it
- Ground under and around hanging body must be examined
- Check: room bolted from inside? Signs of struggle?
- If rope is cut, recover and preserve all pieces
12. HIGH-YIELD EXAM MCQ POINTS
| Fact | Answer |
|---|
| Constricting force in hanging | Body weight |
| Constricting force in partial hanging | Weight of head (~5-6 kg) |
| Ligature mark direction in hanging | Oblique, upward (inverted-V) |
| Ligature mark in hanging - complete or incomplete? | Incomplete (absent at knot) |
| Most common level of ligature mark | Above thyroid cartilage (80%) |
| Primary cause of death in hanging | Cerebrovascular compression (carotid occlusion), not pure asphyxia |
| Jugular vein occlusion pressure | 2 kg |
| Carotid artery occlusion pressure | 3.5 kg |
| Tracheal occlusion pressure | 15 kg |
| Face colour in complete hanging | Pale |
| Face colour in partial hanging | Congested (vertebral arteries still patent) |
| Petechiae in hanging | Partial hanging (not complete) |
| Saliva dribbles from mouth | Opposite side to the knot |
| Head inclines toward | Side opposite the knot |
| Tongue appearance | Protruding, black/dark brown (drying) |
| Fracture in judicial hanging | C2-C3 fracture-dislocation |
| Knot position in judicial hanging | Left side of jaw, near chin |
| PM lividity in hanging | Lower limbs, forearms, hands; face above ligature |
| Fatal period (no cord injury) | 5-8 minutes |
| Most common manner of hanging | Suicidal |
| Hanging in India - more common in? | Males |
| Internal neck injury in non-judicial hanging | Rare (~9-12%); when present: thyroid cartilage superior horns |
| Hyoid fracture in hanging | Rare (more common in strangulation) |
| Ligature marks resist? | Decomposition |
| Intimal tear of carotid - indicates? | Antemortem hanging |
13. ALLIED CONDITIONS TO KNOW
- Bansdola: Form of strangulation using a bamboo stick placed across neck
- Garrotting: Ligature strangulation from behind with sudden jerk
- Mugging: Arm-lock around neck
- Burking: Smothering + compression of chest simultaneously (Burke & Hare)
- Tardieu spots: Petechial haemorrhages from hydrostatic rupture - seen in dependent areas in hanging
Sources: P.C. Dikshit - Textbook of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology; Parikh's Textbook of Medical Jurisprudence, Forensic Medicine & Toxicology; DiMaio's Forensic Pathology, 3rd Ed.
These notes cover everything typically asked in NEET PG, DNB, FMGE, and state PG examinations on the topic of Hanging. Let me know if you want me to expand on any section, add comparison tables for other asphyxial deaths, or cover strangulation/drowning next.