I now have enough information to compile a comprehensive answer. Let me put together the top 10 X-ray findings with images and hallmarks.
Top 10 Classic X-Ray Findings with Images and Hallmarks
1. Air Bronchogram Sign
Condition: Pneumonia, Pulmonary Edema, ARDS, Atelectasis
Hallmarks:
- Branching linear lucencies (air-filled bronchi) visible within an opacified/consolidated lung
- Confirms the opacity is intrapulmonary (not pleural or mediastinal)
- Seen when alveoli are fluid-filled but airways remain patent
- Generalized form = ARDS/hyaline membrane disease
- Also seen in: bronchoalveolar carcinoma, lymphoma, radiation fibrosis, sarcoidosis
2. Silhouette Sign
Condition: Pneumonia, Pleural effusion, Lobar collapse, Mediastinal masses
Hallmarks:
- Loss of a normally visible border between two structures of the same radiodensity (soft tissue + soft tissue = no visible margin)
- Right heart border lost = right middle lobe/right lingular pathology
- Left heart border lost = lingula or left lower lobe
- Diaphragm obscured = lower lobe consolidation or effusion
- Key teaching point: "You can only see a structure if something of different density is adjacent to it"
- Hilum overlay sign: subtype - used to localize hilar masses (if hilar vessels still visible through mass, it's anterior or posterior to hilum)
3. Pleural Effusion - Meniscus Sign
Condition: Heart failure, Malignancy, Infection, PE, Hypoalbuminemia
Hallmarks:
- Dependent opacity with a curved (meniscus-shaped) upper border - higher laterally, lower medially on PA view
- Blunting of costophrenic angles (need ~200-300 mL to blunt on PA; 50-75 mL on lateral)
- Ipsilateral diaphragm obscured (silhouette sign)
- Massive effusion: complete white-out of hemithorax + contralateral mediastinal shift
- Subpulmonic effusion: apparent elevation of hemidiaphragm; lateral decubitus view confirms
4. Pneumothorax + Deep Sulcus Sign
Condition: Spontaneous PTX, Tension PTX, Trauma
Hallmarks (Upright):
- Visible visceral pleural line with absent lung markings peripheral to it
- Ipsilateral hyperlucency
- Tension PTX: mediastinal shift away from affected side + ipsilateral diaphragmatic depression
Hallmarks (Supine - Deep Sulcus Sign):
- Unusually deep and lucent costophrenic angle - air collects anteriorly/basally in supine patient
- Etched diaphragm: hemidiaphragm appears sharper than contralateral side
- Etched mediastinum: increased contrast along heart border
Key: "If the story is right and there's a deep sulcus sign, assume pneumothorax is present."
5. Bat-Wing / Butterfly Pattern - Pulmonary Edema
Condition: Cardiogenic pulmonary edema, Alveolar proteinosis
Hallmarks:
- Bilateral opacities radiating outward from the hila in a fan/bat-wing shape - perihilar consolidation sparing the lung periphery
- Develops when pulmonary venous pressure exceeds 30 mmHg
- Associated with: cardiomegaly (CTR >0.5), Kerley B lines, upper lobe vascular diversion, pleural effusions
- Kerley B lines: short horizontal lines (1.5-2 cm) at the lung bases, perpendicular to pleura = interlobular septal thickening
- Kerley A lines: longer lines (5-10 cm) from hilum to periphery = deep septal fluid
6. Cardiomegaly (CTR >0.5)
Condition: Heart failure, Cardiomyopathy, Pericardial effusion, Valvular disease
Hallmarks:
- Cardiothoracic ratio (CTR) > 0.5 on a PA film (unreliable on AP/supine)
- Pericardial effusion gives a "flask-shaped" or globular cardiac silhouette
- Constrictive pericarditis: pericardial calcification (shell-like, best seen on lateral)
- Associated findings: upper lobe diversion, Kerley B lines, pleural effusions
7. Lobar Consolidation
Condition: Bacterial pneumonia (Streptococcus, Klebsiella), Pulmonary infarction
Hallmarks:
- Homogeneous opacification of a lobe with air bronchograms and intact lobe volume (no collapse)
- Silhouette sign localizes the lobe affected
- Right lower lobe: posterior opacity, visible through cardiac shadow
- Left lower lobe: triangular opacity behind heart, "straight lateral border of heart," loss of left hemidiaphragm
- Klebsiella: "Bulging fissure sign" - fissure bulges convexly toward the opacity due to exudate volume
8. Hampton's Hump + Westermark Sign (Pulmonary Embolism)
Condition: Pulmonary Embolism / Pulmonary Infarction
Hampton's Hump:
- Wedge-shaped, pleura-based opacity with a rounded convex apex pointing toward the hilum
- Represents pulmonary infarction distal to the embolus
- Also called the "melting sign" - resolves over days like a melting ice cube
- Present in ~22% of angiographically confirmed PE (not sensitive)
Westermark Sign:
- Focal oligemia/hyperlucency distal to an occluded pulmonary artery - decreased vascular markings
- Rare (~2% of PE cases); caused by obstruction + reflex vasoconstriction
- Fleischner sign (companion): prominent dilated central pulmonary artery due to large embolus or elevated pulmonary arterial pressure
9. Golden S Sign (Right Upper Lobe Collapse with Central Mass)
Condition: Central bronchogenic carcinoma causing RUL collapse
Hallmarks:
- The "S-shaped" curve formed at the minor fissure:
- Lateral/superior concave portion = downward-displaced minor fissure (collapsed RUL)
- Medial/inferior convex portion = the central hilar mass bulging outward
- Virtually pathognomonic for central obstructing carcinoma when RUL collapses
- Named by Golden in 1925
10. Pneumoperitoneum (Free Air Under Diaphragm)
Condition: Perforated viscus (peptic ulcer, diverticulitis), Post-operative
Hallmarks:
- Crescent of free air visible beneath one or both hemidiaphragms on upright CXR (right side more common - liver creates contrast)
- Requires as little as 1 mL of free air detectable on erect CXR
- Rigler's sign (supine): both sides of bowel wall visible due to intraluminal + extraluminal air
- Falciform ligament sign (supine): free air outlines the falciform ligament as a vertical line
- Continuous diaphragm sign: air outlines inferior aspect of diaphragm including under the heart
- Key: upright film is most sensitive; lateral decubitus (left side down) is alternative
Quick Reference Table
| # | Sign | Pattern | Key Condition |
|---|
| 1 | Air Bronchogram | Branching lucencies within opacification | Pneumonia, pulmonary edema |
| 2 | Silhouette Sign | Loss of normal border | Consolidation, effusion |
| 3 | Meniscus Sign | Curved fluid upper border + blunted CP angle | Pleural effusion |
| 4 | Deep Sulcus Sign | Deep lucent costophrenic angle (supine) | Pneumothorax |
| 5 | Bat-Wing | Perihilar bilateral fan-shaped opacities | Pulmonary edema |
| 6 | Cardiomegaly | CTR >0.5; flask-shape = effusion | Heart failure, pericardial effusion |
| 7 | Bulging Fissure | Fissure convex toward opacity | Klebsiella pneumonia |
| 8 | Hampton's Hump | Wedge pleura-based opacity | Pulmonary embolism/infarction |
| 9 | Golden S Sign | S-shaped minor fissure | Central lung cancer + RUL collapse |
| 10 | Free Air | Crescent under diaphragm / Rigler's | Perforation |
Sources: Goldman-Cecil Medicine; Fishman's Pulmonary Diseases; Braunwald's Heart Disease; Rosen's Emergency Medicine; Harriet Lane Handbook;
Back to Basics - Classical Signs in Thoracic Radiology, PMC;
Radiographic Distribution as a Diagnostic Clue, PMC